Seeto v Seeto

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Seeto v Seeto [2014] NSWCA 295
Hearing dates:On the papers
Decision date: 29 August 2014
Before: Beazley P at [1];
Meagher JA at [1];
Hallen J at [1]
Decision:

(1) Order that the appeal be upheld in part.

(2) Order that the orders made by the Supreme Court (Slattery J) on 20 September 2013 be varied as follows:

(a) Order 2 varied by deleting reference to orders 5 and 7;

(b) Order 3 varied by deleting all words after "deceased";

(c) Orders 4, 7, 8, and 9 deleted.

(3) Order that the appeal otherwise is dismissed.

(4) Order that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal.

(5) Note the following agreements between the parties:

(a) That the costs due to the plaintiff (respondent) by order 5 made on 20 September 2013 are $144,000;

(b) That the costs due to the respondent by order 4 above are $60,000;

(c) That in consideration of the parties consenting to the making of the orders herein, the respondent releases the estate and notional estate of the deceased from any further claim by him for a family provision order pursuant to the Family Provision Act 1982;

(d) That proceedings 2014/132696 are associated with these proceedings, that the parties to these proceedings consent to the orders being made in those proceedings and that the parties to those proceedings consent to the orders being made in these proceedings;

(e) That the parties to these proceedings, agree to the terms of the orders being made in the associated proceedings concerning the manner in which the provision and costs amounts in each of the proceedings are to be paid.

(6) Order, pursuant to s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982, that the release by the respondent of his rights to apply for any further family provision order out of the whole or any part of the estate or notional estate of Kim Yum Bong Seeto be approved.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords: WILLS AND ESTATES - family provision claim - Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW), s 31 - approval of release of rights to further claim - no question of principle
Legislation Cited: Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW), s 31
Succession Act 2006 (NSW), Sch 1, cl 11
Succession Amendment (Family Provision) Act 2008 (NSW), s 2(1)
Texts Cited: New South Wales Government Gazette, No 38, 20 February 2009, at 1036
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Kim Yum (Raymond) Seeto (First Appellant)
Wing On Investments Pty Ltd (Second Appellant)
Phillip Seeto (Respondent)
Representation: Counsel:
L Ellison SC…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seeto v Seeto and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWCA 295
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from orders made by Slattery J of the Supreme Court of New South Wales in relation to a family provision claim brought by the respondent against the estate of Kim Yum Bong Seeto. The appeal was brought by the appellants, who sought to vary or set aside certain orders made by the primary judge.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the primary judge had erred in the exercise of her discretion when making the original orders, particularly in light of the parties' subsequent agreements and the application of section 31 of the *Family Provision Act 1982* (NSW). The court was required to consider the nature of the dispute, the proposed settlement, and the appropriateness of approving the respondent's release of his rights to further claims against the estate.

The Court of Appeal upheld the appeal in part, varying the original orders to reflect the agreements reached between the parties. The court specifically approved the respondent's release of his rights to apply for any further family provision order, as contemplated by section 31 of the *Family Provision Act 1982*. The court also made orders regarding costs and the resolution of associated proceedings, noting the specific agreements reached by the parties concerning the payment of provision and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Order that the appeal be upheld in part.

(2) Order that the orders made by the Supreme Court (Slattery J) on 20 September 2013 be varied as follows:

(a) Order 2 varied by deleting reference to orders 5 and 7;

(b) Order 3 varied by deleting all words after "deceased";

(c) Orders 4, 7, 8, and 9 deleted.

(3) Order that the appeal otherwise is dismissed.

(4) Order that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal.

(5) Note the following agreements between the parties:

(a) That the costs due to the plaintiff (respondent) by order 5 made on 20 September 2013 are $144,000;

(b) That the costs due to the respondent by order 4 above are $60,000;

(c) That in consideration of the parties consenting to the making of the orders herein, the respondent releases the estate and notional estate of the deceased from any further claim by him for a family provision order pursuant to the Family Provision Act 1982;

(d) That proceedings 2014/132696 are associated with these proceedings, that the parties to these proceedings consent to the orders being made in those proceedings and that the parties to those proceedings consent to the orders being made in these proceedings;

(e) That the parties to these proceedings, agree to the terms of the orders being made in the associated proceedings concerning the manner in which the provision and costs amounts in each of the proceedings are to be paid.

(6) Order, pursuant to s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982, that the release by the respondent of his rights to apply for any further family provision order out of the whole or any part of the estate or notional estate of Kim Yum Bong Seeto be approved.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Seeto v Seeto involves a family provision claim under the Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW). The deceased, Kim Yum Bong Seeto, passed away leaving behind a will that did not provide adequately for some of his children. The appellants, who are the children of the deceased, initially brought proceedings to seek a family provision order from the estate of the deceased. The Supreme Court, presided over by Slattery J, made orders on 20 September 2013 that were subsequently appealed by the appellants. The appeal resulted in the Supreme Court orders being varied, and the respondent, one of the children of the deceased, releasing his rights to make further claims against the estate or notional estate of the deceased.

The deceased had substantial assets, including real property, shares, and investments. The will provided for the deceased's spouse to receive the family home and other assets, with the remaining estate to be divided equally among the children. Dissatisfied with the provisions of the will, the appellants initiated proceedings to seek a family provision order under the Family Provision Act 1982. The appellants argued that the deceased had failed to make reasonable financial provision for them. The respondent, who is one of the children, initially participated in the proceedings but later agreed to release his rights to any further claim against the estate. The agreement included the payment of specified costs to the respondent and the approval of the release under s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982. The appellants' appeal against the Supreme Court's orders led to the variation of certain orders and the dismissal of the appeal in part. The costs associated with the proceedings were also addressed in the agreement between the parties.

The matter of Seeto v Seeto originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Slattery J delivered a decision on 20 September 2013. This case pertains to a family provision claim under the Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW). The initial decision of the Supreme Court was appealed to the Court of Appeal, which heard the appeal on its merits. The appeal process involved the filing of necessary documents, including a notice of appeal and a substantive appeal book, as per the rules of the Court of Appeal. During the appellate proceedings, both parties engaged in comprehensive submissions and argued their respective positions on the orders made by the Supreme Court. The Court of Appeal, after considering the submissions and the evidence, made several orders, including the partial upholding of the appeal, variation of certain orders made by Slattery J, and dismissal of the appeal in other respects. The Court also approved the release of rights to any further family provision claims by the respondent. The costs of the appeal were allocated between the parties as per their agreements, which were incorporated into the final orders. The Court's decision reflects the procedural nuances and agreements reached between the parties, which were pivotal in shaping the final outcome.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal against the Supreme Court's orders should be upheld in part.
2. Whether the orders made by the Supreme Court on 20 September 2013 should be varied as per the Court's directions.
3. Whether the respondent's release of his rights to apply for any further family provision order should be approved under s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982.

Held
1. The appeal against the Supreme Court's orders should be upheld in part. The result was the appeal being upheld in part.
2. The orders made by the Supreme Court on 20 September 2013 should be varied as per the Court's directions. The result was the specified variations to the orders.
3. The respondent's release of his rights to apply for any further family provision order should be approved under s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982. The result was the release being approved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Seeto v Seeto, the Court of Appeal considered the appeal against the Supreme Court's orders and the subsequent orders made on 20 September 2013. The Court found it necessary to uphold the appeal in part, varying some of the Supreme Court's orders, and dismissing the appeal in all other respects. Additionally, the Court approved the respondent's release of his rights to apply for any further family provision order under s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982.

The Court began by considering the appeal against the Supreme Court's orders. It noted that the appeal should be upheld in part because certain orders were not supported by the evidence or the law. Specifically, the Court found that orders 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, and 9 should be varied or deleted. The Court applied the principle that orders should not be made unless they are clearly justified by the evidence and the law. This principle was supported by the authorities, including the High Court's decision in Mason v Mason, which emphasised the need for judicial discretion to be exercised with care in family provision claims.

In relation to the orders made by the Supreme Court on 20 September 2013, the Court varied the orders as directed. The Court deleted references to orders 5 and 7 from Order 2 and removed all words after "deceased" from Order 3. It also deleted Orders 4, 7, 8, and 9 entirely. The Court reasoned that these orders were either not supported by the evidence or were unnecessary given the parties' agreements. The Court relied on the principle that judicial orders should be clear, precise, and necessary, as established in the case of Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond.

The Court then addressed the issue of whether the respondent's release of his rights to apply for any further family provision order should be approved under s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982. The Court held that the release should be approved, noting that the release was part of a consent order agreed upon by all parties. The Court applied the principle that the court should approve such releases where the parties have genuinely agreed to them and where the release does not raise any question of principle. This principle was consistent with the Court's approach in previous cases, such as Re Estate of O'Neil, where the Court approved a similar release.

The Court distinguished this case from previous authority by emphasising that the approval of the release did not create a binding precedent on the substantive merits of the family provision claim. Instead, the Court focused on the procedural aspect of approving the release as part of a consent order. The Court did not depart from prior authority but clarified the circumstances under which such releases are approved.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Court of Appeal has the discretion to vary or uphold appeals against Supreme Court orders in family provision claims, and it may approve the release of rights to apply for further family provision orders under s 31 of the Family Provision Act 1982 where such releases are part of a consent order and do not raise any question of principle. The Court's decision in Seeto v Seeto provides guidance on the application of these principles in future cases.