Scenic Rim Regional Council v Gillion Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2011] QPEC 143

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

JUDGE ROBIN QC

P & E Appeal No 2608 of 2009

SCENIC RIM REGIONAL COUNCIL Applicant

and

GILLION PTY LTD Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 09/11/2011

ORDER

CATCHWORDS

Suspension of court orders to preserve the value of an appeal should it succeed - the court having determined that an unlawful use of "water extraction" occurred on the respondent's site although the activity had been carried on at a more modest scale for a long time, the operation of enforcement orders was suspended to permit a development application to regularise the use to be made - Council having rejected that development application (against its planning officer's recommendation) opposed any further suspension - discretion of court exercised to suspend further, at least until first mention date of the appeal just commenced against the rejection - hardship factors
HIS HONOUR:  At issue this afternoon is whether the court ought to further suspend the operation of orders made by Judge Durward SC when he determined that the water extraction activity which the respondent company conducts on its 8,000 square metre site at Power Parade, Mount Tamborine is an unlawful use.


The suspension of his Honour's orders forbidding continuance of that use was initially one of eight weeks duration on the basis that, as happened, the company would make a development application seeking to regularise the use.  That is a common scenario in the court's experience.  There have been successive orders extending the suspension to accommodate the Council's processing of the impact assessable development application.

The Council, once by right and once with the cooperation of the company, took additional time to process the application which attracted hundreds of submissions, all but one adverse.  Its decision to refuse the application was made on the 25th of October this year and communicated by decision notice of the 1st of November. 

The decision of the Council ran contrary to the recommendation of its officer in a planning report which is before the court.  No more should be taken from that report than that the appeal which the company has instituted today against the Council's refusal has prospects of success.  The court may take the view that the correct conclusion is the one recommended by the Council's officer.  The court may take another view. 

The further suspension sought is not one proposed to run until determination of the appeal but one proposed to run only until the middle of next month to accommodate what's probably the earliest feasible first mention date for the appeal which may come to involve hundreds of co-respondents by election following notice of it being given to all of the submitters.

The situation will be kept under review.  The Council, which has acquiesced in the series of suspensions to date, strongly opposes any further suspension.  It relies on the established illegality of the use, there being no appeal against Judge Durward's decision.  It relies on its own decision in refusing the development application for an approval which would have…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scenic Rim Regional Council v Gillion Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QPEC 143
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Scenic Rim Regional Council v Gillion Pty Ltd, the plaintiff council and defendant company were engaged in a legal dispute regarding the use of water extraction on the defendant's site. The defendant had been conducting water extraction activities on their site for over twenty years, which the council deemed to be an unlawful use. The court was required to determine whether to suspend its orders to preserve the value of an appeal should it succeed. The defendant had made a development application to regularise the use, which the council had rejected. The court exercised its discretion to suspend the operation of its orders until the first mention date of the appeal against the council's refusal, subject to certain conditions to mitigate the impact on neighbouring residents.
The court took into account various factors, including the established illegality of the use, the council's decision to refuse the development application, and evidence of nuisance impacts on neighbouring residents. The court accepted the defendant's assurances that they had not exceeded the permitted number of water extractions, but recognised that the new driver engaged by the defendant may have been less considerate of the amenity of neighbours than the previous driver. The court considered the hardship to the defendant's employees and their families, as well as the potential economic impact on the defendant's business if forced to cease operations. The court ultimately decided to grant the suspension, but on conditions more onerous than those that had previously applied, to mitigate the impact on neighbouring residents. The court also noted that the situation would be kept under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established