SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Sentinel Income Pty Ltd v Santrev Pty Ltd & Ors [2023] QSC 165
PARTIES:
SENTINEL INCOME PTY LTD ACN 610 446 976 AS
TRUSTEE FOR THE SENTINEL INCOME TRUST(plaintiff)
v
SANTREV PTY LTD
ACN 124 970 878(first defendant)
SANTREV POULTRY DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
ACN 116 759 589
(second defendant)
LUKE DAVID TREVANION
(third defendant)FILE NO:
BS No 1750 of 2023
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at BrisbaneDELIVERED ON:
28 July 2023
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
13 June 2023
JUDGE:
Cooper J
ORDERS:
1. Paragraphs 9A to 14A and 27(a) of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim are struck out, along with the words “the Buffer Works” in the chapeau of paragraph 27.
2. The plaintiff has leave to replead those paragraphs, or to otherwise replead its cause of action for damages for breach of contract in respect of the Buffer Works, as it may be advised.
3. The plaintiff has leave to amend paragraphs 30A to 32 of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim in the form set out in the draft Third Further Amended Statement of Claim at pages 18 to 41 of exhibit ASK-02 to the affidavit of Adam Saleem Khan filed 13 June 2023, or to otherwise replead its cause of action for damages for breach of contract comprising the loss of a commercial opportunity, as it may be advised.
4. The second defendant be granted leave nunc pro tunc to commence its counterclaim against the plaintiff, pursuant to s 113(2) of the Trusts Act 1973 (Qld).
5. The defendants’ application filed 25 May 2023 is otherwise dismissed.
6. I will hear the parties as to costs.
CATCHWORDS:
PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – STRIKING OUT – DISCLOSING NO REASONABLE CAUSE OF ACTION OR DEFENCE – where the plaintiff purchased a farm from the first defendant – where the plaintiff entered into a contract with the first defendant relating to ongoing repairs and maintenance at the farm – where the second and third defendant guaranteed the performance of the first defendant’s obligations under the contract – where the plaintiff claims that the first defendant failed to undertake certain repair and maintenance works relating to planting trees to create or restore vegetation buffers to comply with a development approval granted by Ipswich City Council – where the plaintiff claims the cost of vegetation buffer works it caused to be done by an alternative contractor as damages for breach of contract – where the plaintiff pleads loss of opportunity from loss arising from the subsequent the sale of the farm – where the defendants have applied to strike out the pleading relating to the recovery of the cost of performing the vegetation buffer works and the loss of opportunity claim – whether the pleading discloses no reasonable cause of action – whether the pleading has a tendency to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceeding…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Sentinel Income Pty Ltd v Santrev Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] QSC 165
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the plaintiff's claims for the cost of performing vegetation buffer works failed to disclose a reasonable cause of action because the plaintiff mischaracterised the effect of certain clauses in the lease agreement. The court also rejected the plaintiff's narrow interpretation of other clauses in the lease agreement. The court further found that the defendants' counterclaim for breach of trust required leave under section 113 of the Trusts Act 1973 (Qld). The court granted the defendants leave to amend their counterclaim accordingly. The plaintiff was granted leave to replead its claims for the cost of vegetation buffer works and loss of opportunity.
The court ordered that specific paragraphs of the plaintiff's pleadings, as well as certain references to "the Buffer Works," be struck out. The plaintiff was granted leave to replead those paragraphs and the words "the Buffer Works" in the chapeau of paragraph 27. Additionally, the plaintiff was allowed to amend its claim for loss of commercial opportunity. The second defendant was granted leave to commence its counterclaim for breach of trust. The defendants' application filed on 25 May 2023 was dismissed, and the court scheduled a hearing on costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Paragraphs 9A to 14A and 27(a) of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim are struck out, along with the words “the Buffer Works” in the chapeau of paragraph 27.
2. The plaintiff has leave to replead those paragraphs, or to otherwise replead its cause of action for damages for breach of contract in respect of the Buffer Works, as it may be advised.
3. The plaintiff has leave to amend paragraphs 30A to 32 of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim in the form set out in the draft Third Further Amended Statement of Claim at pages 18 to 41 of exhibit ASK-02 to the affidavit of Adam Saleem Khan filed 13 June 2023, or to otherwise replead its cause of action for damages for breach of contract comprising the loss of a commercial opportunity, as it may be advised.
4. The second defendant be granted leave nunc pro tunc to commence its counterclaim against the plaintiff, pursuant to s 113(2) of the Trusts Act 1973 (Qld).
5. The defendants’ application filed 25 May 2023 is otherwise dismissed.
6. I will hear the parties as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It is common ground that although cl 10.2, by its terms, would permit the Lessor to enter onto the land and undertake buffer works which the Lessee was bound to undertake, but had failed to carry out, such work would be excluded by the operation of cl 4(a)(vi) of the RMC.[15] That is, whichever of the purposes identified in cl 10.2 for undertaking the vegetation buffer works is relied upon (see [36] above), Sentinel’s claim must rest on the proposition that, on its proper construction, the Lease imposes the obligation to comply with condition 14 of the development approval upon the Lessor rather than upon the Lessee.[15]Transcript 1-29:39 to 1-30:12.Consideration I do not accept the defendants’ submission that the definition of Lessor’s Works in the Agreement for Lease compels a construction by which the Lessor was obliged to construct vegetation barriers when it constructed the Farms, but was not responsible for constructing those buffers in a manner which complied with condition 14 of the development approval. I have already referred, in [15] to [17] above, to the discrepancy between the planting density provided for in the quote referred to in the definition of the Lessor’s Works and the planting density required by condition 14 of the development approval. However, I do not accept that this discrepancy means a reasonable business person would be compelled to the conclusion that the parties had contracted on the basis that the Lessor would plant trees only to the density required by the quote and, thereafter, that the Lessee would be responsible for planting such further trees as may be required to ensure that the planting density of the vegetation buffers complied with condition 14 of the development approval. The fact that the parties agreed that the Lessor would plant vegetation buffers as part of its work in constructing the Farms, the reference in cl 5.3.3 to the Lessor having to perform such construction works in accordance with the requirements of an authority such as Ipswich City Council, and the relatively narrow definition of “Lessee’s Works” to be performed as part of the construction of the Farms (“such items of plant and fittings … as are reasonably required for the operation of the permitted use upon the premises”) all tell against such a construction. Nevertheless, I have reached the conclusion that Sentinel’s pleading of its claim for the cost of vegetation buffer works fails to disclose a reasonable cause of action. There are two reasons for my conclusion. First, Sentinel’s claim that the Lessor was responsible under the Lease (as distinct from the Agreement for Lease) for ensuring compliance with the requirements of the development approval proceeds from a mischaracterisation of the effect of cl 20.1 of the Lease. Secondly, I do not accept Sentinel’s narrow construction of cll 4.1 and 10.1 of the Lease. As to the first reason, cl 20.1 of the Lease did not impose any obligation on the Lessor. Rather, it provided for what would happen if the Lessor did not comply with obligations which it owed under the Agreement for Lease. Relevantly, the obligation to construct each of the Farms by specified dates was created by cl 5.1 of the Agreement for Lease. By virtue of cl 18.1 of the Agreement for Lease, that obligation continued in existence when the Lease was entered into.[16] If the Lessor failed to construct the Farms by the specified dates it would have breached cl 5.1 of the Agreement for Lease. The condition subsequent imposed by cl 20.1 of the Lease would not have been satisfied, but the Lessor would not have breached any separate obligation created by cl 20.1. Similarly, if it be accepted for the purposes of argument that cl 5.3.3 of the Agreement to Lease imposed an obligation on the Lessor to construct the Farms in accordance with the conditions of the development approval, failure by the Lessor to construct the Farms in accordance with those conditions would mean it breached cl 5.3.3 of the Agreement for Lease. Again, the condition subsequent in cl 20.1 of the Lease would not be satisfied, but there would be no breach of any separate obligation created by the Lease. [16]Although I note that cl 20.1 of the Lease amended the dates by which the Lessor was required to perform the obligation it owed under cl 5.1 of the Agreement for Lease.