Settlers Cove Development Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1996] QCA 481
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 225 of 1995

Brisbane

Before Fitzgerald P.
McPherson J.A.
Helman J.

[Council of the Shire of Noosa v. Settlers Cove Development P/L & anor.]

BETWEEN:

COUNCIL OF THE SHIRE OF NOOSA

(Respondent) Appellant

AND:

SETTLERS COVE DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD

and R.F. THOMPSON (QLD) PTY LTD

(Appellants) Respondents

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - FITZGERALD P.

Judgment delivered 29 November 1996

The appellant, The Council of the Shire of Noosa (“the Council”), has appealed against a judgment of

the Planning & Environment Court delivered on 15 September 1995; the Planning & Environment Court

allowed an appeal by Settlers Cove Development Pty Ltd and R.M. Thompson (Qld.) Pty Ltd (“the

developers”) against the Council’s deemed refusal of a combined application for approval to subdivide

land described as Lot 2 on R.P. 801918, Parish of Weyba, and town planning consent to build a

multiple dwelling (36 units) on one of the new lots into which Lot 2 is proposed to be subdivided.
Lot 2 is part of a larger area of land owned by the developers, which is located between the Noosa

Inlet and two roads which connect with each other, Noosa Drive and Banksia Avenue. In 1989, part

of land then owned by the developers was subdivided into the present Lots 1 and 2. Lot 1, an area of

8126 sq.m. at the north-eastern corner of the original parcel, has frontages to Noosa Inlet and Banksia

Avenue and is the site of a three level, 45 unit multiple dwelling. The present subdivisional application

involves subdividing Lot 2 into Lots 2, 3 and 4; it is proposed that the new Lot 2 will abut the western

boundary of Lot 1 and have an area of 6380 sq.m., Lot 3 will abut the western boundary of the new

Lot 2 and have an area of 8260 sq.m., and Lot 4 will comprise the balance of the present Lot 2, which

is approximately 36 ha. in area. Each of proposed Lots 2 and 3 will have a frontage to Noosa Inlet,

and the subdivisional application provides for the construction of a new road from Banksia Avenue

along the southern boundaries of Lot 1 and the proposed Lots 2 and 3, terminating at the south-western

corner of proposed Lot 3. The 36 unit building which is the subject of the current application is to be

built on the proposed new Lot 2, and the erection of another multiple dwelling on the proposed Lot 3

in due course has been foreshadowed.

Except for a small area which can be disregarded for present purposes, the northern section of the

present Lot 2, which consists of a steeply sloping bank adjacent to the southern shore of Noosa Inlet,

is zoned non-urban and is a declared “Sand Dune Problem Area”. Immediately to the south of the non-

urban zone, the presently material section of the present Lot 2 is a relatively level…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Settlers Cove Development Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] QCA 481
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Noosa Shire Council appealed against a judgment of the Planning and Environment Court, which had allowed an appeal by Settlers Cove Development Pty Ltd and R.M. Thompson (Qld.) Pty Ltd (the developers) against the Council’s deemed refusal of a combined application for approval to subdivide land and town planning consent to build a multiple dwelling on one of the new lots into which the land is proposed to be subdivided. The land, Lot 2, is part of a larger area of land owned by the developers, which is located between the Noosa Inlet and two roads which connect with each other, Noosa Drive and Banksia Avenue. The proposed subdivision involves subdividing Lot 2 into Lots 2, 3 and 4; it is proposed that the new Lot 2 will abut the western boundary of Lot 1 and have an area of 6380 sq.m., Lot 3 will abut the western boundary of the new Lot 2 and have an area of 8260 sq.m., and Lot 4 will comprise the balance of the present Lot 2, which is approximately 36 ha. in area. Each of proposed Lots 2 and 3 will have a frontage to Noosa Inlet, and the subdivisional application provides for the construction of a new road from Banksia Avenue along the southern boundaries of Lot 1 and the proposed Lots 2 and 3, terminating at the south-western corner of proposed Lot 3. The 36 unit building which is the subject of the current application is to be built on the proposed new Lot 2, and the erection of another multiple dwelling on the proposed Lot 3 in due course has been foreshadowed. Except for a small area which can be disregarded for present purposes, the northern section of the present Lot 2, which consists of a steeply sloping bank adjacent to the southern shore of Noosa Inlet, is zoned non-urban and is a declared “Sand Dune Problem Area”. Immediately to the south of the non-urban zone, the presently material section of the present Lot 2 is a relatively level area which is zoned residential high density. Another section of the present Lot 2 is zoned open space, but all of that section is intended to be included in the proposed Lot 4 and is of no present relevance. Each of proposed Lots 2 and 3 is to include land which is zoned non-urban as well as land which is zoned residential high density; proposed Lot 2 is to consist of 2423 sq.m. of land which is zoned non-urban and 3937 sq.m. which is zoned residential high density. The proposed unit building and new road are to be built on the portion of the proposed Lot 2 which is zoned residential high density, and the only construction planned for the portion of the proposed Lot 2 which is zoned non-urban is a boardwalk across that area of land, ending in a jetty which is intended to be constructed from the shore into Noosa Inlet; however, all of the non-urban zoned land the subject of the proposed Lot 2 is to be included in the “common property” of the proposed multiple dwelling development, and will be owned and available for use by purchasers who become owners of units in the building: Building Units & Group Titles Act 1980, sub-s. 20(1). The Council has no objection to the subdivision of the land zoned residential high density or the erection of the unit building or associated road in that zone, but contends that no part of the non-urban zoned land can be included in proposed Lots 2 and 3, and that a boardwalk cannot be erected across the non-urban zoned land forming part of proposed Lot 2. Further, in the Council’s view, the subdivisional approval and consent to use should be conditional on the construction of a fence or other effective barrier to prevent access onto land zoned non-urban from the site of the proposed unit building. The Court held that the Council’s appeal should be allowed with taxed costs of and incidental to the appeal. In the event that such an outcome was arrived at, the Council asked for orders in accordance with the schedule to these reasons. However, in my opinion, it is inappropriate to make any additional order except that the order made by the Planning and Environment Court be set aside and the matter remitted to that Court to be further heard and determined in accordance with the judgment of this Court. The orders sought by the appellant were that the appeal be allowed and the matter remitted to the Planning and Environment Court to be dealt with in accordance with the directions in paragraph 3; that the respondents pay the appellant's costs of and incidental to the appeal to be taxed; and that the Planning and Environment Court dispose of the matter in accordance with the following directions: (a) that the respondents be permitted if so advised to modify their combined application by: (i) excluding from proposed Lot 2 on Plan 881128/S2 that part of approximately 2423m2 in area in the Non Urban zone; (ii) excluding from proposed Lot 3 on Plan 881128/S2 that part which is within the Non Urban zone; (iii) increasing the area of proposed Lot 4 on Plan 881128/S2 by including within it the area excluded from proposed Lots 2 and 3 pursuant to (i) and (ii) hereof; (iv) confining the consent component of the combined application to the modified proposed Lot 2 on Plan 881128/S2 and the erection thereon of the proposed 36 unit multiple dwellings; (b) that the respondents notify the appellant of their intention to so modify the combined application within 14 days of today; (c) that the combined application so modified be approved by the Planning and Environment Court subject to lawful conditions including a condition that there be erected along the northern boundary of the modified proposed Lots 2 and 3 adjacent to the boundary between those modified proposed lots and the land zoned Non Urban immediately adjoining to the north a physical landscaped barrier effective to prevent access between the land zoned Non Urban and the modified proposed Lots 2 and 3; (d) that such conditions be agreed (if possible) between the parties within 60 days of today's date and failing agreement within that time be determined by the Planning and Environment Court; (e) that in the event that the respondents do not notify the appellant of their intention to modify the combined application within 14 days of today's date, the appeal be allowed, the judgment of the Planning and Environment Court be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the appeal to the Planning and Environment Court be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.