Shahin Enterprises Pty Ltd v Development Assessment Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

SHAHIN ENTERPRISES PTY LTD v DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT COMMISSION

[2019] SASCFC 44

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Vanstone, The Honourable Justice Kelly and The Honourable Justice Blue)

6 May 2019

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY - CONSIDERATION OF PARTICULAR PLANNING MATTERS - AMENITY

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY - CONSIDERATION OF PARTICULAR MATTERS - TRAFFIC AND PARKING

Appeal by Shahin Enterprises Pty Ltd against dismissal by Environment Resources and Development Court of its appeal against the refusal by the Development Assessment Commission of planning consent in respect of the proposed development of a service station complex on the corner of Kensington Road and May Terrace, Kensington Park.

The City of Burnside Development Plan contains Principle 1 for the Neighbourhood Centre Zone Policy Area 1 which provides that development should comprise small-scale development which amongst other things has minimal impact on the free flow of traffic on Kensington Road and minimal impact on the amenity of residential premises within the locality.

The Environment Court concluded that the proposed development would not have minimal impact on the amenity of residential premises in May Terrace and would not have minimal impact on the free flow of traffic on Kensington Road.

Shahin contends that the Court made various errors of law in reaching its conclusions on these two issues and seeks permission to appeal on two questions of fact. It also contends that the Court erred in law in failing to give adequate reasons for accepting the evidence of the expert witness Ms Mellen concerning tankers encountering difficulties when attempting to exit from the service station onto May Terrace which was contrary to the evidence of Mr Morris.

Held per Blue J (Vanstone and Kelly JJ agreeing) dismissing the appeal:

1. The Court did not make errors of law as alleged in reaching its conclusion that the proposed development would not have minimal impact on the amenity of residential premises in May Terrace:

(a) on its proper construction, the reference in Principle 1(d) to “the amenity of residential premises within the locality” is not confined to the perception of the development from within the boundaries of the residential premises in question but encompasses the perception of residents of such premises when travelling to and from such residential premises (at [32]);

(b) the Court did not erroneously conflate the concept of maintaining existing character contained in Council-wide Principles 56 and 57 with the concept of minimising impact on amenity of residential premises contained in Principle 1(d) (at [36]);

(c) the Court did not err in law by taking into account the significant setbacks of houses on May Terrace in contrast with the lack of any setback from May Terrace of the proposed development (at [37]);

(d) Shahin has failed to establish that the Court did not take into account the scale and setback of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shahin Enterprises Pty Ltd v Development Assessment Commissi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASCFC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shahin Enterprises Pty Ltd (Shahin) appealed to the Environment Court against the Development Assessment Commission's refusal of development plan consent for a petrol filling station. The proposed development involved the demolition of existing structures and the construction of a control building, five fuel dispensers, and dog wash bays on land at the north-eastern corner of Kensington Road and May Terrace. The appeal was heard de novo, with extensive expert evidence presented on traffic engineering, retail economics, urban design, and town planning.

The legal issues before the Supreme Court of South Australia concerned whether the Environment Court erred in fact and law in its assessment of the proposed development's impact. Specifically, Shahin contended that the Environment Court incorrectly concluded that a queuing vehicle might obstruct traffic on Kensington Road, that multiple occasions of two vehicles queuing behind fuel bowsers were likely, and that the proposal would significantly adversely impact the free flow of traffic on Kensington Road. Shahin also argued that the Environment Court erred by having regard to evidence regarding a Department of Planning, Transport and Infrastructure (DPTI) specification that was not formally tendered.

The Court found that the Environment Court did not err in its assessment of traffic impacts. It clarified that the obstruction to Kensington Road traffic was not caused by a queuing vehicle itself, but by another vehicle stopping on Kensington Road to enter the service station. The Court also held that the Environment Court was entitled to rely on expert evidence regarding the likelihood of queuing vehicles and potential obstructions to footpaths, even if documentary evidence of a DPTI policy was not produced. The Court noted that the Environment Court's conclusions were based on the evidence of traffic engineers regarding vehicle dimensions and queuing protocols, and the specific configuration of the proposed development.

The Court dismissed Shahin's contentions regarding the traffic impacts and the consideration of the DPTI specification. It also found that the Environment Court did not err in its assessment of amenity impacts on residences in May Terrace, noting that the setbacks on Kensington Road had little bearing on this assessment. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents do not oppose the proposed amendments to ground 3 but oppose the proposed amendment to add additional ground 2.5. I would grant permission to amend in all three respects because the respondents will not suffer prejudice by reason of the late application to amend.Background In September 2016 Shahin applied for development plan consent for demolition of existing improvements and construction of a petrol filling station on land situated on the north-eastern corner of Kensington Road and May Terrace Kensington Park (the Land). The application was opposed by the second respondent the City of Burnside (the Council) and the third respondent Defence Housing Australia (DHA). In June 2017 the Commission refused development plan consent for the proposed development. In July 2017 Shahin appealed to the Environment Court against the refusal pursuant to section 86 of the Development Act 1993 (SA) (the Act). It is common ground that the appeal was to be heard de novo. In May 2018 the Environment Court heard the appeal. The Court was constituted of a Judge and two Commissioners. Evidence was given by Philip Moir, a business development manager employed by Shahin. Expert evidence was given by:·three consultant traffic engineers: Paul Morris called by Shahin, Benjamin Wilson called by the Commission and Melissa Mellen called by the Council/DHA (who were jointly represented by the same solicitors and counsel);·two retail/economic experts: Geoffrey Hayter called by Shahin and James Atkinson called by the Council/DHA;·two urban design experts: Jason Schulz called by Shahin and Douglas Alexander called by the Council/DHA; and·two town planning experts: Michael Osborn called by Shahin and Christopher Vounasis called by the Council/DHA. The proposed development, as finalised at the time of the hearing of the appeal to the Environment Court, can be summarised as follows. The Land is broadly rectangular, with a frontage to Kensington Road of 30.6 metres, frontage to May Terrace of 29.2 metres and total area of approximately 920 square metres. A rectangular control building comprising 211 square metres would be constructed with its back wall on the May Terrace boundary and windows at the front overlooking the bowsers. The back wall would run for approximately 70 per cent of the May Terrace boundary and would be between 4.6 and 6.6 metres high. It would have a shorter side wall on the Kensington Road boundary. It would have a serving counter; supermarket shelves; fast food and coffee preparation area; cool rooms, freezers and storage area; toilets and office. Vehicles would enter only from Kensington Road and exit only onto May Terrace. The proposed service station would have five fuel dispensers. A single sided fuel bowser with a set of hoses on its right hand (eastern) side only (the western dispenser) would be constructed to the east of the control building, leaving a gap between the control building and bowser to allow cars to travel to the rear to park to enter the shop or to use the dog wash at the rear. Two double sided fuel bowsers one behind the other would be constructed to the east of the single sided fuel bowser. There would be one set of hoses on their left hand side (the middle dispensers). There would be one set of hoses on their right hand side (the eastern dispensers). There would be two coin-operated dog wash bays in the right hand rear (north-eastern) corner. There would be car parks for eight vehicles, mainly at the rear.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Shahin contends that the Environment Court erred in fact and law in concluding that arguably this was a situation of the kind referred to by Bleby J in Wong.[12] For the reasons given above, the conclusion of the Environment Court that it would be the development that would be the operative cause of the behaviour in question was not only not affected by legal error but was also correct. Permission to appeal on a question of fact should be refused. [12] Ground 3.6(c).Evidence of DPTI specification Shahin contends that the Environment Court erred in law by having regard to evidence by Ms Mellen about a DPTI specification which was not produced or tendered or referred to in the formal report of the Commissioner of Highways on mandatory referral of the proposal.[13] [13] Ground 3.3. Ms Mellen gave evidence that the Department of Planning, Transport and Infrastructure has “specified” that it seeks to accommodate a two vehicle queue behind a vehicle refuelling at a bowser being adequately provided on site. Ms Mellen was cross-examined in relation to this and clarified that it is a guide or policy and not a standard. No objection was made by Shahin to Ms Mellen’s evidence on the ground that documentary evidence of the policy was not produced or tendered or on any other ground. Although the report by the Commissioner of Highways did not refer to the policy, that did not evidence that it did not exist. In these circumstances, the Environment Court would have committed no error of law if it had relied on Ms Mellen’s evidence about the Department’s policy. However, and any event, it is plain from the passage of the Court’s reasons extracted above that the Court did not rely on the DPTI policy but rather on the evidence of Mr Morris and Ms Mellen about the need to accommodate a two vehicle queue behind a vehicle refuelling at a bowser.Errors in fact and law in reaching conclusions Shahin contends that the Environment Court erred in fact and law in concluding:(a)that a single second queuing vehicle which in part might overhang the footpath would obstruct traffic on Kensington Road,(b)that there would be multiple occasions when two vehicles will be queued behind either or both fuel bowsers,(c)that the proposal would result in significant adverse impacts on the free flow of traffic on Kensington Road, when such a conclusion was not reasonably open on the expert evidence.[14] [14] Grounds 3.6(a) and (b) and 3.5. The first contention is misconceived: the Court did not find that the second queuing vehicle would itself obstruct the free flow of traffic on Kensington Road: this was merely a step towards the obstruction caused by another vehicle stopping on Kensington Road to enter the service station. Shahin also contends that a second queuing vehicle might not overhang the footpath depending on its length and the position of vehicles and refers to the fact that by definition a B85 vehicle is longer than the average (median) vehicle. However, the clear evidence of Ms Mellen (and indeed Mr Morris) was that traffic engineers typically design for B85 vehicles. Ms Mellen gave evidence that a second queuing vehicle might be longer than a B85 vehicle and the spaces between vehicles could be greater than she assumed. There was no error of law made by the Environment Court in finding that a second queuing vehicle might overhang the footpath.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Court was concerned with the amenity of residences in May Terrace which is a residential suburban street. The existence and extent of setbacks on Kensington Road, a major semi-commercial road and thoroughfare, has virtually no impact on that assessment of amenity. The mixed character of the building setbacks along Kensington Road was obvious. The Court did not deny that mixed character nor reject evidence by Mr Osborne that there was such a mixed character.Conclusion on amenity Ground 2 is not established.Impact on Kensington Road traffic Grounds 3.1 to 3.6 relate to the Court’s conclusion that the proposed development would have an adverse impact on the free flow of traffic on Kensington Road. Ms Mellen gave evidence that Kensington Road is an arterial road with an annual average daily traffic volume of approximately 15,600 vehicles. She described a protocol adopted by traffic engineers of identifying the dimensions of vehicles by reference to vehicles falling within different percentiles of the vehicle population. A B35 vehicle is a vehicle falling at the 35th percentile and is regarded as being 4.5 metres long. A B85 vehicle is a vehicle falling at the 85th percentile and is regarded as being 4.9 metres long. A B99 vehicle is a vehicle falling at the 99th percentile and is regarded as being 5.2 metres long. Traffic engineers typically design for a B85 vehicle. Mr Morris referred in his report to a survey undertaken over a 24 hour period at the OTR service station at Thorngate, which has eight fuel dispensers arranged as two pairs of double sided fuel bowsers with two rear bowsers behind each of the two front bowsers. The survey showed that there was one occasion when one vehicle was queued waiting for a rear bowser to become free and six occasions when two vehicles were queued (one behind the other) waiting for a rear bowser to become free. Mr Morris estimated that the proposed Kensington service station would generate about 15 to 20 more vehicles per hour than the Thorngate service station during the afternoon peak. Ms Mellen prepared diagrams showing that one vehicle could queue behind a vehicle refilling at the western dispenser but if a second vehicle attempted to queue behind that first queuing vehicle, it would obstruct the passing lane leading to the rear of the service station. The diagram showed that if there was one vehicle queued behind two vehicles refilling at the middle dispensers and another vehicle attempted to queue behind that first queuing vehicle, it would obstruct the crossover (the footpath). Similarly, if there was one vehicle queued behind two vehicles refilling at the eastern dispensers and another vehicle attempted to queue behind that first queuing vehicle, it would obstruct the footpath. Ms Mellen gave evidence that it is a breach of the Australian Road Rules to obstruct the footpath. Ms Mellen gave evidence that, if there were eight vehicles refilling or queuing at the service station, a ninth vehicle attempting to enter the service station would obstruct the footpath. Each of the dispensers would not have hoses with all different fuels types (evidence was given that the service station would offer unleaded petrol, premium 95 petrol, premium 98 petrol, diesel and LPG). Some vehicles have their filling points on the left and others on the right and drivers generally prefer to have the dispenser on the same side as their filling point. Accordingly, there could be a second queued vehicle obstructing the footpath even if there was a vacancy at a dispenser if it had hoses on the wrong side or not offering the required fuel type.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established