Saunders v Queensland Insurance Company Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
45 CLR 557

THE QUEENSLAND INSURANCE COMPANY

RESPONDENT. LIMITED

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Insurance-Fire insurance-Proposal-Conditions-Questions not answered to be

deemed answered in negative-Question answered by agent-Answer correct to best of agent's knowledge-Incorrect in fact-Inquiry as to prior claim-Question not deemed answered in negative-Withholding information likely to affect MELBOURNE, acceptance of proposal-Misrepresentation or omission to state fact material to Oct. 12, 13. be known for estimating risk-Questions for jury-New trial.

The appellant effected an insurance of certain premises with the respondent company. The policy contained a provision that the insurance should be subject to the particulars in the proposal for insurance, which it was agreed should constitute the basis of the insurance and be incorporated in and form part of the policy. A condition of the policy was that any question asked in the proposal and not answered should be deemed to be answered in the negative. One of the questions asked by the proposal was whether the proponent had ever been a claimant on a fire insurance company or had property damaged or destroyed by fire. The proposal was filled in by an agent of the proponent who was also an agent for the respondent, and he answered this question: "Not to agent's knowledge"; and signed the proposal as agent for the proponent. The declaration made by the proponent's agent in the proposal also declared that the proponent had not "withheld any information likely to affect the acceptance of this proposal." Condition 1 of the policy provided that if there be any misrepresentation as to any fact material to be known for estimating the risk, or any omission to state such fact," the

45 CLR 558

company should not be liable. The insured having sued the company under the policy, the trial Judge held that the answer "not to agent's knowledge" was not an answer to the question asked, which must accordingly be taken to be answered in the negative he thereupon gave judgment for the company QUEENSLAND

and discharged the jury. On appeal to the High Court,

Held, that the answer "not to agent's knowledge" was not a failure to answer the question asked so as to imply a negative answer, and that the word "withheld" in the declaration meant " refrained from disclosing," and that it should be left to the jury to determine whether the proponent had 'withheld any information likely to affect the acceptance of the proposal: and whether there had been any misrepresentation or " omission" within condition 1 of the policy.

Decision of Supreme Court of Western Australia (Northmore J.) reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The appellant, Marguerita Saunders, brought an action in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, against the respondent, the Queensland Insurance Co. Ltd., claiming a declaration that a policy of insurance against loss or damage by fire which she had effected with the defendant was a valid and subsisting policy and that the defendant was liable to pay and make good to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saunders v Queensland Insurance Company Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1931] HCA 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Marguerita Saunders, sought to enforce a fire insurance policy issued by the respondent, Queensland Insurance Company Limited, after her insured building was destroyed by fire. The dispute arose because the insurance company denied liability, alleging breaches of the policy's conditions and warranties. The policy stipulated that the proposal for insurance formed the basis of the contract, and a condition stated that any unanswered question would be deemed answered in the negative. A key question in the proposal asked if the proponent had ever been a claimant on a fire insurance company or had property damaged by fire. The proposal was completed by an agent of both the appellant and the respondent, who answered this question as "Not to agent's knowledge." The proposal also contained a declaration that the proponent had not withheld any information likely to affect the acceptance of the proposal. The trial judge ruled that the answer was not a valid response, deeming the question unanswered and therefore answered in the negative, which was contrary to fact, thus relieving the company of liability.

The High Court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, whether the answer "Not to agent's knowledge" constituted a valid answer to the question posed in the proposal, or if it should be treated as an unanswered question to be deemed negative. Secondly, the court had to consider the meaning of "withheld" in the declaration, specifically whether it implied an active suppression of information or a mere omission. Thirdly, the court needed to ascertain whether the fact of a previous fire claim was "information likely to affect the acceptance of this proposal" and whether there had been any "misrepresentation as to any fact material to be known for estimating the risk, or any omission to state such fact" as per condition 1 of the policy.

The High Court held that the answer "Not to agent's knowledge" was a valid, albeit imperfect, answer to the question, and therefore the question was not to be taken as unanswered and deemed negative. The court reasoned that the statement qualified the answer by reference to the agent's knowledge, and the insurer, by accepting this answer without further inquiry, could not treat it as a negative response. Furthermore, the court found that the term "withheld" implied an active suppression of information, and whether the appellant had consciously refrained from disclosing the previous claim was a question of fact for the jury. The materiality of the undisclosed information and whether it was likely to affect the acceptance of the proposal were also matters of fact to be determined by a jury, as was the question of misrepresentation or omission under condition 1.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the judgment of the Supreme Court of Western Australia and ordering a new trial. The costs of the first trial were to be costs in the cause.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established