Shannon Associates Ltd v Marlon Goldstein

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Application for removal of registration 814929(42) Mug n Bean by Marlon Goldstein and opposition thereto by Shannon Associates Limited, the registered owner.

Delegate:

Iain Thompson

Representation:

Opponent

Anthony Norris of Collison & Co.

Applicant

No appearance or written submissions

Decision:

2007 ATMO 54

1. Section 92 removal application – ‘person aggrieved’ – applicant adopted different trade mark; application to register has lapsed; applicant not a person aggrieved; application refused.

2. Costs ordered against applicant.

Background

  1. Shannon Associates Limited, of Douglas, the Isle of Man, ‘the opponent’ or ‘the owner’ in these proceedings, is the registered owner of a trade mark, details of which appear below:

    Appn No:  814929

    Priority Date:  24 November 1999

    Goods/Services:              Class: 42 Providing of food and drink

    Trade Mark:  Mug N Bean

    ‘the trade mark’

  2. On 8 February 2005, Marlon Goldstein, of Westfield Shopping Centre, Chatswood, (‘the applicant’) filed an application in terms of section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) for removal of the trade mark from the Register in respect of all of the services for which it is registered.  The application alleges that:

    ·The applicant is a person aggrieved by the registration;

    ·that, on the day on which the application for the registration of the trade mark was filed, the applicant for registration had no intention in good faith to use the trade mark in Australia; or,

    ·that the trade mark has remained registered for a continuous period of 3 years ending one month before the day on which the non use application is filed, and, at no time during that period, the person who was then the registered owner used the trade mark in Australia;

  3. The owner has filed Notice of Opposition to the removal of the trade mark.  The owner cites five grounds of opposition – namely that:

    ·The applicant is not a person aggrieved within the meaning of the Act;

    ·The owner has used the trade mark within the relevant period, which is from 13 July 2001 until 13 July 2004;

    ·On the date that the application was filed, the owner had an intention to use the trade mark in good faith in Australia;

    ·During the relevant period there has been use of the trade mark, or of the trade mark with additions or alterations not substantially affecting its identity, in Australia by the registered owner or an authorised user in relation to the relevant goods; and,

    ·The Registrar in her discretion ought to refuse the application for removal

  4. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the submissions of the opponent, made by Anthony Norris of Collison & Co in Adelaide on 17 July 2007.  The applicant did not appear or make written submissions.

    Evidence

  5. The evidence in support of the opposition to removal is a declaration by Benjamin Conrad Filmalter who states:

    That [his] company developed the trade mark MUG N BEAN in 1992 following a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shannon Associates Ltd v Marlon Goldstein and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for removal of a trade mark from the Register of Trade Marks, brought by Marlon Goldstein (the applicant) against Shannon Associates Ltd (the opponent). The application was heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The applicant did not appear or make written submissions, while the opponent presented submissions through its legal representative.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the trade mark MUG N BEAN should be removed from the Register due to non-use. The opponent also contended that the removal action was initiated in bad faith and that the trade mark was well-known, warranting protection under Article 6bis of the Paris Convention.

The delegate considered evidence from the opponent detailing the extensive development and international use of the MUG N BEAN trade mark since 1992. This included significant investment in marketing and advertising, substantial worldwide turnover, and the establishment of numerous stores in various countries, including South Africa, the Middle East, and the United Kingdom, with plans for further expansion in North America. The opponent argued that due to this widespread use and recognition, Australian residents travelling internationally would likely be familiar with the mark. The delegate noted the opponent's assertion that the trade mark was already registered in Australia when they sought to enter the market, leading them to purchase the existing registration. The opponent also highlighted their participation in franchise associations and various industry awards, underscoring the brand's success and reputation.

The delegate found that the opponent had established that the MUG N BEAN trade mark was well-known internationally and that the applicant's non-use removal action appeared to be initiated in bad faith. Consequently, the delegate exercised discretion to refuse the removal of the registered trade mark.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the submissions of the opponent, made by Anthony Norris of Collison & Co in Adelaide on 17 July 2007. The applicant did not appear or make written submissions.Evidence The evidence in support of the opposition to removal is a declaration by Benjamin Conrad Filmalter who states:That [his] company developed the trade mark MUG N BEAN in 1992 following a trip my wife and I made to Chicago. During that vacation, we happened across a coffee shop with a friendly and generous feel about it. Upon our return to South Africa, I began to develop and evolve the brand, and the fictional history behind the brand, and in particular the fictional characters of Joshua Fenomah Bean and Clement Mugg. The first store opened in the Victoria and Alfred Waterfront in Cape Town. Since then, over 75 stores have opened in South Africa alone.That I have been involved in the food service industry for over 30 years, and the experience gained over that period was levered in the development of the concept as well as the development of the brands identity and history, albeit fictional. The MUGG & BEAN brand was a reduction of the elements of many successful brands that I have developed for the South Africa market. Significant research was applied to the development of the brand such as: what are the correct number of syllables to be used in a brand name; how does the brand related to the product on offer; how does the name translate into other languages, and is it an offence if directly translated or used in its native English.The company has taken great lengths to protect its intellectual property, including but not limited to the MUG N BEAN trade mark, and has either registered, or made application for the registration, of this trade mark in various guises throughout the word, including Australia, Bahrain, Botswana, Egypt, the European Community, India, Kuwait, Lebanon, Namibia, New Zealand, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Tanzania, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom and the United States of America.That once satisfied that the business model worked, and that the food systems were thoroughly tested, the brand was made available to the international market. First to respond were territories such as Australia and New Zealand. The company was advised that the trade mark MUG N BEAN was already registered in Australia. The company then took steps to purchase that trade mark from the previous owner thereof. On researching these markets, the company noted flaws in its business model particularly in the light of high labour costs. Demand for the brand in these markets (Australia and New Zealand) has not depleted, but we are currently testing the concept in the United Kingdom, where similar high labour costs exist.That the concept was, and is viewed as an international brand. The intention at the outset was to develop this brand to the international market. South Africa is a market well known for its acceptance and critical evaluation of brands, as are parts of North America, Belgium and The Netherlands. Therefore, as a strategy, the launch of the brand in South Africa was intentional rather than a necessity.That the company is an active member of the Franchise Association of South Africa (FASA) and has been awarded the following FASA awards:• Winner of the Newcomer of the Year (2000)• Winner of the Brandbuilder of the Year (2003)• Finalist of the Franchisor of the Year (2004)That the company has also won other awards such as:• Institute Marketing Managements Marketer of the Year (2002)•Winner of the "Leisure Section" Top Company of the TOP 300 COMPANIES (2005)•Recorded in the Superbrands Journal as one of the most recognized and sought after brands.Mugg & Bean franchisees have also won a number of awards including FASA's Franchisee of the Year award.That as a result of the review of the companies business model, the decision was taken not to enter the Australian market until such time as the flaw relating to high labour costs could be dealt with. It would be extremely dangerous to enter the market as a franchise operation where the business model is not appropriate.That the company has at all times viewed Australia as an important market for the brand, and intends to promote the brand in Australia shortly.That the company did examine the Middle Eastern markets, such as the United Arab Emirates, and subsequently, in collaboration with a group based in Abudhabi, the company has opened two stores in that city, three in Dubai, and one in Bahrain. A store is soon to open in Kuwait. The company also has one store open in Jeddah, with another store to follow during the course of this year.That the company has begun franchising the concept in the United Kingdom, with three stores set to open over the course of the next 18 months.That the development of the brand in North America is well advanced, with significant demand in Vancouver (where the company has an office) and Toronto.That attached hereto and marked "Exhibit 1" is a schedule of all MUG N BEAN trade marks and derivatives thereof registered, or pending, throughout the world.That from inception of the MUG N BEAN trade mark in 1992, approximately AU$ 17,000,000.00 has been spent on the marketing and advertising of this the companies flagship brand.That the company uses all forms of media to promote its brand, including television, radio, and print.That the company has allocated in excess of AUD 220,300.00 towards the advertising and marketing of the MUG N BEAN trade mark worldwide.That since its inception, the company has reached a total turnover of AU$1.5 billion worldwide.That because of the extensive use of the trade mark throughout the world, including Europe and South Africa, many Australian residents would be familiar with the mark as a result of their international travels.That because of the extensive use of the trade mark, inquiries regarding potential franchising of the MUGG & BEAN brand are received from all over the world, including the European Union, North America and Australasia.That Article 6bis of the Convention of Paris for the Protection of Intellectual Property (the "Paris Convention") provides that a convention country, as Australia is, must afford protection to the proprietor of a well known trade mark, where a third party seeks to use a trade mark that constitutes, or the essential part of which constitutes, a reproduction, imitation or translation of the well known trade mark, where such reproduction, imitation or translation is liable to create confusion.That I believe the Applicant's non-use removal action has been initiated in bad faith, and in a deliberate attempt to take unfair advantage of the distinctive character and international reputation in the company's well known MUG N BEAN trade mark.That in the circumstances, the Registrar ought to exercise her discretion and refuse to remove the registered trade mark.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established