SCOTT V WILLIAMS AND ORS AND SIMS AND ORS (NO 2)
[2001] SASC 252
JUDGE BURLEY. On 11 May 2001 I announced my decision on the plaintiff’s application to strike out the respective responses of the defendants to notices to admit administered by the plaintiff. The defendants have sought the costs of that application. The plaintiff contends that there should be no order as to costs on the application or, alternatively, that the costs order should be costs in the cause. I heard argument on the question of costs on 20 July 2001.
In my reasons delivered on 11 May 2001 I summarised the background to the application as follows:
“These proceedings are brought by the plaintiff pursuant to Section 588G of the Corporations Law. It is alleged that debts totalling in excess of $3.5 million dollars were incurred by the director defendants whilst the company was insolvent. It is therefore necessary for the plaintiff to prove at trial that those debts (some 600 of them) were incurred by the company at a time when the company was insolvent. The plaintiff’s Notice to Admit is directed mainly to those two aspects of the plaintiff’s claim.”
At the hearing of the costs application, Mr Ross-Smith, counsel for the plaintiff, contended that the result of the application to strike out the defendants’ respective responses to the notices to admit was a tie and as such no order for costs ought to be made or, alternatively, costs should be in the cause. Ms Sofroniou, counsel for the defendants, contended that the defendants were substantially successful on the strike out application and that costs should follow that event.
Both parties agreed that the principles set out in Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4 applied. In that case Bray CJ said (at 11):
“Order 65, rule 1 provides generally that all costs shall be in the discretion of the court or judge, subject to a proviso irrelevant for the present purpose. Time and again attempts have been made to fetter that general discretion by the imposition of judge-made rules. Time and again those fetters have been released by appellate courts. I think the guiding principle still stands as it left the House of Lords in the famous case of Donald Campbell & Co v Pollak [1927] AC 732, that the general discretion is absolute and unfettered, except that it must be exercised judicially, not arbitrarily or capriciously, and that it cannot be exercised on grounds unconnected with the litigation.”
Jacobs J said (at 16):
“… I would wish to sound a note of cautious disapproval of applications, which are being made with increasing frequency, to apportion costs according only to the success or failure of one party or the other on the various issues of fact or law, which arise in the course of a trial. … But trials occur daily in which the party, who in the end is wholly or substantially successful, nevertheless fails along the way on particular issues of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott v WILLIAMS and Ors and Sims and Ors (No 2) No. Scciv-9... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 252
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court's decision was based on the principle that the general discretion of the court regarding costs is absolute and unfettered, except that it must be exercised judicially, not arbitrarily or capriciously, and that it cannot be exercised on grounds unconnected with the litigation. The court also considered the submissions of the parties and the principles set out in Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4. The court found that the defendants were substantially successful on the application, and the plaintiff had only achieved partial success. The court took into account the plaintiff's partial success in determining the costs order. The court also declined to consider the application under SCR 54.07 because the defendants had not given clear notice of their intention to do so and had not filed the appropriate application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi