Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Maa Durga Trust (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Maa Durga Trust (Migration) [2021] AATA 1678 (22 April 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Maa Durga Trust

CASE NUMBER:  1819626

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2016/4116364

MEMBER:Terrence Baxter

DATE:22 April 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision approving the nomination.

Statement made on 22 April 2021 at 12:16pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Employer Nomination – approval of nominated position – Direct Entry Nomination – Café or Restaurant Manager – financial capacity to maintain term of employment – contract of employment – financial statements provided – financial position improved considerably – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), r 5.19

CASES
MIBP v Jayshree Enterprises Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 264

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 15 June 2018 to reject the applicant’s application for approval of the nomination of a position in Australia under r.5.19 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations).

  2. The applicant, Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Maa Durga Trust, applied for approval on 6 December 2016. The applicant nominated Mr Gurbhej Singh Brar (the nominee) in the position of Restaurant Manager. The requirements for the approval of the nomination of a position in Australia are found in r.5.19 of the Regulations which contains two alternative streams: a Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream (r.5.19(3)) and a Direct Entry nomination stream (r.5.19(4)). If the application is made in accordance with r.5.19(2) and meets the requirements of either stream, then the application must be approved. If any of the requirements are not met, then the application must be refused: r.5.19(5).

  3. In this case, the applicant has applied for approval of a nomination, seeking to satisfy the criteria in the Direct Entry nomination stream.

  4. The delegate refused the application on the basis the applicant’s nomination did not satisfy r.5.19(4)(d)(i) of the Regulations because the delegate found that the applicant had not demonstrated that it had the financial capacity to offer full-time employment for at least two years to the nominated position.

  5. The applicant lodged an application for review of the delegate’s decision with the Tribunal on 5 July 2018.

  6. Mr Krishna Pathak, the sole director of the corporate trustee of the applicant Trust, appeared before the Tribunal by video conference on 10 February 2021 to give evidence and present arguments. With the applicant’s consent, the hearing was a joint hearing with the hearing of another application by the applicant.

  7. The Tribunal exercised its discretion to hold the hearing by video conference. The hearing was held during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Tribunal determined it was reasonable to hold a hearing by video conference, having regard to the nature of this matter and the individual circumstances of the applicant. The Tribunal also had regard to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Maa Durga Trust (Mi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1678
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Maa Durga Trust for approval of a nominated position under the Direct Entry stream of the Employer Nomination scheme. The applicant sought to nominate a position for a Café or Restaurant Manager. The core dispute revolved around whether the applicant had demonstrated sufficient financial capacity to maintain the nominated employee for the term of employment and whether the nominated position itself met the regulatory requirements.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant met the requirements for approval of the nomination under Regulation 5.19(4) of the Migration Regulations 1994. Specifically, the Tribunal considered whether the application was compliant, including whether it identified a need for the nominator to employ a paid employee to work in the position under their direct control. The Tribunal also considered the broader requirements of Regulation 5.19(4), including the nominator's operational status, the terms and conditions of employment, and the absence of adverse information.

The Tribunal reasoned that while Regulation 5.19(4)(a)(ii) required the identification of a need for a paid employee, its precise scope was uncertain. However, the Tribunal found that the applicant had provided substantial evidence demonstrating a genuine need for the nominated position, including financial statements, tax returns, job advertisements, recruitment summaries, and evidence of business operations. The Tribunal also noted that further evidence, such as recent Australian Taxation Office activity statements, tax returns for the 2019 and 2020 financial years, and payroll documents, had been provided after the hearing, which further supported the applicant's claims. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant had met the requirements for approval of the nomination.

The Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a decision approving the nomination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

After the hearing, the applicant produced to the Tribunal documents including:a.Recent Australian Taxation Office activity statements 001 and 002 for the applicant.b.A recent job advertisement by the applicant with resumes of disqualified applicants and a recruitment summary.c.Tax returns for the 2019 and 2020 financial years.d.Submissions from the applicant, the applicant’s accountant and representative.e.A financial statement for the 2020 financial year for an associated company.f.Payroll documents evidencing calculation of superannuation contributions.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in this case is whether the applicant meets the requirements for approval of the nomination under the Direct Entry nomination stream set out in r.5.19(4), which is extracted in the attachment to this decision. For the nomination to be approved, all the requirements must be met.The application is compliant: r.5.19(4)(a) Regulation 5.19(4)(a) requires that the application for approval must be in the approved form, must be accompanied by the prescribed fee, and, where applicable, must include the required written certification relating to conduct that contravenes s.245AR(1). The application must also identify a need for the nominator to employ a paid employee to work in the position under their direct control. Having regard to the documentation in the file of the Department, the Tribunal is satisfied that the application for approval was in the approved form. The application relates to a visa in the Direct Entry stream seeking to meet the requirements in the Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme and consequently no fee is payable (r.5.19(2) and r.5.37(4) of the Regulations). The application included a written certification stating that the applicant had not engaged in conduct in relation to the nomination that contravenes s.245AR(1) of the Act. The requirements of r.5.19(2) and consequently of r.5.19(4)(a)(i) are therefore met. Regulation 5.19(4)(a)(ii) requires that the application identifies a need for the nominator to employ a paid employee to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control. It is unclear whether this requirement is directed just at a statement to this effect or something of a more qualitative nature. The wording ‘identifies a need’ arguably suggests more is required to meet this criterion than simply a statement or declaration that there is such a need. ‘Identify’ is defined as ‘to recognise or establish as being a particular person or thing; verify the identity of.’[1] On that view, which is consistent with that reflected in Departmental policy, a decision maker would need to be satisfied there is a genuine need on the part of the nominator to employ someone in the nominated position.[2] However, it could alternatively be argued that r.5.19(4)(a) as a whole is directed towards requirements for the application form/process of a more administrative nature, such that r.5.19(4)(a)(ii) could be met by a simple statement or certification of need. Support for this view can also be found in the contrast between the wording of r.5.19(4)(a)(ii) and, for example, r.5.19(4)(h)(ii)(B) (for applications relating to positions in regional Australia), which requires that there be a genuine need for the nominator to employ a paid employee to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control – clearly requiring a qualitative assessment, and r.5.19(4)(d)(i), which requires satisfaction that the employee will be employed on a full-time basis in the position for at least two years. Given the uncertain scope of r.5.19(4)(a)(ii), and the requirement in relation to this application to satisfy r.5.19(4)(h)(ii)(B), the Tribunal considers that this issue is more appropriately considered under r.5.19(4)(h)(ii)(B) later in these Reasons.[1] Dictionary.com (accessed January 2021).[2] In Bharaj Construction Pty Ltd v MIBP [2016] FCCA 902 (Judge Barnes, 28 April 2016), the Court considered a similarly worded provision in respect of a pre-1 July 2012 RSMS nomination, i.e. ‘the employer nomination is made by an employer in respect of a need for a paid employee’. Whilst on the one hand r.5.19(4)(a)(ii) does not appear to impose a different requirement beyond emphasising the requirement for an applicant to identify the need (unlike the pre-1 July 2012 version of r.5.19(2)(a) and (4)(a)), the wording of the criteria does differ slightly and the Tribunal exercises caution in applying the reasoning of Bharaj to a post-1 July 2012 nomination as is currently being considered.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has decided to set aside the decision under review and substitute a decision approving the nomination.Evidence presented prior to the hearing The applicant produced to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (now the Department of Home Affairs) (the Department) documents including:a.Activity statements.b.Financial statements and taxation returns.c.A job advertisement.d.Submissions from the applicant.e.An Employment Contract, Organisational Charts and a position description.f.Photographs and a diagram of the premises.g.The Trust Deed for the Maa Durga Trust.h.ABN information for the applicant.i.An extract from the lease of the business premises.j.Market salary evidence.k.An ASIC company summary for Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd.l.Submissions from the applicant’s accountant and representative.m.An advice from the Queensland Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Toowoomba.n.A recruitment report. The applicant produced to the Tribunal documents including:a.A copy of the delegate’s decision.b.Further copies of documents lodged with the Department.c.Recent activity statements.d.Recent job advertisements and a recruitment summary.e.Recent market salary evidence.f.Menus and promotional material from the business.g.A recent Employment Contract and Organisational Chart.h.Current ASIC extracts for Shanti Pathak Pty Ltd.i.Recent financial statements.j.Plans for refurbishment of the business premises.k.Submissions from the applicant, the applicant’s accountant and the representative.Evidence presented at the hearing regarding the applicant’s operations Mr Pathak gave evidence regarding the business operations of the applicant. He stated that he had initially opened an Indian restaurant in Caloundra in 2008, although that business was operated by a different entity to the applicant. He said that the applicant opened a restaurant in Tewantin in 2013 and later opened a restaurant in Coolum. The application discloses that the position to be filled by the nominee is at the Tewantin restaurant. Mr Pathak said that he also operated a restaurant in Maroochydore, again through a different entity to the applicant. He stated that he was the sole director and shareholder of the corporate trustee of the applicant Trust. Mr Pathak stated that while he was studying at university in Brisbane, he had worked on a casual basis in an Indian restaurant and he set out to establish a chain of Indian restaurants on the Sunshine Coast.Evidence presented after the hearing After the hearing, the applicant produced to the Tribunal documents including:a.Recent Australian Taxation Office activity statements 001 and 002 for the applicant.b.A recent job advertisement by the applicant with resumes of disqualified applicants and a recruitment summary.c.Tax returns for the 2019 and 2020 financial years.d.Submissions from the applicant, the applicant’s accountant and representative.e.A financial statement for the 2020 financial year for an associated company.f.Payroll documents evidencing calculation of superannuation contributions.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision approving the nomination.Terrence BaxterMemberATTACHMENT - EXTRACTS FROM THE MIGRATION REGULATIONS 19945.19Approval of nominated positions (employer nomination)…(2)The application must:(a)be made in accordance with approved form 1395…; and(aa) include a written certification by the nominator stating whether or not the nominator has engaged in conduct, in relation to the nomination, that constitutes a contravention of subsection 245AR(1) of the Act; and(b)be accompanied by the fee mentioned in regulation 5.37.…Direct Entry nomination(4)The Minister must, in writing, approve a nomination if:(a)the application for approval:(i) is made in accordance with subregulation (2); and(ii) identifies a need for the nominator to employ a paid employee to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control; and(b)the nominator:(i) is actively and lawfully operating a business in Australia; and(ii) directly operates the business; and(c)for a nominator whose business activities include activities relating to the hiring of labour to other unrelated businesses — the position is within the business activities of the nominator and not for hire to other unrelated businesses; and(d)both of the following apply:(i) the employee will be employed on a full-time basis in the position for at least 2 years;(ii) the terms and conditions of the employee’s employment will not include an express exclusion of the possibility of extending the period of employment; and(e)the terms and conditions of employment applicable to the position will be no less favourable than the terms and conditions that:(i) are provided; or(ii) would be provided;to an Australian citizen or an Australian permanent resident for performing equivalent work in the same workplace at the same location; and(f)either:(i) there is no adverse information known to Immigration about the nominator or a person associated with the nominator; or(ii) it is reasonable to disregard any adverse information known to Immigration about the nominator or a person associated with the nominator; and(g)the nominator has a satisfactory record of compliance with the laws of the Commonwealth, and of each State or Territory in which the applicant operates a business and employs employees in the business, relating to workplace relations; and(h)either:(i) both of the following apply:(A)the tasks to be performed in the position will be performed in Australia and correspond to the tasks of an occupation specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-subparagraph;(AAA)the occupation is applicable to the person identified under subparagraph (a)(ii) in accordance with the specification of the occupation;(B)either:(I)the nominator’s business has operated for at least 12 months, and the nominator meets the requirements for the training of Australian citizens and Australian permanent residents that are specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-sub-subparagraph; or(II)the nominator’s business has operated for less than 12 months, and the nominator has an auditable plan for meeting the requirements specified in the instrument mentioned in sub-sub-subparagraph (I); or(ii) all of the following apply:(A)the position is located in regional Australia;(B)there is a genuine need for the nominator to employ a paid employee to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control;(C)the position cannot be filled by an Australian citizen or an Australian permanent resident who is living in the same local area as that place;(D)the tasks to be performed in the position correspond to the tasks of an occupation specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-subparagraph;(DA)the occupation is applicable to the person identified under subparagraph (a)(ii) in accordance with the specification of the occupation;(E)the business operated by the nominator is located at that place;(F)a body that is:(I)specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-subparagraph; and(II)located in the same State or Territory as the location of the position;has advised the Minister about the matters mentioned in paragraph (e) and sub-subparagraphs (B) and (C).