Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd v VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd v VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd (No 6) [2010] FCA 1106

Citation: Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd v VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd (No 6) [2010] FCA 1106
Parties: SCHUTZ DSL (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 009 069 907), SCHUTZ GMBH & CO KGAA and PROTECHNA S.A. v VIP PLASTIC PACKAGING PTY LTD (ACN 095 313 705) and VIP STEEL PACKAGING PTY LTD (ACN 095 314 195)
File number: WAD 136 of 2009
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 13 October 2010
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – discovery – confidential documents – inspection by in-house counsel of trade rival – principles to be applied – potential conflict of duties – discovery not yet given – application premature
Cases cited: Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Lundbeck Australia Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1358
Conor Medsystems Inc v University of British Columbia (No 4) [2007] FCA 324
InterPharma Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents [2008] FCA 1422
Roussel Uclaf v ICI (No.2) [1990] RPC 45
Warner-Lambert Co v Glaxo Laboratories Ltd [1975] RPC 354
Date of hearing: 6 August 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 14
Counsel for the Applicants: ML Bennett with WC Zappia
Solicitor for the Applicants: Lavan Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: S Burley SC with AR Lang
Solicitor for the Respondents: Gilbert + Tobin

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 136 of 2009

BETWEEN:

SCHUTZ DSL (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD
(ACN 009 069 907)
First Applicant/Cross-Respondent

SCHUTZ GMBH & CO KGAA
Second Applicant/Cross-Respondent

PROTECHNA S.A.
Third Applicant/Cross-Respondent

AND:

VIP PLASTIC PACKAGING PTY LTD
(ACN 095 313 705)
First Respondent/Cross-Claimant

VIP STEEL PACKAGING PTY LTD
(ACN 095 314 195)
Second Respondent/Cross-Claimant

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 OCTOBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.That the motion for access to documents and exhibits by the respondents/cross-claimants in-house legal counsel be dismissed.

2.The respondents/cross-claimants pay the applicants/cross-respondents’ costs of the motion. 

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 136 of 2009

BETWEEN:

SCHUTZ DSL (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD
(ACN 009 069 907)
First Applicant/Cross-Respondent

SCHUTZ GMBH & CO KGAA
Second Applicant/Cross-Respondent

PROTECHNA S.A.
Third Applicant/Cross-Respondent

AND:

VIP PLASTIC PACKAGING PTY LTD
(ACN 095 313 705)
First Respondent/Cross-Claimant

VIP STEEL PACKAGING PTY LTD
(ACN 095 314 195)
Second Respondent/Cross-Claimant

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE:

13 OCTOBER 2010

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. In this litigation the parties have agreed a confidentiality regime for inspection of documents.  Relevantly, the respondents/cross-claimants (VIP) seek a variation of that regime so as to include provision for Mr Nicholas Perkins who is general counsel for Geminda Holdings Pty Ltd (Geminda), the ultimate holding company of VIP to examine confidential documents.

  2. VIP relies upon Alphapharm Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd v VIP Plastic Packaging Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd v VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd (No 6) involved a dispute between Schutz, a company, and VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd, with the primary issue being the potential disclosure of Schutz’s commercially sensitive information to VIP’s in-house counsel, Mr. Perkins. Schutz argued that the risk of inadvertent misuse or disclosure of their confidential information by VIP outweighed any forensic benefit that VIP could gain from Mr. Perkins’ inspection of these documents. The Court was tasked with determining whether to grant a protective order to prevent the disclosure of Schutz's confidential information to Mr. Perkins and other specified individuals.

The Court considered the dual roles Mr. Perkins held as both an officer of Geminda, with statutory and common law duties, and as legal counsel to Geminda. This dual role potentially placed Mr. Perkins in a conflict of interest, where his obligations to keep confidential information secret could conflict with his duties to act in Geminda’s best interests. Additionally, the risk of inadvertent misuse of the confidential information was significant, as once learned, it could not necessarily be forgotten. The Court referenced several cases that highlighted the importance of balancing the need for full and open discovery against the need to protect parties from misuse of trade secrets by competitors.

The Court concluded that the potential for inadvertent disclosure and the conflict of interest posed by Mr. Perkins’ dual role justified the issuance of a protective order. The Court determined that the risk of harm to Schutz from the disclosure of their confidential information was sufficiently high to warrant protective measures. The Court found that the risk of inadvertent disclosure was a significant concern, as was the potential conflict of interest for Mr. Perkins. These factors led the Court to order that Schutz's confidential information be protected from disclosure to Mr. Perkins and certain other specified individuals, thereby preventing any potential misuse or inadvertent disclosure of sensitive commercial information.

Background

Background to the litigation

Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd is a company involved in the production and distribution of plastic packaging. VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd is another company operating in the same industry. The dispute arose from VIP’s attempt to inspect confidential documents held by Schutz as part of the ongoing legal proceedings. Schutz argued that allowing VIP’s in-house counsel, Mr Perkins, to inspect these confidential documents could result in inadvertent disclosure or misuse of their commercially sensitive information. VIP contended that such inspection was necessary for the proper conduct of their case. The documents in question contained proprietary information and trade secrets essential to Schutz’s business operations.

The case before the court involved a motion by VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd seeking to inspect confidential documents held by Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd. Schutz opposed VIP’s motion, arguing that permitting such inspection would risk the disclosure or misuse of their confidential information. The court had to determine whether to grant VIP’s request or protect Schutz’s confidential information by issuing a protective order. Prior to this hearing, there were no specific rulings or orders regarding the inspection of these documents, making this the first instance where the court was required to address the issue of confidential document inspection in this context.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd's request to inspect confidential documents held by Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd.
2. If the inspection is granted, what measures should be put in place to protect Schutz’s commercially sensitive information from inadvertent disclosure or misuse.
3. Whether the in-house counsel of VIP, Mr Perkins, should be allowed to inspect the confidential documents given his dual role as a legal practitioner and officer of VIP.

Held
1. The court decided that VIP Plastic Packaging Pty Ltd's request to inspect confidential documents held by Schutz DSL (Australia) Pty Ltd should not be granted.
2. In the event that an inspection were to be granted, the court would impose measures to protect Schutz’s commercially sensitive information from inadvertent disclosure or misuse.
3. The court ruled that Mr Perkins, the in-house counsel of VIP, should not be allowed to inspect the confidential documents due to his dual role as a legal practitioner and officer of VIP.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Schutz complains that the prejudice it would suffer in the event that their commercially sensitive information was inadvertently disclosed or misused by VIP would outweigh any forensic advantage VIP could obtain from Mr Perkins’ inspection of confidential documents in the proceedings. CONSIDERATION In the absence of any evidence as to the terms of Mr Perkins’ employment as general counsel, or with respect to his position as company secretary, the Court is left with the knowledge that he is both an officer of Geminda with statutory and common law duties as well as being a legal practitioner and legal adviser to Geminda. Any information provided to Mr Perkins, if he has access to the confidential documents, may place him in a situation where his undertaking to the Court and Schutz could conflict with his obligations to Geminda as such an undertaking could be inimical to his obligations to act in the best interests of Geminda. Even if that inherent conflict of obligations can be resolved, there remains a risk that Schutz’s commercially sensitive and confidential information may be quite inadvertently misused by VIP. Once the information is learned by Mr Perkins it cannot necessarily be forgotten. In Conor Medsystems Inc v University of British Columbia (No 4) [2007] FCA 324 Finkelstein J said (at [7]-[8]):7When deciding whether or not to make a protective order to protect trade secrets United States courts strike a balance between, on the one hand, the need for full and open discovery and, on the other, the need to protect parties from a misuse of trade secrets by competitors. Striking the right balance will present difficulties in the case of in-house counsel.8In-house counsel are not automatically denied access to an opponent’s confidential information: R R Donnelley & Sons Co v Quark Inc 2007 US Dist Lexis 424. But if in-house counsel is involved in "competitive decision-making" a protective order is often made. It has been said that involvement in competitive decision-making is the "crucial" or "decisive" or determinative factor in denying in-house counsel access to confidential information: Brown Bag Software v Symantec Corp (1960 F.2d 1465, 1470 (9th Cir, 1992)); Glaxo Inc v Genpharm Pharmaceuticals Inc 796 F.Supp 872, 874 (ED NC, 1992); Carpenter Technology Corp v Armco Inc 132 FRD 24, 27 (ED Pa, 1991). At [9] and [10] his Honour referred to Warner-Lambert Co v Glaxo Laboratories Ltd [1975] RPC 354 and Roussel Uclaf v ICI (No.2) [1990] RPC 45, a case which followed Warner-Lambert, continuing (at [11]-[13]):11The leading Australian case is Mobil Oil Australia Ltd v Guina Developments Pty Ltd (1995) 33 IPR 82. Roads Corporation, sometimes known as VicRoads, a statutory corporation, had called for expressions of interest for the development of a service centre. Mobil was the successful tenderer. Guina Developments sued VicRoads for a declaration that its choice of Mobil was invalid. The parties were required to make discovery. VicRoads objected to the production of documents that disclosed trade secrets (rates of return) that had been provided to it by Mobil, which was then joined to the action to protect its interests. The judge ordered the documents be disclosed. Mobil successfully appealed. The judgment of the Court of Appeal was delivered by Hayne JA (as he then was). He said first (33 IPR at 87) that merely because documents contained confidential information that did not ordinarily constitute a sufficient reason to deny inspection. In most cases in his opinion the rule that the information could not be used except for the purposes of the litigation was a sufficient measure of protection. But Hayne JA said that disclosure of confidential information to a trade rival fell into a different category. The reason was that "Once the documents are inspected by the principals of the trade rival the information which is revealed is known to the trade rival and cannot be forgotten." (33 IPR at 87). There was also the problem that the party whose information has been disclosed will likely never know when and how the information has been used. Hayne JA went on to say (33 IPR at 88) that the problem facing the court was "one of balancing the needs of a party to the litigation and the legitimate concern of a trade rival to retain secrecy of commercially sensitive information". That would justify distinguishing between a party and its advisers making it permissible, in an appropriate case, to deny inspection to a party but not to its lawyers and experts. He said (33 IPR at 89) that it was not possible to frame a rule that covered all cases but "each case will fall for determination, according to its own facts. In particular the nature and the content of the disputed documents is a matter that will usually, if not invariably, be of great importance in forming a conclusion and, if that is so, it will be appropriate for the judge to inspect the documents concerned."12As is apparent from a review of the cases, the problem that confronts the court is the risk of inadvertent or accidental disclosure. The risk is two-fold. First, it involves the unconscious use of confidential information. That is to say, information which once in a person’s possession cannot be distinguished from other information in the person’s possession. The other kind of inadvertent use is when it is impossible to ignore the confidential information once it is known. That is the kind of inadvertent disclosure, I think, Hayne JA had in mind in Mobil. 13There is another risk to guard against in the case of disclosure of extremely potent information to in-house counsel, although the risk is not confined to in-house counsel. Providing confidential information to in-house counsel could produce a conflict between his duty of loyalty to his principal and his duty to keep the confidential information to himself. This could place in-house counsel in a position of great difficulty. Proper advice may not be forthcoming. Counsel’s hands may be tied in the further conduct of the litigation. It may make it impossible to avoid unwitting disclosure in a prolonged working relationship. These are all dangers that, in some cases, need to be fended against.