Sebastian v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sebastian v State of Western Australia [2008] FCA 926

ABORIGINES – Native Title – motion for summary dismissal under s 31A Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) of motion for interlocutory injunctive relief – whether the “Rubibi applicant” still the registered native title claimant and native title party and thereby entitled to negotiate with the State of Western Australia future acts on behalf of the Yawuru Community, including the Walman Yawuru clan – s 30 Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – whether Rubibi applicant had ceased to be the registered native title claimant – s 30(2) of the Native Title Act – whether Rubibi applicant, even if it was the registered native title claimant had been authorised to make original application to the Court – ss 61 and 251B Native Title Act – whether Rubibi applicant entitled to negotiate on behalf of the Yawuru Community, including the Walman Yawuru clan with the State.  

COSTS – proceedings under Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – whether s 85A of the Act had application – if so whether applicant in motion engaged in unreasonable conduct such as to enliven s 85(2) displacing prima facie rule that each party bear his or her own costs.      

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), ss 29(2)(b), 30(1)(a); 30(2), 56(1), 57(2), 61(1), 66B, 85A, 189A(b), 190(4)(d), 190C, 193(2)(e), 223(1), 225(c), 251B, 253
Native Title Amendment (Technical Amendments) Act 2007 s100
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 22, 23, 31A, 43

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v The Shell Company of Australia Limited (1997) 72 FCR 386 referred to
Birri-Gubba (Cape Upstart) People v State of Queensland [2008] FCA 659 referred to
Boston Commercial Services Pty Ltd v GE Capital Finance Australasian Pty Ltd (2006) 236 ALR 720 cited
Caboolture Park Shopping Centre Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) v White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd (1993) 45 FCR 224 cited
James on behalf of the Martu People v State of Western Australia [2002] FCA 1208 referred to
Remington Products Australia Pty Ltd v Energizer Australia Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 47 cited
Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 3) (2002) 120 FCR 512 referred to

Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 5) [2005] FCA 1025 referred to
Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 6) [2006] FCA 82 referred to
Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 7) [2006] FCA 459 referred to

The State of Western Australia v Sebastian [2008] FCAFC 65 referred to
White Industries Australia Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 160 FCR 298 cited

FRANK SEBASTIAN and JOSEPH ROE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA& ORS

WAD 6006 OF 1998

FRANK SEBASTIAN, JOSEPH ROE, ELSIE EDGAR v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA& ORS
WAD 223 OF 2004

GILMOUR J
19 JUNE 2008
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 6006 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

FRANK SEBASTIAN, JOSEPH ROE & ORS
Applicants

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA &…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sebastian v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 926
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Frank Sebastian & Others, on behalf of the Rubibi People, sought the dismissal of a motion by Margaret Mary Robinson, Edward Leonard Roe, and Peter Nuggett Matsumoto. The case involved competing claims under the Native Title Act 1993 for native title in the Broome area of Western Australia. The applicants, known as the Rubibi applicant, brought the proceedings on behalf of the Yawuru Community. The respondents, known as the Walman Yawuru respondents, initially sought to assert their own native title rights but were later joined as respondents. The central legal issues in the case were whether the Walman Yawuru respondents had native title rights or other interests in the claim area, and whether their special attachment to specific areas should be recognised in the determination. The Court examined these issues within the framework of the Native Title Act, considering the nature and extent of the rights and interests claimed by both the Yawuru and Walman Yawuru communities.

The Court found that the Walman Yawuru respondents did not possess native title rights or interests in the claim area, as these were held communally by the Yawuru people. Additionally, the special attachment of the Walman Yawuru respondents to specific areas did not constitute the kind of "other interests" required to be recognised under the Act. The Court concluded that the first motion lacked a reasonable prospect of success and, therefore, should be dismissed under section 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976. Given the complexity of the issues and the fact that the applicants were not represented by legal counsel, the Court determined that no party should be ordered to pay costs related to the motion or its dismissal.

The Court dismissed the notice of motion brought by Margaret Mary Robinson, Edward Leonard Roe, and Peter Nuggett Matsumoto. The decision was based on the lack of arguable serious issues to be tried and the absence of a reasonable prospect of success for the first motion. The Court also noted that the applicants' representation by a law student, Ms Hanigan, did not warrant an order for costs against them. The dismissal motion effectively resolved the disputes between the parties, leading to the conclusion of the substantive proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The notice of motion of Margaret Mary Robinson, Edward Leonard Roe and Peter Nuggett Matsumoto dated 6 May 2008 be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant in the proceeding Frank Sebastian & Others, on behalf of the Rubibi People, by its motion dated 28 May 2008, seeks an order that the first motion be dismissed pursuant to the provisions of s 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The application is supported by the affidavit of Krysti Justine Guest affirmed on 28 May 2008. GENERAL BACKGROUND The substantive proceedings concerned competing claims under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (“the Act”) for native title in respect of land and waters in and around Broome in the West Kimberley Region of Western Australia. The applicant has been called the “Rubibi applicant” in these proceedings. This is because they were brought by a group of people who adopted the name “Rubibi”, which is an aboriginal soak or waterhole in Broome and a name generally associated with the Broome Aboriginal community. The Rubibi applicant brought the proceedings on behalf of the Yawuru Community. The applicants in the first motion were originally applicants but became respondents to the proceedings on behalf of a subset of the Yawuru Community, known as the Walman Yawuru (“the Walman Yawuru respondents”). Their independent application for native title was dismissed: Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 7) [2006] FCA 459. They were joined as respondents on their application, by order of Merkel J: Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 3) (2002) 120 FCR 512. The Walman Yawuru respondents had contended that they had competing and conflicting native title rights and interests, relevantly, in respect of the area being claimed by the Rubibi applicant on behalf of the Yawuru Community. The joinder was made so that the Court could determine all disputes between the competing claimants as to the existence, nature and extent of the native title rights and interests being claimed by both the Yawuru and the Walman Yawuru claimants. The Walman Yawuru respondents were found to have a special attachment to part of the claim area known as the Mangalagun area. However, it was not such as to constitute or give rise to a native title right or interest as defined in ss 223(1) and 253 of the Act. It followed that no rights or interests claimed by the Walman Yawuru respondents were possessed by them as members of the Walman Yawuru clan: Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 5) [2005] FCA 1025 [233] and [375]. In later reasons, Merkel J held that any native title rights and interest in the claim area were held by the Yawuru people on a communal basis and not by members of the Walman Yawuru on a group or clan basis and that they did not have native title rights and interests in that capacity in the claim area: Rubibi Community v The State of Western Australia (No 6) [2006] FCA 82. [9] Nonetheless, the Walman Yawuru respondents later contended that, as a result of this recognition of special attachment to specific areas in Rubibi (No 5) they were entitled, under s 225(c) of the Act to have that attachment recognised in the determination as an “other interest” in relation to the determination area. However, Merkel J held that the only “rights” or “interests” the Walman Yawuru clan members might have in relation to the Yawuru claim area were those held in any capacity they might have as members of the Yawuru Community and not “other interests” that were required to be set out in the determination pursuant to s 225(c) of the Act: Rubibi (No 7), [13]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GILMOUR J
This submission also fails. CONCLUSION For these reasons I am satisfied that there are no arguable serious issues to be tried. Accordingly I am of the opinion that there is no reasonable prospect that the first motion can be successfully prosecuted and it ought to be dismissed under the provisions of s 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). COSTS The jurisdiction to order costs is conferred by s 43 of the FCA Act. The power to do so is discretionary. However that power is affected, in respect of proceedings brought under the Act by virtue of s 85A of the Act which provides: 85A Costs (1)Unless the Federal Court orders otherwise, each party to a proceeding must bear his or her own costs. Unreasonable conduct (2) Without limiting the Court’s power to make orders under subsection (1), if the Federal Court is satisfied that a party to a proceeding has, by any unreasonable act or omission, caused another party to incur costs in connection with the institution or conduct of the proceeding, the Court may order the first-mentioned party to pay some or all of those costs. The first motion is brought within the substantive proceedings which are proceedings under s 61 of the Act. I have proceeded, in these reasons, on the basis that the Court has jurisdiction and is not functus officio. The prima facie position under s 85A(1) is that in such proceedings each party will bear his or her own costs. The issues involved are, at one level, complex. The applicants in the first motion have not been represented by solicitors or counsel. I would not, in the circumstances, be prepared to characterise the conduct of the applicants in the first motion as being unreasonable. This is so, even though I have concluded that the first motion has no reasonable prospect of success. The position may well have been different if the applicants in the first motion had been represented by experienced lawyers: cf Birri-Gubba (Cape Upstart) People v State of Queensland [2008] FCA 659. [37] These observations should not be seen in any way as a reflection on Ms Hanigan. Ms Hanigan is a law student who I have no doubt has been doing her best to represent the interests of the applicants in the first motion. They are not in receipt of public funding. Furthermore, the articulation by Ms Hanigan of the two issues, which I have dealt with, together with her concession, quite properly made, that the resolution of these adverse to those whom she represents would justify the summary dismissal of the first motion greatly reduced both the time of the hearing and the issues for judgment. No other basis exists, in my view, to depart from the prima facie rule under s 85A. I would make no order as to costs either in respect of the first motion or the dismissal motion, each of which was necessarily tied to the other.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GILMOUR J