Saunders v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Saunders v Commissioner of Police [2020] QDC 90

PARTIES:

DANINE EVA SAUNDERS
(appellant)

v

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(respondent)

FILE NO:

D2/20

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against sentence

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Maroochydore
(Acting Magistrate Hillan)

DELIVERED ON:

22 May 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Maroochydore

HEARING DATE:

22 May 2020

JUDGE:

Cash QC DCJ

ORDERS:

1.     The appeal is allowed.

2.     The orders of the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore on 10 December 2019 are set aside.

3. The appellant is released under the supervision of an authorised corrective services officer for a period of 18 months. She must comply with the conditions set out in section 93 of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) and report to an authorised corrective services officer at Maroochydore before 4.00 pm on Wednesday 27 May 2020. A conviction is not recorded.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE – SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE – where applicant sentenced to six months’ imprisonment immediately suspended for 12 months, and ordered to pay $1,500 compensation for one count of assault occasioning bodily harm – where complainant suffered physical and psychological injury – where appellant co-operated, had absence of prior offending, general good character and offending was partly due to her psychological makeup – whether sentence excessive

Justices Act 1886 (Qld), s 222, s 225

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld), s 9, s 12

House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 488
R v Coutts [2008] QCA 380
R v Hilton [2009] QCA 12
R v Hite
(unreported, Toowoomba District Court, 11 February 2011)
R v Matauaina
[2011] QCA 344
R v Monro
[2002] QCA 483
R v Sanders [2007] QCA 165
Teelow v Commissioner of Police [2009] 2 Qd R 489

COUNSEL:

DL Crews for the appellant

SR Drinovac for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the appellant

The Commissioner of Police for the respondent

Introduction

  1. On 10 December 2019 the appellant appeared before an Acting Magistrate at Maroochydore. She pled guilty to a charge that, on 18 July 2019, she assaulted the complainant, Michelle Grayson, and did her bodily harm. The appellant was in her mid-twenties and had not previously offended. After hearing submissions the Acting Magistrate sentenced the appellant to imprisonment for six months, but immediately suspended the sentence for 12 months. He also ordered the appellant pay compensation in the amount of $1,500. On 7 January 2020 the appellant filed notice of her intention to appeal against the severity of the sentence.

  2. In my view the sentence imposed was excessive. The appeal will be allowed, the orders at first instance set aside and the appellant will be sentenced instead to probation for 18 months without a conviction being recorded. What follows are my reasons for reaching this conclusion.

    Circumstances of the offence and its effect on the complainant

  3. The facts of the offence were detailed in an agreed statement of facts tendered at the sentence hearing.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saunders v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QDC 90
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Saunders v Commissioner of Police, the appellant appealed against her sentence, arguing it was excessive. The appellant, who had no prior convictions, was convicted of assault occasioning bodily harm. She was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment, suspended for 12 months, and ordered to pay $1,500 in compensation. The complainant suffered physical and psychological injury, but the appellant cooperated with authorities, had a good character, and her offending was partly due to her psychological makeup.

The central legal issue was whether the sentence was manifestly excessive or inadequate, given the appellant's personal circumstances and the nature of the offence. The court applied the principles in House v The King, reviewing the evidence and the Magistrate’s reasoning to determine if the sentence was unreasonable or plainly unjust. The court also considered relevant matters under the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld), such as the risk to the community, the appellant's antecedents, character, and remorse, and the nature of the violence used.

The court found that the sentence was excessive. The appellant’s single punch, thrown in self-defence, did not show disregard for public safety, and her age, character, and psychological difficulties supported a lenient sentence. Although the complainant’s injuries were significant, they did not outweigh the other considerations. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the original sentencing orders were set aside.

The court ordered that the appellant be released under the supervision of an authorised corrective services officer for 18 months, without recording a conviction. The appellant must comply with the conditions set out in section 93 of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) and report to an authorised corrective services officer at Maroochydore before 4.00 pm on Wednesday, 27 May 2020.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The orders of the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore on 10 December 2019 are set aside.

3. The appellant is released under the supervision of an authorised corrective services officer for a period of 18 months. She must comply with the conditions set out in section 93 of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) and report to an authorised corrective services officer at Maroochydore before 4.00 pm on Wednesday 27 May 2020. A conviction is not recorded.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant was 26 years old when she committed the offence and 27 years old when she was sentenced. As noted above, she had no previous convictions. The appellant had been seeing a psychologist for counselling since September 2018. The counselling was aimed at addressing symptoms of anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder apparently originating in physical and sexual abuse suffered by the appellant as a child. The psychologist appeared to link the assault to the appellant’s psychological state, suggesting that the appellant’s “fight or flight” instinct was activated in the circumstances. Others wrote of the appellant’s voluntary work in the Rural Fire Service. She was described as hard working and trustworthy and usually not violent. The material was such that the offence should rightly be regarded as out of character for the appellant. The sentence hearing and decision of the Magistrate The prosecutor submitted that a sentence of between nine and 12 months’ imprisonment was appropriate and also asked for compensation on behalf of the complainant. On the appellant’s behalf it was emphasised that she saw the complainant intervene in a fight and threw a single punch when she felt threatened. The appellant relied upon the agreed position that the appellant was acting in defence but used more force than was necessary in the circumstances. It was submitted the appellant’s culpability was further reduced by her personal situation, with her psychological makeup being such that she was more prone to an instinctive reaction than other people might be. The appellant was remorseful, had made admissions and pled guilty early. Her solicitor said:“Aside from this offence, she is a caring person … who contributes to the community by volunteering as a firefighter. She is a dog foster carer and is currently providing full-time care for her family. This is out of character, as evident in the fact that she hasn’t been before court before and the factual basis of the plea.” It was submitted that a community based order was appropriate and that a conviction should not be recorded as it would prevent her volunteering in the Rural Fire Service and may have other negative impacts upon the appellant. The Acting Magistrate summarised the facts and submissions of the parties. His Honour considered the offending serious because of the extent of injury caused and the impact upon the complainant. Comparison was made to a sentence imposed by a Judge in the District Court at Toowoomba in 2011 and on that basis made the orders for suspended imprisonment and compensation.Relevant legal principles governing the appeal The appellant appeals pursuant to section 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld). Because the appellant pled guilty, the sole ground of appeal permitted by the legislation is that the “punishment was excessive”. Pursuant to section 223 of that Act, the appeal is by way of rehearing on the evidence given in the proceedings before the Acting Magistrate (and any further evidence that might be admitted with leave). I am required to conduct a real review of both the evidence before the Magistrate, and the Magistrate’s reasons for imposing the sentence, to determine whether there has been error. As this is an appeal against the exercise of the sentencing discretion, it must be determined in accordance with the well-known principles in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499.[2] If I find that the sentence imposed was “unreasonable or plainly unjust”, or if the Magistrate acted upon a wrong principle, took into account irrelevant matters, failed to take into account relevant matters, or mistook the facts, then I can exercise the sentencing discretion afresh.[2] Teelow v Commissioner of Police [2009] 2 Qd R 489.Consideration

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appellant appeals pursuant to section 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld). Because the appellant pled guilty, the sole ground of appeal permitted by the legislation is that the “punishment was excessive”. Pursuant to section 223 of that Act, the appeal is by way of rehearing on the evidence given in the proceedings before the Acting Magistrate (and any further evidence that might be admitted with leave). I am required to conduct a real review of both the evidence before the Magistrate, and the Magistrate’s reasons for imposing the sentence, to determine whether there has been error. As this is an appeal against the exercise of the sentencing discretion, it must be determined in accordance with the well-known principles in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499.[2] If I find that the sentence imposed was “unreasonable or plainly unjust”, or if the Magistrate acted upon a wrong principle, took into account irrelevant matters, failed to take into account relevant matters, or mistook the facts, then I can exercise the sentencing discretion afresh.[2] Teelow v Commissioner of Police [2009] 2 Qd R 489.Consideration In support of the complaint that the punishment was excessive the appellant submits the Acting Magistrate made a number of discrete errors. I find it unnecessary to consider these complainants because I am satisfied, having regard to comparable decisions and applying the relevant provisions of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) (“PSA”), that the sentence was excessive. Because the appellant had been convicted of an offence that involved the use of violence (and that resulted in physical harm to another person), the principle that a sentence of imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort did not apply. Instead the primary considerations for the sentencing court were those found in section 9(3) of the PSA:“(a) the risk of physical harm to any members of the community if a custodial sentence were not imposed;(b) the need to protect any members of the community from that risk;(c) the personal circumstances of any victim of the offence;(d) the circumstances of the offence, including the death of or any injury to a member of the public or any loss or damage resulting from the offence;(e) the nature or extent of the violence used, or intended to be used, in the commission of the offence;(f) any disregard by the offender for the interests of public safety;(g) the past record of the offender, including any attempted rehabilitation and the number of previous offences of any type committed;(h) the antecedents, age and character of the offender;(i) any remorse or lack of remorse of the offender;(j) any medical, psychiatric, prison or other relevant report in relation to the offender;(k) anything else about the safety of members of the community that the sentencing court considers relevant.” A consideration of these matters serves to identify the present matter as one not requiring a sentence of imprisonment. There is little to no risk or physical harm to members of the community in the absence of a custodial sentence, and consequently no need to impose a sentence that protects against this risk. The violence used was a single punch thrown in response to a perceived need to act defensively. In circumstances where the appellant intervened defensively in a fight that was already occurring, she did not show disregard for the interests of public safety. Her age, antecedents, character and remorse all provided support for a sentence that was lenient, as did the appellant’s psychological difficulties. The personal circumstances of the victim and the injury she suffered were relevant, but could not overwhelm the other considerations.