Schulz v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeal: Criminal)

SCHULZ v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2025] SASC 94

Judgment of the Honourable Justice B Doyle 

11 June 2025

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - GROUNDS - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - NON-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - SUSPENDED SENTENCE OF IMPRISONMENT - BREACH OF CONDITIONS OF SUSPENSION AND SENTENCE FOLLOWING BREACH

The appellant is a 20 year old Aboriginal woman.  Her upbringing was plagued by instability, substance abuse and mental health difficulties.  In early 2024, she was convicted of offences that resulted in the imposition of a term of imprisonment that was partially suspended upon her entering into a bond to be of good behaviour.  At the relevant time, the remaining term of the suspended sentence was six months and two weeks.  During the term of the bond, the appellant committed 11 offences of a low to mid-level of seriousness.  A magistrate revoked the suspension and ordered that the earlier sentence be carried into effect.  In respect of the offences, the magistrate imposed penalties which included a small fine and a combined term of imprisonment of 25 days, to be served cumulatively upon the reactivated sentence (but which term of imprisonment was itself to be suspended on condition that the appellant enter into a bond to be of good behaviour).

The appellant appeals against sentence, contending that:

1.the magistrate’s reasons for not being satisfied that there were proper grounds on which the appellant’s failure to comply with the conditions of her bond should be excused were inadequate;

2.the magistrate’s decision not to refrain from revoking the suspension, and not to reduce the term of the reactivated sentence, was unreasonable or plainly unjust.

Held, dismissing the appeal:

1.      the magistrate’s reasons were adequate;

2.the decision to revoke and not reduce the term of the suspended sentence was not shown to be erroneous.

Bail Act 1985 (SA) s 17(1); Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA) s 33L(1)(c); Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) ss 20(3), 20AA(3), 134; Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) s 114; Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) ss 7(1)(a), 21E(1), 41(1), referred to.

Bugmy v The Queen (2013) 249 CLR 571; Hann v Police [2019] SASC 213; Ludgate v Police [2018] SASC 175 ; McKenna v The Queen [2022] SASCA 10; Police v Heritage (2019) 135 SASR 1; Police v Peel (2021) 137 SASR 584 ; Police v Taleporos (2022) 301 A Crim R 348; R v Buckman (1988) 47 SASR 303; R v Chandra (unreported, Court of Criminal Appeal, SA, No S56554, 17 February 1998); R v Smith [2014] SASCFC 98, discussed.

SCHULZ v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2025] SASC 94

Magistrates Appeal—Criminal

  1. B DOYLE J: The appellant appeals against a sentencing decision made by a magistrate on 30 January 2025.  The appellant had pleaded guilty to a series of offences and admitted that by doing so she had breached the terms of a suspended sentence bond that had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schulz v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 94
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, a 20-year-old Aboriginal woman with a history of substance abuse and mental health issues, was before the court following a breach of her good behaviour bond. This breach involved multiple instances of criminal activity, including assault, unlawful possession, and drug-related offenses. The court was tasked with deciding whether to revoke the suspended sentence and determine an appropriate sentence for the new offenses. The primary legal issue was whether the appellant's personal circumstances, including her ongoing struggles with addiction and mental health, warranted a reduction in the sentence. The court considered the appellant’s youth, her pattern of reoffending, and the severity of the new offenses, concluding that the suspended sentence should be revoked and the remaining term of imprisonment served.

The court reasoned that despite the appellant’s personal challenges, her consistent pattern of reoffending, particularly in breach of her good behaviour bond, indicated that the bond was not achieving its intended deterrent or rehabilitative purpose. The magistrate observed that the appellant's new relationship and intentions to pursue education did not constitute a "special circumstance" that would justify a reduction in the term of the revoked suspended sentence. The court highlighted that while the appellant's youth and personal struggles were significant, they did not outweigh the need for the sentence to be enforced to maintain public safety and the rule of law.

The court ultimately decided to revoke the suspended sentence and ordered the appellant to serve the remaining term of imprisonment. The sentencing for the new offenses took into account the appellant's early guilty pleas and resulted in a combination of fines and additional imprisonment where appropriate. The court emphasized the importance of addressing the underlying issues contributing to the appellant's offending behavior while also ensuring that justice is served.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is clear that the serious disadvantage that the appellant has encountered, coupled with substance abuse and related mental health issues, have made it difficult for the appellant to comply with the terms of her bond. However, the offending which involved a breach of good behaviour, whilst not involving offending of a high level, was of a persistent and concerning kind. Seen in the context of the appellant’s history, it showed that the bond was not achieving a deterrent or rehabilitative purpose. Regrettably, there was little if any alternative to the revocation of the suspended sentence, and no sufficient justification for a reduction in its term. Background The appellant is a 20 year old Aboriginal woman whose father was from Yuendumu. She lived with her parents until age 10 and then moved to live with her aunty until age 15, before moving back with her mother. Tragically, she has had an ongoing amphetamine addiction since the age of 12. She has used intravenously since the age of 15. She is highly addicted and has had issues with drug-induced psychoses. The material before the sentencing magistrate suggested the appellant had multiple presentations at hospital emergency departments. The magistrate summarised the appellant’s recent offending history in terms about which no complaint has been made. He said:Putting to one side your Youth Court history, your adult criminal history commenced in 2022. You committed an aggravated assault and two aggravated breaches of intervention orders for which, in December 2022, the court, without convicting you, placed you on a $500 bond to be of good behaviour for 12 months. You breached that bond. You were not of good behaviour, and on 19 June 2023 were dealt with for non-residential serious criminal trespass and theft, illegal use of a motor vehicle, driving while unauthorised, driving while under the influence, and four counts of breaching bail. On this occasion your breach was excused, and you were placed on another $500 bond to be of good behaviour, this time for 18 months. You breached that bond. You were not of good behaviour. On 4 January 2024 you were convicted of offences that included illegal interference with a motor vehicle, theft, bail breaches, unlawful possession offences, assault, and unlawfully on premises. This the matter in which the court sentenced you to 11 months imprisonment, but ordered that if you served 4 months 2 weeks the rest could be suspended upon you entering a $500 bond to be of good behaviour for 12 months, which you now admit you have breached. It can be seen that you have breached every good behaviour bond the court has imposed upon you. Circumstances of offending The admitted offending in breach of the appellant’s good behaviour requirement was described in the following terms by the magistrate.On MCCRM-24-035857 you have pleaded guilty to assaulting a prescribed worker, punishable by a maximum penalty of 5 years imprisonment. The timing of your guilty plea entitles you to a reduction of up to 40% upon the sentence that the court would otherwise impose, for instance if you had not pleaded guilty but were found guilty at trial. On 3 April 2024 at about 12.20pm, Woolworths Tea Tree Plaza assistant manager Craig Paterson heard shouting at the front of the store and saw you and a man arguing. He approached and asked if you were all right. You said ‘fuck off you cunt.’ He asked you to leave the store. He called store security. You pushed a trolley away from you forcefully, and he had to grab it to ensure it did not hit another customer. You then started throwing items from your trolley into the mall area, and you threw a bottle at Mr Paterson; you hit him in the face. He tried to guide you out the store and you shoved him twice to the chest before leaving. The incident was caught on CCTV, and Mr Paterson independently identified you in an identification procedure. When questioned about this matter you denied any knowledge of the incident, but you did say you were off your face when that happened. This offence was aggravated by the fact that it was committed in breach of the 5 January 2024 suspended sentence bond.On MCCRM-24-025829 you have pleaded guilty to an offence of disorderly behaviour and an offence of unlawful possession. The timing of your guilty pleas entitles you to a reduction of up to 30% upon the sentence that the court would otherwise impose. On 23 April 2024 police were called to Elizabeth Street at Torrensville. They found you on a bike in a front yard. You had several bags and a package in your possession. In one of your bags they found a wallet with a card in the name of Taryn Palmer, which they suspected you had obtained by unlawful means. That became count 2. You became heightened and began yelling at police ‘don't fucking touch my stuff.’ When they arrested you for disorderly behaviour, they found that you had a Toyota car key in your possession, which they also suspected you had obtained by unlawful means.When you were arrested you began to hit your head on the ground and made comments about self-harm that caused police to take you for mental health assessment. They did not question you further due to your demeanour and their suspicion that you were suffering drug induced psychosis.This offence was aggravated by the fact that it was committed in breach of the 5 January 2024 suspended sentence bond. On MCCRM-24-018383 you have pleaded guilty to possessing a knife in a public place, which is punishable for a first offence by a $2,500 fine or 6 months and for a second offence, a $5,000 fine or up to 12 months. The timing of your guilty plea entitles you to a reduction of up to 30% upon the sentence that the court would otherwise impose. This offence was committed 5 days after the previous offence I have mentioned. On 28/4/24, police responded to a duress alarm activated at the X Convenience Service Station on Henley Beach Road at Torrensville. They discovered that you had been with another man there, who had stolen some chips and left before the security doors closed and locked. That left you locked inside when police arrived. They searched you, and found you had a 15cm flip knife in your handbag. You said you knew this was an offence. You said you used it as a toothpick. By your plea, you admit that you had possession of a knife in a public place. This offence was also aggravated by the fact that it was committed in breach of the 5 January 2024 suspended sentence bond.On MCCRM-24-029732 you have pleaded guilty to an aggravated assault with a weapon, punishable by a maximum 4 years imprisonment. The timing of your guilty plea entitles you to a reduction of up to 30% upon the sentence that the court would otherwise impose. This offence was committed just over two weeks after the last offence I have mentioned. On 14 May 2024 a woman called Tanya Winter was sitting on Bank St in the city on her mobile phone. You sat next to her, yelling and swearing, and threw an empty coke bottle onto the foot path. She left and walked to a nearby hotel reception area, but when she could no longer hear you shouting she returned, intending to smoke a cigarette. You returned. You approached her. You shouted "you're going to have to learn the hard way". She told you to get out of her face. You swung your bag, hitting her in the head, and then hit her with an open right palm to the side of the face. You then walked off. She pointed you out to passing police and you were arrested. You were granted bail that night, but it was a condition that you not enter the area bounded by East Terrace, North Terrace, West Terrace and Currie and Grenfell Streets. That becomes relevant later on. This offence was aggravated by the fact that it was committed in breach of the 5 January 2024 suspended sentence bond.On MCCRM-24-043174 you have pleaded guilty to possessing equipment to use with a controlled drug, punishable by a maximum $2,000 fine or up to 2 years imprisonment; an offence of theft punishable by up to 10 years imprisonment; and an offence of unlawful possession punishable by a maximum $10,000 fine or up to 2 years imprisonment. The timing of your guilty pleas entitles you to a reduction of up to 40% upon the sentence that the court would otherwise impose. At about 1:30 in the morning of 2 June 2024 police found you on Travers Street at Sturt. You said you'd been using methamphetamine. You produced a glass ice pipe which became the subject of count 1. You said you had taken it from your partner and were going to smash it but decided to hold on to it. The police found that you had a Westpac credit card in the name of Noel Holley. You said it belonged to a female friend from Victoria whose name you could not remember. Upon further investigation by police, they learned from 85 year old Mr Holley that in fact that card had been stolen from him. When they told you the card belonged to an 85-year-old man, you said it must be a set up to get you locked up. By your plea you admit that you dishonestly dealt with that card without Mr Holley's consent. You also produced a mobile phone that police suspect had been obtained by unlawful means and that became the basis for count 3. You gave different versions about this phone, first saying you did not know whose it was, then saying it was yours although you didn't know its passcode or who bought it for you. This offending was aggravated by the fact that it was committed in breach of the 5 January 2024 suspended sentence bond.On MCCRM-24-032360 you have pleaded guilty to failing to comply with a bail agreement, punishable by a maximum $10,000 fine or up to 2 years imprisonment. The timing of your guilty plea entitles you to a reduction of up to 30% upon the sentence that the court would otherwise impose. On 14 May 2024 you were granted bail but as I said before, it was a condition that you not enter the area bounded by East Terrace, North Terrace, West Terrace and Currie and Grenfell Streets. On 9 June 2024 police found you inside that area at McDonald's Rundle Mall. You were asleep and apparently drug affected when woken by police. You were arrested. While you were not formally interviewed because of your apparent drugged state, you did say that you thought you were only banned from Hindley Street. This offence was aggravated by the fact that it was committed in breach of the 5 January 2024 suspended sentence bond.On MCCRM-24-038339 you have pleaded guilty to an offence of failing to comply with a bail agreement punishable by a maximum $10,000 fine or 2 years imprisonment; and an offence of possessing equipment to use with a controlled drug punishable by a maximum fine of $2,000 or 2 years imprisonment. The timing of your guilty pleas entitles you to a reduction of up to 40% upon the sentence that the court would otherwise impose.This offence involved another breach of that same bail agreement, because on this occasion police were called to Kmart Rundle Mall to remove you from the premises due to your behaviour. When they realised you were in breach of your bail agreement they arrested you, and at the time of your arrest they found you in possession of two ice pipes. You were not interviewed due to your erratic state and apparent drug affected state. This offence was aggravated by the fact that it was committed in breach of the 5 January 2024 suspended sentence bond.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant was arrested on a warrant on 5 December 2024. She had been in custody since 6 December 2024 when sentenced by the magistrate.The sentencing decision After canvassing the circumstances of the offending and the appellant’s history of offending, the magistrate turned to the appellant’s personal circumstances. In addition to those circumstances mentioned earlier in these reasons, the magistrate recorded that he had been informed that the appellant’s partner owns and works in a flooring business and that, for that reason, the appellant had entered the most stable time of her life. Her partner encouraged her to stop using drugs and the appellant had informed her lawyer she wanted to do a beauty course and had enrolled in a TAFE course to become a beautician. As will be seen, the appellant submits that the prosocial circumstances surrounding the relationship that she had entered into prior to sentencing amounted to or resulted in a ‘special circumstance’ capable of justifying a reduction in the term of any revoked suspended sentence. Before dealing with the sentences to be imposed for the admitted offending, the magistrate first addressed the application to enforce the suspended sentence bond imposed on 5 January 2024. The magistrate observed:I turn to the sentencing considerations that apply here. High in the sentencing considerations is your youth. You are only 20 years old. This is far too young to be facing sentences of imprisonment. But it is not a special circumstance that would entitle the court to be justified in reducing the sentence of imprisonment. You were even younger when you received the partially suspended period of imprisonment and I have no doubt the court was painfully aware of your youth at that time. Your pattern of offending since you were released into the community on the split suspended sentence bond appears to be a recommencement and continuation of low to mid-level offending united by the common theme of drug addiction. Those offences have extended to offences of violence and offences of dishonesty. It is not possible to describe your behaviour since that release as remaining of good behaviour. Your breach cannot be described as trivial. I am not persuaded that it would be a disproportionate result if, as a result of these multiple offences, the order of suspension was revoked and that you were ordered to serve the remaining period of the split sentence in a prison. Initially I thought there might have been a change in your circumstances which, had it existed at the time of the imposition of the original bond, may have led that court to impose a lesser sentence. I had been told, when you were applying for bail, that you had become pregnant. At the time of sentencing submissions, no reference was made to this and accordingly I asked you directly whether you were pregnant and you indicated that you did not think you were. As a result, I do not have a factual basis to find that you have, since the original bond was imposed, fallen pregnant, a circumstance which, had it been in in existence at the time of the original sentence, might have led that court to impose a lower sentence. I accept that you have entered a new relationship since the original suspended sentence bond was imposed, but I do not consider that that would have led the earlier court to impose a lesser sentence and I think there is authority to the fact that a mere compliance with the terms of the bond in ceasing to offend is not, in itself, a special circumstance.The order that suspended the remaining 6 month 2 week period of imprisonment must be revoked, and you must therefore serve that period.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning in this case centered on whether the appellant's personal circumstances, particularly her youth, her entry into a stable relationship, her decision to pursue a beauty course, and her ongoing drug addiction, constituted special circumstances warranting a reduction in the term of the revoked suspended sentence. The court meticulously evaluated each of these factors against the legal principles and authorities governing sentencing.

The court first addressed the appellant's youth, noting that she was only 20 years old at the time of sentencing. While acknowledging her youth as a mitigating factor, the court found that it did not constitute a 'special circumstance' that would justify a reduction in the term of the revoked suspended sentence. This aligns with the principle that age alone, without additional extenuating circumstances, does not warrant a reduction in sentencing. The court referenced relevant authorities that support the notion that youth, while a consideration, does not automatically lead to a reduced sentence.

Next, the court examined whether the appellant's entry into a stable relationship and her decision to pursue a beauty course constituted special circumstances justifying a reduction in the term of the revoked suspended sentence. The court noted that while these factors indicated a positive change in the appellant's life, they did not sufficiently alter the circumstances that existed at the time of the original sentencing. The court relied on case law that suggests that a mere compliance with the terms of the bond, such as entering a stable relationship or enrolling in a course, does not in itself constitute a special circumstance warranting a sentence reduction. The court distinguished this from cases where more profound and impactful changes in circumstances have been recognized as special circumstances.

The court also considered the appellant's ongoing drug addiction and repeated breaches of good behaviour bonds. The court found that these factors did not justify a reduction in the term of the revoked suspended sentence. Instead, they warranted the revocation of the suspended sentence and the imposition of the full custodial term. The court emphasized that persistent offending, despite multiple opportunities to reform, demonstrated that the bond was not achieving a deterrent or rehabilitative purpose. The authorities cited supported the principle that persistent breaches of good behaviour bonds indicate a failure of non-custodial sentences to address the underlying issues, thus justifying the enforcement of the full custodial sentence.

Further, the court examined whether the appellant's persistent offending, despite multiple opportunities to reform, warranted the enforcement of the full custodial sentence. The court found that the appellant's history of persistent offending, including multiple breaches of good behaviour bonds, showed that the bond was not achieving its intended deterrent or rehabilitative purpose. The authorities supported the court's finding that repeated breaches of non-custodial sentences justify the enforcement of the full custodial term.

The court also assessed whether the appellant's persistent breaches of good behaviour bonds demonstrated that the bond was not achieving a deterrent or rehabilitative purpose. The court concluded that the persistent nature of the breaches indicated that the bond was ineffective in preventing further offending. The authorities supported the principle that persistent breaches of good behaviour bonds are indicative of a need for a more punitive response.

Lastly, the court considered whether there were any alternative sentences that could have been considered instead of enforcing the full custodial term. The court found that, given the appellant's history and the nature of her breaches, there was little alternative to the revocation of the suspended sentence. The authorities supported the court's conclusion that in cases of persistent breaches of good behaviour bonds, alternative sentences are often insufficient to address the underlying issues.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while personal circumstances such as youth, entry into a stable relationship, and pursuit of education can be considered in sentencing, they do not automatically constitute special circumstances warranting a reduction in the term of a revoked suspended sentence. Persistent offending and breaches of good behaviour bonds, particularly when coupled with ongoing drug addiction, justify the enforcement of the full custodial term. The court's decision reflects a balanced approach that considers the appellant's circumstances while emphasizing the need for accountability and effective deterrence.