Sekhon v Director of Quarantine

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sekhon v Director of Quarantine [2013] FCA 1423

Citation: Sekhon v Director of Quarantine [2013] FCA 1423
Appeal from: Sekhon v Director of Quarantine [2013] FCCA 863
Parties: TEJINDER SINGH SEKHON v DIRECTOR OF QUARANTINE
File number: SAD 219 of 2013
Judge: WHITE J
Date of judgment: 23 December 2013
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal – review of order under s 48 of the Quarantine Act 1908 (Cth) directing that a dog be exported from Australia – whether order into quarantine valid under s 35 of the Quarantine Act – whether s 35 qualified by more specific provisions – whether valid order into quarantine under s 55A of the Quarantine Act – whether a quarantine officer examined the animal within the meaning of s 55A – whether relevant and irrelevant considerations taken into account
Legislation: Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth), s 5
Quarantine Act 1908 (Cth) ss 4 5, 5D, 13, 16A, 18, 19A, 35, 35AA, 35A, 44C 44D, 48, 52, 52A, 53, 54, 55A, 66AA, 70, 82
Quarantine Amendment Act 1981 (Cth)
Quarantine Amendment Act 1999 (Cth)
Quarantine Amendment Bill 1981 (Cth)
Quarantine Proclamation 1998 (Cth), ss 36, 37, 70, Schedule 3
Cases cited: Australian Education Union v Department of Education and Children’s Services [2012] HCA 3; (2012) 248 CLR 1
BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v National Competition Council [2007] FCAFC 157; (2007) 162 FCR 234
Brown v West (1990) 169 CLR 195
Buzzacott v Minister for Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities [2013] FCAFC 111
Hanson v Commonwealth Director of Quarantine (1984) 57 ALR 365
Harris v Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority [1999] FCA 437; (1999) 162 ALR 651
Johns v Australian Securities Commission (1993) 178 CLR 408
Lansen v Minister for Environment and Heritage [2008] FCAFC 189; (2008) 174 FCR 14
Mercantile Mutual Life Insurance Co Ltd v Australian Securities Commission (1993) 40 FCR 409
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Nystrom [2006] HCA 50; (2006) 228 CLR 566
Nezovic v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1263; (2003) 133 FCR 190
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355
Rural Press Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2003] HCA 75; (2003) 216 CLR 53
Sean Investments Pty Ltd v MacKellar (1981) 38 ALR 363
Date of hearing: 20 September 2013
Date of last submissions: 20 September 2013
Place: Adelaide
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 182
Counsel for the Appellant: Mrs M Shaw QC with Ms J Fuller
Solicitor for the Appellant: Sekhon Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Dr C Bleby SC with Mr S McDonald
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 219 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

TEJINDER SINGH…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sekhon v Director of Quarantine and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Sekhon v Director of Quarantine, the appellant, Mr. Sekhon, challenged an order made by the Director of Quarantine directing the export of his dog, Pepper, from Australia. The order was made under the Quarantine Act 1908 (Cth) due to concerns that Pepper was infected with Canine Monocytic Ehrlichiosis (CME). The primary legal issues were whether the order was valid under the relevant sections of the Quarantine Act and whether the decision-maker considered relevant factors in making the order.

The court examined whether the order was valid under section 35 or section 55A of the Quarantine Act. The appellant argued that neither section provided a valid basis for the order. The court found that the quarantine officer had not physically examined Pepper as required by section 55A, but rather relied on test results and veterinary advice. However, the court concluded that the decision-maker, Mr. McDonald, had validly exercised his powers under section 55A by considering the test results and expert advice, which constituted an examination within the meaning of the Act. The court also rejected the appellant's argument that the decision-maker failed to consider a relevant factor by not taking into account the recommended indefinite treatment plan for Pepper. The court held that the treatment plan was not a relevant consideration under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth).

The court dismissed the appeal, affirming the validity of the quarantine order and the decision-maker's exercise of his powers under the Quarantine Act. The order for Pepper's export remained in effect.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The effect of a series of orders by the FCC and this Court is that the operation of the direction to export is presently stayed until seven days after the delivery of this judgment.Background Pepper was born in Australia in April 2007 and purchased by the appellant shortly thereafter. In July 2007, he was taken to Singapore as a pet of the appellant’s family. The appellant and his family relocated to Australia from Singapore in early 2012. The appellant sought permission to import Pepper. As part of that process, a test for CME was carried out on Pepper in Singapore on 14 June 2012. It returned a negative result and an import permit was issued. Pepper left Singapore on 9 July 2012 and, on arrival in Perth on 10 July, was ordered into quarantine with a direction that he be detained at the Byford Quarantine Station until 9 August 2012. Subsequently, Pepper became unwell. On 3 August 2012, he was taken to the Murdoch University Veterinary Hospital where he remained until released from quarantine on 9 August and flown to Adelaide. A blood sample taken from Pepper on 6 August had been sent to a laboratory in the United States for analysis. The results of that analysis, which did not become known until 23 August, indicated the presence of CME. On 24 August, a quarantine officer (Dr Cass) ordered Pepper into quarantine and directed that he be detained at the appellant’s residential address in Adelaide. Subsequently, Dr Cass imposed a number of conditions directed to the treatment of Pepper and to precautions to prevent the spread of the CME. These included a requirement that Pepper be treated by a veterinary specialist, Dr Davies, and that Dr Davies provide regular reports to DAFF on Pepper’s progress, including the results of testing known as “canis PCR testing”. This testing involved analysis of blood samples taken from Pepper. On 4 October 2013, a pathology report of a sample tested on 28 September indicated the presence of CME. On the same day, Dr Irwin, of the School of Veterinary and Biomedical Science at Murdoch University, confirmed the diagnosis of CME. Mr McDonald then issued an order on 23 October 2012. This too ordered Pepper into quarantine and directed that he be detained at the appellant’s address. However, in addition, it required the appellant to arrange, at his own expense, for Pepper to be exported by air from Australia within 30 days. Two days later, Mr McDonald issued a further order and direction. These were in relevant respects in the same terms as those of 23 October, save that the direction required the appellant to export Pepper by no later than 22 November 2012 and to inform Mr McDonald by 6 November of the arrangements which he had made for that export. The order and direction of 23 October were not withdrawn, but the respondent relied on the order and direction of 25 October. It is the direction to export Pepper issued on 25 October 2012 which is the subject of the present appeal. A letter dated 23 October 2012, which accompanied the direction of that date, had informed the appellant that he could choose to have Pepper euthanased instead of being exported.Canine Ehrlichiosis

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I reject this submission.Conclusion on s 35 The appellant has not made good his challenge to the decision of the FCC Judge that the order into quarantine of 25 October 2012 could be justified by reference to s 35. That conclusion makes it unnecessary, strictly speaking, to consider whether the order into quarantine was authorised by s 55A. However, in case this matter goes further, I will state my views on that issue.Was there a valid order into quarantine under s 55A? The submissions of both parties proceeded on the basis that there were three conditions for the exercise of the power in s 55A(1) to order Pepper into quarantine: that the quarantine officer had examined the dog (subs (1)(a)); that Pepper was an imported animal, whether subject to quarantine or otherwise (subs (2)(a)); and that the quarantine officer had formed the opinion that Pepper was, or was likely to be, infected with a disease, or had been exposed to infection from a disease (subs (1)(a)). There was no dispute about the second and third of these conditions. The only question was therefore whether either Dr Cass or Mr McDonald had, in the manner contemplated by subsection (1)(a), “examined” Pepper. The parties’ submissions accepted that s 55A(1) does not bestow powers which may be exercised independently, i.e. a power to examine goods and, separately, a power to order into quarantine goods which, in the quarantine officer’s opinion, satisfy the prescribed criteria. I consider the interpretation accepted by the parties to be appropriate. It fits aptly with the language used in the provision, involves a construction of s 55A which is consistent with the analogous provisions in ss 52-54, and is consistent with its legislative history. Dr Cass did not conduct a physical examination of Pepper before ordering Pepper into quarantine on 24 August 2012. Instead, Dr Cass relied on a notification dated 23 August 2012 from Dr Irwin from Murdoch University that the testing in the United States had returned a positive result for CME, as well as departmental information about CME. In addition, Dr Cass spoke by telephone to Dr Irwin. Mr McDonald did not conduct a physical examination of Pepper. In fact, he had never set eyes on Pepper. Nor did he request any other quarantine officer to examine Pepper or to cause tests to be carried out on Pepper. In his statement of reasons, Mr McDonald identified the materials and information to which he had referred. These included (relevantly) Australia’s import requirements for dogs imported from Singapore as published on the DAFF website, which specified:Ehrlichiosis: Dogs must be tested for Ehrlichia canis infection by the indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFAT). The test must produce a negative result at a dilution of 1:40.In addition, Mr McDonald said that he had regard to a pathology report of 4 October 2012 which confirmed a positive test result and a covering email, also dated 4 October 2012, from Dr Irwin attaching the laboratory test result and confirming the diagnosis of CME. Mr McDonald’s reasons included the following paragraphs:[13]In considering, pursuant to s 55A of the Act, whether to order goods into quarantine, I am first required to examine the goods and order into quarantine any goods that … in my opinion are, or are likely to be, infected with a disease or pest. Section 5 of the Act defines “examine” in relation to an animal as including the carrying out of tests, the taking of samples or to carry out a veterinary procedure on the animal. As set out at paragraph 14 below, tests were carried out on the animal, and accordingly, I find that the goods have been examined and were ordered into quarantine.[14]In considering, pursuant to s 48 of the Act, whether … goods (goods include animals) which have been ordered into quarantine are to be exported, I am required to consider the purposes of the Act. I have done so in relation to this matter.[15]The dog’s blood test results were received by the Department on 4 October 2012. The results showed a positive test result for Ehrlichia canis (antibody titre of 1:10240). I received this result with a covering email from a specialist veterinarian in canine medicine confirming a diagnosis of canine ehrlichiosis.[16]After taking the blood test results and the covering email confirming a disease diagnosis into consideration, I formed the opinion that the dog either was, or was likely to be, infected with a disease and had also been exposed to infection from a disease.The reference in [13] to “paragraph 14” should be understood as a reference to [15].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For these reasons, I consider that the appellant has not made good his challenge to Mr McDonald’s reliance on s 55A, and in turn to his reliance on s 48.Ground 2: Failure to consider a relevant consideration? In his letter dated 31 August addressed to Dr Buttery which was copied to a number of officers within DAFF), Dr Davies informed her of the positive test result of CME and outlined the results of his physical examination of Pepper and of laboratory tests which he had organised. Under the heading “Management”, Dr Davies included the following:Doxycycline should continue indefinitely, until repeat testing has shown that infection is cleared.Doxycycline is a form of antibiotic. The appellant contended that, when making the decision to direct that Pepper be exported, Mr McDonald had not taken account of this aspect of Dr Davies’ recommended management plan. This had the consequence, it was submitted, that Mr McDonald’s decision was an improper exercise of the power in s 48(1) because he had failed to take a relevant consideration into account (ADJR Act s 5(2)(b)). In his evidence before the FCC judge, Mr McDonald said that he was aware of a recommendation that the administration of Doxycycline should continue indefinitely, but was not certain that he had been aware that it was Dr Davies who had made that recommendation. He then gave the following evidence in answer to questions from the appellant’s counsel:QIn arriving at your decision that the dog should be exported did you take into account the opinion that Doxycycline should continue indefinitely until repeat testing has shown that infection has cleared, and before you answer that I don’t mean the fact that there was a treatment strategy in place involving Doxycycline but the opinion of which you were aware that that treatment strategy should continue indefinitely until repeat testing has shown that infection is clear?AAs an explicit taking into account in terms of the decisions I exercised under the order and the direction, I would say that I did not take it into account.QCan you say why you didn’t take that into account, being aware of that opinion?AYes. I didn’t take it into account because of the other advice made available to me which was that the literature, the research literature suggests that this is a very difficult disease to clear under treatment, and treatments are not definitive in their reliability to be effective. The FCC Judge held that this evidence indicated that Mr McDonald had taken account of the recommendation that Doxycycline should continue, but had not attached any weight to it because of the literature indicating the difficulty in treating CME successfully. In the proceeding before the Judge, the appellant did not challenge Mr McDonald’s view of the literature concerning the efficacy of treatment. In my opinion, the appellant does not make good this ground of appeal. Dr Davies’ recommendation was not a “relevant consideration” within the meaning of s 5(2)(b) of the ADJR Act. That is because a treatment or management plan of an infected animal is not a matter which a quarantine officer is obliged to take into account when considering the exercise of the powers under s 48(1).