Schultz v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Schultz v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2020] QIRC 208

PARTIES:

Schultz, Tautala Faanana
(Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2019/113

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED 
EX TEMPORE ON:

24 November 2020

HEARING DATES:

16, 17, 18 September, and 24 November 2020

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Industrial Commissioner Dwyer

Brisbane

ORDER:

1.     The appeal is dismissed.

2.     The Appellant pay the costs of the hearing.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION – APPEAL – reasonable management action – industrial fairness –actions of management reasonable in the circumstances.

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 32

Forensic Disability Act2011

Delaney v Q-COMP Review Unit [2005] QIC 11; (2005) 178 QGIG 197

Lawton v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 99

APPEARANCES:

Mr C. Clark, Counsel instructed by Bennett and Philp Lawyers for the Appellant.

Mr P. Rashleigh, Counsel directly instructed by the Workers' Compensation Regulator, Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

The following reasons are taken from the transcript of the decision delivered ex tempore on 24 November 2020. The reasons have been subjected to minor editing including the addition of headings and footnotes.

The Appeal

  1. This is an appeal against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator. The decision was dated 6 June 2019. The appellant is Ms Tautala Schultz. Ms Schultz sustained an injury on 2 October 2018 of a psychological or psychiatric nature.

  2. The Regulator has conceded the key elements in respect of s 32 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 ("the Act") have been met, namely:

    ·that Ms Schultz is a worker within the meaning of the Act;

    ·that she suffered a personal injury of a psychiatric nature;

    ·that the injury arose out of or in the course of her employment; and

    ·that her employment was the major significant contributing factor, which I note was the test under the relevant legislation at the time of injury.

  3. There is no issue raised by the Regulator with respect to the fact that the injury arose as a consequence of management action taken on 2 October 2018, and that management action was in the form of a letter[1] and the actions of Mr Graeme Kirkup with respect to Ms Schultz's employment.

    [1] In evidence as Exhibit 10.

  4. The only issue for determination is whether s 32(5) of the Act operates to exclude Ms Schultz's entitlement to compensation. The question, fundamentally, is whether or not the action taken was reasonable and/or whether it was taken in a reasonable way.

    Background

  5. Turning to the facts. Ms Schultz is employed as a forensic disability officer and clinician with the Forensic Disability Service, which is part of the Department of Communities, Disability Services and Seniors, which I will refer to throughout the rest of these reasons as 'the Department'.

  6. At the relevant time, Ms Schultz was employed at a secure facility at Wacol that housed a number of persons who were being held there pursuant to orders of the Mental Health Review…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schultz v Workers' Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QIRC 208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Schultz v Workers' Compensation Regulator, the primary issue before the court was whether the actions taken by Ms Schultz, a forensic disability officer, were reasonable and in a reasonable manner, particularly in relation to the supervision of a client with a history of criminal behaviour and complex medical conditions. The court was required to determine if these actions, specifically allowing the client to go for a swim at a facility outside the secure complex, were reasonable and if Ms Schultz's subsequent psychiatric injury entitled her to compensation. This determination hinged on whether section 32(5) of the Workers' Compensation Act excluded her entitlement to compensation.

The court meticulously examined the evidence regarding the events of 29 September 2018, when Ms Schultz took the client, identified as JPH, to the swimming pool. Despite the recommended supervision ratio not being strictly adhered to, and there being incidents on the way to the pool and at the pool, the court found that Ms Schultz's decision to proceed with the outing was not an exercise of poor judgment. Both Ms Schultz and other staff members, including Mr King and Ms Ison, who signed off on the outing, had no initial objections to the decision. The court concluded that the incidents were not particularly out of the ordinary for managing a client like JPH, given his history and medical conditions.

In its reasoning, the court underscored that it was not evaluating the correctness of Ms Schultz's actions but rather whether they were reasonable in the circumstances. The court found that the actions taken by Ms Schultz, up until the incident later that day, were reasonable and in a reasonable manner, as there was no evidence to suggest otherwise. Consequently, the court held that Ms Schultz's actions did not exclude her from compensation under section 32(5) of the Act. However, the appeal was ultimately dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the costs of the hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The Appellant pay the costs of the hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

The only issue for determination is whether s 32(5) of the Act operates to exclude Ms Schultz's entitlement to compensation. The question, fundamentally, is whether or not the action taken was reasonable and/or whether it was taken in a reasonable way. Background Turning to the facts. Ms Schultz is employed as a forensic disability officer and clinician with the Forensic Disability Service, which is part of the Department of Communities, Disability Services and Seniors, which I will refer to throughout the rest of these reasons as 'the Department'. At the relevant time, Ms Schultz was employed at a secure facility at Wacol that housed a number of persons who were being held there pursuant to orders of the Mental Health Review Tribunal. These were typically persons who had a history of criminal behaviour but lacked the competence to stand trial for their actions. Ms Schultz held an appointment under the Forensic Disability Act2011 as a 'senior practitioner with limited powers'. The effect of this appointment was that it gave Ms Schultz certain additional powers by comparison to, for example, a forensic disability officer with respect to the management of clients in the facility, including such things as authorising restraint. The facility at which Ms Schultz worked housed approximately six to seven clients, with four to each unit. One client, who was identified in these proceedings only as 'JPH' for confidentiality reasons, had a criminal history dating back to 1998. It was primarily related to property offences but also included a number of assaults. The Individual Development Plan ('IDP') in relation to JPH, which is in evidence as Exhibit 3, identifies him as having a complex array of medical conditions that affected him. The IDP outlines a detailed personal history and a detailed history of his problematic behaviours. The IDP that is in evidence is dated 28 September 2018, although I understand from the evidence[2] that there are previous IDPs which are updated from time to time. However, for the purposes of this matter we have relied on the IDP that was dated 28 September 2018. [2] Transcript, page 1-20, line 29-30. This IDP identifies (at page 6) a need for a 3:1 ratio for Limited Community Treatments ('LCT'), which are effectively approved outings under conditions of supervision. The IDP identified JPH as an ongoing risk of absconding. It also identifies a propensity for aggressive behaviour and a sexual preoccupation with children[3]. [3] Page 6 of Exhibit 3. On 29 September 2018, which was a Saturday, Ms Schultz was rostered to work. Near the commencement of her shift she acceded to a wish expressed by JPH to attend the swimming pool for a swim. There was some evidence with respect to the swimming pool, and to the extent that it is relevant, it was not regarded as being within the secure complex in which JPH was housed, but it was within a broader secure complex and had to be accessed by a short walk along a path and then through a locked gate. In accordance with the appropriate protocol, Ms Schultz developed a limited community treatment, which I will refer to as ‘LCT’ for the remainder of these reasons.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Following receipt of this correspondence, Ms Schultz suffered a psychiatric injury and has not returned to work since. Her application for compensation and the subsequent review were rejected, leading to this appeal. The evidence There was extensive evidence dealing with the events of and around 29 September 2018. For reasons that will become apparent, it does not fall to me to evaluate the correctness or otherwise of the actions taken by Mr Schultz in respect of the outing with JPH on that day. However, for completeness, it is necessary to address some of the aspects of the evidence dealing with the incident. Ratios Firstly, on the issue of ratios with respect to the management of JPH, both Ms Schultz and Ms Ogilvie indicated that the recommended ratio, be it 3:1 or otherwise, were not strictly complied with[8].[8] Transcript, page 2-8, line 20-45. Other witnesses also seem to confirm this practice, including Mr King[9] and Ms Ison[10]. I note that both Mr King and Ms Ison were prepared to sign off on the LCT on 29 September 2018 notwithstanding that the IDP recommended 3:1. I note in particular that Ms Ison had, in fact, signed off on that individual development plan only the day before.[9] Mr King signed off on the LCT at a ratio of 2:1 and offered, but did not insist, on sending an extra staff member. [10] Ms Ison signed off on the LCT at a ratio of 2:1, plus see transcript at page 2-28, line 25-30 "I now know…". To that end I accept that the practice, prior to 29 September 2018 at least, was that there was not a rigid adherence to the recommended supervision ratio as set out in the individual development plan.The LCT plan on 29 September 2018 Secondly, if I could turn to the soundness or otherwise of the decision to do the LCT on 29 September 2018 with JPH. Having considered the evidence I find that there is nothing that indicates that the idea and the initiation of the LCT plan was an exercise of poor judgment by Ms Schultz. On the contrary, it would appear that Ms Schultz had a good understanding of JPH and had a sufficient level of professional confidence in the decision to take him to the pool on that day. I note also that, certainly prior to the incident that occurred later that day, there did not appear to be any particular objection by Mr King, who was at the facility that day and was charged with the responsibility of reviewing the LCT plan. I note also that Ms Ison signed off on it. At least up until the point of the incident in the afternoon, or after the trip to the swimming pool, it was not only Ms Schultz but also Mr King and Ms Ison who appeared to have no difficulty with the decision to take JPH to the pool at a 2:1 ratio. There were a number of incidents on the way to the pool, and they were dealt with in the evidence.The incidents described on the way to the pool, and at the pool, whilst being evidence of JPH's potential for being difficult, do not, on the evidence that I have heard, strike me as especially out of the ordinary for the management of an individual such as JPH, particularly given his array of medical conditions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There was extensive evidence dealing with the events of and around 29 September 2018. For reasons that will become apparent, it does not fall to me to evaluate the correctness or otherwise of the actions taken by Mr Schultz in respect of the outing with JPH on that day. However, for completeness, it is necessary to address some of the aspects of the evidence dealing with the incident. Ratios Firstly, on the issue of ratios with respect to the management of JPH, both Ms Schultz and Ms Ogilvie indicated that the recommended ratio, be it 3:1 or otherwise, were not strictly complied with[8].[8] Transcript, page 2-8, line 20-45. Other witnesses also seem to confirm this practice, including Mr King[9] and Ms Ison[10]. I note that both Mr King and Ms Ison were prepared to sign off on the LCT on 29 September 2018 notwithstanding that the IDP recommended 3:1. I note in particular that Ms Ison had, in fact, signed off on that individual development plan only the day before.[9] Mr King signed off on the LCT at a ratio of 2:1 and offered, but did not insist, on sending an extra staff member. [10] Ms Ison signed off on the LCT at a ratio of 2:1, plus see transcript at page 2-28, line 25-30 "I now know…". To that end I accept that the practice, prior to 29 September 2018 at least, was that there was not a rigid adherence to the recommended supervision ratio as set out in the individual development plan.The LCT plan on 29 September 2018 Secondly, if I could turn to the soundness or otherwise of the decision to do the LCT on 29 September 2018 with JPH. Having considered the evidence I find that there is nothing that indicates that the idea and the initiation of the LCT plan was an exercise of poor judgment by Ms Schultz. On the contrary, it would appear that Ms Schultz had a good understanding of JPH and had a sufficient level of professional confidence in the decision to take him to the pool on that day. I note also that, certainly prior to the incident that occurred later that day, there did not appear to be any particular objection by Mr King, who was at the facility that day and was charged with the responsibility of reviewing the LCT plan. I note also that Ms Ison signed off on it. At least up until the point of the incident in the afternoon, or after the trip to the swimming pool, it was not only Ms Schultz but also Mr King and Ms Ison who appeared to have no difficulty with the decision to take JPH to the pool at a 2:1 ratio. There were a number of incidents on the way to the pool, and they were dealt with in the evidence.The incidents described on the way to the pool, and at the pool, whilst being evidence of JPH's potential for being difficult, do not, on the evidence that I have heard, strike me as especially out of the ordinary for the management of an individual such as JPH, particularly given his array of medical conditions. The pausing and the difficulty in getting him to move forward on the way to the pool, and even the difficulty at the pool where he locked himself in the bathrooms, are not, in my view, particularly out of the ordinary and not necessarily the sorts of things that might be 'red flag' events that might attract a need for Ms Schultz to call upon additional assistance at that time.