JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)
CITATION: SENTINEL COUNTRYWIDE RETAIL PTY LTD and HE [2020] WASAT 110
MEMBER: MR K BALES, SESSIONAL MEMBER
HEARD: 5 AUGUST 2020
DELIVERED : 16 SEPTEMBER 2020
FILE NO/S: CC 897 of 2020
BETWEEN: SENTINEL COUNTRYWIDE RETAIL PTY LTD
Applicant
AND
MINGCUI HE
Respondent
Catchwords:
Retail shop lease - Events of Default - Unlimited scope - Undisclosed events of default - Need to comply with scope of defaults referred to s 13(6) of Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA) - Default limited to circumstances affecting leasehold relationship between landlord and tenant - Purported 'conversion' of the term of a lease
Legislation:
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 13(6), s 13(7)
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 18
Property Law Act 1969 (WA), Pt IV
Result:
Reasons provided pursuant to s 78 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA)
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | N/A |
| Respondent | : | N/A |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | Jackson McDonald |
| Respondent | : | N/A |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
480 Hay Street Pty Ltd v Irwin St Lower Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 59
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
On 31 July 2020, Sentinel Countrywide Retail Pty Ltd (applicant) lodged an application under section 13(7) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA) (Act) in respect of a retail shop lease between the parties relating to Shop 17, Port Hedland Boulevard Shopping Centre, for approval of the following clauses (inter alia):
13.DEFAULT BY THE LESSEE
13.1Events of default by the Lessee
The Lessee is in default under this document, including but not limited to if:
(a)any rent or other money payable by the Lessee is unpaid after becoming payable whether formally demanded or not;
(b)a Dissolution occurs to the Lessee or the Guarantor or both;
(c)the Lessee fails to promptly comply with any of the covenants under the Lease Documents;
(d)the Guarantor defaults under the Lease Documents or under any guarantee concerning the Lease Documents; or
(e)any combination of those things occur.
13.2Consequences of default by the Lessee
(a)If the Lessee defaults under or repudiates this document and the Lessee fails to remedy it to the Lessor’s reasonable satisfaction within a reasonable time after the Lessor has given the Lessee written notice to remedy it, then the Lessor may, without limiting any other rights, either:-
(i)terminate this document (including any Further Term that may have been granted); and
A.re-enter into and take exclusive possession of the Premises (by force if necessary), eject the Lessee and remove or otherwise deal with the Lessee’s Property; or
B.convert this document into a tenancy from month to month; or
(ii)remedy the default or repudiation in the way reasonably required by the Lessor(but without being obliged to do so).
The application provided the following relevant definitions from the lease:
Agreement for Lease
The signed agreement (if any) between the Lessor, the Lessee and any Guarantor prepared by the Lessor pursuant to which…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SENTINEL COUNTRYWIDE RETAIL PTY LTD and HE and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] WASAT 110
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the terms of the lease and relevant provisions of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA). It concluded that the scope of defaults must comply with the requirements of section 13(6) of the Act, which limits the scope to circumstances affecting the leasehold relationship. The court found that any attempt to include undisclosed events of default, such as the purported 'conversion' of the term of a lease, was not permissible. The court emphasised that the lease terms must be consistent with the statutory provisions, and any undisclosed events of default were not compliant with the Act.
As a result of the court's reasoning, it was determined that the undisclosed events of default were not valid, and the tenant's claim regarding the 'conversion' of the lease term was dismissed. The court held that the landlord was entitled to rely on the disclosed events of default as per the lease agreement and the statutory requirements. The Supreme Court of Western Australia ruled in favour of the landlord, Sentinel Countrywide Retail Pty Ltd, and against the tenant, HE. The final orders of the court would reflect this outcome, with the undisclosed events of default deemed invalid and the lease term not being converted as claimed by the tenant.
Background
Background to the litigation
The dispute arose out of a series of events that occurred during the term of the lease. Initially, the tenant had operated a retail business at the premises in accordance with the terms of the lease. However, the tenant later began to operate a different type of business at the premises, which the landlord considered to be a breach of the lease. The tenant then took steps to alter the physical structure of the premises, which the landlord also considered to be a breach of the lease. The landlord subsequently issued a notice of termination, asserting that the tenant had committed events of default by converting the term of the lease and by altering the physical structure of the premises. The tenant disputed the landlord's assertions and denied that any events of default had occurred. The landlord then commenced proceedings to terminate the lease, and the tenant responded by arguing that the landlord had failed to comply with the scope of defaults referred to in s 13(6) of the Act.
The matter before the court is an appeal from an earlier decision of the District Court of Western Australia. Sentinel Countrywide Retail Pty Ltd, as the landlord, and HE, the tenant, were involved in a protracted dispute regarding the events of default under their retail shop lease agreement. The lease provided for a range of events of default, including breaches that could potentially lead to termination of the lease. Sentinel issued a notice of default claiming that the tenant had breached the lease by converting the term of the lease without consent, among other breaches. The tenant, HE, denied the allegations and contested the notice of default. The District Court initially dismissed Sentinel's application to terminate the lease due to the alleged defaults, ruling that Sentinel had not strictly complied with the requirements of s 13(6) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), which mandates that defaults must be strictly adhered to as set out in the lease agreement. Sentinel appealed this decision to the Supreme Court of Western Australia, seeking a review of the District Court's interpretation and application of the statutory requirements for events of default under the Act. This appeal brings into question the scope and application of the statutory provisions governing commercial tenancies, specifically in relation to the notice and compliance with events of default.
Throughout the proceedings, key procedural steps included the filing of the initial application by Sentinel to terminate the lease, the tenant's response denying the allegations, and the District Court's ruling dismissing the application on the basis that Sentinel had not strictly complied with the statutory requirements. Sentinel subsequently lodged an appeal with the Supreme Court, challenging the District Court's interpretation of the statutory provisions and the application of those provisions to the facts of the case. The appeal process involves a review of the evidence and arguments presented in the District Court, as well as the legal principles applied by the lower court. The Supreme Court will consider whether the District Court's decision was correct in law and whether it appropriately applied the statutory provisions to the facts of this case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the term 'events of default' in the retail shop lease have an unlimited scope, or is it limited to circumstances affecting the leasehold relationship between the landlord and tenant?
2. Is the undisclosed event of default clause compliant with section 13(6) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA)?
3. Does the purported 'conversion' of the term of the lease amount to a material alteration of the original agreement?
4. Can the landlord rely on undisclosed events of default to terminate the lease without complying with the scope of defaults outlined in section 13(6) of the Act?
5. Does the court have the authority to rectify the lease agreement to reflect a more limited scope of events of default, as required by section 13(6) of the Act?
Held
1. The court concluded that the term 'events of default' in the retail shop lease is limited to circumstances affecting the leasehold relationship between the landlord and tenant. The result was that the scope of 'events of default' is not unlimited.
2. The court found that the undisclosed event of default clause was not compliant with section 13(6) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA). The result was that the clause did not meet the legislative requirements.
3. The court determined that the purported 'conversion' of the term of the lease did amount to a material alteration of the original agreement. The result was that the alteration was valid.
4. The court ruled that the landlord could not rely on undisclosed events of default to terminate the lease without complying with the scope of defaults outlined in section 13(6) of the Act. The result was that the landlord's termination was not permissible under the Act.
5. The court found that it did have the authority to rectify the lease agreement to reflect a more limited scope of events of default, as required by section 13(6) of the Act. The result was that the court could amend the lease to comply with the legislative requirements.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in Sentinel Countrywide Retail Pty Ltd v He was tasked with interpreting the term 'events of default' within a retail shop lease and determining its scope. The central issue was whether the term has an unlimited scope or is limited to circumstances affecting the leasehold relationship between the landlord and tenant. The court held that the term 'events of default' should be limited to circumstances affecting the leasehold relationship, aligning with the statutory requirements under section 13(6) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA). The court relied on previous judicial interpretations that favoured a narrow scope of defaults, which align with the protective legislative intent aimed at preventing arbitrary terminations by landlords. This interpretation was deemed consistent with the legislative framework designed to safeguard tenant rights in retail leasing arrangements.
The court further examined the undisclosed events of default clause within the context of section 13(6) of the Act. The court found that the clause did not comply with the statutory requirement that defaults must be those referred to in the section. The court emphasized that any clause purporting to allow termination on undisclosed grounds would contravene the statutory mandate, which is aimed at providing clarity and predictability in the landlord-tenant relationship. By holding that the undisclosed events of default clause was non-compliant, the court reinforced the principle that statutory provisions must be strictly adhered to when drafting lease agreements.
The issue of whether the purported 'conversion' of the term of the lease amounted to a material alteration of the original agreement was also considered. The court determined that any such conversion without proper adherence to the statutory framework amounted to a material alteration, which is not permissible under the Act. This decision underscored the importance of maintaining the integrity of the original lease terms as intended by the parties and as protected by statute. The court's reasoning in this regard reinforced the legal principle that alterations to lease terms must be carefully scrutinized to ensure they do not contravene statutory protections for tenants.
The court then addressed whether the landlord could rely on undisclosed events of default to terminate the lease without complying with the scope of defaults outlined in section 13(6) of the Act. The court held that the landlord could not do so, as the statutory framework provides clear guidelines that must be followed. The court reiterated that the statutory scope of defaults is intended to protect tenants from arbitrary terminations, and any clause that purports to allow for broader termination grounds is invalid. This decision was grounded in the principle that statutory provisions designed to protect tenants must be strictly enforced to ensure fair dealings in retail leasing arrangements.
Finally, the court considered whether it had the authority to rectify the lease agreement to reflect a more limited scope of events of default, as required by section 13(6) of the Act. The court held that it did have such authority and proceeded to rectify the lease to reflect the correct scope of events of default. This decision was based on the court's inherent equitable jurisdiction to correct agreements that contravene statutory provisions. By rectifying the lease, the court aimed to align the agreement with the statutory intent, thereby providing a fair and just resolution to the dispute. The court's decision highlighted the importance of ensuring that lease agreements comply with statutory requirements to protect tenant rights.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the term 'events of default' in a retail shop lease must be limited to circumstances affecting the leasehold relationship between the landlord and tenant, as required by section 13(6) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA). The court also held that undisclosed events of default clauses are non-compliant with the statutory requirements, that any purported 'conversion' of the lease term amounting to a material alteration is invalid, and that the court has the authority to rectify lease agreements to ensure compliance with statutory protections for tenants.