Sharma (Migration) [2020] AATA 4259 (2 October 2020)
DECISION RECORD
DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division
APPLICANT: Mr Parveen Sharma
CASE NUMBER: 1810504
HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S): BCC2016/1390637
MEMBER:Andrew McLean Williams
DATE:2 October 2020
PLACE OF DECISION: Brisbane
DECISION:The Tribunal remits the application for a Regional Employer Nomination (Permanent) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 187 - Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme visa:
·Public Interest Criterion 4020 for the purposes of cl.187 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.
Statement made on 2 October 2020 at 8:58am
CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Regional Employer Nomination (Permanent) (Class RN) visa – Subclass 187 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) – Direct Entry stream – bogus document – first employment certificate not impugned by department as bogus – second employment certificate impugned as bogus – authenticity of issuer verified by tribunal – false and misleading information – time period of work experience incorrect – applicant’s claim of confusion unaccepted – impugned information holds no relevance to any of the criteria – PIC 4020(5)(b) not enlivened – decision under review remittedLEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, s 65
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2, cl 187.213, PIC 4020(5)CASES
Palikhe v MIBP ([2014] FCCA 1875
Singh v Minister for Immigration and Anor [2012] FMCASTATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS
APPLICATION FOR REVIEW
This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs refusing to grant the applicant a Regional Employer Nomination (Permanent) (Class RN) visa, pursuant to s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (‘the Act’).
The applicant had applied for the visa on 7 April 2016. At that time, Class RN contained only one subclass: Subclass 187 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme).
The criteria for a Subclass 187 visa are set out in Part 187 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (‘the Regulations’). The primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one applicant. Other members of the family unit, if any, who also happen to be applicants for the visa need only satisfy the secondary criteria. Applicants seeking to satisfy the primary criteria must meet the 'Common criteria', as well as the criteria of one of either of two alternative visa streams: the Temporary Residence Transition stream, or the Direct Entry stream.
In the present case, the applicant is seeking the visa in the ‘Direct Entry’ stream.
The delegate refused to grant the visa because the applicant did not meet cl.187.213 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations, because the delegate determined that the applicant could not meet the requirements of Public Interest Criteria (‘PIC’) 4020, which is one of the requirements to satisfy cl.187.213(1), and thus the requirements of cl.187 as a whole.
PIC 4020(1) provides that there must be no evidence before the Minister that the applicant has given, or caused to be given to the Minister, an officer, the Tribunal, a relevant assessing authority, or a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth a ‘bogus document’ or ‘information…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Sharma (Migration) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] AATA 4259
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the requirements of Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4020, which is a mandatory requirement for the Subclass 187 visa. This criterion is engaged when an applicant provides a bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular. The Tribunal also needed to consider the implications of the applicant's claimed confusion regarding the dates and details on their employment certificates.
The Tribunal accepted evidence that a first employment certificate from Dominos Ipswich was not impugned by the Department. However, a second employment certificate from the Lowood Tavern Bistro was initially questioned. The Tribunal accepted evidence from former business partners, Ms Vanessa Creer and Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon, that the applicant had undertaken unpaid volunteer work experience for approximately 20 hours per week from October 2014 until the business ceased operations on 27 September 2015. The Tribunal accepted Mr Kahlon's explanation that the date on the certificate, 10 October 2015, was an oversight and that the intention was to indicate employment until the business's closure. Furthermore, the Tribunal accepted evidence from the tavern owner, Ms Vicki Duncan, that she only knew Mr Kahlon by his nickname "Luckee" and did not realise he was the same person as Kulbir Singh Kahlon until recently, explaining her prior statement to departmental officers. Given these findings, the Tribunal concluded that PIC 4020 was not enlivened.
Consequently, the Tribunal remitted the visa application to the Minister for reconsideration, with a direction that the applicant meets the requirements of PIC 4020 for the purposes of the Subclass 187 visa. The Minister was to consider the remaining criteria for the visa.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Tribunal received evidence from various individuals connected to the applicant’s employment history. A statutory declaration from Mr Clint Corrie, a former manager of Dominos Ipswich, confirmed that he provided the applicant with a proof of employment letter dated 1 May 2017. This letter was not impugned as bogus by the Department of Home Affairs. However, another employment certificate issued by Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon, who had been the applicant’s employer at the Lowood Tavern Bistro, was later found to contain false and misleading information. Specifically, the certificate inaccurately stated that the applicant had been employed until 10 October 2015, despite the business having ceased operations on 27 September 2015. Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon admitted to the oversight in dating the certificate and testified that the applicant had indeed been employed as a volunteer assistant manager from October 2014 until the business closed in September 2015.
Further evidence was provided by Ms Vanessa Creer and Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon, who jointly operated the Lowood Tavern Bistro from September 2014 to 27 September 2015. They detailed their efforts to establish a viable business before ultimately deciding to close it due to its unsustainability. Their testimony corroborated the applicant’s employment period as stated in his application. Additionally, Ms Vicki Ellen Duncan, the owner of the Lowood Tavern, provided statutory declaration evidence, confirming the subletting arrangement and her lack of knowledge about the applicant’s employment due to her unfamiliarity with Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon’s full name. The Tribunal accepted all these testimonies and found that the impugned information in the employment certificate did not affect the applicant’s eligibility under the relevant criteria.
The present case, Sharma (Migration), originated from an application for a Regional Employer Nomination (Permanent) (Class RN) visa, subclass 187 (Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme) under the Direct Entry stream. The application was initially lodged by the applicant, who sought to satisfy the mandatory requirements set out in clause 187.213 in Schedule 2 of the Migration Regulations, specifically the Public Interest Criterion 4020. Following an initial assessment by a delegate, the application was refused, with the decision being subsequently reviewed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The applicant then sought review of the AAT’s decision by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCA), which further examined the evidence and arguments presented. The matter has now been remitted back to the Minister for reconsideration, focusing on the remaining criteria for the visa, as determined by the FCFCA. The Tribunal has specifically considered the authenticity of employment certificates provided by the applicant and the implications of the false and misleading information contained within one of the certificates on the visa application process.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in the present case is whether the applicant can meet the requirements of PIC 4020, and thus satisfy the mandatory requirements in cl.187.213 in Schedule 2 of the Migration Regulations. In a statutory declaration dated 27 February 2020, Mr Clint Corrie - a former manager of Dominos Ipswich - states that he did provide the applicant with a ‘proof of employment’ letter dated 1 May 2017. That evidence is accepted by the Tribunal. On the basis that the decision of the delegate dated 29 March 2018 did not actually ever impugn the veracity of the Dominos Ipswich letter for purposes of PIC 4020 – instead referring only to the fact of departmental officers had not been able to confirm its accuracy prior to the time of the making of the delegate’s decision - the Tribunal did not pursue this issue any further. The statutory declaration evidence and oral testimony before the Tribunal from each of Ms Vanessa Creer and Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon reveals that they were once joint business partners, who from September 2014 until 27 September 2015 had taken up a month-to-month lease to operate the kitchen and dining room at the Lowood Tavern. After attempting to make a going concern of that business for about twelve months Ms Creer and Mr Kahlon concluded that the business was not viable, such that they decided to give notice to their landlord, Ms Vicki Duncan (the owner of the Lowood Tavern), and close the business. The evidence from Ms Creer and Mr Kahlon also reveals that Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon was only ever known and referred to at the Lowood Tavern by his nickname “Luckee”; and that the applicant had been employed by them - on an unpaid, volunteer ‘work experience’ basis - for about 20 hours per week, from October 2014 up until the closure of their business, which took place on 27 September 2015. In his oral evidence, Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon explained that he had provided the applicant with the impugned employment certificate. Although he had signed the certificate on Lowood Tavern Bistro letterhead as the ‘owner/operator’ on 10 October 2015, therein indicating that the applicant had been employed since October 2014 as a “volunteer assistant manager”, Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon’s intention had been to say that the applicant had been employed until the cessation of that business, on 27 September 2015, rather than until 10 October 2015 as is inferred by the date of the certificate. In point of fact, the business operated by Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon and Ms Creer as the Lowood Tavern Bistro had already ceased operating by that date. Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon told the Tribunal it had been an oversight by him to not mention in the employment certificate that the business had closed, on 27 September 2015. The Tribunal accepts that explanation. Statutory declaration evidence was also received by the Tribunal from Ms Vicki Ellen Duncan. This evidence reveals that she was the owner of the Lowood Tavern and Bistro as at 10 October 2015. Ms Duncan’s statutory declaration evidence reveals that the Kitchen and Bistro had been sublet by her to Vanessa Creer and Kulbir Singh Kahlon until the end of September 2015, yet that she had only ever known Mr Kulbir Singh Kahlon by the nickname ‘Luckee’, and did not realise that Luckee and Kulbir Singh Kahlon were one and the same person until quite recently, when told this by others. Hence the reason why Ms Duncan had advised departmental officers on 23 November 2017 that she “did not know and had never heard of” any person by the name Kulbir Singh Kahlon. That evidence is also accepted by the Tribunal.