Schneider v Hoechst Schering Agrevo Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Schneider v Hoechst Schering Agrevo Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 154

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - cases heard together but not consolidated – evidential difficulties.

REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – damaged wheat crops – reduced yield at harvest.

NEGLIGENCE – product liability – manufacturers and distributors of agricultural herbicide – failure to warn– causation – foreseeability – sufficiency of trials on the herbicide.

CAUSATION – a combination of unknown factors –distinction between “essential condition” and “legal cause” – “but for” test - role of expert evidence in determining causation.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 70, 71 and 74
Sale of Goods Act 1924 (NSW) ss 18 and 19
Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 42

McGhee v National Coal Board [1973] 1 WLR 1 referred to

March vStramare [1991] 171 CLR 506 followed
Bennett v Minister of Community Welfare [1992] 176 CLR 408 followed
Commonwealth v McLean [1997] 41 NSWLR referred to
Chappel v Hart [1998] 156 ALR 517 referred to
Tubemakers of Australia Ltd v Fernandez (1976) 50 ALJR 720 referred to
Dahl v Grice [1981] VR 513 applied

DAVID LOUIS SCHNEIDER v HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD, IAMA LTD
NG 374 of 1997

JIM MASMAN, LORETTA MASMAN, JAMES MASMAN and JON MASMAN v CASTLEREAGH MACQUARIE COUNTY COUNCIL, HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
NG 931 of 1997

ELWIN JOHN EDWARDS and SCOTT ANTHONY EDWARDS v BAYEBB PTY LTD, HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
NG 932 of 1997

WILLIAM LUDLOW CHAPMAN and JEAN CHAPMAN v WICKMAN RYAN PTY LTD, WESFARMERS DALGETY LTD, HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
NG 77 of 1998

JUDGE:         MATHEWS J
PLACE:         SYDNEY
DATE:           29 MARCH 2000

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 77 of 1998

BETWEEN:

WILLIAM LUDLOW CHAPMAN & JEAN CHAPMAN
Applicants

AND:

WICKMAN RYAN PTY LTD
First Respondent/First Cross-Claimant/Third Cross-Respondent

WESFARMERS DALGETY LTD
Second Respondent/Second Cross-Claimant/Third Cross-Respondent

HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
Second Cross-Respondent/Third Cross-Claimant

JUDGE:

MATHEWS J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 MARCH 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   The Application be dismissed.

2.   The cross-claims be dismissed.

3.   The Applicants are to pay the Respondents’ and Cross-Respondents’ costs of the proceedings.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 374 of 1997

BETWEEN:

DAVID LOUIS SCHNEIDER
Applicant

AND:

HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
First Respondent/Cross- Respondent/Cross-Claimant

IAMA LTD
Second Respondent/Cross-Claimant/Cross-Respondent

NG 931 of 1997

BETWEEN:

JIM MASMAN, LORETTA MASMAN, JAMES MASMAN & JON MASMAN
Applicants

AND:

CASTLEREAGH MACQUARIE COUNTY COUNCIL
Respondent/Cross-Claimant

HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
Cross-Respondent

NG 932 of 1997

BETWEEN:

ELWIN JOHN EDWARDS & SCOTT ANTHONY EDWARDS
Applicants

AND:

BAYEBB PTY LTD
Respondent/Cross-Claimant

HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
Cross-Respondent

NG 77 of 1998

BETWEEN:

WILLIAM LUDLOW CHAPMAN & JEAN CHAPMAN
Applicants

AND:

WICKMAN RYAN PTY LTD
First Respondent/First Cross-Claimant/Third Cross-Respondent

WESFARMERS DALGETY LTD
Second Respondent/Second Cross-Claimant/Third Cross-Respondent

HOECHST SCHERING AGREVO PTY LTD
Second Cross-Respondent/Third Cross-Claimant

JUDGE:

MATHEWS J

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schneider v Hoechst Schering Agrevo Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Schneider v Hoechst Schering Agrevo Pty Ltd involved the applicants, Schneider, contesting the liability and quantum of damages against the respondents, Hoechst Schering Agrevo Pty Ltd, in relation to the alleged adverse effects of the herbicide Puma S on wheat crops during the 1996 season. The matter was heard over three weeks, with initial discussions around splitting the issues of liability and quantum into separate hearings. However, the respondents objected to this proposal, leading to the hearing proceeding on all issues. Near the end of the third week, complications arose regarding the evidence of a witness proposed by Hoechst on the issue of damages, necessitating the deferral of further evidence and submissions on damages until a later date. Consequently, final submissions were limited to the question of liability, with an agreement that if the applicants succeeded on this issue, the proceedings would be reconvened to address damages.

The court was required to decide several legal and factual issues, including the general nature and function of Puma S, the evidence relating to the 1996 wheat crop of eight wheat-growers, the conclusions of various expert witnesses, and the trials carried out on Puma S before the 1996 season. The court also needed to assess the efficacy of Puma S in eradicating weeds such as black oats and its impact on wheat crops when applied at the recommended rate. Furthermore, the court had to determine whether Puma S's use led to any adverse effects on the wheat crops, which formed the basis of the applicants' claims.

In delivering the judgment, the court concluded that Puma S is a post-emergent selective herbicide designed to eradicate weeds without affecting wheat crops, containing fenoxaprop-p-ethyl and fenchlorazole-ethyl. It found that while Puma S effectively eradicated black oats when applied at the recommended rate, there were no complaints regarding its efficacy. However, the court determined that the applicants failed to prove that Puma S had any adverse effect on the wheat crops. The court dismissed the application, cross-claims, and ordered the applicants to pay the respondents' and cross-respondents' costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Application be dismissed.

2. The cross-claims be dismissed.

3. The Applicants are to pay the Respondents’ and Cross-Respondents’ costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Three weeks were set aside for the hearing of this matter. At the outset, Mr Rowe, on behalf of the applicants, suggested that the issues of liability and quantum might be split, and that the primary hearing should be restricted to matters relevant to liability. The respondents successfully objected to this course, and the hearing thus proceeded on all issues. However, on the last day of evidence, which was well into the third week of the hearing, several difficulties arose in relation to the foreshadowed evidence of a witness whom Hoechst proposed to call on the issue of damages. It was acknowledged that some time would be needed to rectify these problems. The only way to accommodate to this situation was to defer further evidence and submissions on the issue of damages until a later date. Accordingly, all final submissions were restricted to the question of liability. It was agreed that, should the applicants succeed on this issue, the proceedings would need to be reconvened at a later date in order to deal with damages. As it transpires, this course will not be necessary.Outline of Judgment This judgment will deal with the following matters:· the general nature and function of Puma S;· the evidence relating to the 1996 wheat crop of each of the eight wheat-growers whose losses have been raised in these proceedings;· the conclusions of the various experts who gave evidence in the case;· an outline of the trials carried out on Puma S before the 1996 season;· outline and discussion of the legal and factual issues involved in the case.Puma S – General Description I shall be describing later the mode of operation of Puma S and the history of its manufacture and sale. For present purposes it is sufficient to say that Puma S is generally classified as a post-emergent selective herbicide. In other words, it is designed to eradicate weeds which have emerged during the growth of wheat crops, without affecting the wheat itself. It contains an active ingredient, fenoxaprop-p-ethyl (‘FPE’) and a ‘safener’ fenchlorazole-ethyl (‘FCE’). Both weeds and wheat crop take up the active ingredient at much the same time, which sometimes leads to a yellowing in the wheat. However, the wheat metabolises the active ingredient at a faster rate than the weeds, a process which is accelerated by the safener. The result is that FPE is detoxified within the wheat within a short time, so that no long term damage is suffered by the crop. The weeds, however, do not detoxify in this manner and Puma S is apparently regarded as very effective in the eradication of a number of weeds, particularly black oats (sometimes described as “wild oats”) and winter phalaris. It was the emergence of black oats amongst the 1996 wheat crops which led to the application of Puma S by most of the represented growers. Black oats, on all accounts, is a particularly virulent weed. If left unchecked, a black oats infestation can significantly reduce the yield of a wheat crop, sometimes to the extent of rendering harvest uneconomical. Attempts can be made to control the weed prior to the sowing of a crop, by applying a systemic herbicide such as Round-Up. This was done by some of the growers involved in this case, but the weed re-emerged during the growth season. When this occurs, a grower must choose between leaving the weed unchecked or spraying with a post-emergent selective herbicide such as Puma S. This chemical is, as I have indicated, generally very effective in eradicating black oats. It did so in all the crops involved in these proceedings when it was applied at the recommended rate. In general, therefore, no complaint is made that Puma S failed to meet the purpose for which it was intended. It was the allegedly adverse effect of the chemical on the wheat crop itself which gave rise to these proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.