Segator Pty Ltd v FKS Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Segator Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application number 1849584 (class 30) – PAGOTO GELATO & WAFFLE HOUSE and device - in the name of FKS Australia Pty Ltd.

– and –

Application by FKS Australia Pty Ltd for an extension of time to file evidence in answer

Delegate:

Aaron Walters

Representation:

Opponent: Victor Ng of Cooper Mills Lawyers.

Applicant: Morris Averill for Minas & Associates.

Decision:

2019 ATMO 126

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under section 52 – application for extension of time to file evidence under regulation 5.15 – grounds for extension of time under regulation 5.15(a) and (b) considered – extension refused - request to admit late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 – request refused.

Background

  1. Registration of trade mark application number 1849584 in the name of FKS Australia Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’) has been opposed by Segator Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’). The evidence stages commenced with the Applicant filing its Notice of Intention to Defend on 28 June 2018 and on 3 October 2018 the Opponent filed its completed evidence in support.

  2. Regulation 5.14(4) of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘the Regulations’), provides that the Applicant must file its evidence in answer within three months of being provided and notified, by the Registrar, of the Opponent’s filed and completed evidence in support. Accordingly, the Applicant was required to file its evidence in answer by 11 January 2019.

  3. On 11 January 2019, the Applicant sought an extension of time (‘EOT’) of one month within which to file its evidence in answer. The EOT was accompanied by a declaration in support (‘the first EOT declaration’). A further declaration was filed annexing a “certified translation of the word “pagoto” from the Etymological Dictionary of Modern Greek”, with the translation having been undertaken by the “Translation Service of the Greek Ministry of Foreign Affairs” (‘the Translation declaration’).

  4. A delegate of the Registrar wrote to the Applicant on 24 January 2019 intending to refuse the EOT and a copy of the delegate’s letter, as well as the EOT, were sent to the Opponent at the same time. On 7 February 2019, the Applicant responded with a declaration supplementing the EOT (‘the second EOT declaration’) and filed its completed evidence in answer, being the declaration made on 23 January 2019 by Constantin Skouras as director of the Applicant (the Skouras Declaration’). The Skouras Declaration included attachments marked “A” to “D” with attachment “C” being a declaration made on 23 January 2018 by Costa Potiris, an accredited Greek translator, and attachment “D” being a statutory declaration made 22 January 2019 by Nektaria Theodossiou. The delegate of the Registrar again responded, expressing an intention to refuse, though gave the Applicant a window of time in which to seek a hearing. The second EOT declaration and the delegate’s letter were again forwarded to the Opponent.

  5. On 25 February 2019, the Opponent sought to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Segator Pty Ltd v FKS Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 126
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by Segator Pty Ltd (the Opponent) against an application by FKS Australia Pty Ltd (the Applicant) for a trade mark. The Opponent sought an extension of time to file evidence in support of its opposition, and subsequently sought to admit late-filed evidence. The decision was made by Aaron Walters.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Applicant had established sufficient grounds for an extension of time to file its evidence, pursuant to regulation 5.15 of the *Trade Marks Regulations 1995* (Cth), and whether the late-filed evidence should be admitted under regulation 21.19. The Applicant's stated reasons for seeking the extension included the need to review a statement of grounds and particulars from a separate, but related, dispute between the parties, and to obtain further declarations regarding the translation of the Greek word "PAGOTO" and the Opponent's use of that word as a business name.

The court refused the application for an extension of time. It found that the Applicant's initial assertion that it needed to review a statement of grounds from another proceeding was insufficient, and that the Applicant had already prepared evidence in relation to the current opposition, requiring only amendment and finalisation. The court noted that the Applicant had filed only one declaration on the statutory deadline, with the remainder of its evidence filed significantly later. The reasons provided for the delay, including the Christmas and New Year break and a relocation of the Applicant's office, were not considered to be exceptional circumstances justifying an extension. Consequently, the request to admit the late-filed evidence was also refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Segator Pty Ltd, the Applicant, filed an opposition to the registration of trade mark application 1849584 by FKS Australia Pty Ltd, the Opponent, under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The opposition hinged on multiple grounds, including the meaning of the term "PAGOTO," which is used in the device mark. In its opposition, the Applicant argued that the term "PAGOTO" translates to "ice cream," which the Applicant contended could lead to confusion with its own trade mark. The Applicant aimed to contest the validity of the mark by providing various declarations to substantiate its claims.

The Applicant initially filed a Translation Declaration on the statutory deadline but delayed filing the remaining evidence until 7 February 2019. The Applicant attributed the delay to several factors, including the inability to access the Opponent’s Statement of Grounds and Particulars filed on 11 December 2018, which the Applicant claimed was relevant to preparing its evidence. Additionally, the Applicant encountered difficulties obtaining a certified translation of the Greek word "PAGOTO" and a declaration from a Greek-Australian translator. These delays were exacerbated by the Christmas and New Year break and the relocation of the Applicant's office. Despite obtaining the necessary translations and declarations by 23 January 2019, the Applicant still sought an extension of time to file its evidence.

Further, the Applicant needed additional time to gather updated evidence regarding whether the Opponent operated under the name "PAGOTO" at various advertised locations in New South Wales and Victoria. Declarations were obtained from Constantin Skouras and Nektaria Theodosiou on 23 and 22 January 2019, respectively, to address these issues. Despite the reasons provided, the Applicant sought an extension of time to file its evidence and also requested the tribunal to admit the late filed evidence, both of which were ultimately refused by the tribunal.

The case of Segator Pty Ltd v FKS Australia Pty Ltd originated as an opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Applicant, Segator Pty Ltd, filed an opposition to the registration of a trade mark by the Respondent, FKS Australia Pty Ltd. During the course of this opposition, Segator Pty Ltd made an application for an extension of time (EOT) to file evidence, pursuant to regulation 5.15 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth). The initial application for an EOT was made on 7 February 2019, and further declarations were subsequently filed to explain the reasons for the delay in submitting the required evidence. The opposition proceedings included submissions and counter-submissions from both parties regarding the adequacy of the reasons for the delay and the relevance of the evidence sought to be filed out of time. Following this, Segator Pty Ltd also sought to admit the late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth), a request that was ultimately refused by the court.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Returning then, I find it useful to start with the first EOT declaration in which the Applicant declares it had not been able to access the Opponent’s Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’) filed on 11 December 2018 in relation to a separate dispute between the parties. The Applicant asserted that this other SGP was relevant to the preparation of evidence for the current opposition. Relevantly, the Applicant sought the EOT to: … review the [SGP] and amend and finalize evidence prepared in relation to TM 1849584. [Emphasis added] Notwithstanding the limited adequacy of such a reason for an EOT, the above quoted statement indicates the Applicant as having prepared evidence in relation to this opposition which is in an almost completed state, requiring only amendment and finalization. Noting that evidence is often filed as it becomes ready,[6] I find it telling, particularly in light of there being five nominated grounds of opposition to address, that the Applicant chose to file only the Translation Declaration on the day of the statutory deadline, while the remainder of its evidence was filed sometime after on 7 February 2019. The reasons for the delay are further detail in the second EOT declaration, reproduced below:2. In the declaration of Kathy Koulax, dated 3 October 2018, the Opponent asserted that the correct translation of the Greek word PAGOTO, which is used in the device mark, is ICECREAM. The Opponent has also based its opposition to the registration of the device mark on section 62(b) Trade Marks Act and the Opponent has asserted that the Applicant has accepted that the correct translation Greek word PAGOTO is ICECREAM. The applicant needs further time in which to obtain a declaration from a certified translator from the Greek language to the English language as to the appropriate translation of the Greek word PAGOTO in order to answer the assertions of the Opponent.3. The Applicant has obtained a certified translation of an extract from the "Etymological Dictionary of Modern Greek" as to the meaning of PAGOTO and the Applicant needs further time to obtain a declaration from a Greek-Australian translator, as to the literal meaning of PAGOTO as being "congealed" as indicating a frozen dessert, which can be made from cream and milk or be milk free. The Applicant was delayed in obtaining the further declaration by:3.1 the Christmas and New Year break from 21 December 2018 - 14 January3.2 the relocation of my office from Suite 7 1 Clarke St Earlwood NSW 2206 to:Suite 62 3-7 Fetherstone St Bankstown NSW 2200 during the period 10 January 2019 - 21 January 2018.4. A declaration was obtained from Costa Potiris, a Greek-Australian translator, on 23 January 2019, which has been filed with IP Australia, together with the declaration from Constantine Skouras, dated 23 January, 2019, which addressed the matters raised in the declaration of Kathy Koulax, dated 3 October 2018.5. In the declaration of Kathy Koulax, dated 3 October 2018, the Opponent asserted use of the business name Pagoto at various locations. The applicant needs further time in which to obtain updated evidence as to whether the Opponent actually operates under the name Pagoto at any of its advertised locations in the State of NSW and State of Victoria on the Opponent's website. Declarations were obtained from Constantin Skouras dated 23 January 2019 and Nektaria Theodosiou dated 22 January 2019.[6] Trek Bicycle Corporation v Red Hawk Holdings Pty Ltd [2019] ATMO 88, [24].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) permit an extension of time for filing evidence in opposition proceedings under regulation 5.15(a) and (b) when the applicant asserts they could not access relevant documents?
2. Was the delay in obtaining a translation declaration for the Greek word "PAGOTO" due to the Christmas and New Year break, and the relocation of the applicant’s office, sufficient grounds for an extension of time under regulation 5.15?
3. Does the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) allow for the admission of late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 when the applicant has already filed some evidence on time?
4. Is the inability to verify the opponent's claimed use of the business name "Pagoto" at various locations a valid reason for extending the time to file evidence in opposition proceedings?

Held
1. Does the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) permit an extension of time for filing evidence in opposition proceedings under regulation 5.15(a) and (b) when the applicant asserts they could not access relevant documents? The court concluded that the inability to access relevant documents, specifically the Opponent’s Statement of Grounds and Particulars, did not justify an extension of time under regulation 5.15(a) and (b). As a result, the extension of time was refused.
2. Was the delay in obtaining a translation declaration for the Greek word "PAGOTO" due to the Christmas and New Year break, and the relocation of the applicant’s office, sufficient grounds for an extension of time under regulation 5.15? The court concluded that the Christmas and New Year break and the relocation of the applicant’s office did not constitute sufficient grounds for an extension of time under regulation 5.15. Consequently, the extension of time was refused.
3. Does the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) allow for the admission of late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 when the applicant has already filed some evidence on time? The court concluded that the late filing of evidence, despite some evidence being filed on time, was not permitted under regulation 21.19. Thus, the request to admit the late filed evidence was refused.
4. Is the inability to verify the opponent's claimed use of the business name "Pagoto" at various locations a valid reason for extending the time to file evidence in opposition proceedings? The court concluded that the inability to verify the opponent’s claimed use of the business name "Pagoto" at various locations did not constitute a valid reason for extending the time to file evidence in opposition proceedings. Therefore, no extension of time was granted for this reason.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Segator Pty Ltd v FKS Australia Pty Ltd considered whether the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) permits an extension of time (EOT) for filing evidence in opposition proceedings under regulation 5.15(a) and (b) when the applicant asserts they could not access relevant documents. The applicant in this case had prepared evidence in relation to the opposition, which was in an almost completed state, requiring only amendment and finalization. The applicant claimed that it could not access the Opponent’s Statement of Grounds and Particulars, which was relevant to the preparation of its evidence. Despite this, the applicant chose to file only the Translation Declaration on the day of the statutory deadline, while the remainder of its evidence was filed after the deadline. The court found that the applicant had prepared evidence in an almost completed state, indicating that the reasons for delay were insufficient to warrant an extension under regulation 5.15.

The second major issue addressed by the court was whether the delay in obtaining a translation declaration for the Greek word "PAGOTO" due to the Christmas and New Year break and the relocation of the applicant’s office was sufficient grounds for an extension of time under regulation 5.15. The applicant had obtained a certified translation of an extract from the "Etymological Dictionary of Modern Greek" and needed further time to obtain a declaration from a Greek-Australian translator. The applicant was delayed by the Christmas and New Year break and the relocation of its office. The court considered these reasons for the delay and noted that while the applicant had made efforts to obtain the necessary declaration, the reasons provided did not sufficiently justify the delay in filing the evidence. The Christmas and New Year break and the relocation of the applicant’s office were considered insufficient grounds for an extension of time under regulation 5.15.

The third issue was whether the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) allows for the admission of late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 when the applicant has already filed some evidence on time. The applicant had filed some evidence on time but sought to admit late filed evidence. The court considered the relevant principles and authorities and found that the applicant’s request to admit late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 was not sufficient to warrant an exception to the statutory deadline. The court held that the applicant’s failure to file the remaining evidence on time was not justified and that the request to admit the late filed evidence was refused.

Lastly, the court considered whether the inability to verify the opponent's claimed use of the business name "Pagoto" at various locations was a valid reason for extending the time to file evidence in opposition proceedings. The applicant sought further time to obtain updated evidence as to whether the opponent actually operates under the name "Pagoto" at any of its advertised locations. The court found that the inability to verify the opponent's claimed use of the business name "Pagoto" was not a valid reason for extending the time to file evidence in opposition proceedings. The applicant's request for an extension of time was refused.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) does not permit an extension of time for filing evidence in opposition proceedings under regulation 5.15(a) and (b) when the applicant asserts they could not access relevant documents, the delay in obtaining a translation declaration due to the Christmas and New Year break and the relocation of the applicant’s office is insufficient grounds for an extension of time under regulation 5.15, the court will not admit late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 when the applicant has already filed some evidence on time, and the inability to verify the opponent's claimed use of the business name is not a valid reason for extending the time to file evidence in opposition proceedings. The court in this case followed prior authority and did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority.