Saywell and Comcare (Freedom of information) [2025] ARTA 377 (16 April 2025)
Applicant/s: Scott Saywell
Respondent: Comcare
Tribunal Number: 2024/4736
Tribunal:Deputy President Britten-Jones
Place:Melbourne
Date:16 April 2025
Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
................[SGD]........................................................
Deputy President Britten-Jones
Catchwords
Freedom of Information – consideration of s 42 of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 – legal professional privilege - whether privilege fails due to an improper or illegal purpose - consideration of s 22 of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 – whether there is an obligation to provide an edited copy where all the material in the document is exempt or irrelevant matter - decision under review affirmed
Legislation
Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)
Cases
Commissioner of Taxation v PricewaterhouseCoopers [2022] FCA 278
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674
Hillier v Martin (No 19) [2024] FCA 210
Kline v Official Secretary to the Governor-General [2013] HCA 52; (2013) 249 CLR 645
Mann v Carnel (1999) 201 CLR 1
Russell v Jackson (1851) 9 Hare 387; 68 ER 558Southern Equities Corporation Ltd (in liq) v Arthur Anderson & Co (1997) 70 SASR 166
Secondary Materials
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, FOI Guidelines: Guidelines issued under s 93A of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)
Statement of Reasons
The Applicant has requested access to documents under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (the FOI Act). Access has been refused under s 42 of the FOI Act on the basis that the documents are protected by legal professional privilege. The request for access was made to Comcare on 12 April 2024 seeking any communication between Comcare and Ms Kate Watson (a lawyer from HBA Legal) relating to an email from the Applicant dated 22 February 2024 in Tribunal case number 2023/7232. The refusal decision was made by the Respondent on 13 May 2024.
Background
The background to this request is the Applicant’s claim for compensation brought against the Respondent in Tribunal case number 2023/7232. Kate Watson, a partner at HBA Legal, was acting for the Respondent, Comcare, in the compensation proceedings. During the compensation proceedings the Tribunal made directions on 20 February 2024 in relation to documents produced under summons that:[1]
[4] On or before 23 February 2024 the Respondent must give to the Tribunal and the Applicant a redacted copy of the documents that the Respondent objects to the Applicant inspecting.
[5] On or before 1 March 2024 the Applicant must advise the Tribunal and the Respondent whether he presses for access to those documents in full, and not in redacted form, and if so, provide written submissions in support of his position.
[6] On or before 8 March 2024 the Respondent must give to the Tribunal and the Applicant any written submissions in reply.
[1] Supplementary T-Documents, ST2.
Ms Watson, for and on behalf of the Respondent in the compensation proceedings, complied with the direction in [4] above on 21 February 2024.[2] The Applicant, in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Saywell and Comcare (Freedom of information) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] ARTA 377
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether Comcare had breached its obligations under section 22 of the FOI Act by not providing an edited copy of the documents and whether legal professional privilege applied to the email chains in question. Additionally, the court had to consider whether Comcare had waived the privilege claim and whether the documents contained any irrelevant matter.
The AAT found that Comcare had not breached its obligations under section 22 of the FOI Act. The tribunal held that the email chains were protected by legal professional privilege as they were communications between Comcare and their lawyer for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice and conducting litigation. The tribunal noted that the email chain was confidential and marked as such, indicating the privileged nature of the communication. The tribunal further found that there was no evidence of waiver of privilege and that the documents contained no irrelevant matter. Consequently, the tribunal affirmed the decision under review.
The tribunal's decision was that Comcare had not breached its obligations under the FOI Act, and the application for review was dismissed. The tribunal affirmed the original decision of Comcare not to provide an edited copy of the privileged documents.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Applicant does not deny the Respondent’s claim based on legal professional privilege but says that the Respondent has waived the right to claim privilege and further that the Respondent has not met its disclosure obligations under s 22(2)(b) of the FOI Act.CONSIDERATION OF THE PRIVILEGE CLAIM Documents 1 and 2 are email chains. The claim for privilege applies to all the emails in both chains except in so far as Document 2 contains irrelevant matter. The application of the principles of legal professional privilege in the context of email chains was considered in Commissioner of Taxation v PricewaterhouseCoopers:[10][175] The application of the principles of legal professional privilege in the context of email chains was discussed by Thawley J in Kenquist Nominees at [19]. Relevantly for present purposes, I consider that the principles apply to email chains in the following way (referring to the latest email in time as the “latest email”): (a) If the communication being the latest email was made for the dominant purpose of the giving or receiving of legal advice, then it may be that the email chain will be privileged because the earlier emails in the chain are to be regarded as copies of documents provided for the dominant purpose of the giving or receiving of legal advice. (b) For example, if the dominant purpose of the communication being the latest email was the giving of legal advice by a lawyer, then it may be that the email chain will be privileged because the earlier emails in the chain are to be regarded as copies of documents furnished by the lawyer with the advice being the latest email: see Kenquist Nominees at [19(2)]. (c) By way of further example, if the dominant purpose of the communication being the latest email was the obtaining of legal advice from a lawyer, then the email chain may be privileged because the earlier emails are to be regarded as copies of communications provided to the lawyer for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice: see Kenquist Nominees at [19(3)]. (d) The same principles can apply to earlier emails in the chain. For example, it may be that the latest email in the chain is not privileged, but the penultimate email (in time) may be a communication made for the dominant purpose of the giving or receiving of legal advice, and the earlier emails are to be regarded as copy documents which have been provided for the same dominant purpose.[10] [2022] FCA 278. Document 1 is an eight-page email chain in reverse chronological order. The most recent emails are between Comcare and Ms Watson dated 22 March 2024 in which advice is sought and is given in relation to the Applicant’s compensation claim in Tribunal case number 2023/7232. Included in the email chain are emails of an earlier date relevant to the legal advice being given. Subject to any issue of waiver, the whole of the email chain would be privileged from production in legal proceedings on the ground of legal professional privilege. The reason why the whole of the email chain is protected is because the earlier emails are attached to and form part of the communication on 22 March 2024 between Ms Watson, as the lawyer, and Comcare, as the client. That communication was confidential. The email was marked “Sensitive” and “Legal-Privilege”, and it was brought into existence for the purpose of obtaining legal advice and in the conduct of litigation.