Sebastian Temesi v Judo Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Case number: NST-E22-1788986

Case Title: Sebastian Temesi v Judo Australia Limited

Determination

National Sports Tribunal

General Division

sitting in the following composition:

Panel Member                  Mr Christopher Johnstone (Presiding Member)

in the arbitration between

Sebastien Temesi  (Appellant)

Represented by Mr Darren Kane of Advocatus Lawyers & Consultants

And  

Judo Australia Limited  (Respondent)

Represented by Mr John Mullins of Mullins Lawyers

And                 

Jake Bensted     (Interested party)

Represented by Paul Horvath of SportsLawyer

And                 

Commonwealth Games Australia  (Interested party)

Represented by Lisa Marcus of Thomson Geer Lawyers

  1. PARTIES AND PROCEDURE

  1. The appellant in this proceeding, Sebastien Temesi, competes in the sport of Judo and is a current and financial member of the respondent, Judo Australia Limited (JAL).  

  2. JAL is the named respondent and is a company limited by guarantee and is the national federation for the sport of Judo in Australia. 

  3. Mr Bensted is named as an interested party because, the outcome of this appeal could, potentially, impact on his selection by the other interested party, Commonwealth Games Australia ACN 629 915 448 (CGA), as a team member in the sport of Judo, albeit in a weight category different to Mr Temesi.

  4. Each party was represented by, and appeared through, lawyers. 

  5. Mr Temesi’s application was filed on 28 June 2022 in this Tribunal in these terms: “This is an appeal against a decision by Judo Australia not to nominate me to Commonwealth Games Australia for selection in the Australian Team for the 2022 Commonwealth Games”.  A preliminary conference was conducted by the registry of the Tribunal on 30 June 2022 at which various directions were made for the filing of submissions and material. 

  6. As originally framed, Mr Temesi’s appeal is as to the decision of JA to “not nominate” him to be a team member of the Australian team to compete in his particular weight category in the sport of Judo at the XXII Commonwealth Games to be held in Birmingham, United Kingdom from 28 July to 8 August 2022.  As it turned out, the issue was not quite as confined as the appeal, as originally framed, suggested.

  7. Because there was no factual dispute between the parties, at that directions hearing, the parties agreed that they were content for the matter to proceed on the basis of submissions only without the need for a hearing to be convened.  They each subsequently confirmed this in writing.

  8. Each party complied with the directions and filed extensive written submissions with exhibits including, reply submissions.

  9. For the purposes of the record, the Tribunal has marked those submissions and exhibits as follows:

    (a)Submissions of Mr Temesi dated 1 July 2022 together with exhibits 1 – 11 thereto: Exhibit A;

    (b)Submissions of Judo Australia dated 1 July 2022 (filed on 4 July 2022) together with exhibits JA1-JA13 thereto: Exhibit B;

    (c)Submissions of Mr Bensted dated 4 July 2022 together with Annexures 1 – 3 thereto: Exhibit C;

    (d)Submissions of CGA dated 4 July 2022 together with enclosures (a) to (j): Exhibit D;

    (e)Supplementary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sebastian Temesi v Judo Australia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NST NST-E22-1788986
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Tribunal was required to determine an appeal brought by Sebastian Temesi against the decision of Judo Australia Limited (JAL) not to nominate him for selection by Commonwealth Games Australia (CGA) as a team member for the 2022 Commonwealth Games. The appeal raised issues about the application of JAL's nomination policy and the subsequent de-selection of Temesi by CGA. The court had to examine whether JAL properly applied its nomination policy, whether JAL could rescind its nomination of Temesi, and whether CGA had the power to de-select Temesi. The court also had to consider the additional relief sought by Temesi.

The court rejected Temesi's principal submission that JAL did not properly apply its nomination policy. It found that the policy did not require the selection of two athletes in the men's 90kg division, and that JAL was not mistaken in its nomination process. The court also found that Temesi's appeal was a "Non-Selection Appeal" rather than a "Non-nomination Appeal." Regarding the additional relief sought by Temesi, the court held that it did not have the power to overturn the decision of JAL to rank the eight male athletes or the de-selection by CGA of Temesi. It concluded that CGA had the power to de-select Temesi as the result of its own mistake.

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed. The court found no basis upon which it could overturn the decision of JAL to rank the eight male athletes or the de-selection by CGA of Temesi. The decision highlights the importance of adhering to nomination policies and the consequences of not doing so, as well as the limited powers of sports tribunals in certain situations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.