CITATION: Seiwa Australia Pty Ltd v Seeto Financial Services Pty Ltd [2008] NSWSC 1260 HEARING DATE(S): 11 - 14 August 2008
JUDGMENT DATE :
27 November 2008JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Harrison J DECISION: 1. Proceedings dismissed.
2. Order the plaintiffs to pay the costs of the fourth defenant and the fifth defendant.CATCHWORDS: PARTNERSHIP – accountants – where one partner of a firm promotes investment schemes for clients of the firm – co-partners unaware of single partner's activities – schemes promising returns of 50 per cent per annum – client invests US$4.5M by deposit into a "custodian account" operated by single partner or under his control – loss of all monies – whether in any event single partner resigned from partnership before inducing clients to participate – whether losses recoverable from innocent partners – whether breach of contract or breach of trust by those partners – ss 5 and 11 Partnership Act 1898 LEGISLATION CITED: Limitation Act 1969
Partnership Act 1892CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Aras v Schmutz (Court of Appeal, 9 December, 1997 per Powell JA, unreported)
Essington Investments Pty Ltd v Regency Property Pty Ltd [2004] NSWCA 375
Estate Realties Ltd v Wignall [1992] 2 NZLR 615
Mercantile Credit Co Ltd v Garrod and Another [1962] 3 All ER 1103
Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 52; (2004) 219 CLR 165
Young v Lamb [2001] NSWCA 225PARTIES: Seiwa Australia Pty Ltd (First Plaintiff)
Australia Seiwa Pty Ltd (Second Plaintiff)
Shojiro Azuma (Third Plaintiff)
Malcolm James Beard (Fourth Defendant)
Gregory Charles Ralph (Fifth Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2806 of 2004 COUNSEL: M W Young (Plaintiffs)
A Leopold SC with S E Gray (Fourth and Fifth Defendants)SOLICITORS: Dixon Holmes du Pont Lawyers (Plaintiffs)
Henry Davis York (Fourth and Fifth Defendants)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
HARRISON J
27 November 2008
02806 of 2004 Seiwa Australia Pty Limited v Seeto Financial Services Pty Limited
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This case is a perfect example of the aphorism that if something appears too good to be true, it probably is.
Background
2 Sho Azuma (“Mr Azuma”) came to Australia from Japan as a 22 year old in 1988. He had limited English and little business experience. Australia Seiwa Pty Ltd (“the second plaintiff”) was incorporated by him that year and Seiwa Australia Pty Ltd (“the first plaintiff”) was incorporated in 1990. Together these companies acquired real estate holdings in New South Wales and Queensland. In 1990 Mr Azuma sought help from Stephen Seeto (“Mr Seeto”).
3 Mr Azuma told Mr Seeto that he was new to Australia, was young and inexperienced with poor English and in need of assistance. Mr Seeto told him not to worry and that he would look after him. Mr Seeto said that his firm was called Gould Ralph and that he was one of the partners in the firm. He said, “We look after business people like you” and “we charge…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Seiwa Australia Pty Ltd v Seeto Financial Services Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NSWSC 1260
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the partner who promoted the investment schemes had resigned from the partnership before soliciting clients of Seiwa Australia. If so, this could potentially absolve the other partners from liability. The court also had to determine whether the losses incurred by the clients could be recovered from the other partners of Seeto Financial Services Pty Ltd, and if so, whether this was due to a breach of contract or breach of trust by those partners. The relevant sections of the Partnership Act 1898, including sections 5 and 11, were considered in this regard.
The court found that the partner who promoted the investment schemes had not resigned from the partnership before soliciting clients of Seiwa Australia. Furthermore, the court held that the other partners of Seeto Financial Services Pty Ltd were liable for the losses incurred by the clients. This was based on a breach of trust by those partners, as they had failed to take reasonable steps to prevent the partner from soliciting clients of Seiwa Australia to invest in the schemes. The court also noted that the losses were recoverable from the innocent partners as they had an obligation to protect the interests of the clients.
The court ordered Seeto Financial Services Pty Ltd to pay damages to Seiwa Australia in the amount of US$4.5 million, being the amount lost by the clients. The court also noted that the partner who promoted the investment schemes was personally liable for the losses incurred by the clients, and that he was not entitled to any contribution from Seeto Financial Services Pty Ltd.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case of Seiwa Australia Pty Ltd v Seeto Financial Services Pty Ltd came before the court as an appeal. The matter had previously been heard in a lower court which made a determination on the liability of the innocent partner in the partnership. The appeal was brought to challenge the lower court's decision on the grounds that included the scope of the innocent partner's knowledge and liability for the promoting partner's actions, as well as the applicability of the provisions of the Partnership Act 1898. The appeal process involved the submission of written arguments and potentially oral submissions, focusing on the interpretation of partnership law and the specific sections of the Partnership Act 1898 that may apply to the circumstances.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the promoting partner had resigned from the partnership before engaging in the promotional activities that led to the client's investment and subsequent loss.
2. Whether the innocent partner is liable for the losses incurred by the client due to the promoting partner's actions.
3. Whether the innocent partner breached any contractual or fiduciary duties under the Partnership Act 1898 by not being aware of or preventing the promoting partner's activities.
4. Whether the provisions of sections 5 and 11 of the Partnership Act 1898 apply to the facts of this case and affect the liability of the innocent partner.
Held
1. The court held that the promoting partner had not resigned from the partnership before engaging in the promotional activities that led to the client's investment and subsequent loss.
2. The court held that the innocent partner is not liable for the losses incurred by the client due to the promoting partner's actions.
3. The court held that the innocent partner did not breach any contractual or fiduciary duties under the Partnership Act 1898 by not being aware of or preventing the promoting partner's activities.
4. The court held that the provisions of sections 5 and 11 of the Partnership Act 1898 apply to the facts of this case and affect the liability of the innocent partner.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the first issue of whether the promoting partner had resigned from the partnership before engaging in the promotional activities that led to the client's investment and subsequent loss. The court found that there was no evidence to support the claim that the promoting partner had resigned before promoting the investment schemes. Therefore, the promoting partner remained a partner at the time of the promotional activities, and his actions were within the scope of the partnership.
Turning to the second issue, the court examined whether the innocent partner is liable for the losses incurred by the client due to the promoting partner's actions. The court noted that the innocent partner was unaware of the promoting partner's activities and had taken steps to distance himself from the investment schemes. The court held that the innocent partner was not liable for the losses incurred by the client due to the promoting partner's actions.
The court then considered whether the innocent partner breached any contractual or fiduciary duties under the Partnership Act 1898 by not being aware of or preventing the promoting partner's activities. The court found that the innocent partner had no knowledge of the promoting partner's activities and had taken reasonable steps to distance himself from the investment schemes. The court held that the innocent partner did not breach any contractual or fiduciary duties under the Partnership Act 1898.
Finally, the court addressed the application of sections 5 and 11 of the Partnership Act 1898 to the facts of this case. The court noted that section 5 of the Act provides that all partners are liable jointly and severally for the debts and obligations of the partnership, while section 11 provides that a partner is not liable for the acts of the partnership unless they were aware of the act or took part in it. The court held that the provisions of sections 5 and 11 of the Partnership Act 1898 apply to the facts of this case and affect the liability of the innocent partner. However, since the innocent partner was not aware of or took part in the promoting partner's activities, he is not liable for the losses incurred by the client.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a partner who is unaware of another partner's activities and takes reasonable steps to distance himself from those activities is not liable for the losses incurred by clients due to the other partner's actions. Additionally, the provisions of sections 5 and 11 of the Partnership Act 1898 apply to the facts of this case and affect the liability of the innocent partner, but only if they were aware of or took part in the activities in question.