LAND COURT BRISBANE 18 MAY 2001
[2001] QLC 40
Re:Appeal against Categorisation City of Brisbane Act 1924 (VC00-632)
Vincent R and Carol G Schokman v.
Brisbane City Council
D E C I S I O N
Background -
This matter relates to an appeal by Vincent Ronald and Carol Gwendoline Schokman (the appellants) against the categorisation of their land by the Brisbane City Council (the respondent). The subject land is located at 9 Waldo Street, Norman Park, and is described as Lots 84 to 86 on RP 12495, Parish of Bulimba, and contains an area of 1,215 m². The land is zoned as "Residential A", and is currently categorised for rating purposes as Category 2 under the City of Brisbane Act 1924. Mr R Jones of Counsel, instructed by Rouyanian & Co, Lawyers, appeared for the appellants. Mr R Needham of Counsel, instructed by Brisbane City Council, appeared for the respondent.
History of the Site -
The subject land had formerly been operated under a consent decision as a non-conforming use in the "Residential A" zone, initially as a hostel for disabled girls since 1940, later as a nursing home and then as accommodation for intellectually handicapped people. When the appellants acquired the property in July 1986 they transformed the premises into what has been broadly described as a hostel for financially disadvantaged and psychiatric patients.
Waldo Street is a quiet, narrow, dead-end street in a very attractive part of Norman Park. It is the stated intention of the appellants to relocate and demolish existing buildings upon the subject land, to make way for a new dwelling as the residence of the appellants. The appellants currently reside at 160 Wynnum Road, Norman Park, which adjoins the subject land to the south. That land is designated as Category 1 land, being the single-unit dwelling and principal place of residence of the
appellants. The appellants argue that once they have built their new home on the subject land, they intend selling their current place of residence.
The Nature of the Land -
The subject land contains two buildings which are connected by a covered walkway. The western building fronting Waldo Street is a large residential dwelling, which apparently has been classified as a "character building" under the Town Plan. The eastern building is a brick semi-lowset structure containing nine bedrooms, a bathroom, toilet and shower room and a small laundry. The second building has an area of approximately 156 m², and is located behind the residential building. There were no facilities for cooking in the eastern building.
Following a refusal to relocate the existing residential dwelling, the appellants obtained a decision of the Planning and Environment Court on 31 May 2000 in their favour, allowing for the removal of the western character building, and the demolition of the eastern building, with certain conditions attached to the demolition or removal of the building. The western building is proposed for relocation to Maleny.
Action to remove the building has not proceeded to the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Schokman v Brisbane City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] QLC 40
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case revolve around the classification of the subject land under the City of Brisbane Act 1924. The appellants argue that their land should be categorised as Category 1, as it is the principal place of residence. The Council contends that the land should remain as Category 2, as it has not been used for residential purposes since December 1999 and has been vacant beyond the allowable six-month period under the Brisbane Town Plan. The court had to determine whether the cessation of the non-conforming use and the vacancy of the buildings affect the eligibility of the land to be categorised as Category 1.
The court found that the appellants' land should be categorised as Category 2. The primary consideration was the current use and vacancy of the land, which had not been used for residential purposes since December 1999 and remained vacant beyond the allowable period. The court held that the land did not qualify for Category 1 status as it was not being used for residential purposes. The cessation of the non-conforming use and the vacancy of the buildings were significant factors in the court's decision.
In conclusion, the court dismissed the appeal, upholding the Brisbane City Council's categorisation of the appellants' land as Category 2 for rating purposes. The court found that the land did not meet the criteria for Category 1 status due to its vacancy and the cessation of the non-conforming use. The final orders of the court reflect the dismissal of the appeal and the maintenance of the Category 2 rating classification.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi