Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No.8)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No.8) [2022] NSWSC 1806
Hearing dates: 18 March 2022
Date of orders: 21 March 2022
Decision date: 21 March 2022
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Garling J
Decision:

Notice of Motion of 17 March 2022 dismissed.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE — application for leave to rely on expert reports — reports filed and served on day 14 of four-week hearing — reports elicit expert opinions based upon additional documents not previously considered by experts — documents always available to parties — other party unable to reasonably reply — unexplained delay — interests of justice favour rejection of reports — leave refused

Legislation Cited:

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 rr 29.5, 31.20

Cases Cited:

Searle v The Commonwealth of Australia[2019] NSWCA 127

Texts Cited:

Not Applicable

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: Clayton William Searle (P)
Commonwealth of Australia (D)
Representation:

Counsel:
N Kidd SC / D Meyerowitz-Katz (P)
K Andronos SC / S Keizer (D)

Solicitors:
Levitt Robinson (P)
McCullough Robertson (D)
File Number(s): 2016/45027
Publication restriction: Not Applicable

Judgment

  1. The Court is presently hearing evidence for the purpose of assessing the damages to be awarded to nine individual Group Members in these proceedings.

Proceedings

  1. It is unnecessary for me to recount in this interlocutory judgment the history of the proceedings. It's sufficient to note that the history is available from the judgment of the Court of Appeal in the proceedings Searle v The Commonwealth of Australia [2019] NSWCA 127. This judgment assumes knowledge of the proceedings.

  2. The damages assessment hearing commenced on 28 February 2022. Four weeks were allocated for the matter and the matter has been allocated for many months.

  3. It is the case for the Commonwealth that although it is liable for damages to each claimant arising from its breach of the respective Training Contracts, those damages ought not to be assessed on the basis that there was a complete failure to perform the Training Contract but, rather, that there had been only a defective performance because training relevant to an MEM qualification was in fact provided to each claimant. It accepts that such training as was provided was not sufficient to achieve a Certificate IV in Engineering (MEM40105) within a four year period. Accordingly, it submits that a relevant integer for the Court in assessing damages is the number of competencies which an individual claimant had obtained prior to his discharge from the navy and what competencies remained to be attained to enable a Certificate IV in Engineering to be obtained or else an appropriate Certificate III qualification. Another relevant integer is the time which it may take to achieve these "outstanding" competencies if enrolled with a registered training organisation.

  4. The plaintiff and the claimants do not accept that this is a proper method of assessing damages for each claimant. They say that such integers are entirely irrelevant. In part, this submission is based upon the absence of any pleading and the position of the Commonwealth…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No.8) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 1806
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involved Searle as the applicant and the Commonwealth as the respondent. The applicant sought leave to rely on expert reports, which were filed and served on the 14th day of a scheduled four-week hearing. The reports were intended to elicit expert opinions based on additional documents that had not been previously considered by the experts. These documents had always been available to both parties. However, the respondent was unable to reasonably reply due to the unexplained delay in the submission of the reports. The court had to consider whether the interests of justice favoured the rejection of the reports. The court ultimately found that the interests of justice did favour the rejection of the reports due to the unexplained delay in their submission and the lack of reasonable opportunity for the respondent to reply. Consequently, the court refused the applicant's leave to rely on the reports.

The legal issues before the court were whether the applicant should be granted leave to rely on expert reports that were filed and served late, and whether the respondent had a reasonable opportunity to reply to the reports. The court had to balance the need for the applicant to present expert evidence against the potential prejudice to the respondent caused by the late filing and the lack of opportunity to respond. The court considered the principles of procedural fairness and the need to ensure that the interests of justice were served. Ultimately, the court decided that the applicant's failure to provide the expert reports in a timely manner, coupled with the respondent's inability to reasonably reply, warranted the refusal of leave to rely on the reports.

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter concerns an application for leave to rely on expert reports in proceedings between Searle and the Commonwealth of Australia. The parties were involved in a complex civil dispute, the details of which are not the primary focus of this summary. The reports in question were filed and served on the fourteenth day of a scheduled four-week hearing. These expert reports provided opinions that were based on additional documents which had not been previously considered by the experts. Despite the fact that these documents were always available to the parties, the other party was unable to reasonably reply to the reports due to the timing of their submission. The delay in filing the reports was unexplained, and the court had to consider whether to allow the late submission of the expert evidence in the interests of justice.

The procedural history of this matter involved an application for leave to rely on expert reports that were submitted late in the proceedings. The Federal Court had previously scheduled a four-week hearing for the case, and on the fourteenth day of this hearing, Searle filed and served expert reports. The Commonwealth opposed the admission of these reports due to their late filing and the lack of reasonable opportunity to respond. The court was required to determine whether the late submission of the expert reports should be allowed, taking into account the circumstances of the case and the interests of justice.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave should be granted for the late filing of expert reports based on additional documents that were always available to the parties.
2. Whether the unexplained delay in filing the expert reports affects the interests of justice and the reasonable opportunity of the other party to reply.
3. Whether the interests of justice favour the rejection of the expert reports due to the late filing and the impact on the proceedings.

Held
1. The court decided that leave should not be granted for the late filing of expert reports. The reports were filed and served on the 14th day of a four-week hearing and were based on additional documents not previously considered by the experts, although these documents had always been available to the parties.
2. The unexplained delay in filing the expert reports was found to affect the interests of justice and the reasonable opportunity of the other party to reply. The late filing prevented the other party from reasonably replying to the expert evidence.
3. The interests of justice were held to favour the rejection of the expert reports due to the late filing and the impact on the proceedings. Consequently, leave was refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of whether leave should be granted for the late filing of expert reports, which were based on additional documents always available to the parties. The court noted that while the documents had been available, the experts had not previously considered them, and the reports were filed and served late in the hearing process. The court examined the principle of procedural fairness and the need for parties to have a reasonable opportunity to respond to expert evidence. It also considered the impact of the unexplained delay on the proceedings and the other party's ability to reply.

In assessing whether the delay affected the interests of justice and the other party's opportunity to respond, the court found that the late filing prevented the other party from adequately preparing and presenting a response to the expert evidence. This timing issue undermined the fairness of the proceedings and the other party's ability to participate effectively.

Finally, the court weighed the interests of justice and concluded that the late filing and its consequences warranted rejecting the expert reports. The court held that the late filing was not justified and that the interests of justice were better served by refusing leave to rely on the reports. The decision underscores the importance of timely filing of expert reports and the court's discretion to refuse leave in cases of unexplained delays that prejudice the fairness of the proceedings.