[2011] FWA 9329
The attached document replaces the document previously issued with the above code on 29 December 2011.
The numerals 243 in paragraphs [28], [48] and [59] have in each instance been replaced with the numerals 423.
Leanne Weeding
Relief Associate to Senior Deputy President Kaufman
Dated 30 December 2011
[2011] FWA 9329 |
|
REASONS FOR DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.423—Suspend or terminate industrial action
Schweppes Australia Pty Ltd
v
United Voice - Victorian Branch
(B2011/4097)
SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT KAUFMAN | MELBOURNE, 29 DECEMBER 2011 |
Section 423 application to suspend or terminate protected industrial action - significant economic harm to employees - nature of discretion.
[1] On 19 December 2011, Schweppes Australia Pty Ltd (Schweppes) filed an application pursuant to section 423 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act), seeking an order from Fair Work Australia terminating protected industrial action for a proposed enterprise agreement that is being engaged in.
[2] I heard the application on 23 December 2011 at which time Schweppes was represented by Mr S Wood, S C with Mr M Follett of Counsel. United Voice, a bargaining representative for the proposed agreement, was represented by Mr E White of Counsel to oppose the application.
Background
[3] The background facts leading to the application were largely uncontested and I draw much of what follows from the witness statement of Peter Todd, Human Resources Partner - Supply Chain, for Schweppes.
[4] Schweppes develops, manufactures, sells, distributes and markets a range of non-alcoholic beverages and cordials. Schweppes also manufactures certain alcoholic beverages under third-party arrangements.
[5] Schweppes operates manufacturing, distribution, warehousing and sales sites throughout Australia. It employs approximately 1,500 people.
[6] Schweppes has a facility at Tullamarine at which both alcoholic and non-alcoholic products are manufactured. It is the largest manufacturer of Schweppes’ products in Australia. Tullamarine is also the site of Schweppes’ Victorian distribution centre, and is home to Schweppes’ science and technology, business services and sales groups.
[7] The terms and conditions of employment of approximately 153 production and warehouse employees employed at the Tullamarine site are regulated by the Schweppes (Tullamarine) Production and Warehouse Employees Enterprise Agreement 2010 (the 2010 Agreement).
[8] The 2010 Agreement is an enterprise agreement made under the Act and has an unusually short life with a nominal expiry date of 23 September 2011. The 2010 Agreement covers United Voice.
[9] The employees covered by the 2010 Agreement work exclusively in the Supply Chain business unit at the Tullamarine site which produces, packages and distributes product.
Overview of enterprise bargaining negotiations
[10] On Monday 7 June 2011, Schweppes issued a Notice of Employee Representational Rights in relation to a proposed enterprise agreement to replace the 2010 Agreement (to be called the Schweppes (Tullamarine) Production and Warehouse Employees Enterprise Agreement 2011)(the proposed Agreement)
[11] United Voice is the only employee bargaining representative that Schweppes is aware of for the proposed Agreement.
[12] Bargaining meetings for the proposed Agreement have been…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Schweppes Australia Pty Ltd v United Voice Victorian Branch and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] FWA 9329
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Commission were the threshold for establishing significant economic harm under section 423 and the nature of the discretion available to the Commission in deciding whether to suspend or terminate the industrial action. Schweppes Australia contended that the economic harm caused by the action was substantial and warranted suspension or termination. The union, on the other hand, maintained that the action was necessary and proportionate in response to the employer's conduct and that the Commission should not exercise its discretion to intervene.
The Commission, after considering the evidence and arguments presented, determined that while the industrial action had caused some economic harm, it was not of a magnitude that warranted suspension or termination under section 423. The Commission emphasised that the discretion under the section was not to be exercised lightly and required a high threshold to be met. The Commission concluded that the harm caused did not reach the level of significance necessary to justify intervention and accordingly, declined to exercise its discretion to suspend or terminate the protected action. The decision was based on a careful consideration of the economic impact of the action, the proportionality of the action in response to the employer's conduct, and the need to balance the rights of employers and employees under the Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi