Selfwealth Ltd, in the matter of Selfwealth Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Selfwealth Ltd, in the matter of Selfwealth Ltd [2025] FCA 214

File number(s): VID 77 of 2025
Judgment of: O'BRYAN J
Date of judgment: 14 March 2025
Date of publication of reasons: 20 March 2025
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – scheme of arrangement – first court hearing – order sought under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – exercise of discretion to order convening of scheme meeting – consideration of order to permit the postponement of the meeting – orders made for convening meeting
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 411, 412, 1319

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) reg 5.1.01, Sch 8

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) rr 1.3, 2.4, 3.2, 3.3

Cases cited:

Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485

FT Eastment & Sons Pty Ltd v Metal Roof Decking Supplies Pty Ltd (1977) 3 ACLR 69

Re ACM Gold Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 530

Re Amcor Ltd [2019] FCA 346

Re Carbon Revolution Limited (No 2) [2023] FCA 1173

Re Crown Resorts Ltd [2022] FCA 367

Re DuluxGroup Ltd [2019] FCA 961

Re Foundation Healthcare Ltd [2002] FCA 742

Re Japara Healthcare Limited [2021] FCA 1150

Re Lonsdale Financial Group Ltd [2007] VSC 394

Re Macquarie Private Capital A Ltd [2008] NSWSC 323

Re NRMA Insurance Ltd (No 1) [2000] NSWSC 82

Re Opes Prime Stockbroking Ltd (2009) 179 FCR 20

Re PM Capital Asian Opportunities Fund Limited [2021] FCA 1380

Re QMS Media [2019] FCA 2172

Re Rex Minerals Limited [2024] FCA 1051

Re Verdant Minerals Ltd [2019] FCA 556

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 64
Date of hearing: 14 March 2025
Counsel for the Plaintiff: B K Holmes
Solicitors for the Plaintiff: Herbert Smith Freehills
Counsel for Svava Pte Ltd: C Möller SC
Solicitors for Svava Pte Ltd: Hamilton Locke

ORDERS

VID 77 of 2025

IN THE MATTER OF SELFWEALTH LTD (ACN 154 324 428)

SELFWEALTH LTD (ACN 154 324 428)

Plaintiff

SVAVA PTE LTD
Interested Person

ORDER MADE BY:

O'BRYAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 MARCH 2025

OTHER MATTERS:

A.The Court notes that the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) was provided with at least 14 days’ notice of the hearing of this application.

B.The Court is satisfied that ASIC has had a reasonable opportunity to:

(a)examine the terms of the proposed scheme of arrangement to which the application relates (Scheme) and a draft explanatory statement relating to that Scheme; and

(b)make submissions to the Court in relation to the Scheme and the draft explanatory statement.

C.The Court notes the letter from ASIC to the directors of the plaintiff (Selfwealth) dated 13 March 2025 produced at the hearing.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to subs 411(1) and s 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act), Selfwealth convene and hold a meeting (Scheme Meeting) of its members holding fully paid ordinary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Selfwealth Ltd, in the matter of Selfwealth Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 214
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Selfwealth Ltd, an Australian online trading platform, and the proposed acquisition of its shares by Syfe. The dispute pertains to the convening of a scheme meeting for Selfwealth members to consider the acquisition. The court was tasked with deciding whether to exercise its discretion under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to order the convening of the scheme meeting, considering the circumstances in which the scheme meeting was requested following a change in the proposed acquirer from Bell Financial Group Limited to Syfe.

The court first considered the statutory requirement under s 411(17) that ASIC must produce a statement for the court's consideration before convening a meeting. The court held that if it seems likely that ASIC will produce the required statement at the second court hearing, this does not prevent the meeting from being convened at the first hearing. In this case, ASIC did not oppose the application, making it appropriate to proceed under the assumption that ASIC would provide the necessary statement. The court further concluded that the scheme was fit for consideration by Selfwealth members and that the scheme booklet would adequately inform members about the nature of the scheme. Consequently, the court exercised its discretion to order the convening of the scheme meeting.

The court issued orders convening the scheme meeting on 22 April 2025 and specified the process for informing Selfwealth shareholders and facilitating their participation in the meeting. The orders also addressed the dispatch of the scheme booklet and proxy forms to shareholders, provided details on the eligibility to vote at the meeting, and outlined the process for any future hearing to approve the scheme.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to subs 411(1) and s 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act), Selfwealth convene and hold a meeting (Scheme Meeting) of its members holding fully paid ordinary shares (other than Svava Pte Ltd and any of its related bodies corporate which hold fully paid ordinary shares in Selfwealth) (Selfwealth Shareholders):

(a) for the purpose of considering and, if thought fit, agreeing (with or without modification) to the proposed Scheme between Selfwealth and the Selfwealth Shareholders, the terms of which are set out in Annexure A to these orders; and

(b) to be held on 22 April 2025 commencing at 10.30 am (Melbourne time) at the offices of Herbert Smith Freehills, Level 24, 80 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria.

2. Pursuant to subs 411(1) and s 1319 of the Act, the Scheme Meeting be convened by sending on or before 20 March 2025 to each Selfwealth Shareholder:

(a) in the case of shareholders who have elected to receive communications from Selfwealth by email (Email Shareholders), an email substantially in the form of the template emails at pages 179 to 182 of Annexure CK2 to the affidavit of Craig Keary affirmed on 12 March 2025 (Second Keary Affidavit) which contains a hyperlink to a website from which the Email Shareholder may:

(i) access and download an electronic copy of a document substantially in the form which appears at pages 12 to 178 of Annexure CK2 to the Second Keary Affidavit as amended in the manner set out in Annexure RAL4 to the affidavit of Rodd Ashton Levy sworn on 13 March 2025 (Scheme Booklet); and

(ii) lodge online an electronic form containing a proxy appointment; and

(b) in the case of shareholders who have elected to receive communications from Selfwealth in physical form (Hard Copy Shareholders), the following documents in hard copy:

(i) the Scheme Booklet;

(ii) a personalised proxy form (Proxy Form); and

(iii) a business reply-paid envelope (or, in the case of Selfwealth Shareholders with registered addresses outside of Australia, a self‑addressed envelope) for the return of completed Proxy Forms.

(c) in the case of shareholders who are not Email Shareholders or Hard Copy Shareholders (Non-Electing Shareholders), the following documents in hard copy:

(i) a letter substantially in the form which appears at pages 183 to 184 of Annexure CK2 to the Second Keary Affidavit which contains a URL address of a website from which the Non-Electing Shareholder may:

A. access and download an electronic copy of the Scheme Booklet; and

B. lodge online an electronic form containing a proxy appointment;

(ii) a personalised Proxy Form; and

(iii) a business reply-paid envelope (or, in the case of Selfwealth Shareholders with registered addresses outside of Australia, a self‑addressed envelope) for the return of completed Proxy Forms.

3. If it comes to the attention of Selfwealth that any email dispatched to Email Shareholders in accordance with order 2(a) above has returned an undeliverable or undelivered receipt for an Email Shareholder’s nominated email address, Selfwealth is to dispatch to that Email Shareholder within a reasonable time thereafter the hard copy letter referred to in order 2(c) above.

4. The documents referred to in orders 2(b), 2(c) and 3 be sent:

(a) in the case of shareholders whose registered address is within Australia, by prepaid ordinary post addressed to the relevant addresses recorded in Selfwealth’s share register; and

(b) in the case of shareholders whose registered address is outside Australia, by airmail or international courier service addressed to the relevant addresses recorded in Selfwealth’s share register.

5. A proxy in respect of the Scheme Meeting will be valid and effective if, and only if, a Proxy Form is completed and delivered in accordance with its terms or a proxy is lodged online in accordance with the instructions on the website referred to in orders 2(a) and (c) and received by Selfwealth by 10.30 am (Melbourne time) on 20 April 2025.

6. Christine Christian or, failing her, Paul Clark, be chairperson of the Scheme Meeting.

7. Voting on the resolution to agree to the Scheme is to be conducted by way of a poll.

8. Selfwealth Shareholders whose names are recorded in the register of members of Selfwealth at 7.00 pm (Melbourne time) on 20 April 2025 will be eligible to vote at the Scheme Meeting.

9. The chairperson of the Scheme Meeting shall have the power to adjourn the Scheme Meeting to such time, date and place as she or he considers appropriate and, in that event, only Selfwealth Shareholders whose names are recorded in the register of members of the Selfwealth at 7.00 pm (Melbourne time) on the date that is two calendar days before the date that the adjourned meeting resumes will be eligible to vote at the Scheme Meeting.

10. Selfwealth shall have power to postpone the Scheme Meeting to such time, date and place as it considers appropriate in accordance with its Constitution and, in that event, notwithstanding any other part of these orders:

(a) only Selfwealth shareholders whose names are recorded in the register of members of the Selfwealth at 7.00 pm (Melbourne time) on the date that is two calendar days before the date of the postponed meeting will be eligible to vote at the Scheme Meeting;

(b) a proxy in respect of the Scheme Meeting will be valid and effective if, and only if, a Proxy Form is completed and delivered in accordance with its terms or a proxy is lodged online in accordance with the instructions on the website referred to in orders 2(a) and (c) and received by Selfwealth at least 48 hours before the time scheduled for the commencement of the postponed Scheme Meeting; and

(c) a reference in these orders to the Scheme Meeting is taken to include a reference to the postponed meeting.

11. Pursuant to r 1.3 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth), compliance with rr 2.4(1), 2.15, 3.4 and Form 6 is dispensed with.

12. Selfwealth is to publish an announcement via the ASX Market Announcements Platform substantially in the form at page 218 of Annexure CK2 to the Second Keary Affidavit which sets out the details for the hearing of any application to approve the Scheme and the process for any person wishing to appear at that hearing to oppose the approval of the Scheme.

13. The notice referred to in order 12 must be published at least 5 days before the date of the hearing of any application to approve the Scheme.

14. The further hearing of the originating process is adjourned to the Honourable Justice O’Bryan at 2.15 pm (Melbourne time) on 28 April 2025 for the hearing of any application to approve the Scheme.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

Scheme

[The Order entered is available on the Commonwealth Courts Portal, which attaches the Scheme.]

Background

Background to the litigation

On 14 March 2025, I made orders convening the Scheme Meeting. These are my reasons for making those orders. Background On 24 November 2024, Selfwealth entered into a scheme implementation deed with Bell Financial Group Limited (Bell) providing for Bell to acquire all of the shares in Selfwealth for $0.25 cash per share, with a scrip consideration alternative (Bell Scheme). The first court hearing in relation to the Bell Scheme took place on 20 February 2025, immediately after which I made orders which provided for the Bell Scheme meeting to be held on 28 March 2025. At the time that the 20 February 2025 orders were made, Selfwealth had received a non-binding and indicative proposal from Syfe to acquire all of the shares in Selfwealth for $0.28 cash per Selfwealth share. The Bell Scheme booklet accordingly addressed the Syfe proposal and its potential implications for the Bell Scheme. In circumstances where, at that point in time, the Syfe proposal was indicative only, non-binding, and may not have proceeded, I considered it appropriate to make orders convening a meeting of the members of Selfwealth to consider the Bell Scheme (consistently with the observations of Beach J in Re PM Capital Asian Opportunities Fund Limited [2021] FCA 1380 (at [89]-[92]) and in Re Carbon Revolution Limited (No 2) [2023] FCA 1173 (at [87]-[92])). That would ensure that Selfwealth could comply with its obligations under the Bell scheme implementation deed and enable Selfwealth members to consider the Bell Scheme, while Selfwealth continued to engage with Syfe in relation to its non-binding proposal. On 24 February 2025, Selfwealth announced to the ASX that a binding proposal had been made by Syfe to acquire all Selfwealth shares not already held by Syfe for $0.28 cash per share. Bell was provided with the opportunity to match that offer under the matching rights provisions of the Bell scheme implementation deed. However, on 26 February 2025, Bell advised Selfwealth that it would not be making a counterproposal, and the Bell scheme implementation deed was terminated. On 27 February 2025, Selfwealth announced to the ASX that it had entered into the Scheme Implementation Deed with Syfe. In light of these developments, on 28 February 2025 Selfwealth contacted my chambers seeking orders vacating the 20 February 2025 orders in relation to the Bell Scheme and adjourning the proceeding to a first court hearing in relation to the Syfe scheme. In support of the orders sought, Selfwealth filed an affidavit of Rodd Ashton Levy sworn on 28 February 2025, which summarised the developments that had occurred since the hearing on 20 February 2025. On Tuesday 4 March 2025, I made orders as sought by Selfwealth. Overview of the Scheme Selfwealth operates an Australian online trading platform which provides customers with opportunities to trade across Australian, United States and Hong Kong markets. Selfwealth's platform also provides customers with access to investment and research tools, market news, and a tailored peer-to-peer network allowing customers to track the portfolio performance of other customers, in real time, on a depersonalised basis. Selfwealth’s registered office is in Victoria.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 411(17) does not present a bar to a meeting being convened at the first court hearing if it seems likely that ASIC will produce the relevant statement at the second court hearing: Re Lonsdale Financial Group Ltd [2007] VSC 394 at [40]. In the present case, ASIC does not oppose the application for convening the meeting. It is therefore appropriate to proceed on the basis that ASIC will in due course provide a statement for the purpose of s 411(17)(b). Conclusion on exercise of discretion I am satisfied that the Scheme is of such a nature and cast in such terms that, if it achieves the statutory majorities at the Scheme Meeting, the Court would be likely to approve it, and that the Scheme Booklet will properly inform members as to the nature of the Scheme. It is therefore appropriate to make the orders sought convening the Scheme Meeting.Explanatory statementApproval by the Court of the explanatory statement Subsection 411(1) provides that, if the Court has made an order convening a meeting or meetings of members or creditors, the Court “may approve the explanatory statement” (which in this matter is contained in the Scheme Booklet). The practice of courts varies in this respect. Consistent with recent practice in this Court, I have not made an order approving the Scheme Booklet: see Amcor at [114]-[115] and Re Verdant Minerals Ltd [2019] FCA 556 at [84].Dispatch of the explanatory statement Selfwealth sought orders to convene the Scheme Meeting by sending the following documents to each Selfwealth shareholder: (a)in the case of Selfwealth shareholders who have elected to receive shareholder communications electronically (Email Shareholders), an email which contains a hyperlink to an online portal and website from which the Email Shareholder may: (i) access and download an electronic copy of the Scheme Booklet; and (ii) lodge online a proxy form for the Scheme Meeting;(b)in the case of Selfwealth shareholders who have elected to receive hard copy shareholder communications (Hard Copy Shareholders), the following documents in hard copy: (i) the Scheme Booklet; (ii) a personalised proxy form; and (iii) a business reply-paid envelope (or, in the case of Selfwealth shareholders with registered addresses outside of Australia, a self-addressed envelope) for the return of the proxy form; and (c)in the case of Selfwealth shareholders who are not Email Shareholders or Hard Copy Shareholders (Non-Electing Shareholders), the following documents in hard copy: (i) a letter which contains the URL address of websites from which the Non-Electing Shareholder may: (A) access and download an electronic copy of the Scheme Booklet; and (B) lodge online an electronic form for the Scheme Meeting; (ii) a personalised proxy form; and (iii) a business reply-paid envelope (or, in the case of Selfwealth shareholders with registered addresses outside of Australia, a self-addressed envelope) for the return of the proxy form. These documents in respect of the Hard Copy Shareholders and Non-Electing Shareholders will be sent: (a)in the case of shareholders whose registered address is within Australia, by prepaid ordinary post addressed to the relevant addresses recorded in Selfwealth’s share register; and (b)in the case of shareholders whose registered address is outside Australia, by airmail or international courier service addressed to the relevant addresses recorded in Selfwealth’s share register.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The relevant discretionary consideration involves two main questions: (a)first, whether the Scheme is fit for consideration by the members: see for example FT Eastment & Sons Pty Ltd v Metal Roof Decking Supplies Pty Ltd (1977) 3 ACLR 69 at 72 (Street CJ) and Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485 at 504; and (b)second, whether the members are to be properly informed as to the nature of the Scheme: see Re NRMA Insurance Ltd (No 1) [2000] NSWSC 82; 156 FLR 349 at [30]; Foundation Healthcare at [38].The Scheme is fit for consideration In addressing the first question of whether a scheme is fit for consideration by the members, the Court will scrutinise the terms of the scheme to satisfy itself that the scheme is of such a nature and cast in such terms that, if agreed to at the Scheme Meeting, the Court would be likely to approve the scheme at the second court hearing. In the context of schemes for the transfer of all of the shares in a company to an acquirer, the Court will also scrutinise the terms of the agreement between the company and the acquirer to implement the scheme (which in this case is recorded in the Scheme Implementation Deed). Typically, the company and the acquirer agree commercial terms governing their negotiations and dealings, including such matters as representations and warranties, exclusivity arrangements, break fees if the transaction does not proceed and the funding arrangements for the proposed transaction. Strictly, commercial terms of that kind are not part of the scheme and do not form any part of the arrangements that are approved by shareholders pursuant to the scheme. They are a commercial arrangement between the company and the acquirer. The appropriateness of such commercial terms is a matter for the business judgment of the directors of the company. However, the Court will seek to ensure that the terms agreed between the company and the acquirer have no potential to cause prejudice or unfairness to the company’s shareholders in connection with their consideration of the scheme and the implementation of the scheme if it is approved. Terms of the Scheme The Scheme proposal is fit for consideration by the members of Selfwealth. As noted earlier, the question whether or not to accept particular consideration for shares is quintessentially a commercial matter for the members to assess. The terms of the Scheme are in standard form and do not raise any specific matters of concern from the perspective of shareholders.Funding of the Scheme Consideration If the Scheme is implemented, the total amount of Scheme Consideration payable by Syfe for the Scheme Shares will be approximately $52,491,800. The Scheme Booklet states that Syfe will fund the Scheme Consideration from existing cash resources and that Syfe currently holds an amount of cash in its US$ denominated bank account with United Overseas Bank Limited which exceeds the total Scheme Consideration, and these funds are unconditionally available to Syfe for the purpose of meeting its obligations under the Scheme. Syfe’s Chief Operating Officer, Samantha Horton, deposed to the steps taken by Syfe to verify the information in the Scheme Booklet that related specifically to Syfe, including the information regarding funding of the Scheme Consideration. On the basis of that evidence, I am satisfied that Syfe will have sufficient funding to finance the Scheme Consideration. Performance risk