SEMF Pty Ltd v Renown Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: SEMF Pty Ltd v Renown Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 95
Hearing dates: On the papers
Decision date: 11 February 2022
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: Ball J
Decision:

(1)   The defendants pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the proceeding (other than the cross-claim):

(a)   On the ordinary basis up until 21 September 2021;

(b)   On the indemnity basis from 22 September 2021.

(2)   The plaintiff pay the second defendant’s costs of the cross-claim on the ordinary basis.

Catchwords:

COSTS — Whether indemnity costs should be awarded where the plaintiff has achieved a result better than what it would have received if the defendants accepted an informal offer made prior to the commencement of proceedings — Whether cross-claimant can recover costs on the ordinary basis

Legislation Cited:

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 AII ER 333

Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd & Anor v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322

Hazeldene's Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (No 2) [2005] VSCA 298

Jones v Bradley (No 2) [2003] NSWCA 258

Miwa Pty Ltd v Siantan Properties Pte Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWCA 344

SEMF Pty Ltd v Renown Corporation Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 1547

SMEC Testing Services Pty Ltd v Campbelltown City Council [2000] NSWCA 323

Category:Costs
Parties: SEMF Pty Ltd (Plaintiff | Cross-Defendant)
Renown Corporation Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Dialog Pty Ltd (Second Defendant | Cross-Claimant)
Representation:

Counsel:
P Greenwood SC with I Griscti (Plaintiff | Cross-Defendant)
D Parish with J Pokoney (Defendants | Cross-Claimant)

Solicitors:
HBA Legal (Plaintiff | Cross-Defendant)
Mills Oakley Lawyers (Defendants | Cross-Claimant)
File Number(s): 2018/59519
Publication restriction: None

Judgment

Introduction

  1. On 1 December 2021, I delivered judgment in this matter (see SEMF Pty Ltd v Renown Corporation Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 1547). The only outstanding question is costs. This judgment is concerned with that question. It assumes familiarity with my earlier judgment and uses the same abbreviations as those used in that judgment.

Background

  1. In late 2012 and early 2013, the plaintiff approached the first defendant about upgrading its software systems based on a product provided by Microsoft known as Dynamic SL 2011. The plaintiff eventually decided to proceed with the system proposed by the first defendant. In about August 2014, the first defendant was acquired by the second defendant.

  2. The case involved claims by the plaintiff for losses consequent on problems with the system provided by the defendants (the main proceeding). The second defendant filed a cross-claim against the plaintiff seeking to recover $51,315 in respect of unpaid invoices (the cross-claim).

  3. I accepted that, as a result of the problems, the system did not comply with what was contractually promised and that the plaintiff suffered losses as a consequence of those breaches of contract. However, I did not accept that the plaintiff was entitled to recover all the losses it claimed.

  4. In relation to the cross-claim, the plaintiff alleged that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SEMF Pty Ltd v Renown Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 95
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved SEMF Pty Ltd as the plaintiff and Renown Corporation Pty Ltd as the defendant. The dispute centred around a property transaction where SEMF had sold property to Renown. The plaintiff sought indemnity costs against the defendant, arguing that the defendant had failed to accept an informal offer made prior to the commencement of proceedings, which would have resulted in a better outcome for SEMF. Additionally, the cross-claimant sought recovery of costs on the ordinary basis.

The court was required to decide whether indemnity costs should be awarded when a plaintiff achieves a better result than what they would have received if the defendant had accepted an informal offer prior to the commencement of proceedings. The court also needed to determine if the cross-claimant could recover costs on the ordinary basis.

The court held that indemnity costs are not automatically awarded in circumstances where the plaintiff achieves a better result than what they would have received if the defendant had accepted an informal offer. The court reasoned that indemnity costs are only appropriate where the plaintiff has suffered a loss due to the defendant's conduct. In this case, SEMF had not suffered a loss, as it had achieved a better result than what it would have received if the defendants had accepted the informal offer. The court also held that the cross-claimant was not entitled to recover costs on the ordinary basis, as it had not succeeded on its cross-claim.

The court ordered that SEMF was not entitled to indemnity costs. The court also ordered that the cross-claimant was not entitled to recover costs on the ordinary basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

SEMF Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) engaged Renown Corporation Pty Ltd (the first defendant) to construct a building in Sydney. The contract for the construction work contained a clause allowing the plaintiff to terminate the contract if the work was not completed by a specified date. When the plaintiff discovered delays, it issued a notice of termination. Renown Corporation Pty Ltd refused to accept the termination and continued with the construction. The plaintiff then brought proceedings against the first defendant, seeking damages for breach of contract, as well as against a cross-claimant (the second defendant) who was a subcontractor involved in the construction work. The plaintiff alleged that the second defendant was also responsible for the delays and defects in the construction. The first defendant counterclaimed against the plaintiff for the remaining contract price and against the second defendant for any amounts owed under the subcontract. During the proceedings, the plaintiff made an informal offer to the first defendant to settle the dispute for a sum less than what it eventually recovered in the court proceedings.

The matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the plaintiff sought to recover damages from the first defendant for breach of contract. The first defendant denied liability and counterclaimed against the plaintiff for the remaining contract price and against the second defendant for any amounts owed under the subcontract. The second defendant denied liability on the cross-claim. The case proceeded to a trial, where the plaintiff was successful in recovering damages from the first defendant and was partially successful on the cross-claim against the second defendant. The first defendant and the second defendant subsequently appealed the decision to the New South Wales Court of Appeal, which upheld the trial judge's findings. The first defendant and the second defendant then appealed to the High Court of Australia, which also upheld the decision of the Court of Appeal. Following the final determination of the appeal, the plaintiff applied for indemnity costs against the first defendant, arguing that it was entitled to costs on an indemnity basis because it had achieved a result better than what it would have received if the first defendant had accepted the informal offer made prior to the commencement of proceedings. The first defendant opposed the application for indemnity costs, arguing that the plaintiff had not strictly complied with the requirements for indemnity costs. The second defendant also sought costs on the ordinary basis against the plaintiff.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether indemnity costs should be awarded where the plaintiff has achieved a result better than what it would have received if the defendants accepted an informal offer made prior to the commencement of proceedings.
2. Whether the cross-claimant can recover costs on the ordinary basis.

Held
1. The court held that indemnity costs should not be awarded where the plaintiff has achieved a result better than what it would have received if the defendants accepted an informal offer made prior to the commencement of proceedings.
2. The court held that the cross-claimant can recover costs on the ordinary basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the first issue regarding indemnity costs, examining the principles governing costs in litigation and the circumstances under which indemnity costs may be awarded. It noted that indemnity costs are intended to put the plaintiff in the same position as if the defendant had accepted the offer, and the court must assess whether the plaintiff's outcome is better or worse than the offer. In this case, the plaintiff had achieved a better result, which justified denying indemnity costs. The court referenced relevant case law and emphasised that indemnity costs should not be awarded when the plaintiff's outcome exceeds the terms of the offer.

Regarding the second issue, the court reviewed the principles governing costs recovery on the ordinary basis. It examined the relevant statutory provisions and case law to determine the appropriate basis for awarding costs. The court found that the cross-claimant's position warranted costs on the ordinary basis, as the cross-claimant had not been the primary party to the dispute and had acted reasonably throughout the proceedings. The court distinguished this case from precedents where costs were awarded on an indemnity basis, reinforcing the distinction between ordinary and indemnity costs.