Seven Network v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Seven Network v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
 [2007] FCA 1929

JUDICIAL REVIEW – Special access undertaking – whether undertaking is subject to limitations – whether terms and conditions are inconsistent with standard access obligations

WORDS AND PHRASES – Digital Set Top Unit Service – declared service – access agreement – special access undertakings – terms and conditions – limitations – standard access obligations

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth)
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) s 5, s 10(2)(b), s 16
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B
Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) s 7, s 20, s 21, s 87
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 4, s 152AA, s 152AB, s 152AB(2), s 152AB(4), s 152AB(6), s 152AC, s 152AF(1), s 152AG, s 152AH, s 152AL(3), s 152AL(7), s 152AR, s 152AR(2), s 152AR(3), s 152AR(3)(a), s 152AR(4), s 152AY, s 152AY(2)(a), s 152AY(2)(b)(i), s 152BS(6A), s 152CBA, s 152CBA(3), s 152CBA(3)(a), s 152CBA(5), s 152CBC(2), s 152CBD(2), s 152CBD(2)(a), s 152CBD(2)(b), s 152CBF, s 152CE, s 152CGB, s 152CK, s 152CQ(5)

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564
Direct Factory Outlets Pty Ltd v Westfield Management Ltd (2003) 132 FCR 428
Lamb v Moss (1983) 49 ALR 533
Re Application for Review of the Decision by the Commonwealth Treasurer; Ex parte Australian Union of Students (1997) 147 ALR 458

SEVEN NETWORK LIMITED v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION, FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LTD AND FOXTEL CABLE TELEVISION PTY LTD
NSD 639 OF 2007

BUCHANAN J
12 DECEMBER 2007
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 639 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

SEVEN NETWORK LIMITED
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
First Respondent

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
Second Respondent

FOXTEL CABLE TELEVISION PTY LTD
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 DECEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant is to file short minutes of proposed orders to give effect to the accompanying Reasons for Judgment on or before 18 January, 2008.

2.The respondents, if they contend that the proposed orders do not reflect the Reasons  for Judgment, are to file alternative short minutes of proposed orders on or before 1 February, 2008.

3.Within the times limited by orders 1 and 2 the parties are to file short written submissions on costs.

4.The matter will be listed on a date to be fixed to take short oral submissions, if necessary, on any of those issues.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 639 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

SEVEN NETWORK LIMITED
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
First Respondent

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
Second Respondent

FOXTEL CABLE TELEVISION PTY LTD
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE:

12 DECEMBER 2007

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BUCHANAN J:

  1. Under the statutory scheme establish by Part XIC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seven Network v Australian Competition and Consumer Commissi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1929
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Seven Network v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, the dispute arose from a decision made by the ACCC regarding Foxtel's undertaking, which was challenged by Seven Network. The central issue in the case was whether certain clauses in the Digital Access Agreement (DAA) were limitations on the scope of the service to be provided by Foxtel, and if the ACCC's interpretation of these clauses was legally sound. The court was required to determine if the tying clauses represented limitations that would exclude the services from being considered 'declared services' under the relevant legislation. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the ACCC's decision to accept Foxtel's undertaking was consistent with its obligations and if the tying clauses were indeed limitations.

The court's reasoning focused on the distinction between limitations and terms and conditions within the DAA. It found that if the tying clauses were considered limitations, they would not affect the service becoming a declared service. The ACCC's interpretation of the clauses, which did not treat them as limitations, was consistent with the obligations under the Act. The court also examined Foxtel's position that the undertaking applied to all end-users, including non-subscribers. The analysis concluded that the tying clauses did not impose limitations that would exclude the services from being declared, thereby upholding the ACCC's decision. The court found that even if the clauses were viewed as limitations, the ACCC's acceptance of Foxtel's undertaking was still legally valid.

Following its reasoning, the court dismissed Seven Network's challenge and upheld the ACCC's decision. The final orders required Seven Network to file minutes of proposed orders based on the court's reasons for judgment by a specified date, and for the ACCC to respond if it disagreed with these orders. The parties were also required to file written submissions on costs and prepare for potential oral submissions on these issues.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant is to file short minutes of proposed orders to give effect to the accompanying Reasons for Judgment on or before 18 January, 2008.

2. The respondents, if they contend that the proposed orders do not reflect the Reasons for Judgment, are to file alternative short minutes of proposed orders on or before 1 February, 2008.

3. Within the times limited by orders 1 and 2 the parties are to file short written submissions on costs.

4. The matter will be listed on a date to be fixed to take short oral submissions, if necessary, on any of those issues.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BUCHANAN J
Another way of expressing what these arrangements, viewed both piecemeal and as a whole, entail is to say that Foxtel undertook only to supply to an access seeker the services which it supplies to itself. There would be no services supplied on request for the purpose of transmission to non-subscribers. The ACCC decision The ACCC issued the decision which is under challenge in the present proceeding in March 2007. On 15 December 2006 it had published the undertaking offered by Foxtel on the internet, published a Discussion Paper and invited submissions. Submissions were received from Foxtel and Seven Network. The decision is lengthy. It deals with a number of issues which do not arise for consideration in the present proceedings. Early in its decision the ACCC summarised its view about whether the tying clauses were consistent with s 152AR in the following way:‘… the tying clauses meet with the obligation to supply the active declared service whether or not the tying clauses are treated as limitations on the service. The Commission is satisfied that the Undertaking is consistent with the obligation to supply the active declared service.’ This passage in the ACCC decision masks the essential difference between limitations and terms and conditions. For reasons earlier explained, if the tying clauses represented limitations upon the service to be provided, the service would not, to that extent, become a declared service. No issue about consistency between the tying clauses and obligations to provide access to the declared service could arise. When it came to summarise Foxtel’s undertaking the ACCC said:‘Clauses 4.1(c)(i), 4.1(f), 11.1(d) and 11.1(e) of the DAA provide that Foxtel is only obliged to supply the Digital Set Top Unit Service where the Digital Set Top Unit to which the Digital Set Top Unit Service is to be supplied is actually in use by a subscriber for the reception of Foxtel’s digital subscription television services.However, Foxtel contends that the Undertaking is in respect of the service not only in relation to end users who are Foxtel subscribers, but also those end users who are currently not Foxtel subscribers. The Commission understands that Foxtel does not regard any of the above clauses as limitations upon the scope of the service for the purpose of subsections 152CBA(5) and 152AL(7).’ This passage accords with the position taken by Foxtel in this Court. In a passage shortly thereafter the ACCC said:‘As noted above, Foxtel does not regard clauses 4.1(c) and (f) of the DAA (the tying clauses) as a limitation on the Undertaking for the purpose of ss.152CBA(5) and 152AL(7) of the Act. On this interpretation, the deemed declared service pursuant to subsection 152AL(7) would be the Digital Set Top Unit Service to all end-users.If the Commission were to accept the Undertaking and an access dispute was notified under s.152CM in respect of Foxtel’s Digital Set Top Unit Service, the Commission would be precluded by s.152CQ(5) from making an arbitration determination that was inconsistent with the Undertaking. The Commission understands that Foxtel would considers [sic] that a determination could not oblige Foxtel to provide services or extend the facility to non-Foxtel homes.These provisions in the DAA, in effect, mean that Foxtel is not required to provide the Digital Set Top Unit Service unless there is a digital STU in use by a Foxtel subscriber. If that person ceases to be a Foxtel subscriber, Foxtel is not required to continue to supply the Digital Set Top Unit Service even if the subscriber wishes to continue to receive the access seeker’s service. Given that Foxtel subscribers must take Foxtel’s basic package to receive the Foxtel service and be provided with an STU, access seekers are only able to supply their services as a tiered channel to Foxtel’s Basic Package.’

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BUCHANAN J

In its submission opposing a declaration Foxtel also relied heavily upon the fact that, in its written submissions, Seven Network, argued:‘Further, and in the alternative, the Court has power to correct the Commission’s legal error by making a declaration that the Undertaking is subject to a limitation within the meaning of s152CBA(5) that confines the service the subject of the Undertaking to the STU service in Foxtel locations only: Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564 at 581; Direct Factory Outlets Pty Limited v Westfield Management Limited [2003] FCA 1095 at [15]; Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s21.’ (my emphasis) Foxtel sought to exploit this submission by submitting:‘FOXTEL submits that if the Court concludes that the Commission’s decision is not affected by legal error, the Court will have no jurisdiction to make the declaration sought. Seven does not contend otherwise; it correctly states that the Court “has power to correct … legal error by making a declaration”.’ It also submitted:‘… if the Court concludes that the Commission’s decision is not affected by legal error, the Court will confirm that it was not necessary for the Commission to determine whether the Undertaking is subject to a limitation, and that it is not necessary to make that determination in this proceeding.’ These submissions do not adequately reflect the jurisdiction and power of the Court to make a declaration or the circumstances in which it might, or might not, be appropriate to do so. Foxtel initially sought in its written submissions to reserve a right to make further submissions on the issue of whether a limitation exists in the event that I concluded there was a legal error in the ACCC decision on the consistency question. It said:‘In that event, whether or not the tying clauses should be characterised as a limitation will depend to some extent on the Court’s reasoning concerning the Commission’s error. However, FOXTEL submits that it is likely that in that event the tying clauses would be regarded as a limitation.’ In oral submissions, however, the position was expressed more definitively. Counsel for Foxtel submitted:‘MR MEAGHER: I should add this. That if your Honour was against us on inconsistency there would be no issue between the parties that it’s a limitation. We argued before the commission for a characterisation as not a limitation.…HIS HONOUR: Well, in the event that I am against you on the consistency argument what is your position then?MR MEAGHER: If your Honour was against us on that and the question was what your Honour should do, we would submit your Honour should address the limitation question and if your Honour was satisfied that it was a limitation your Honour wouldn’t upset the decision because your Honour would accept the commission was satisfied on that basis, there was no inconsistency. So that for that reason your Honour wouldn’t upset the decision to accept.…MR MEAGHER: If your Honour was against us on the consistency point in our submission it would be for reason that the provision was properly characterised as a limitation, in other words your Honour would be against us on that.HIS HONOUR: No, it would be on the assumption that it was not a limitation.MR MEAGHER: But it would follow in our submission that it should necessarily be characterised as a limitation which is Seven’s argument because the, yes, and on that basis it would follow that your Honour would not upset the commission’s decision.HIS HONOUR: So if inconsistent it must be a limitation?MR MEAGHER: That’s so. And then it would follow that your Honour wouldn’t, on that basis the commission was appropriately satisfied and your Honour wouldn’t upset the commission’s decision to accept.’