Scholle Industries Pty Ltd v AEP Industries (NZ) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

SCHOLLE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD v AEP INDUSTRIES (NZ) LTD & ANOR

[2009] SASC 145

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

21 May 2009

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - PLEADINGS

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS

Application by defendants for permission to amend defences - defendants wish to plead that plaintiff's claim for damages in respect of its liability to a non-party for which the plaintiff received indemnity from its liability insurers was limited to the amount which the plaintiff had paid to those insurers to secure the release of the insurers' subrogated rights - defendants apprehend that plaintiff made an agreement with its insurers for the release of their subrogated rights - application by first defendant for discovery by plaintiff of the apprehended agreement - whether defence raised by defendants in proposed amended defences is reasonably arguable - whether apprehended agreement directly relevant to an issue on the pleadings.

Held:  matters raised in proposed amended defences not reasonably arguable - permission to amend defences refused - apprehended agreement not directly relevant to any issue on the pleadings - application for discovery of apprehended agreement dismissed.

Evidence Act 1929 (SA) s 67C; Supreme Court Rules 1987 r 58A, referred to.
Duke Group Ltd (in liq) v Arthur Young (No 4) (1991) 55 SASR 24; Pavlovic v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1992) 56 SASR 587; Re T H Knitwear (Wholesale) Ltd [1988] Ch 275; Orakpo v Manson Investments Ltd [1978] AC 95; Re Palmdale Insurance Ltd [1986] VR 439; Boscawen v Bajwa [1996] 1 WLR 328; Re Trivan Pty Ltd (1996) 134 FLR 368; Castellain v Preston (1883) 11 QBD 380; State Government Insurance Office (Queensland) v Brisbane Stevedoring Pty Ltd (1969) 123 CLR 228; Napier and Ettrick v Hunter [1993] AC 713, applied.
Protec Pacific Pty Ltd v WMC (Olympic Dam Corporation) Pty Ltd [2006] VSC 208; Insurance Commission of Western Australia v Kightly (2005) 30 WAR 380, discussed.
Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341; Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu v JP Morgan Portfolio Services Ltd (2007) 240 ALR 540; Scholle Industries Pty Ltd v AEP Industries (NZ) Ltd & Anor (2007) 99 SASR 178, considered.

SCHOLLE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD v AEP INDUSTRIES (NZ) LTD & ANOR
[2009] SASC 145

Civil

WHITE J:         

  1. The first defendant (AEP) has applied, amongst other things, for leave to amend its defence, and for an order that the plaintiff (Scholle) discover an agreement which AEP apprehends Scholle has made with its insurers.  The second defendant (DS Smith) made an application to amend its defence in similar terms to those proposed by AEP.  Apart from some limited submissions of its own, DS Smith adopted the submissions made by AEP.  Scholle opposed each application.

  2. This judgment contains my reasons on those applications.

    Background to the Applications

  3. In very general terms, in these proceedings Scholle sues…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scholle Industries Pty Ltd v AEP Industries (NZ) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Scholle Industries Pty Ltd v AEP Industries (NZ) Ltd, the defendants, AEP and DS Smith, sought permission to amend their defences to include a claim that Scholle's liability to a non-party was limited by the amount Scholle paid to its insurers to secure the release of the insurers' subrogated rights. The defendants also sought an order for Scholle to disclose an agreement between Scholle and its insurers regarding the release of the insurers' subrogated rights. The application was made in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The key legal issues were whether the defences proposed by the defendants were reasonably arguable and whether the apprehended agreement was directly relevant to any issue on the pleadings.

The court found that the proposed defences were not reasonably arguable. The court noted that the defendants had not provided any evidence to support their belief that an agreement existed between Scholle and its insurers. The court also found that the apprehended agreement was not directly relevant to any issue on the pleadings. The court held that the defendants had not established that the agreement, if it existed, was directly relevant to any issue raised on the pleadings. The court therefore dismissed the application for further discovery.

In conclusion, the court refused the defendants' applications for leave to amend their defences and to discover any agreement made between Scholle and its insurers regarding the release of the insurers' subrogated rights. The court held that the defendants had not established that the apprehended agreement, if it existed, was directly relevant to any issue on the pleadings. The court will hear the parties as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This judgment contains my reasons on those applications.Background to the Applications In very general terms, in these proceedings Scholle sues AEP and DS Smith to recover losses which it claims to have suffered as a result of the supply by AEP of defective taps designed by DS Smith. Scholle used the taps in wine cask inserts. It alleges, amongst other things, that the defects in the taps had the effect that large quantities of wine were spoilt, and that it became liable to two wine producers, the Hardy Wine Company and Yalumba, for the losses which they suffered in consequence. It was common ground that Scholle had been insured in respect of some of its losses and, in particular, in respect of at least some, if not all, of the liability which it incurred to the Hardy Wine Company. It also seemed to be common ground that Scholle’s insurers had indemnified it in respect of some, if not all, of its losses arising out of claims made by the Hardy Wine Company (the Hardy Claim). The present applications arise out of the defendants’ belief that Scholle and its insurers have, since the indemnification, entered into an agreement providing for the “purchase” by Scholle of the insurers’ subrogated rights (the apprehended agreement). The defendants do not know the nature of the agreement but apprehend that it may take the form of an agreement between the insurers and Scholle by which the insurers, in consideration of a payment to them by Scholle, have agreed not to enforce the lien over any judgment monies to which their right of subrogation gave rise. Scholle does not acknowledge that an agreement of the kind apprehended by the defendants does exist. It does, however, positively deny that there has been any assignment of a claim by the insurers to it. Initially, AEP wished its application for discovery of the apprehended agreement to be determined before its application to amend its Amended Defence. However, later it put the amendment application at the forefront of its applications. DS Smith supported the submissions of AEP in this respect. Although the amendment proposed by DS Smith is not identical with that proposed by AEP, it is sufficient to refer only to that proposed by AEP. AEP wishes to add a paragraph 25 to its Amended Defence so as to plead:25 As to the allegations of the Hardy Losses generally, AEP says that:25.1 The plaintiff was indemnified by its insurers in relation to the claim made against it by Hardy (“the Hardy Claim”).25.2 The plaintiff’s insurers reimbursed the plaintiff for $4.5 million of the Hardy Claim, and paid $6.48 million to Hardy with the said reimbursement and payment totalling $10.928 million thereby resolving the plaintiff’s purported liability to Hardy.25.3 The Hardy Claim was subrogated to the insurers upon the indemnification referred to in 25.2 herein.25.4 On or about 16 December 2008, the plaintiff agreed with its insurers that for consideration from the plaintiff to the insurers, the rights of the insurers to exercise a lien over any award of damages with respect to the Hardy Claim (“the Insurers’ Lien”) would be released or terminated.25.5 Accordingly, if the plaintiff establishes a liability on the part of AEP to it in relation to the Hardy Claim (which is denied), AEP says that, as a matter of law or public policy, any such liability is limited to the amount Scholle paid to its insurers for the release or termination of the Insurers’ Lien.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In summary, for the reasons given above, I am not satisfied that AEP has established that the apprehended agreement, if it exists, is directly relevant to any issue raised on the pleadings. Accordingly, I dismiss the application for further discovery.Conclusion Each of the applications by AEP and DS Smith for leave to amend their respective defences is refused. The application by AEP that Scholle discover any agreement made between its insurers and it in December 2008 regarding the enforcement by the insurers of their subrogated rights is also refused. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.