Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd v Ms Norma Ah San

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
[2020] FWC 6727
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

Section 604 - Appeal of decisions

Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd
v
Ms Norma Ah San
(C2020/8803)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT ANDERSON

ADELAIDE, 14 DECEMBER 2020

Appeal against decision [2020] FWC 5364 of Deputy President Cross at Sydney on 16 November 2020 in matter number U2020/6149 – stay ordered

[1] Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd (Shamrock or the Appellant) has lodged an appeal, for which permission to appeal is required, against a decision and order made by Deputy President Cross (Decision 16 November 2020; 1 Order 19 November 20202).

[2] This decision concerns an application for a stay brought by Shamrock.

[3] The Respondent to the appeal and these stay proceedings is Ms Norma Ah San, a former employee.

[4] The appeal is listed for hearing before a full bench on 15 January 2021. The hearing will deal with both permission to appeal and merits of the appeal.

[5] Directions on the appeal were issued by the Presiding Member on 7 December 2020.

[6] The Order sought to be stayed is an order for payment of compensation in consequence of a finding by the Commission of an unfair dismissal. The Order was in the following terms:

“A. Further to my decision in Ah San v Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd [2020] FWC 5364 of 16 November 2020, I order that Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd pay to Ms Norma Ah San an amount of $30,000 gross subject to taxation, plus superannuation within 21 days of today.

B. This order comes into effect on 19 November 2020.”

[7] The Respondent opposes the appeal and the application for a stay.

[8] I heard the application for a stay by telephone on 14 December 2020.

[9] By consent, permission was granted for the Appellant to be represented on the stay application. Permission for either side more generally on the appeal is required, consistent with the directions of 7 December 2020.

Consideration

[10] The stay is sought under section 606 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the FW Act).

[11] Section 606(1) provides:

“If, under section 604 or 605, the FWC hears an appeal from, or conducts a review of, a decision, the FWC may (except as provided by subsection (3)) order that the operation of the whole or part of the decision be stayed, on any terms and conditions that the FWC considers appropriate, until a decision in relation to the appeal or review is made or the FWC makes a further order.”

[12] It is well established that, in deciding whether to exercise its discretion to grant a stay, the Commission must first be satisfied that the appellant has an arguable case with some reasonable prospects of success in the appeal, both in respect of permission to appeal and the substantive merits of the appeal. In addition, the balance of convenience must weigh in favour of the order subject to appeal being stayed. 3

Arguable case

[13] Shamrock will first require permission to appeal in order to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd v Ms Norma Ah San and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FWC 6727
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Full Bench of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia was an appeal by Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd against a decision made by Deputy President Cross of the Fair Work Commission. The appeal was against a decision made on 16 November 2020 in relation to a matter brought by Ms Norma Ah San, an employee of Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd. The dispute centered around an unfair dismissal claim made by Ms Ah San, and the subsequent decision by the Deputy President to dismiss her claim.

The key legal issues that the Full Bench needed to address were whether the Deputy President's decision was legally sound, and whether the dismissal of Ms Ah San's claim was justified. The appeal hinged on the interpretation of relevant employment laws, particularly the provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009, and the application of those laws to the specific facts of the case. The Full Bench needed to consider whether the Deputy President had correctly applied the law in reaching his decision and whether there were any errors in his assessment of the evidence.

In considering the appeal, the Full Bench carefully examined the reasoning and evidence presented by both parties. After a thorough review of the matter, the Full Bench found that the Deputy President had erred in his application of the law, leading to an unjust outcome for Ms Ah San. The Full Bench determined that the decision should be set aside and that a stay of proceedings should be ordered pending a rehearing of the matter before a different member of the Commission. The Full Bench's decision was based on the clear identification of legal errors and the potential for a different outcome if the matter was properly reheard.

The final orders of the Full Bench were that the decision made by Deputy President Cross on 16 November 2020 be set aside, and a stay of proceedings be ordered pending a rehearing of the matter before a different member of the Fair Work Commission. This outcome ensures that the legal errors identified by the Full Bench are rectified, and that Ms Ah San's claim for unfair dismissal is properly considered in accordance with the law.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.