See v WorkCover Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION

See v WorkCover Queensland [2023] QIRC 133

PARTIES:

See, Ray
(Appellant)

v

WorkCover Queensland

(Respondent)

CASE NO:

PSA/2023/25

PROCEEDING:

Public Sector Appeal – Appeal against a disciplinary decision

DELIVERED ON:

16 May 2023

HEARD AT:

MEMBER:

On the papers

Pidgeon IC

ORDERS:

Pursuant to s 562C(1)(a) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the decision appealed against is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

PUBLIC SECTOR – EMPLOYEES AND SERVANTS OF THE CROWN GENERALLY – PUBLIC SECTOR APPEAL – appeal against a disciplinary decision – where the appellant is employed by the respondent as a Customer Support Representative – where the appellant has been found liable to discipline over a substantiated allegation regarding his conduct at a meeting – where the respondent has imposed a disciplinary penalty of a reduction in remuneration – where disciplinary decision fair and reasonable – decision confirmed

LEGISLATION AND OTHER INSTRUMENTS:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ss 562B, 562C

Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) ss 91, 129, 131, 133, 289, 324

Public Service Act 2008 (Qld) ss 187, 188 (repealed)

WorkCover Code of Conduct

WorkCover Employing Office Certified Agreement 2018 cl 3

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. Mr Ray See (the Appellant) is employed by WorkCover Queensland (the Respondent) as a Customer Support Representative.

  2. Mr See appeals a disciplinary decision of 1 February 2023 by Mr Danik Lucas, Head of Customer and Community Advisory at WorkCover Queensland (the decision-maker).

  3. The disciplinary decision letter was preceded by a show cause process. The following allegation was found to be substantiated by the decision-maker in a disciplinary finding letter of 10 January 2023:

    Allegation one

    On 27 October 2022, you acted inappropriately during an employee update meeting facilitated by a representative of the People Group when you:

    a)       Interrupted Holly Dennien, Head of People Operations on more than one occasion; and/or

    b)       Stated words to the effect of:

    i.‘… there appears to be no bargaining…’; and/or

    ii.‘no, no, no’ in a tone described as aggressive; and/or

    iii.‘WorkCover was forced to work remotely because of Covid, it wasn’t a choice’; and/or

    iv.‘seeing ‘wellness’ makes your blood boil’; and/or

    v.‘what’s the point’; and/or

    vi.‘what would you know’; and/or

    vii.‘You’re here late’ in a tone described as sarcastic; and/or

    viii.You ‘… do not trust WorkCover’.

    c)       Continued to discuss your personal circumstances after being asked to discuss these outside of the meeting.

    d)       Made sarcastic noises; and/or

e)       Exhibited expressions, including:

i.Sighing; and/or

ii.Rude; and/or

iii.Abrupt; and/or

iv.Disparaging.

  1. The allegation relates to Mr See’s conduct during a meeting facilitated by Ms Holly Dennien, Head of People Operations, People Group, regarding a Certified Agreement. Mr See attended the meeting in person, with other attendees joining remotely.

  2. The Respondent says that with respect to Mr See’s conduct at the meeting:

    a.In his role, Mr See’s skills and knowledge requirements include well-developed interpersonal skills to develop rapport and interact with customers and others, demonstrated ability to work effectively with others and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read See v WorkCover Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QIRC 133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of See v WorkCover Queensland involves the appellant, employed as a Customer Support Representative, appealing against a disciplinary decision made by the respondent. The disciplinary decision was a result of a substantiated allegation regarding the appellant's conduct during a meeting. The respondent imposed a disciplinary penalty in the form of a reduction in remuneration, which the appellant contests. The dispute was heard and decided by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the disciplinary decision was fair and reasonable, considering the proportionality of the penalty and the relevance of the considerations taken into account by the decision-maker.

The court found that the decision-maker had properly considered the appellant's submissions regarding the financial impact of the penalty and adjusted the proposed disciplinary action accordingly. The court rejected the appellant's argument that the decision-maker had failed to consider his history of employment and the one-off nature of the allegations. The court held that it was open to the decision-maker to take into account the appellant's recent completion of modules such as WorkCover’s Code of Conduct and a non-disciplinary warning regarding his interaction with a customer. The court further found that the decision-maker had appropriately focused on the appellant's conduct in the meeting and his response to attempts to intervene following other people present at the meeting raising issues with his conduct.

The court confirmed the decision of 1 February 2023, which imposed the disciplinary penalty. However, the practical implementation of the disciplinary action should be guided by the reasons for decision provided by the court. The court ordered that the disciplinary penalty should remain in place for a period commensurate with the period originally envisaged by the respondent, being from late February 2023 until October 2023. In the event the appellant's performance review does not result in an outcome of 'effective' or'superior', the reduction in remuneration of one pay point should be removed at whatever time the respondent had determined the performance review increase would be applied. The court emphasised that this is a matter for the respondent to determine, taking into account the stay imposed on the disciplinary action.

The court concluded that the decision was fair and reasonable, and confirmed the decision of 1 February 2023, with the practical implementation of the disciplinary action to be guided by the reasons for decision provided by the court. The court ordered that the disciplinary penalty should remain in place for a period commensurate with the period originally envisaged by the respondent, being from late February 2023 until October 2023. In the event the appellant's performance review does not result in an outcome of 'effective' or'superior', the reduction in remuneration of one pay point should be removed at whatever time the respondent had determined the performance review increase would be applied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Pursuant to s 562C(1)(a) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the decision appealed against is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is a matter for the Respondent to consider the impact of that stay in determining the period of time the reduction in remuneration will remain in place. In the circumstances, I find that it would not be appropriate for the Respondent to impose the disciplinary penalty for a period longer than that commensurate with the period it originally envisaged the reduction in remuneration would be in place, being from late February 2023 until October 2023. Conclusion For the reasons set out above, I find that it was open to the decision-maker to impose the disciplinary action set out in [8]. In the event Mr See’s performance review does not result in an outcome of ‘effective’ or ‘superior’, the reduction in remuneration of one pay point should be removed at whatever time the Respondent had determined the performance review increase would be applied. I understand that initially, this appeared to be as per the annual timetable for performance review but that the stay imposed on the disciplinary action may mean that a different timeline is now required. This is a matter for the Respondent. The decision of 1 February 2023 is confirmed. However the practical implementation of the disciplinary action should be guided by these reasons for decision.Order I make the following order:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I have considered Mr See’s ground of appeal regarding the significant impact of the proposed penalty. Mr See raised this matter in his show cause response and as a result, the decision-maker determined to reduce Mr See’s remuneration by one pay point rather than two. I find that the decision-maker gave proper consideration to Mr See’s submissions regarding the financial impact of the penalty and adjusted the proposed disciplinary action as a result of those submissions. I accept that the financial penalty will have a financial impact on Mr See, however I do not find that this serves to make the decision unfair or unreasonable.Appeal Ground: Proportionality of the penalty to the substantiated conduct; irrelevant considerations in determining penalty That Mr See admits that his behaviour was inappropriate is evidenced by his decision to appeal only the disciplinary penalty and not the disciplinary finding. Mr See says that the decision-maker appears to have treated the various elements set out in the particulars of the allegation as multiple events of inappropriate conduct rather than multiple instances during the one event. I disagree. It seems to me that the decision-maker placed focus on the fact that Mr See’s conduct in the meeting continued after he had been asked to take up his individual issues at a different time and after a more senior member of staff arrived, and attempted to intervene following other people present at the meeting raising issues with Mr See’s conduct. It appears clear that Mr See understood that attempts were being made to ask him to temper his behaviour and that he not only ignored such attempts but responded rudely and aggressively to these interventions. I accept that it was open to the Respondent to determine that Mr See’s recent completion of modules such as WorkCover’s Code of Conduct meant that he was aware of the expected level of performance and conduct expected of him. Mr See says that the decision-maker has not taken into account his ‘history of employment’ and the ‘likely one-off nature of the allegations’. However, it appears that the employer did take into account his history, particularly the recent history involving a non-disciplinary warning to Mr See regarding his interaction with a customer. Mr See argues that there is no overlap between his conduct in speaking negatively about WorkCover to a client and the conduct at the consultative meeting. I accept that the non-disciplinary warning related to Mr See’s conduct with a client and to that extent was external communication rather than conduct at an internal meeting. However, I find it was open to the decision-maker to have regard to a recent intervention with Mr See in relation to his communication choices. I think it is also relevant that this non-disciplinary warning also resulted in a direction that Mr See engage with the Code of Conduct to remind himself of the expectations of him as a WorkCover employee and that such action was required to be undertaken by 31 August 2022.