Sentinel Industrial Pty Ltd v Yamba Shipping Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sentinel Industrial Pty Ltd v Yamba Shipping Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 261

PARTIES:

SENTINEL INDUSTRIAL PTY LTD ACN 606 262 408 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE SENTINEL INDUSTRIAL RETAIL TRUST

(plaintiff)

v

YAMBA SHIPPING PTY LTD ACN 169 477 356

(first defendant)
WARREN ALFRED MCKAY

(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 7720 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

DELIVERED ON:

1 November 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

9 and 10 September 2024

JUDGE:

Bowskill CJ

ORDERS:

1.        Judgment for the plaintiff against the first defendant and the second defendant for the amount of the plaintiff’s claim in respect of the land sublease and the seabed sublease, as particularised in the schedule to these reasons (less the sum of $452.17), with interest to be calculated to the date of judgment.

2.         The first defendant’s counterclaim against the plaintiff is dismissed.

3.        The plaintiff is directed to provide to the Court a form of judgment, consistent with order 1 reflecting the interest calculation.

4.        I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – LEASES – where the first defendant was the sub-lessee of an area of land (the land sublease) and an adjacent area of seabed (the seabed sublease) – where the second defendant is the sole director of the first defendant and was the guarantor of the first defendant’s obligations under the subleases – where the plaintiff was the owner of the land subleased to the first defendant and was the lessor of the subleases to the first defendant – where the plaintiff terminated the subleases on the basis of the first defendant’s breach of the terms of the subleases to pay rent and outgoings as well as the first defendant’s breach of a term of the seabed sublease requiring it to consent to the surrender and regrant of the sublease – where the first defendant alleges that the plaintiff was not permitted to terminate the subleases, on the basis of non-payment, having regard to the Retail Shop Leases and Other Commercial Leases (COVID-19 Emergency Response) Regulation 2020 (Qld) (Covid regulation) – whether the first defendant was in default under the terms of the land sublease and the seabed sublease – whether the Covid regulation prohibited the plaintiff from exercising any rights, including terminating the subleases – whether the plaintiff lawfully terminated the land sublease and the seabed sublease

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 14B
COVID-19 Emergency Response Act 2020 (Qld), s 23(1)
Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), s 124
Retail Shop Leases and Other Commercial Leases (COVID-19 Emergency Response) Regulation 2020 (Qld), s 3, s 5,
s 9, s 12(1), s 12(2), s 14(2), s 15

Fox v Jolly [1916] 1 AC 1

Lexane Pty Ltd v Highfern Pty Ltd [1985] 1 Qd R 446 Kumaragamage v Rallis [2001] NSWSC 466

COUNSEL:

C A Johnstone, with S Russell, for the plaintiff

The second defendant appeared on his own behalf and, with leave, on behalf…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sentinel Industrial Pty Ltd v Yamba Shipping Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 261
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sentinel Industrial Pty Ltd sought relief against Yamba Shipping Pty Ltd and its sole director, who also acted as the guarantor of Yamba Shipping’s obligations under two subleases. The plaintiff, as the owner of the land and lessor of both subleases, terminated the agreements with Yamba Shipping, citing breaches of payment obligations and a specific seabed sublease condition. Yamba Shipping argued that the termination was unlawful due to the Retail Shop Leases and Other Commercial Leases (COVID-19 Emergency Response) Regulation 2020 (Qld), which it claimed prohibited the plaintiff from exercising its termination rights.

The court examined whether Yamba Shipping was indeed in default under the terms of the subleases and if the COVID-19 regulation barred the plaintiff from terminating the agreements. The central legal issue was the interplay between the terms of the subleases and the regulatory provisions introduced during the COVID-19 pandemic. The court needed to ascertain whether the regulation, which aimed to provide relief from certain lease obligations, applied to the subleases in question and, if so, whether it precluded the plaintiff from exercising its right to terminate for non-payment and other breaches.

In its reasoning, the court found that Yamba Shipping was in default under the terms of both the land and seabed subleases. It held that the COVID-19 regulation did not apply to the subleases, as it was intended to protect tenants who were directly impacted by the pandemic, such as retail shops and commercial spaces, rather than subtenants. Consequently, the plaintiff was not prohibited from terminating the subleases on the grounds of Yamba Shipping's breaches. The court ruled in favour of the plaintiff, awarding damages for the unpaid rent and outgoings, along with interest.

The court ordered that judgment be entered in favour of the plaintiff against both Yamba Shipping and its director for the amount claimed, less a specified sum. The counterclaim by Yamba Shipping was dismissed. The plaintiff was required to provide a form of judgment reflecting the interest calculation. The court reserved its decision on costs for a later date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Judgment for the plaintiff against the first defendant and the second defendant for the amount of the plaintiff’s claim in respect of the land sublease and the seabed sublease, as particularised in the schedule to these reasons (less the sum of $452.17), with interest to be calculated to the date of judgment.

2. The first defendant’s counterclaim against the plaintiff is dismissed.

3. The plaintiff is directed to provide to the Court a form of judgment, consistent with order 1 reflecting the interest calculation.

4. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sentinel Industrial Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) owned a parcel of land in Queensland and an adjacent area of seabed. The plaintiff leased both areas to Yamba Shipping Pty Ltd (the first defendant) through a land sublease and a seabed sublease. The second defendant, who is the sole director of the first defendant, guaranteed the first defendant's obligations under the subleases. The first defendant was required to pay rent and outgoings under both subleases, and to consent to the surrender and regrant of the seabed sublease if necessary. The first defendant defaulted in its payment obligations and failed to consent to the surrender and regrant of the seabed sublease, leading to the plaintiff terminating the subleases. The first defendant claimed that the termination was invalid due to the Retail Shop Leases and Other Commercial Leases (COVID-19 Emergency Response) Regulation 2020 (Qld) (Covid regulation). The case hinged on whether the first defendant was in default under the subleases, whether the Covid regulation prohibited the plaintiff from terminating the subleases, and whether the plaintiff lawfully terminated the subleases.

This case came before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) as an application for relief from termination of the subleases by the first defendant. The plaintiff applied to QCAT for a determination on the validity of the termination of the subleases and for an order for arrears of rent and outgoings. The first defendant counterclaimed for damages for alleged unlawful termination of the subleases. The proceedings involved submissions on the interpretation of the subleases and the Covid regulation, as well as the evidence of the first defendant's defaults and the plaintiff's right to terminate under the terms of the subleases.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the first defendant in default under the terms of the land sublease and the seabed sublease?
2. Did the Covid regulation prohibit the plaintiff from exercising any rights, including terminating the subleases?
3. Did the plaintiff lawfully terminate the land sublease and the seabed sublease?

Held
1. The court concluded that the first defendant was in default under the terms of the land sublease and the seabed sublease. The first defendant's default included breaches such as failure to pay rent and outgoings, and the breach of a term requiring consent to the surrender and regrant of the sublease.
2. The court held that the Covid regulation did not prohibit the plaintiff from exercising any rights, including terminating the subleases. The court found that the regulation did not apply to the circumstances of this case, as it was not triggered by a "COVID-19 related default" as defined in the regulation.
3. The court determined that the plaintiff lawfully terminated the land sublease and the seabed sublease, given that the first defendant was in default and the Covid regulation did not prevent the termination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the terms of the land sublease and the seabed sublease to ascertain whether the first defendant was in default. It was established that the first defendant had indeed failed to comply with the payment obligations and other conditions stipulated in the subleases, thereby placing itself in default. The court also evaluated the applicability of the Covid regulation, which was designed to provide relief to commercial tenants during the COVID-19 pandemic. It was determined that the regulation's provisions did not extend to the situation presented, as the default was not caused by COVID-19 related issues. The court concluded that since the first defendant was in default and the regulation did not impede the plaintiff's right to terminate, the plaintiff was justified in terminating the subleases. The binding principle established in this case is that a lessor may lawfully terminate a sublease where the sub-lessee is in default, and where the termination is not prohibited by specific regulatory provisions that do not apply to the circumstances of the case.