Shane Andrew Watson v. Bristol-myers Company

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952 - and - In the Matter of Patent Application 42190/78 in the Name of SHANE ANDREW WATSON - and - In the Matter of an Application for Extension of Time under Section 160 - and - In the Matter of an Opposition thereto by BRISTOL-MYERS COMPANY.

 

DECISION OF A SUPERVISING EXAMINER OF PATENTS:

Background

Patent application 31301/77 in the name of Dr. Shane Watson was lodged on 7 December, 1977, accompanied by a complete specification. Following a request under section 42 that the complete specification be treated as a provisional specification, a further complete specification was lodged on 30 November, 1978, at which time the present application number was allotted to the application. The claims of that complete specification are directed to "a method for prophylaxis against human cancer".

Following examination of the application and complete specification a first (adverse) examiner's report issued on 2 July, 1981. The time for acceptance of the application was extended under sub-section 54(lB) to 2 April, 1983 - the maximum extension allowable under that sub-section. On 15 December, 1983 the time for acceptance was extended under sub-section 160(1) to 23 December, 1983 . The application has not yet been accepted. On 23 December, 1983 the then attorneys for Dr. Watson lodged an application, under sub-section 160(2), for a two month extension of the time for acceptance to 23 February, 1984. On the same date Dr. Watson lodged an application for "an extension of the period of acceptance of three months from 30 December, 1983 to 30 March, 1984". On 23 March, 1984 Dr. Watson lodged a substitute application under sub-section 160(2) for "an extension of the period of acceptance of a further three months from 23 March, 1984, that is from 23 December, 1983 to 23 March, 1984 and from 23 March, 1984 to 23 June, 1984". On 17 April this Office advised Dr. Watson that your request for a second period extension of time to the 23 June, 1984 has to be considered with your first period extension to 23 March, 1984. In these circumstances, it is necessary to advertise the application under Section 160 for opposition purposes. The application will be advertised in the Official Journal of Patents, Trade Marks and Designs dated 3 May, 1984". The application for extension of time was duly advertised, and was opposed by the Bristol-Myers Company ("Bristol Myers") on 1 June, 1984. This opposition to the application for extension of time was the subject of a hearing in Melbourne on 8 March, 1985 when the applicant appeared in person and the opponent was represented by Mr. M.J. Royal, Patent Attorney, of Phillips, Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, Melbourne.

Locus Standi of the Opponent

It is necessary for an opponent to an application for extension of time to show locus standi: in this case the evidence lodged by Bristol-Myers in support of the opposition shows that Dr. Watson brought an action against them in the High Court on 31 March, 1983…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shane Andrew Watson v. Bristol-myers Company and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1985] APO 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision involves an application for an extension of time for patent acceptance by Shane Andrew Watson, opposed by Bristol-Myers Company. The Supervising Examiner of Patents, J.L. Roveta, was tasked with determining whether the application for extension should be granted under section 160 of the Patents Act 1952. The legal issues revolved around whether Dr. Watson's circumstances justified an extension of time, whether the application was properly filed, and if the extension should be granted despite the opposition.

Dr. Watson had previously applied for an extension under section 160(1), which was granted but expired on 23 December 1983. He subsequently applied for further extensions, which were opposed by Bristol-Myers. The court had to determine if Dr. Watson had established "circumstances beyond the control of the person concerned" as per section 160(2)(b). This involved assessing Dr. Watson's preoccupation with other legal matters and his physical disability from a car accident.

The court concluded that Dr. Watson's inability to meet the acceptance deadline was due to circumstances beyond his control, including his preoccupation with other legal actions and his physical disability. The court also ruled that the application for extension was effective and properly filed. Despite the opposition, the court found it unjust to deny the extension, as the application had lapsed during the opposition process. Therefore, the court granted the extension up to three months from the date of the decision and awarded costs to Dr. Watson for his out-of-pocket expenses.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established