Shao v Crown Global Capital Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Shao v Crown Global Capital Pty Limited (No 2) [2023] NSWSC 1114
Hearing dates: On the papers
Decision date: 14 September 2023
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: Ball J
Decision:

Application to vary order 2 of the orders made on 14 July 2023 is dismissed

Catchwords:

COSTS — Party/Party — Exceptions to general rule that costs follow the event — Where defendants succeeded on the basis of a defence raised shortly before the hearing in an amended list response — Whether defendants are entitled to costs prior to the filing of the amended defence — Where no evidence that the proceedings would have been conducted any differently had the defence been raised earlier — The defence deprived the plaintiff of a claim not relief in respect of an admitted breach — Not within an exception to the rule that costs follow the event

Legislation Cited:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Bonic v Pacific General Security Limited [2009] NSWSC 1221

Ciaglia v Ciaglia [2010] NSWSC 723

David v Abdishou [2007] NSWSC 890

Harrington v Greenwood Grove Estate Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWSC 1598

Leading Edge Events Australia Pty Ltd v KiriTeKanawa (No 2) [2007] NSWSC 568

Murrihy v Radio 2UE Sydney Pty Limited [2000] NSWSC 318

Shao v Crown Global Capital Pty Limited [2023] NSWSC 820

Williamson v Bors (1900) 21 LR (NSW) Eq 302

Category:Costs
Parties: Yakun Shao (Plaintiff)
Crown Global Capital Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Crown Group Holdings Pty Ltd (Second Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
J Horowitz (Plaintiff)
SA Lawrance SC with C Ernst (Defendants)

Solicitors:
Yau & Wang, Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Mangioni Biggs + Co (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2022/48845
Publication restriction: Nil

JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. I delivered judgment in this matter on 14 July 2023 (see Shao v Crown Global Capital Pty Limited [2023] NSWSC 820). At that time, I dismissed the plaintiff’s claim and ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs, but I gave liberty to the parties to apply to vary the costs order within 21 days. The plaintiff, in exercise of that liberty, seeks in place of the costs order I made one of the following orders:

(a)   “The Court makes no order as to costs”; or, in the alternative,

(b)    “The Defendants are to pay the Plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings prior to 25 May 2023 and the Plaintiff is to pay the Defendants’ costs of the proceedings on and from 25 May 2023”; or, in the further alternative,

(c)    “The Defendants are to pay the Plaintiff’s costs of the mediation held on 26 April 2023, and otherwise, the Plaintiff is to pay the Defendants’ costs of the proceedings.”

This judgment concerns that application. It assumes familiarity with my earlier judgment and uses the same abbreviations as used in that judgment.

A preliminary matter

  1. After the plaintiff had filed her submissions in support of her application, provisional liquidators were appointed to each of the defendants.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shao v Crown Global Capital Pty Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 1114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Shao, the plaintiff, was involved in a legal dispute against Crown Global Capital Pty Limited, the defendant. The case centred around allegations of breaches of fiduciary duty and unauthorised trading by the defendant. The proceedings reached a conclusion with the defendant successfully arguing that the plaintiff's claims were statute-barred. The plaintiff sought to challenge the order for costs made in favour of the defendant, arguing that the defence was raised very late in the proceedings and that the defendant should not be entitled to costs prior to the filing of the amended defence. The court was required to determine whether the defendant was entitled to costs prior to the filing of the amended defence and whether the plaintiff's claims for relief should have been considered in light of the late-raised defence.

The court examined whether the defendant's successful defence qualified for an exception to the general rule that costs follow the event. The court considered the timing of the defence, which was raised shortly before the hearing in an amended list response, and whether this deprived the plaintiff of a claim not relief in respect of an admitted breach. The court also looked at whether there was any evidence that the proceedings would have been conducted differently had the defence been raised earlier. The court noted that the defence did not deprive the plaintiff of a claim but rather relieved the defendant in respect of an admitted breach. The court further noted that there was no evidence that the proceedings would have been conducted differently if the defence had been raised earlier.

The court concluded that the defendant was not entitled to costs prior to the filing of the amended defence as the defence did not fall within an exception to the rule that costs follow the event. The court found that the defence deprived the plaintiff of a claim not relief in respect of an admitted breach and there was no evidence that the proceedings would have been conducted differently if the defence had been raised earlier. The court ordered that the plaintiff's application for an order for costs be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Shao, the plaintiff, and Crown Global Capital Pty Limited (Crown), the defendant, regarding financial transactions and the application of costs. Shao originally filed a claim against Crown, alleging breaches of fiduciary duty and other wrongdoing. Crown initially responded to the claim but later filed an amended defence, raising a new defence of statute-barred claims shortly before the hearing. The new defence was successful, leading to Crown's overall success in the proceedings. Shao sought to argue that Crown should not be entitled to costs incurred prior to the filing of the amended defence. The central issue revolved around whether Crown was entitled to such costs under the circumstances, given the timing of the new defence and its impact on the proceedings.

The matter came before the court as a response to Shao's application for an order regarding costs. Initially, Shao filed a claim against Crown, which led to Crown filing an initial defence. Subsequently, Crown filed an amended defence, introducing a new defence of statute-barred claims just before the hearing. The amended defence was accepted by the court, resulting in Crown's success in the case. Following this outcome, Shao applied for an order to limit the costs that Crown could claim, arguing that the new defence was raised too late. The court was asked to decide whether Crown was entitled to costs incurred prior to the filing of the amended defence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Crown is entitled to costs incurred prior to the filing of the amended defence.
2. Whether the timing of the new defence, which was successful, affects the entitlement to costs under the general rule that costs follow the event.
3. If the new defence deprived Shao of a claim, not just relief in respect of an admitted breach, whether this situation falls within an exception to the general rule that costs follow the event.

Held
1. The Crown is not entitled to costs incurred prior to the filing of the amended defence.
2. The timing of the new defence, which was successful, does not affect the entitlement to costs under the general rule that costs follow the event.
3. The situation where the new defence deprived Shao of a claim, not just relief in respect of an admitted breach, does not fall within an exception to the general rule that costs follow the event.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that the Crown was not entitled to costs incurred prior to the filing of the amended defence. The court reasoned that there was no evidence that the proceedings would have been conducted any differently had the defence been raised earlier. The court noted that the timing of the successful new defence did not alter the entitlement to costs under the general rule that costs follow the event. The court found that the new defence deprived Shao of a claim, not merely relief in respect of an admitted breach, which did not fit within an established exception to the general rule. In determining the costs, the court considered the established principle that costs follow the event, except in cases where a successful defence deprives the plaintiff of a claim. The court did not find any compelling reason to depart from this established principle in the context of this case, affirming that the general rule remains applicable.