Scotney and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

Scotney and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2016] AATA 72 (12 February 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2014/5291

Re

Joanne Scotney

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

Date 12 February 2016
Place Perth

The Tribunal sets aside the Reviewable Decision of the Respondent dated 21 August 2014 and, in substitution therefor, decides that a right hip replacement procedure for the Applicant, Ms Joanne Scotney, is reasonable in the circumstances.

The Tribunal orders, pursuant to s 67(8) of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (Cth), the costs of the proceeding incurred by the applicant be paid by the respondent in accordance with Section 6.9 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction. 

................[sgd]..................................................

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – injury to right lower back with groin strain and labral tear to right hip in workplace – multiple medical and surgical procedures – severe pain continuing – claim for costs of hip replacement – reasonableness of costs associated with total hip replacement in woman of relatively young age – costs found to be reasonable in the circumstances – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – sections 4 and 16(1)

CASES

Jorgensen v Commonwealth of Australia (1990) 23 ALD 321

Alamos and Comcare [2014] AATA 629

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

12 February 2016

BACKGROUND

  1. Joanne Scotney is aged 47.  In April 2009, she commenced employment with Australia Post as a part-time mail sorter at the Perth Parcel centre in Welshpool (T4). 

  2. In December 2009, Ms Scotney injured herself while lowering a carton of wine into the back of a Unit Load Device (“ULD”) (T27).  She has described this as “experiencing a ‘ping’ like an elastic band snapping” from her groin to her knee and also out through her back (T27).

  3. On 2 May 2010, Ms Scotney completed a workers compensation claim form for “strain injury – groin/back” (T4).  

  4. On 10 September 2012, Australia Post accepted liability for a right hip arthroscopy and changed the injury description to “right lower back, groin strain and labral tear to right hip” (T29). 

  5. Following her injury, Ms Scotney underwent numerous medical examinations and medical procedures.  Her medical procedures have been described as including “2 arthroscopic debridements, 16 injections, extensive therapy and many radiological exams” (T59).  She is currently heavily medicated for pain management. It is suggested that any future pain management plan may need to include to the use of opiates should hip replacement surgery not occur.

  6. Ms Scotney claims that none of these procedures or interventions has provided any long term benefit and that she suffers from considerable pain on a daily basis that diminishes her quality of life.

  7. Ms Scotney’s treating orthopaedic surgeon, Mr Sani Erak, agrees with this assessment and has recommended that Ms Scotney have a total right hip replacement as nothing else has provided any relief to Ms Scotney.

  8. Evidence before this Tribunal indicates that the cost of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scotney and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Scotney and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation), the Federal Circuit Court was tasked with reviewing a decision concerning the reasonableness of the costs associated with a total hip replacement for Ms Joanne Scotney, who had sustained an injury to her right lower back with a groin strain and labral tear to her right hip during her employment with Australia Post. Ms Scotney's claim for compensation involved the severe and ongoing pain she experienced, which had significantly impacted her daily life, emotional well-being, and ability to work. The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the costs of the proposed total hip replacement were reasonable under the circumstances, given Ms Scotney's relatively young age and the potential benefits of the procedure.

The Court examined the evidence presented by Ms Scotney, including her proof of evidence and written medical evidence, which detailed her physical and emotional restrictions, the extent of her injuries, and the impact on her life. The Tribunal found that the Tribunal's previous decision to deny the reasonableness of the costs for a total hip replacement was incorrect. The Court concluded that, considering Ms Scotney's age, the severity of her injuries, and the potential benefits of the hip replacement in alleviating her pain and improving her quality of life, the costs of the procedure were reasonable. The Tribunal set aside the previous decision and substituted it with a decision that a right hip replacement procedure for Ms Scotney was reasonable in the circumstances.

The Court further ordered that the costs of the proceeding incurred by Ms Scotney be paid by Australia Post, in accordance with the provisions of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (Cth). This decision underscores the importance of considering the individual circumstances of each case when determining the reasonableness of compensation for medical procedures in workplace injury claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal sets aside the Reviewable Decision of the Respondent dated 21 August 2014 and, in substitution therefor, decides that a right hip replacement procedure for the Applicant, Ms Joanne Scotney, is reasonable in the circumstances.

The Tribunal orders, pursuant to s 67(8) of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (Cth), the costs of the proceeding incurred by the applicant be paid by the respondent in accordance with Section 6.9 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

“Medical Treatment” is defined in section 4 of the SRC Act.DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE FROM MS SCOTNEYMs Scotney’s Proof of Evidence Ms Scotney provided a lengthy proof of evidence, dated 17 June 2015. The Tribunal notes the following relevant paragraphs from that proof of evidence: 1. I was born on 18 October 1968.2.On 20 December 2009 in the course of my employment with Australia Post, I had a carton of wine in my hand from waist height ULD and was going to place it in floor level ULD. The technique of brick-stacking was expected and wine was to be placed at the back of ULD first and then filled towards the front. As my knees touched ULD when I bent down, using safe manual handling techniques, I positioned myself more side-on to the ULD to be able to bend forward to place the carton of wine. As I was moving to place it, I saw a better opening just to the left and swung toward it to place the carton of wine. At this point there was a sensation of tearing from what seemed like my pubic bone and snapping at my knee. It felt like a rubber band had just snapped. I was in pain. Australia Post have since introduced a safer practice of making it mandatory to remove the gates, thus removing the barrier to safe manual handling for taller people.3.I experienced excruciating pain at the time of the incident in the groin and lower back. As I continued to work over the coming weeks, the pain in the groin continued and intensified on activity as with the back pain. The right side of my leg started to ache continually until I could not even sleep, lie on it, or sit for any period of time. To this day I still have trouble getting to sleep as I cannot be on my natural side. Over time it all worsened to the point it impacted on all areas of my life and I could no longer work in any capacity as I could not sit in any position for a length of time, limped when I stood up and walked and overall it was having a negative emotional impact on me.…..15. The hip injury, restriction, and inability to work have resulted in:1.1the financial impact - just managing to keep my house of 12 years by renting it, have no car and have crippling debt that has been acquired over the past few years to make ends meet;1.2the relationship strain;1.3the pain and medications that alter the way you feell.4 no social interactions as nothing changes in my life, I am still in pain and cannot do activities with friends so they no longer invite me;1.5 isolation of being alone most of the time;1.6loss of independence, self-esteem and confidence;1.7feelings of hopelessness and anger. Australia Post and I were both made aware in the very beginning that a total hip replacement may be the eventual outcome and for them to say there is not enough reasonable medical evidence is just unfathomable for me. I have resisted a hip replacement as much as possible and done every program (physiotherapy, hydrotherapy, Pilates) and treatment (a total of 21 injections) possible to avoid it, but I can no longer stand the pain or negative impact on my life and am desperate to have the hip surgery and give me an improved outcome. No doctor will ever guarantee for any surgery outcome and the hip replacement may not solve everything, but one thing is certain - I will be in less pain around my hip joint than I am now and I will be able to engage in more activities than I currently do, and ultimately become an active contributing and worthwhile member of society again.16. My physical restrictions are:1.8walking limited to about 30-40mins before pain takes over;1.9sitting limited to about 1 hour maximum, even at home on a couch. Even less if in car and I cannot walk properly at first when I get out of a car;1.10need to sit in chairs with generous seats and no arm frames that touch my thigh or it is excruciating pain;1.11need to physically assist putting my right leg into the car and slowly get out of car to avoid fast twisting and resulting pain;1.12sweeping (very restricted) and cooking is very guarded as the twisting motion exacerbates the groin pain;1.13I am not able to carry heavy things in my right hand or have anything touch the right side of my thigh;1.14I am unable to put my weight on my right side;1.15I cannot lie on my right side, affecting quantity and quality of sleep;1.16I am very restricted in sexual positioning and activity;1.17I cannot lift my right leg from thigh when seated;1.18showering such as shaving my legs and washing the underside of my right foot cannot be done in the shower as I cannot position my right leg and foot. I instead need to have a bath to perform these activities.1.19I cannot cross my legs on a floor;1.20I cannot put my right leg (heel) on my left knee;1.21I cannot turn my body without ensuring to move my feet or I will get sharp pains;1.22I am not able to exercise which has had a huge impact on body image, weight, self-esteem and overall health;1.23I need assistance to do housework and shopping;1.24I do not want to be around people in case I get bumped on my thigh;1.25gardening is no longer and [sic] activity I can do;1.26I have a permanent disfigurement on the outside of my right thigh that is visible, sensitive to touch and restricts what I wear, e.g. jeans or heavy side seams.2.My emotional restrictions are:2.1depression needing medication;2.2sleep disturbance that need medication from time to time to allow me to sleep when the depression is worse;2.3relationship strain;2.4isolation;2.5lack of self-worth and esteem.WRITTEN MEDICAL EVIDENCE

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal determines that a right hip replacement procedure for the Applicant, Ms Joanne Scotney, is reasonable in the circumstance.DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the Reviewable Decision of the Respondent dated 21 August 2014 and, in substitution therefor, decides that a right hip replacement procedure for the Applicant, Ms Joanne Scotney, is reasonable in the circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.