Sarah Nickolls v Noakes Rigging Pty LtdPeter Bush v Noakes Rigging Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read
CITATION: Sarah Nickolls v Noakes Rigging Pty LtdPeter Bush v Noakes Rigging Pty Ltd [2008] NSWDC 299
HEARING DATE(S): 20, 21, 22 August, and 13 October 2008
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

23 December 2008
JURISDICTION: District Court - Civil
JUDGMENT OF: Levy SC DCJ
DECISION: 1. Verdict for the Defendant in each case.
2. Plaintiff to pay the Defendant’s costs in each case.
CATCHWORDS: BAILMENT – duty of bailee for reward – yachts propped up on dry stands in boatyard – yachts blown over and damaged during storm involving gale force southerly winds – whether Defendant bailee discharged onus of establishing damage was not due to negligence on its part – DAMAGES – whether marine survey fees incurred by an insurer claimable as damages
CASES CITED: Glebe Island Terminals Pty Ltd v Continental Seagram Pty Ltd (1993) 40 NSWLR 206
Califf v Danvers (1792) Peake 155; 170 ER 112
Jacap Low Loaders v Lindores Plant and Equipment [2004] NSWCA 5
Simpson v Thomson [1877] 3 App Cas 279
Florida Hotels Pty Ltd v Mayo & Anor (1969) 113 CLR 588
Redken Laboratories (Aust) Pty Ltd v Docker & Anor [2000] NSWCA 100
Fox v Percy [2003] 214 CLR 118
PARTIES: Sarah Nickolls (Plaintiff)
Noakes Rigging Pty Ltd (Defendant)
Peter Bush (Plaintiff)
Noakes Rigging Pty Ltd (Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): 0702 of 2006; 2269 of 2006
COUNSEL: Mr JG Stewart (Plaintiffs)
Mr MG McHugh (Defendant)
SOLICITORS: McCulloch & Buggy (Plaintiffs)
Piper Alderman (Defendant)

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. These two cases were heard together. They involve subrogated claims for liquidated damages brought by one insurer against another in respect of damage sustained to two yachts that were owned by the respective Plaintiffs. These yachts were resting on hard stands within the Defendant’s boatyard when they were blown over during a storm involving gale force southerly winds in the early hours of 23 March 2005.

Issues for determination

2. The following issues arise for determination:

(a) Was the legal relationship between the parties in respect of the yachts that of bailment for reward and if so what was the content of the duty of care owed by the Defendant bailee?

(b) Was the damage to the yachts belonging to the Plaintiffs caused by a want of exercise of reasonable skill and care or negligence on the part of the Defendant bailee?

(c) In the event that the Plaintiffs are entitled to damages, are the marine survey fees incurred by the Plaintiff’s insurer properly characterised as forming part of the Plaintiff’s damages?

Summary of findings

3. I find that the relationship between the parties was that of bailor and bailee. I find that the bailment was for reward. I find that the Defendant has proven that it had discharged its duty to take reasonable care of the yachts left in its custody. I find that the damage occasioned to the yachts occurred due to the operation of unpredictable natural forces and was not due to or materially contributed to by any act, neglect or default on the part…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sarah Nickolls v Noakes Rigging Pty LtdPeter Bush v Noakes R... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWDC 299
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceedings involved two plaintiffs, Sarah Nickolls and Peter Bush, who were each the owners of a yacht that was stored at the defendant’s boatyard, Noakes Rigging Pty Ltd. The dispute arose from the damage sustained by their yachts during a storm involving gale force southerly winds, which caused the yachts to be blown over. The plaintiffs sought damages for the negligence of the defendant in the storage and maintenance of the yachts. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The primary legal issues were whether the defendant had discharged the onus of proving that the damage to the yachts was not due to its negligence and whether the marine survey fees incurred by an insurer as part of a claim for damages were claimable. The court had to consider the duty of care owed by the defendant as a bailee for reward and assess the evidence provided regarding the circumstances of the storm and the adequacy of the precautions taken by the defendant.

The court held that the defendant had successfully demonstrated that the damage to the yachts was not due to any negligence on its part but was instead a result of the extraordinary weather event. The evidence showed that the defendant had taken reasonable steps to secure the yachts, including the use of proper mooring techniques and the implementation of storm preparations. The court further found that the marine survey fees were not claimable as damages, as they were not a direct result of the loss but rather a part of the process of assessing the damage. The court concluded that the plaintiffs had not proven their cases, and the verdict was in favour of the defendant.

The orders of the court were that there would be a verdict for the defendant in each case, and the plaintiffs were to pay the defendant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Verdict for the Defendant in each case. 2. Plaintiff to pay the Defendant's costs in each case.