Seekamp v Nominal Defendant

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

SEEKAMP v NOMINAL DEFENDANT

[2008] SASC 320

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice David)

20 November 2008

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT - WHERE FINDINGS BASED ON CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES - NECESSITY FOR FINDING TO BE CLEARLY WRONG

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - RIGHT OF APPEAL - WHEN APPEAL LIES - ERROR OF LAW - PARTICULAR CASES INVOLVING ERROR OF LAW - FAILURE TO GIVE REASONS FOR DECISION - EXTENT OF OBLIGATION TO GIVE REASONS

Appeal from dismissal of claim for damages for personal injuries following trial - proceedings issued against Nominal Defendant pursuant to s 115 of Motor Vehicles Act 1959 (SA) - issue at trial was whether appellant had been hit by unidentified motor vehicle causing his injury - trial judge considered eyewitness evidence of appellant and appellant's brother unreliable - trial judge found that appellant had not been hit by unidentified motor vehicle causing his injury - whether trial judge adequately considered evidence led at trial as to what caused appellant's injury.

Held:  Appeal dismissed - trial judge adequately considered evidence - trial judge did not err in not considering causes of injury which were not supported by evidence.

Motor Vehicles Act 1959 (SA) s 115, referred to.
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118, applied.
Papps v Police (2000) 77 SASR 210; Sun Alliance Insurance Ltd v Massoud [1989] VR 8, considered.

SEEKAMP v NOMINAL DEFENDANT
[2008] SASC 320

Full Court:  Gray, Sulan and David JJ

GRAY J.

  1. This is an appeal from the dismissal of a claim for damages following a trial in the District Court.

  2. Ashley Cameron Seekamp, the plaintiff and appellant, claimed damages from the nominal defendant, the defendant and respondent.  Mr Seekamp claimed that he had been struck by a motor vehicle and as a consequence sustained a serious leg injury.  The issue at trial was whether there had been any collision at all, or whether Mr Seekamp had injured his knee through some other incident.

  3. The trial Judge dismissed the claim, concluding that she was not satisfied that Mr Seekamp had established that a collision had occurred between himself and a motor vehicle.

  4. The trial Judge concluded that Mr Seekamp and his brother, the suggested witnesses to the incident, were unreliable witnesses.  The Judge was not prepared to act on their evidence.  In reaching this conclusion, the Judge had regard to the inconsistent accounts of the incident given by Mr Seekamp.  Initially, Mr Seekamp spoke of tripping in the gutter.  His assertion that he had been struck by a motor vehicle was not made until about 10 days later.  The fact that Mr Seekamp provided glaringly inconsistent accounts of how he sustained the injury, together with other factors identified by the Judge, led to the conclusion that his testimony was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seekamp v Nominal Defendant and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 320
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Seekamp v Nominal Defendant was an appeal against the dismissal of a claim for damages for personal injuries following a trial. The appellant alleged that he was hit by an unidentified motor vehicle, resulting in injury. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the trial judge dismissed the claim. The appellant's contention was that the trial judge did not adequately consider the evidence regarding the cause of his injury. The court was tasked with determining whether the trial judge's findings were clearly wrong and if there was an error of law in the failure to give reasons for the decision.

The primary legal issue in this appeal was whether the trial judge adequately considered the evidence presented at trial and whether there was an error of law in the failure to give reasons for the decision. The appellant argued that the trial judge did not properly consider the evidence, particularly the medical evidence and eyewitness accounts. The court needed to assess whether the trial judge's findings of fact were based on credible evidence and whether there was a legal obligation to provide reasons for the decision.

The court held that the trial judge had adequately considered all the evidence presented at trial, including the medical evidence and eyewitness accounts. The trial judge observed the witnesses and found their evidence unreliable due to significant inconsistencies. The court found that the trial judge's findings were not clearly wrong and that there was no error of law in the failure to give reasons for the decision. The appellate court emphasised the importance of the trial judge's observations of the witnesses and the credibility of their testimony in reaching a decision.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeal, affirming the trial judge's findings and conclusions. The court found no merit in the appellant's contention that the trial judge had not adequately considered the evidence or failed to provide reasons for the decision. The court held that the trial judge's findings were supported by the evidence and that there was no error of law in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appellant gave evidence and called his brother. In addition, three orthopaedic surgeons were called, namely, Mr Rory Montgomery, Mr Adrian von der Borch and Mr Robert Atkinson. In addition, the appellant called his mother, Lynette Seekamp. The respondent called no oral evidence. The parties tendered written material, including notes from the Royal Adelaide Hospital, the Glenside Hospital and the appellant’s general practitioner, of Brooker Medical Clinic.The appellant’s evidence at trial The appellant gave evidence that he is aged 26 years. He said that on the evening of the incident he went to a friend’s house at Hectorville with his brother, Justin Seekamp. They travelled in his brother’s motor vehicle. Whilst there, the appellant consumed six stubbies of beer and both he and his brother smoked “a little bit of pot”. When they left the friend’s house to return home at around 11.45 pm, his brother drove and they travelled north‑east along Lower North East Road, Campbelltown. The appellant wanted to stop at a service station, located on the opposite side of the road, to buy some cigarettes. His brother missed a turnoff in the median strip, and instead of performing a u-turn to park in front of the service station, he stopped the vehicle on the opposite side of the road, facing the north-easterly direction in which they had been travelling. The appellant intended to alight from the vehicle and walk across the road. The appellant gave evidence that he stepped out onto the footpath on the passenger’s side of the motor vehicle, walked around the back of the vehicle and proceeded to step out onto the road behind the vehicle, having looked both ways several times. He said that as he stepped out onto the road, a motor vehicle hit him. The appellant said he had not seen the vehicle before it hit him. He told the court that he was “swiped” by the motor vehicle and that it was the back left wheel arch that came into contact with his left knee. The appellant said he was “thrown” to the ground, directly behind his brother’s motor vehicle. He said he screamed out to his brother, who rushed around and helped him back into his vehicle. While being driven home in his brother’s motor vehicle, the appellant told his brother that he thought he had dislocated his knee. However, they did not call an ambulance because he did not think the injury warranted it. When the appellant and his brother arrived home, the appellant told his mother that he had injured his leg in a fall. His mother called an ambulance, which subsequently arrived and took him to the Royal Adelaide Hospital. Whilst in the ambulance, the appellant told the ambulance officers that his foot had been caught in drainage. He said in evidence that he told these stories to both his mother and the ambulance officers because his mother suffers from multiple sclerosis and he was concerned that if he had told her that a motor vehicle had hit him, the stress would have caused her condition to worsen.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J (dissent) SULAN J (dissent) DAVID J (dissent)
In my view, the trial judge has carefully analysed and had regard to all of the evidence. She had the distinct advantage of observing the important eyewitnesses give evidence. That advantage is especially significant in this type of case, where there are only two eyewitnesses, with no direct evidence to the contrary. For the reasons already mentioned, the trial judge was obviously unimpressed with the evidence of both of them. The inconsistencies pointed out in her reasons were significant, and it is understandable why they made such an impact on her decision. The trial judge also carefully analysed the medical evidence. She carefully considered whether it supported the accounts of the eyewitnesses. As I have indicated, there was no need to go into the suggested scenario postulated by Mr Atkinson, as that scenario was not supported by the evidence.Conclusion I would dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

Full text does not contain this section.