Sargent v Goebbels

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

 Sargent v Goebbels [2024] QDC 138

PARTIES:

CAMERON JAMES SARGENT (DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND SCIENCE)

(appellant)

v
PAUL JOHN GOEBBELS

(respondent)

and

CAMERON JAMES SARGENT (DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND SCIENCE)

(appellant)

v

GOEBBELS MACHINERY PTY LTD

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

D1/23; D2/23

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeals pursuant to s 222 of the Justices Act 1886

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Dalby

DELIVERED ON:

30 August 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Toowoomba District Court

HEARING DATE:

20 July 2023

JUDGES:

Horneman-Wren SC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The appeals are dismissed.

2.   The parties are directed to file written submissions on costs within 14 days.

CATCHWORDS:

CIVIL LAW – APPEAL – JUSTICES ACT 1886 – SECTION 222 – ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ACT 1994 – ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION REGULATIONS 2019 – STATUTORY INTERPRETATION - appeal against a decision of a magistrate – where the respondents was charged with offences under the Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld) – where at trial the magistrate found the respondents not guilty of the offences – whether the appellant misconstrued the meaning of waste under the Act – whether the appellant misapplied the provisions of s 62(2)(h) of schedule 2 of the Environmental Protection Regulation – whether the magistrate made findings of fact contrary to the evidence – whether the magistrate had regard to irrelevant considerations

LEGISLATION:

Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld) ss 10, 11, 13, 18, 19, 62, 363A, 363E, 426, 493(1), 493(2)
Environmental Protection Regulation 2019 (Qld) s 19(1), Sch 2 s 62
Justices Act 1886 (Qld) s 222

CASES:

Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172
Brunskill v Sovereign Marine & General Insurance Co Pty Ltd [1985] 59 ALJR 841
CDJ v VAJ (1998) 197 CLR 172
Chambers v Jopling [1986] 7 NSWLR 1
City of Fremantle v Chief Executive Officer of Department of Environment and Conservation [2013] WASAT 24
Coal & Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2000) 203 CLR 194
Environment Protection Authority v Terrace Earthmoving Pty Ltd and Page [2012] NSWLEC 216
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
Stevenson v Yass [2006] 2 Qd R 150

COUNSEL:

B J Power KC and K W Wylie for the appellant
A N S Skoien for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legal Unit of the Department of Environment and Science for the appellant
Carvosso & Winship Lawyers for the respondents

Introduction

  1. Proceedings were brought against each of Goebbels Machinery Pty Ltd (“the Company”) and Paul John Goebbels for offences alleged to have been committed by them against the Environment Protection Act 1994. 

  2. The company was charged with three offences: one of having carried out an environmentally relevant activity (ERA), namely Resource Recovery and Transfer facility operation, without holding, or acting under, an environmental authority for the activity, contrary s 426(1) of the Act; and two of failing to comply with a directions notice contrary to s 363E of the Act. Each of the direction’s notices related to the company carrying out the activity without an authority.

  3. Mr Goebbels was charged with three offences…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sargent v Goebbels and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QDC 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sargent v Goebbels, the appellant sought to appeal a decision of a magistrate who acquitted the respondents of offences under the Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld). The appeal focused on whether the magistrate misconstrued the meaning of waste under the Act and whether the statutory provisions of s 62(2)(h) of schedule 2 of the Environmental Protection Regulation were misapplied. Additionally, the appeal questioned whether the magistrate's findings of fact were contrary to the evidence and whether irrelevant considerations were taken into account.

The legal issues at the heart of this appeal were the interpretation of statutory provisions concerning waste and the validity of the magistrate's findings of fact. The appellant argued that the magistrate's conclusion that the respondents were not operating an Environmental Recovery Activity (ERA) was contrary to compelling evidence, particularly photographic and video evidence of waste on the site. The court had to determine whether these findings were indeed contrary to the evidence or whether they were reasonably open on the evidence presented.

The court found that the magistrate's findings of fact, which were not seriously challenged, were consistent with the evidence presented. The photographic and video evidence, while suggestive of waste, did not compel the conclusion that an ERA was being conducted. The court held that the magistrate's conclusion was not "glaringly improbable" or "contrary to compelling inferences," as the evidence supported the magistrate's findings that the respondents' business involved buying, selling, and repairing farming machinery, with any waste being managed in accordance with the business operations.

The appeals were dismissed, and the parties were directed to file written submissions on costs within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeals are dismissed.

2. The parties are directed to file written submissions on costs within 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The second ground of appeal fails.The third error – making findings of fact contrary to evidence This third ground of appeal challenges the learned Magistrate’s finding that the complainant had not proven beyond reasonable doubt that an ERA was being carried out on the site. That is, it challenges the learned Magistrate’s ultimate finding. As already referred to, the findings of fact set out above, made by the Magistrate are not themselves challenged. That is a relevant and an important consideration. The appellant submission at paragraph 48 of his written submissions is:“Having regard to that evidence, and in particular the nature and quantum of material observed on the site, it is submitted the Court would be satisfied that the trial Magistrate’s finding that the complainant had not proved the appropriate standard that an ERA was being carried out on the site was either ‘glaring improbable’ or ‘contrary to compelling inferences’, and that on the facts as found only conclusion open was that an ERA was being carried out as alleged by DES.” The appellant does not identify which of the facts found by the Magistrate compelled a conclusion that an ERA was being carried out. In my view, none of the unchallenged, found facts set out above, alone or in any combination, compels such a conclusion to the exclusion of any other. In my view, I could not conclude that they do. To the contrary, I would conclude, as the Magistrate did, that an acceptance of those facts does not prove that the company was operating a facility for receiving and sorting, dismantling or baling waste (or for receiving and temporarily storing waste before it is moved to a waste facility). The appellant’s submission that the Magistrate finding that the complainant had not proved beyond reasonable doubt that an ERA was being carried out was “glaring improbable” or “contrary to compelling inferences” is based on aerial photographs, still images taken at the site and bodyworn camera footage taken on a walk-through of the site. Those expressions are taken from the plurality reasons in Fox v Percy.[20] [20][2003] 214 CLR 118. In essence, the appellant’s submission is that one need look only at those photographs and video footage to be satisfied that much of what is depicted is waste and that the company thus carried on the ERA on site. The photographic and video evidence does not stand alone. It must be considered in the context of all the evidence in the case. That evidence includes Exhibits 12 and 13, the content of which has already been analysed, and Mr Goebbels’ evidence including about items which can be seen in the photographs and footage. The Magistrate’s unchallenged findings of fact are consistent with the body of evidence. When the photographs and video recording are considered in that context, the learned Magistrate’s ultimate conclusion is not glaringly improbable. It is, in my view, more probable than not; particularly where the case was being conducted on a broad brush, unparticularised basis and an explanation of the presence of the items on site had been given by Mr Goebbels in the context of the business conducted by the company. In her detailed reasons the learned Magistrate set out at length Mr Goebbels’ evidence concerning various items depicted in the exhibits. It was uncontradicted evidence which the Magistrate expressly accepted and reflected in her findings of fact.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

ERA 62 in Sch 2 provided:“62 Resource recovery and transfer facility operation (1)Resource recovery and transfer facility operation (the relevant activity) consists of operating a facility for— (a) receiving and sorting, dismantling or baling waste; or (b) receiving and temporarily storing waste before it is moved to a waste facility. (2) The relevant activity does not include— … (h) sorting or storing— (i)a total quantity of no more than 6t or 6m3 of general waste at any one time; orThe Magistrate’s decision Having set out in detail the evidence adduced on the trial by both the complainant and the defendants, the learned Magistrate set out the following findings of fact:“Goebbels operated a business which buys and sells farming machinery and equipment, components and parts or [sic] such machinery and equipment. It also repairs farming machinery. The business is operated from three lots owned by Mr Goebbels. The site is not aesthetically pleasing. There is more than six cubic metres of material on site. The business has operated in excess of 40 years. Most of the machinery is bought and sold second-hand. Some of the items brought onto site are rusty; rusty items are not necessarily of no further use. The business also buys and sells new parts. Items bought by the business are bought for the purpose of resale as machinery or parts of machinery used in the agricultural industry.The majority of items purchased are purchased from farm clearing sales; some of the items are purchased new from other suppliers. Items of machinery are dismantled after purchase for transport to the site and often remain dismantled when stored on site until either sold as whole or parts are taken from machines and used to repair other machinery or are sold as part. Any items not used will ultimately be put into scrap metal bins or wheelie bins and disposed of. The machines and other items may stay on site for considerable periods of time before they are either used, purchased or scrapped. Occasionally, items may be purchased at the clearing – at a clearing sale and when received on site are scrapped because they are determined to be of no use.” Those findings of fact are not really challenged on the appeal.Nor is her Honour’s recitation of the evidence on which they were found. On the basis of those factual findings, the learned Magistrate turned to consider what she described as “the threshold issue of whether Goebbels Machinery received materials on site which is waste in accordance with the legislation and if so, whether [indistinct] cubic metres of that waste is shared or sorted on site.[1][1]The Magistrate’s decision was delivered orally. The only written record of the decision is the transcript of her Honour’s oral reasons. There are passages of the transcript which were in indistinct to the transcriber. In this passage, the indistinct words must have been to the effect of “more than six” as that was the statutory provision to which her Honour was referring.