Seirlis v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND

ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION:

Seirlis & Ors v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2023] QCAT 299

PARTIES:

TERRY SEIRLIS

(first applicant)

TIES GROUP PTY LTD ACN 130 450 341

(second applicant)

UKL PTY LTD ACN 123 360 823

(third applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

QR160-07

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

26 June 2023

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

A/Deputy President Brown

ORDERS:

The application for miscellaneous matters filed 26 April 2023 is refused.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY – ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION – MEDIATION – where the applicants sought an order from the tribunal referring the matter for private mediation – where the proposed mediator is not one of the persons referred to in s 79 of the QCAT Act – where the tribunal does not have the power to refer the matter to private mediation

Dispute Resolution Centres Act 1990 (Qld), s 27AB

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 3(b), s 4(b) s 75(1), s 79

Goldfield Projects Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2015] QCATA 101

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

What is this application about?

  1. The applicants have applied for an order that the proceeding be referred for private mediation with the costs of the mediation to be borne equally by the parties.

  2. The order sought by the applicants is in the following terms:

    That pursuant to s. 75 of the QCAT Act or alternatively paragraphs 31 – 33 of QCAT PD no. 9 of 2022 by no later than 7 June 2023 the parties attend and genuinely participate in a mediation of the dispute on the following terms:

    a.       The parties appoint Mr Martin Daubney AM KC as the mediator;

    b.       The mediation must be attended by those persons who have the ultimate responsibility for deciding to settle the dispute, and the terms of any settlement, and the lawyers who have ultimate responsibility to advise the parties in relation to the dispute and its settlement;

    c.       The costs of the mediation, including venue and the mediators fees, are to be borne equally between the parties;

    d.       The brief to the mediator shall be prepared by the applicants, with a draft to be provided to the respondent for review, no later than 7 days before the mediation is to occur.

    The background

  3. This matter is one of a number of related proceedings which have had an extraordinarily lengthy history in the Court of Appeal, this Tribunal and, prior to the creation of QCAT, the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal (‘CCT’).

  4. The facts of the case are of some complexity which I do not propose to recite at length. In summary, the construction of 10 townhouses was undertaken by a building contractor. The applicants’ (the building…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seirlis v Queensland Building and Construction Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 299
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Seirlis v Queensland Building and Construction Commission, the applicants sought an order from the tribunal referring the matter for private mediation. The applicants proposed that Mr Martin Daubney AM KC act as the mediator and that the mediation be attended by individuals with decision-making authority, along with their legal representatives. The applicants argued that mediation would provide an opportunity for the parties to discuss all outstanding claims and potentially resolve the disputes in a cost-effective and timely manner. The Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) opposed the application, contending that the tribunal lacked the power to refer the matter to private mediation because the proposed mediator did not fall within the categories specified in section 79 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (QCAT Act).

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the tribunal had the jurisdiction to refer the matter to private mediation when the proposed mediator was not one of the persons listed in section 79 of the QCAT Act. The court considered whether the tribunal had the authority to order mediation under section 75 of the QCAT Act or through the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Practice Directions 2022. The court also examined whether the mediation terms proposed by the applicants were appropriate and whether there were any valid reasons for the QBCC to oppose the mediation.

The court concluded that the tribunal did not have the power to refer the matter to private mediation because the proposed mediator did not meet the criteria set out in section 79 of the QCAT Act. The court found that the tribunal’s authority to refer matters for mediation was limited to mediators appointed by the tribunal or principal registrar, or those listed in section 79. Since Mr Daubney AM KC was not an approved mediator under the Act, the tribunal could not order the parties to participate in mediation with him. The court further noted that even if it had the jurisdiction to order mediation, the proposed terms were not unreasonable, but the lack of jurisdictional power precluded the making of the order sought by the applicants.

The court declined to make the order sought by the applicants, stating that the tribunal did not have the necessary jurisdiction to refer the matter for private mediation with the proposed mediator. The application for miscellaneous matters was consequently refused. The court emphasized that the proposed mediator must fall within the categories specified in section 79 of the QCAT Act for the tribunal to have the authority to order mediation. As Mr Daubney AM KC did not meet these criteria, the tribunal was unable to grant the applicants' request.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for miscellaneous matters filed 26 April 2023 is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

The order sought by the applicants is in the following terms:That pursuant to s. 75 of the QCAT Act or alternatively paragraphs 31 – 33 of QCAT PD no. 9 of 2022 by no later than 7 June 2023 the parties attend and genuinely participate in a mediation of the dispute on the following terms:a. The parties appoint Mr Martin Daubney AM KC as the mediator;b. The mediation must be attended by those persons who have the ultimate responsibility for deciding to settle the dispute, and the terms of any settlement, and the lawyers who have ultimate responsibility to advise the parties in relation to the dispute and its settlement;c. The costs of the mediation, including venue and the mediators fees, are to be borne equally between the parties;d. The brief to the mediator shall be prepared by the applicants, with a draft to be provided to the respondent for review, no later than 7 days before the mediation is to occur. The background This matter is one of a number of related proceedings which have had an extraordinarily lengthy history in the Court of Appeal, this Tribunal and, prior to the creation of QCAT, the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal (‘CCT’). The facts of the case are of some complexity which I do not propose to recite at length. In summary, the construction of 10 townhouses was undertaken by a building contractor. The applicants’ (the building owners’) affairs involved a complex arrangement of individuals, corporations and trusts. Suffice it to say the applicants assert that the building work was defective. This led to claims being made for assistance under the statutory insurance scheme operated by the (then) QBSA. The claim relating to the lot the subject of this proceeding was, as were the other claims, declined by the QBSA on the basis that the named claimant was not the owner of the lot. The applicants sought a review of the QBSA decision. The present proceeding was commenced in the CCT as were proceedings in respect of another five lots. This and three other proceedings were adjourned pending the outcome of another two proceedings relating to different lots. Those proceedings ended with an unsuccessful appeal to the Court of Appeal. Of the four proceedings remaining in the Tribunal, this proceeding has continued, with the other three proceedings adjourned pending the outcome in this matter. It should be added that there are also other related claims for assistance under the statutory insurance scheme. Following a compulsory conference in November 2022 the applicants were directed to file points of claim identifying the legal and factual issues in the proceedings, the material facts relied upon and specifying the relief sought. Directions were made for the respondent to respond and permitting the applicants to reply. These directions were complied with prior to a further compulsory conference being held in May 2023. What do the parties say? The applicants say that mediation will present an opportunity for the parties to discuss all current review applications and the further claims made by the applicants but not yet decided by the QBCC. A mediation, say the applicants, will afford the parties an opportunity to dispose of all the outstanding claims in a cost effective and timely manner.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the foregoing reasons even if I was satisfied that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to make the orders sought by the applicants, I would decline to do so. Conclusion The application for miscellaneous matters is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicants in reply say, by reference to the sub-paragraphs above:(a)There are a number of issues of fact and law which were not relevant to or raised in the proceedings determined by the Court of Appeal. There is therefore utility in a mediation to assist in adding clarity to the matters in dispute and affording the parties an opportunity to reconsider their positions;(b)The QBCC is required to assist the Tribunal to make the correct and preferable decision. As a Model Litigant the QBCC is also required to facilitate the appropriate and timely resolution of the dispute. As to the absence of any power in the mediator to order that the QBCC reconsider its decision, the applicants say that an agreement could be reached that the Decision be set aside;(c)Until such time as the points of claim directions had been complied with, there could not be any worthwhile discussions between the parties. The QBCC concedes that a further compulsory conference could be held, however a mediation is a more efficient way of progressing the proceeding;(d)The applicants concede that there will be a cost associated with a mediation, however the QBCC is better placed than the applicants to bear this cost. Additionally, the mediation could be conducted expeditiously;(e)The matters raised by the Commission in relation to the constraints imposed upon it by the policy of insurance are not valid reasons why a mediation should not be held.Consideration The Tribunal is required to deal with matters in a way that is accessible, fair, just, economical, informal and quick.[1] The Tribunal must encourage the early and economical resolution of disputes including, if appropriate, through alternative dispute resolution processes.[2] The procedure for a proceeding is at the discretion of the Tribunal subject to the QCAT Act and rules and any relevant enabling Act.[3][1]QCAT Act, s 3(b).[2]Ibid, s 4(b).[3]Ibid, s 28(1). Chapter 2, Part 6, Divisions 1A, 2 and 3 of the QCAT Act deal with alternative dispute resolution processes. The tribunal or the principal registrar may refer parties to a proceeding to attend conciliation (Division 1A). The tribunal or the principal registrar may direct the parties to a proceeding to attend a compulsory conference (Division 2). The tribunal or the principal registrar may refer the subject matter of a proceeding for mediation by a mediator appointed by the tribunal or principal registrar (Division 3). Section 75(1) of the QCAT Act provides that the tribunal may refer the subject matter of a proceeding for mediation by a mediator appointed by the tribunal or principal registrar. Section 79 sets out who may be a mediator. A person may be a mediator for a proceeding only if the person is:(a)A member; (b)An adjudicator;(c)The principal registrar;(d)A mediator under the Dispute Resolution Centres Act 1990 (Qld); or(e)A person, including, for example, a registrar or registry staff member, approved by the principal registrar as a mediator for the tribunal. The Dispute Resolution Centres Act 1990 (Qld) (‘DRCA’) s 2 defines a mediator, in relation to a dispute resolution centre, as: the director of the centre; or a person appointed under s 27AB as a mediator for the centre.