Scenic Rim Regional Council v Cutbush

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Scenic Rim Regional Council v Cutbush [2024] FCA 1135  

File number(s): QUD 262 of 2024
Judgment of: MEAGHER J
Date of judgment: 24 September 2024
Catchwords:  BANKRUPTCY – application for substituted service of creditor’s petition – whether abnormal difficulties exist – whether alternative means of service have a reasonable probability of informing the respondent – where there have been various unsuccessful attempts at personal service – where property is secured – application for substituted service granted – application for declaratory relief as to the validity of the bankruptcy notice deferred until after service has been effected
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 309(2)
Cases cited: Ginnane v Diners Club Ltd (1993) 120 ALR 375
Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 24
Date of hearing: 24 September 2024
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr SJ Tan
Solicitor for the Applicant: King & Company Solicitors

ORDERS

QUD 262 of 2024
BETWEEN:

SCENIC RIM REGIONAL COUNCIL

Applicant

AND:

PAUL CUTBUSH

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MEAGHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 SEPTEMBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Personal service of the Creditor’s Petition be dispensed with.

2.The Creditor’s Petition, the affidavit verifying the Creditor’s Petition, the affidavit of service of the bankruptcy notice, the copy of the consent of a registered trustee, the affidavit of Antoni Bergman filed on 28 August 2024, the affidavits of Ethan Nicholas John Brian Edwards filed on 28 August 2024 and 20 September 2024, the interlocutory application filed on 4 September 2024, the outline of submissions filed on 28 August 2024, the outline of submissions provided to the Court on 24 September 2024 and a sealed copy of this order (collectively, the Documents) be served on the Respondent by:

a.Leaving the Documents in the letter box at 25-29 Durrant Court, Tamborine QLD 4270; and

b.Sending the Documents via email to paul.cutbush1@bigpond.com and paulcutbush@gmail.com.

3.Service of the Documents be deemed to be effected on 11 October 2024 upon the condition that the two events referred to in order 2 occur by 8 October 2024.

4.Paragraph 1 of the interlocutory application filed on 4 September 2024 be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

5.The Applicant file the outline of submissions provided to the Court on 24 September 2024 by 4:00pm AEST on 25 September 2024.

6.Costs be reserved.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(REVISED FROM TRANSCRIPT)

MEAGHER J

INTRODUCTION

  1. Before the Court is an ex parte interlocutory application brought by the applicant seeking orders for substituted service of the Creditor’s Petition and supporting documentation on the respondent, as well as declaratory relief with respect to the validity of the bankruptcy notice.

  2. Specifically, the applicant seeks the following orders allowing for substituted service on the respondent:

    1.That personal service of the Creditor’s Petition, the affidavit verifying the Creditor’s Petition, the affidavit of service of the bankruptcy notice, the copy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scenic Rim Regional Council v Cutbush and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1135
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The court case, Scenic Rim Regional Council v Cutbush, involves a creditor's petition filed by the Scenic Rim Regional Council against Paul Cutbush. The Council claims that Cutbush owes a sum of $113,527.38 due to non-compliance with a bankruptcy notice. The dispute primarily revolves around the service of the creditor's petition and the validity of the bankruptcy notice. The court was tasked with determining whether abnormal difficulties justified substituted service of the creditor’s petition and whether alternative means of service had a reasonable probability of informing Cutbush of the creditor's petition. The court had to consider the applicant's multiple unsuccessful attempts at personal service and the security features of Cutbush’s property, which made personal service challenging.

The court acknowledged that the applicant had faced significant difficulties in serving Cutbush personally, as evidenced by the locked gate, the absence of any response to calls and attempts to contact via phone, and the lack of interaction despite leaving calling cards. The court also considered the nature of Cutbush’s property, which included an intercom system that allowed him to screen visitors, further complicating personal service. Given these circumstances, the court concluded that abnormal difficulties indeed existed, warranting the grant of a substituted service order. The court was satisfied that the proposed alternative means of service—leaving documents in the letterbox and emailing them to Cutbush’s known email addresses—had a reasonable probability of informing him of the creditor’s petition.

In light of these findings, the court granted the application for substituted service, allowing the creditor's petition and related documents to be served on Cutbush by leaving them in his letterbox and emailing them to his known email addresses. The court deferred the application regarding the validity of the bankruptcy notice until after service had been effected to ensure Cutbush was properly informed of the creditor's petition. The court reserved costs and directed the filing of specific documents by a certain date.

The final orders included dispensing with personal service of the creditor's petition, specifying the method of substituted service, deeming service to be effected on a particular date upon certain conditions, adjourning the application for declaratory relief, and reserving costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Personal service of the Creditor’s Petition be dispensed with.

2. The Creditor’s Petition, the affidavit verifying the Creditor’s Petition, the affidavit of service of the bankruptcy notice, the copy of the consent of a registered trustee, the affidavit of Antoni Bergman filed on 28 August 2024, the affidavits of Ethan Nicholas John Brian Edwards filed on 28 August 2024 and 20 September 2024, the interlocutory application filed on 4 September 2024, the outline of submissions filed on 28 August 2024, the outline of submissions provided to the Court on 24 September 2024 and a sealed copy of this order (collectively, the Documents) be served on the Respondent by:

a. Leaving the Documents in the letter box at 25-29 Durrant Court, Tamborine QLD 4270; and

b. Sending the Documents via email to paul.cutbush1@bigpond.com and paulcutbush@gmail.com.

3. Service of the Documents be deemed to be effected on 11 October 2024 upon the condition that the two events referred to in order 2 occur by 8 October 2024.

4. Paragraph 1 of the interlocutory application filed on 4 September 2024 be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

5. The Applicant file the outline of submissions provided to the Court on 24 September 2024 by 4:00pm AEST on 25 September 2024.

6. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the substituted service application is allowed. The application with respect to the validity of the bankruptcy notice is adjourned to a date to be fixed, to allow the applicant to serve the relevant documents on the respondent. BACKGROUND The proceeding is commenced by a Creditor’s Petition filed on 21 May 2024, by which the applicant contends that the respondent owes the applicant an amount of $113,527.38, arising from two Money Orders of the District Court of Queensland. The act of bankruptcy relied upon is the respondent’s failure to comply on or before 21 November 2023 with the bankruptcy notice served on him on 31 October 2023, or to satisfy the Court that he had a counter-claim, set-off or cross demand equal to or more than the sum claimed in the bankruptcy notice, being a counter-claim, set-off or cross demand that he could not have set up in the action in which the judgment referred to in the bankruptcy notice was obtained. It is necessary to set out the background as it relates to the attempted service of the Creditor’s Petition and supporting documentation. As is deposed to in Mr Edwards’ affidavits filed on 21 May 2024 and 28 August 2024, the applicant’s solicitor searched the electoral roll, and found that the address was recorded as being 25 Durrant Court, Tamborine, Queensland 4270. Mr Edwards also deposes that the applicant’s solicitors act on behalf of the applicant in other proceedings brought by the respondent and, with respect to the Queensland Court of Appeal proceeding 7955/20, the respondent’s address for service is recorded as 25-29 Durrant Court, Tamborine Queensland, 4270. It is for those reasons that Mr Edwards believes that the respondent’s last known address is 25-29 Durrant Court, Tamborine Queensland 4270. This address will hereafter be referred to as the Relevant Address. Mr Bergman, a Licenced Process Server, deposes in his affidavit filed on 28 August 2024 that he attended the Relevant Address on 6 June 2024. He deposes that the gate at the front of the property was locked and that there was no other means by which to enter the property. He deposes that he attempted to gain the attention of the occupants of the house by using the intercom at the front gate, as well as by calling out loudly. He did not receive any response. Further, he deposes that he tried to contact the respondent through both mobile and landline telephone numbers which had been provided to him, but the calls went unanswered, and he was unable to leave a message. He deposes that he also left a calling card with his contact details, requesting a call, in the letterbox of the Relevant Address. Mr Bergman deposes to making two further attempts to effect personal service on the respondent, on 8 June 2024 and 8 July 2024, respectively. Mr Bergman’s affidavit sets out that, similar to the circumstances which prevailed on 6 June 2024, he was unable to attract the attention of the occupants of the house, nor was there a response to his telephone calls. On both occasions, Mr Bergman also left calling cards in the letterbox. Mr Bergman further deposes that on 8 June 2024, he saw a silver SUV parked in front of the house with all of the doors open but did not see any persons. On 8 June 2024, Mr Bergman also left an additional card in the gate.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the applicant’s written submissions dealt with the question of the validity of the bankruptcy notice, at the hearing counsel for the applicant acknowledged that it is an issue which ought to be determined after the respondent has been served. I consider that to be the appropriate course. CONCLUSION In these circumstances, I am satisfied that it is appropriate to make orders with respect to substituted service. The application with respect to the validity of the bankruptcy notice ought to be adjourned until after the respondent has been served. Costs ought to be reserved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

With respect to the relationship between the two limbs of the relevant test, the Full Court in Ginnane stated at 381: Although as a matter of methodology, it is useful to consider these two limbs separately, it must be remembered that the discretion conferred by s 309(2) of the Bankruptcy Act is unfettered. The two limbs are not separate and distinct compartments. Together, they form a composite basis for the exercise of a discretion. Normally, the evidence must show some need for substituted service and the basis by which the substituted form of service will, in all probability, be effective to bring the petition to the knowledge of the debtor. In some cases, the evidence may establish almost a certainty that the form of substituted service will have the effect of bringing the petition to the knowledge of the debtor.CONSIDERATION The applicant referred to the following matters as constituting “abnormal difficulties” in respect of which the Court should exercise its discretion to grant substituted service: (1)The respondent’s property is secured by a fence and a gate; (2)The intercom system at the respondent’s property allows the respondent to screen visitors; (3)The nature of the respondent’s secured property makes it difficult to raise the respondent’s attention, noting that Mr Bergman called out loudly in all three attempts at service; and (4)The respondent did not respond to any of the calling cards left by Mr Bergman. The applicant submitted that the proposed alternative means of service, namely by leaving the documents in the letter box at the Relevant Address and emailing the documents to the two email addresses, has a reasonable probability of informing the respondent of the creditor’s petition. To that end, the applicant submitted that it is reasonable to conclude that the Relevant Address is the one at which the respondent resides. The applicant also submitted that as to the slight difference between the address recorded on the electoral roll and the Relevant Address, the property is a large block located in a regional area and the letterbox records the number 25. While there is no evidence before the Court as to this, I am satisfied that it is clear that the address on the electoral roll and the relevant address are at the same location. The applicant contended that the two email addresses to which it refers, and by which it proposes to also serve the documents, have recently been used by the respondent in other legal proceedings, and therefore would provide the requisite probability of informing the respondent of the creditor’s petition. I am satisfied that abnormal circumstances exist which warrant the making of a substituted service order. As contended by the applicant, the secure nature of the respondent’s property, particularly in relation to the intercom system, may mean that the respondent can screen visitors. Given that the applicant has attempted to serve the respondent at the Relevant Address on several occasions and has attempted to garner his attention by various means, all of which have been unsuccessful, I accept that substituted service is appropriate.