SFVY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SFVY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2022] AATA 721 (11 April 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2021/4076          

Re:SFVY  

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndYWMN

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Damien Cremean, Senior Member

Date:11 April 2022

Place:Melbourne

1.The Decision under review is set aside and in substitution a determination is made as follows:

(a)  As regards the period from 8 April to 7 June 2020 I make a determination of care of 100% in favour of SFVY and 0% in respect of YWMN

(b)  As regards the period from 8 June to 8 October 2020 I make a determination of care of 70% in favour of SFVY and 30% in respect of YWMN

2.Such decision takes effect from 18 February 2021.

...............................[SDG]...................................

Dr Damien Cremean, Senior Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT—percentage of care—pattern of care—delegated care—relevance of financial support—relevance of emotional support—decision set aside.

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)Legislation

CASES

P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312

Polec and Staker [2011] FMCA fam 1398

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Damien Cremean, Senior Member

Introduction

  1. The Applicant (SFVY), mother of minor child (“T”) applies to review a decision of the Social Services & Child Support Division (Tier 1) of this Tribunal dated 21 May 2021 setting aside a decision upon review dated 7 September 2020 and substituting a decision that from


    8 April 2020 she had 81% and the Other Party (YWMN), T’s father had 19% of the care of T.

  2. Tier 1 also decided not to make a determination under s 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (“1988 Act”), with the consequence that the date of effect of its decision was 18 February 2021 which was the date on which YWMN lodged his application with Tier 1.

  3. SFVY and YWMN are the separated parents of T.

  4. The dispute between SFVY and YWMN is (I agree with the Respondent) essentially a dispute between them as to the circumstances surrounding care provided to T during the period from 8 April 2020 to 8 October 2020 (“relevant period”). But in respect of that relevant period there are two distinct periods of time involved—one during school boarding time and one away from school.

    Hearing

  5. The hearing in this matter took place on 25 November 2021.

  6. At the hearing both SFVY and YWMN were self-represented, and each gave affirmed evidence and cross-examined the other.

  7. The Respondent was represented by Mr Cummings, lawyer of Sparke Helmore Lawyers.  While he did ask some questions of the parties and make submissions, he adopted, quite properly, a position of neutrality.

  8. After the hearing, both SFVY and YWMN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SFVY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 721
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support assessment before Senior Member Dr Damien Cremean. The dispute centred on the percentage of care each parent, SFVY and YWMN, had of their child, T, during the period of 8 April 2020 to 8 October 2020. The parents had formally separated on 8 April 2020, and there was significant ill-will and limited contact between T and YWMN thereafter.

The Senior Member was required to determine the applicable section of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1989 (Cth) for assessing the percentage of care and, consequently, to make a new determination of the care percentages for the relevant period. This involved considering the evidence presented by both parents regarding T's living arrangements, including periods at boarding school and during COVID-19 restrictions, and the communication between the parents and the Child Support Registrar regarding care changes.

In reaching his decision, the Senior Member applied section 54H of the Act, which directs consideration of the relevant period for determining the percentage of care. He found both parents to be truthful witnesses and had regard to the principles outlined in *Polec and Staker* [2011] FMCA fam 1398. The Senior Member determined that the initial administrative care determination of 15 May 2020, which had been subsequently altered and then erroneously re-issued, did not accurately reflect the pattern of care.

Consequently, the Senior Member revoked the previous determination and made new findings. From 8 April 2020 to 7 June 2020, SFVY was determined to have 100% care and YWMN 0%. From 8 June 2020 to 8 October 2020, SFVY was determined to have 70% care and YWMN 30%. This new determination was made effective from 18 February 2021, in accordance with section 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

The case pertains to the determination of care percentages between SFVY and YWMN for their child T. The parents formally separated on 8 April 2020, and since then, T has not resided with YWMN or had contact with him, causing significant emotional distress to YWMN. The separation was the result of long-standing issues, including disagreements over living arrangements. During the relevant period, T was either at boarding school or residing with SFVY. YWMN has faced various difficulties, such as medical conditions and COVID-19 ramifications, while SFVY has been working part-time in sales.

Initially, an administrative determination on 15 May 2020 allocated 100% care to SFVY and 0% to YWMN, effective from 8 April 2020. However, this decision was revoked the same day and replaced with a new determination that assigned 51% care to SFVY and 49% to YWMN, effective from 26 April 2020. This change followed YWMN's notification of a care change. On 10 June 2020, SFVY objected to the second determination, asserting that T was solely in her care from 8 April to 7 June 2020. YWMN responded that T would be at boarding school from 9 June 2020 until 8 September 2020 and that he would pay for T’s care during this period.

On 17 August 2020, SFVY informed the Respondent that T would be living at home with her due to COVID-19 restrictions. However, on 19 August 2020, YWMN notified the Respondent that T would spend six weeks at home, with two weeks with him and four weeks with SFVY. This was followed by SFVY's notification on 31 August 2020 that there was no arrangement for T to spend time with YWMN. Subsequently, an officer of the Respondent erroneously allowed SFVY's objection but failed to change the care percentages set by the 15 May 2020 decision, incorrectly stating that the care percentages were 100% to SFVY and 0% to YWMN, when they should have been 50% to each from 26 April 2020.

This case before the court concerns a second review of a child support determination, initiated by SFVY, seeking to overturn the initial percentage of care determinations made by the Child Support Registrar. The matter originated from a decision rendered on 15 May 2020, which determined the percentages of care between SFVY and YWMN in relation to their child, T. This initial decision was subsequently altered on the same date, reducing SFVY's care percentage to 51% and increasing YWMN's to 49%. The changes followed a notification from YWMN regarding a change in care arrangements. SFVY contested the revised percentages, arguing that there was no shared care arrangement and that T had been solely in her care from 8 April 2020 to 7 June 2020. This contention was further complicated by various notifications regarding T's living arrangements, including periods at boarding school and at home with either parent, influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic. The procedural history involves multiple notifications, objections, and corrections regarding the care percentages, culminating in the erroneous issuance of a decision reflecting the initial percentages despite the intended adjustments.

The procedural journey of this case has seen numerous notifications and objections exchanged between SFVY and YWMN, leading to several amendments and corrections in the care determinations. The erroneous allowance of SFVY's objection on 7 September 2020 without the appropriate adjustment to the care percentages further complicated the matter. This procedural misstep led to the current review, where the court was tasked with re-evaluating the evidence and circumstances surrounding the care of T during the specified period. The court's review aimed to ascertain the correct percentages of care attributable to each parent, considering the various notifications, objections, and the overall context of the parents' separation and its impact on T. The ultimate goal of this review was to ensure that the child support determination accurately reflected the realities of T's care situation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I make findings of fact to give effect to the above, and as to the matters set out in particular in paras 44-51. These factual findings underly an overall finding that, in light of the evidence given to me, percentages of care have changed during the relevant period. I have had regard to the matters addressed in Polec and Staker [2011] FMCA fam 1398, to which I was referred. I must indicate in that regard that I found both SFVY and YWMN to be truthful witnesses in matters of concern to me.DECISION As a result, I am satisfied that under the 1989 Act, in particular s 54H, the determination made on 15 May 2020 must be revoked. Acting under the provisions of the 1989 Act, including s 50, I am satisfied a different percentage of care determination must be made in respect of the relevant period—being the care period of concern to me in this proceeding. From 8 April 2020 until 7 June 2020, I make a determination of 100% in favour of SFVY and 0% in respect of YWMN. And from 8 June 2020 until 8 October 2020, I make a determination of 70% in favour of SFVY and 30% in respect of YWMN. I am required also to make a determination as to the date of effect of the percentage of care determination I have now made. I have considered the application of s 95N(2) of the 1988 Act, and I am unable to identify any facts or factors which would warrant me departing from the aspect of the decision of Tier 1 which relates to its date of effect; so that the determination made by me takes effect from 18 February 2021.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I shall set out that evidence in the context of considering these issues and not separately, as the dispute between the parties is quite well defined.Consideration As regards (a) above I agree with the Respondent that s 54G does not apply by virtue of s 54G(1)(a) of the 1989 Act. Further, I agree with the Respondent also that s 54F does not apply except as below. It remains then to consider the application of s 54H relating to percentage of care. In determining that question I am directed to the relevant period which, as I have noted, is 8 April 2020 to 8 October 2020. Both SFVY and YWMN gave evidence in respect of the relevant period which includes both when T either was at boarding school or residing with SFVY. As it also happens, it appears that 8 April 2020 is the date when the parents formally separated. As T has not resided with YWMN since that time, or had much or any contact with him, YWMN is “shattered” as he describes it. YWMN says that T even has been “refusing to acknowledge me”. SFVY counters however that T does not have contact with YWMN in particular following “a degrading and embarrassing email” sent to family and friends. It appears that the separation between SFVY and YWMN may have been a long time in the making, focusing particularly on the location of living arrangements and related issues. Ill-will between them is still quite evident. YWMN has been self-employed in a business for some time but has faced various difficulties over time, including certain medical conditions for which he has had surgery (with more contemplated) and ramifications of COVID-19. SFVY has for a while been working part-time in a sales or sales-related position and had experience previously in the retail sector. An initial care determination administratively made on 15 May 2020 recorded SFVY as having 100% care and YWMN having 0% care of T from 8 April 2020 with effect from 20 April 2020. However, a second care determination made on the same date revoked that determination with effect from 25 April 2020, and determined that with effect from 26 April 2020 SFVY had 51% care and YWMN had 49% care. This second determination followed an approach by YWMN on 9 May 2020 notifying of a care change. On 10 June 2020 SFVY objected to the second determination and commented that there was “no shared care arrangement” and that between 8 April 2020 and 7 June 2020 T was solely in her care. The response of YWMN to this was that from 9 June 2020 until 8 September 2020 T was at boarding school and he would be paying for T’s care during this period. On 17 August 2020 SFVY notified the Respondent that T would be living at home with her (due to COVID-19 restrictions). But on 19 August 2020 YWMN notified the Respondent that T would be spending six weeks at home–being two weeks with him and four weeks with SFVY. However, on 31 August 2020 SFVY notified the Respondent that there was no arrangement for T to spend time with YWMN. There followed an erroneous allowance by an officer of the Respondent of the objection of SFVY but with no change made to care percentages set by the 15 May 2020 decision. It was issued on 7 September 2020 but in error stated the care percentages were 100% to SFVY and 0% to YWMN; whereas it should have been 50% to each from 26 April 2020, in accordance with SFVY’s notification to the respondent forwarded on 15 May 2020.