Shani Southwell v New Horizons Enterprises Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
[2022] FWC 1740

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Shani Southwell
v

New Horizons Enterprises Ltd

(U2022/2454)

Stephen Prager
v

New Horizons Enterprises Ltd

(U2022/2827)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT EASTON

SYDNEY, 6 JULY 2022

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – section 596 – representation by lawyers and paid agents – permission to be represented granted.

  1. Ms Shani Southwell and Mr Stephen Prager separately made applications for unfair dismissal remedies against New Horizons Enterprises Limited.

  1. New Horizons Enterprises Limited (“New Horizons”) has sought the permission of the Commission to be represented by a lawyer pursuant to s.596 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW Act). This decision deals only with New Horizons’ application.

  1. Section 596 of the FW Act is relevantly in the following terms:

    “596      Representation by lawyers and paid agents

    (1)       Except as provided by subsection (3) or the procedural rules, a person may be represented in a matter before the FWC (including by making an application or submission to the FWC on behalf of the person) by a lawyer or paid agent only with the permission of the FWC.

    (2)       The FWC may grant permission for a person to be represented by a lawyer or paid agent in a matter before the FWC only if:

    (a)       it would enable the matter to be dealt with more efficiently, taking into account the complexity of the matter; or

    (b)       it would be unfair not to allow the person to be represented because the person is unable to represent himself, herself or itself effectively; or

    (c)       it would be unfair not to allow the person to be represented taking into account fairness between the person and other persons in the same matter.

    Note:   Circumstances in which the FWC might grant permission for a person to be represented by a lawyer or paid agent include the following:

    (a)       where a person is from a non English speaking background or has difficulty reading or writing;

    (b)       where a small business is a party to a matter and has no specialist human resources staff while the other party is represented by an officer or employee of an industrial association or another person with experience in workplace relations advocacy.”

  1. New Horizons relies on each of the subsections in s.596(2).

  1. The following general principles can be drawn from earlier decisions of the Commission and of the Federal Court on permission to appear:

(a)the default position is that each party appears on their own behalf;[1]

(b)permission may be granted “only if” at least one of the requirements of s.596(2) are made out;

(c)the assessment of whether permission should be granted under s 596 involves a two-step process: firstly considering whether one or more of the criteria in s 596(2) is satisfied, and secondly considering whether the Commission’s discretion should be exercised in favour of the party seeking permission in all of the circumstances of the case;[2]

(d)a decision to grant or refuse permission is not a mere…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shani Southwell v New Horizons Enterprises Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FWC 1740
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shani Southwell and Stephen Prager have separately applied for unfair dismissal remedies against New Horizons Enterprises Limited. New Horizons has sought permission from the Fair Work Commission to be represented by a lawyer under section 596 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The Deputy President, Easton, granted permission in a decision delivered on 6 July 2022. The applicants were both dismissed from their roles in disability services, which were subject to public health orders requiring vaccination against COVID-19. They were not vaccinated and were subsequently dismissed. The applicants are represented by Alex Smith, who insists he is not a lawyer or a paid agent. New Horizons argued that the applicants’ cases rely on complex legal issues that require the assistance of legal representation to be efficiently addressed. The Deputy President accepted that the applicants’ cases involve complex legal issues and granted permission for New Horizons to be represented by a lawyer.

The Deputy President noted that the default position is that each party appears on their own behalf and that permission may be granted if it would enable the matter to be dealt with more efficiently, it would be unfair not to allow the person to be represented, or it would be unfair not to allow the person to be represented taking into account fairness between the person and other persons in the same matter. The Deputy President found that the applicants’ cases involve complex legal issues that would benefit from legal representation and that there are greater prospects of the case being run more efficiently and focused on the relevant issues to be determined if permission is granted.

The Deputy President granted permission for New Horizons to be represented by a lawyer. The decision highlights the importance of the Fair Work Commission’s role in ensuring that proceedings are fair, just, quick, informal, and avoid unnecessary technicalities. The decision also emphasises the importance of ensuring that legal representatives conduct themselves with probity, candour, and honesty and give close regard to the boundaries of the matters subject to the dispute. The Deputy President’s decision to grant permission for New Horizons to be represented by a lawyer ensures that the matter will be dealt with more efficiently and focused on the relevant issues to be determined.

The Fair Work Commission’s decision to grant permission for New Horizons to be represented by a lawyer ensures that the matter will be dealt with more efficiently and focused on the relevant issues to be determined. The decision highlights the importance of ensuring that proceedings are fair, just, quick, informal, and avoid unnecessary technicalities. The decision also emphasises the importance of ensuring that legal representatives conduct themselves with probity, candour, and honesty and give close regard to the boundaries of the matters subject to the dispute. The decision is a useful reminder of the importance of ensuring that legal representatives are familiar with and/or experienced in the Fair Work Commission’s jurisdiction.