Shen (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Shen (Migration) [2020] AATA 6032 (16 September 2020)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Ms Weiping Shen

Miss Zhenfei Gu

CASE NUMBER:  1918244

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S): BCC2017/1479284 BCC2017/1535931 BCC2019/3143208 BCC2019/3143223

MEMBER:P Ranson

DATE:16 September 2020

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decisions not to grant the visa Applicants Business Skills (Residence) (Class DF) visas.

Statement made on 16 September 2020 at 1:16pm

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – Business Skills (Residence) (Class DF) visa – Subclass 890 (Business Owner) – beneficial owner of a residential property – net business and personal assets – property purchased in the name of the secondary applicant – secondary applicant was financially independent – no evidence of Declaration of Trust being stamped or registered – resulting trust – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, s 65
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2, cls 890.215; rr 1.03, 1.05, 1.11

CASES

Yu v MIMIA (2004) 140 FCR 126

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

Table of Contents

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

Requirements relating to Applicant’s business and personal assets

The George Street Property

The Declaration of Trust

Does the Declaration of Trust satisfy reg 1.11A requirements?

Does reg 1.11A(4) apply?

Has a resulting trust been created?

DECISION

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 19 June 2019 to refuse to grant the visa Applicants Business Skills (Residence) (Class DF) visas under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The Applicants applied for the visas on 21 April 2017. Certain criteria must be satisfied during the two years immediately before the application is made, that is, 21 April 2015 to 20 April 2017 (the Application Period).

  3. At the time of application, Class DF contained four subclasses: 890 (Business Owner), Subclass 891 (Investor), Subclass 892 (State/Territory Business Owner) and 893 (State/Territory Sponsored Investor). The Applicants in this case are seeking to satisfy the criteria for the grant of Subclass 890 (Business Owner) visas, as set out in Part 890 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). At least one member of the family unit must satisfy the primary criteria set out in Subdivision 890.2. The others need only to satisfy the secondary criteria set out in Subdivision 890.3.

  4. The delegate in this case refused to grant the visas on the basis the first named visa Applicant, Ms Weiping Shen, (the Applicant) did not satisfy the requirements of cl.890.215 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations because she could not establish she was the beneficial owner of a property she sought to include as part of the value of her net business and personal assets in Australia. Miss Zhenfei Gu is the daughter of the Applicant (the Second Visa Applicant).

  5. The Applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 9 July 2020 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal was to receive oral evidence from the Second Visa Applicant, and Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shen (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 6032
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Applicant, Weiping Shen, against a decision of the Department of Home Affairs regarding her application for a Business Skills (Residence) (Class DF) visa, Subclass 890 (Business Owner). The central dispute revolved around whether the Applicant and her spouse held beneficial ownership of a residential property located at 710-722 George Street, Sydney, which had been purchased in the name of the secondary applicant, Zhenfei Gu. The Applicant claimed this property, along with business assets, met the net asset requirements for the visa. The case was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant had successfully demonstrated beneficial ownership of the George Street Property in accordance with Regulation 1.11A of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). This regulation prescribes the evidentiary requirements for assets subject to beneficial ownership arrangements to be included in the calculation of net business and personal assets for Business visa purposes. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the provided Declaration of Trust, or any other documentation, sufficiently evidenced the Applicant's beneficial ownership to satisfy the requirements of the regulation, which mandates that such evidence be stamped or registered by an appropriate authority.

The Tribunal reasoned that while a Declaration of Trust was provided, it was drafted in the future tense, suggesting it recorded intentions rather than an existing arrangement at the time of purchase. Crucially, Regulation 1.11A(2) requires that evidence of beneficial ownership, such as a trust instrument or contract, be stamped or registered by an appropriate authority. The Declaration of Trust in this case was neither stamped nor registered. The Tribunal noted that the purpose of Regulation 1.11A is to prevent claims to ownership that cannot be substantially proven by authenticated documents, thereby addressing the difficulties decision-makers face in verifying claims, particularly when documents may be in a foreign language or reflect foreign legal systems. The contract for the property itself also did not indicate that the purchaser was acting as a nominee or trustee for another party.

For these reasons, the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant had failed to satisfy the evidentiary requirements for beneficial ownership under Regulation 1.11A. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded the decision under review should be affirmed. The issue in this case is whether the Applicant and her spouse have beneficial ownership of a residential unit in Sydney, wholly paid for by them and purchased in the name of the Second Visa Applicant, and subject to a Declaration of Trust dated 16 February 2017 between Zhenfei Gu (the Second Visa Applicant) as trustee and Yuming Gu and Weiping Shen (the Applicant) as purchasers. The property in question is Unit 1503/710-722 George Street, Sydney NSW 2000 (the George Street Property). In accordance with the President’s Direction[2], the Tribunal will address only those elements of the criteria on which the delegate made an adverse finding, being the satisfaction of cl 890.215 in this case.[2] Presidents Direction for Conducting Migration and Refugee Reviews dated 1 August 2018 Clause 890.215 requires the Applicant meet certain requirements relating to their business and personal assets. Throughout the period of 12 months immediately before the application is made and as at the time of application, the net value of the business and personal assets in Australia of the Applicant, or the Applicant’s spouse or de facto partner or their assets combined, had been at least A$250,000. The Tribunal must consider whether the substantive requirements of this criterion are met. The Applicant submitted the requirements concerning business and personal assets are met by the combination of the net assets of the nominated business, Australian N Power International Pty Ltd ACN 163 913 737 (Australian N Power), some cash and beneficial ownership of the George Street Property. Whilst the Tribunal has not tested the net business assets of the Applicant, it notes the net assets of Australian N Power may not exceed A$100,000 once related party loans are eliminated, and the Applicant’s loan to the company is added. Absent net business assets reaching A$250,000, it is necessary to consider the Applicant’s personal assets, which means testing the Applicant’s claim to beneficial ownership of the George Street Property. The Applicant asserts the George Street Property is hers as she paid the deposit and all loan repayments plus all holding costs since acquisition and it was only purchased in the name of the Second Visa Applicant because of poor advice at the time of purchase. On 30 March 2012, Miss Zhenfei Gu, the Second Visa Applicant, signed a contract to purchase the George Street Property for $625,000 (the Contract). Settlement occurred on 10 May 2012. A copy of the contract (stamped by the then NSW Office of State Revenue), and Settlement and Adjustments Sheet prepared by Yau & Wang Lawyers, were provided in response to a request for information received by the department on 25 September 2018. Relevantly, there is no indication on the Contract to indicate the purchaser is anyone other than the Second Visa Applicant, for example, the purchaser is not shown as: ‘Zhenfei Gu as trustee for …’ or ‘Zhenfei Gu as nominee for …’ or similar. This omission is relevant later in the discussion about resulting trusts and the presumption of advancement, see paragraph [34].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A document titled Declaration of Trust dated 16 February 2017 between Zhenfei Gu, the Second Visa Applicant, as Trustee, and Yuming Gu and Weiping Shen, the Applicant, was provided to the department as evidence of the asserted trust arrangement between the parties (the Declaration of Trust). The terms of the Declaration of Trust are reproduced below: The Tribunal observes the Declaration of Trust is written in future tense, that is, it appears to have been drafted as though the purchase of the George Street Property is contemplated rather than had already occurred. For example, Introduction A says: ‘the trustee have [sic – has] agreed to’ and Introduction D which says: ‘The purpose of the Trustee's involvement in the purchase of the Property is to assist …’. Paragraph 1(a) says: ‘The Trustee acknowledges that it is purchasing the property as nominee for the Purchasers’. Curiously, Introduction B says: ‘The purchase of property was made in the name of the Trustee …’ which is past tense. The Applicant was asked about the drafting of the document in future tense and it became apparent tense does not feature in the Mandarin language, so she was unable to assist the Tribunal. Nonetheless, the Tribunal must deal with the evidence before it. The Declaration of Trust appears to record the asserted intentions of the parties regarding beneficial ownership of the George Street Property, that is, the Second Visa Applicant entered into the Contract and applied for the loan on behalf of her parents, the Applicant and her husband. Ownership of an asset includes ‘beneficial ownership’. Regulation 1.11A of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations) prescribes the evidentiary requirements to be met for an asset, which is subject to beneficial ownership arrangements, to be included in the asset calculation for Business visa purposes. Ownership by an Applicant, or the Applicant’s spouse or de facto partner, of an asset includes beneficial ownership only if the beneficial ownership is evidenced in accordance with reg 1.11A(2). Regulation 1.11A(2) provides (emphasis added):(2) To evidence beneficial ownership of an asset, eligible investment or ownership interest, the applicant must show to the Minister:(a)a trust instrument; or(b)a contract; or(c)any other document capable of being used to enforce the rights of the applicant or the applicant’s spouse or de facto partner, as the case requires, in relation to the asset, eligible investment or ownership interest;stamped or registered by an appropriate authority under the law of the jurisdiction where the asset, eligible investment or ownership interest is located. The purpose of reg 1.11A was described in Yu v MIMIA (2004) 140 FCR 126 at [35] as follows:Regulation 1.11A has the effect of excluding from an applicant’s assets claims to ownership which cannot be substantially proven by reference to authenticated documents. Claims to beneficial ownership are easily made. There may often be little or no documentation of the contract or other arrangement which is said to create the ownership interest, leaving the decision-maker to determine the veracity of a claim based upon an oral arrangement with no objective evidence to assist that determination. And when documentation is provided it may be difficult to assess its authenticity. In the context of migration and visa applications there are added difficulties for the decision-maker in verifying documents put forward, since they may be in a foreign language or reflect aspects of a foreign legal system. It is these difficulties which the regulation addresses.