Sara Davies v The Trustee for the Bella Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
[2023] FWC 2438

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.365—General protections

Sara Davies
v

The Trustee For The Bella Trust

(C2023/3265)

Oliviah Hancock
v

The Trustee For The Bella Trust

(C2023/3275)

COMMISSIONER LIM

PERTH, 23 OCTOBER 2023

Application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal

  1. Ms Sara Davies and Ms Oliviah Hancock have both applied pursuant to s 365 of the Fair Work Act (Cth) (Act), alleging that The Trustee for the Bella Trust (the Respondent) contravened Part 3-1 of the Act by dismissing them from their employment (Applications).

  1. The Respondent has raised a jurisdictional objection alleging that Ms Davies and Ms Hancock were not dismissed; they resigned from their employment.

  1. It is uncontroversial that for the matter to proceed, Ms Davies and Ms Hancock need to have been dismissed. In Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd v Milford[1] (Coles v Milford), the Full Court of the Federal Court held that where a respondent submits that the applicant to a section 365 application was not dismissed, as is the case here, the FWC must determine that issue before exercising its powers under s 368 of the Act.[2]

  1. Ms Davies is Ms Hancock’s mother. Both Ms Davies and Ms Hancock were employed by the Respondent, and the Applications arise from the same series of events. Accordingly, in the interests of efficiency, both matters were listed and heard together. However, each application must be determined on its own merits.

  1. The matter was allocated to my Chambers and a mention was held on 1 August 2023. Directions were issued to the parties for the filing of material in relation to the jurisdictional objection.

  1. A determinative conference was conducted via MS Teams on 26 September 2023. At the hearing, Ms Davies and Ms Hancock represented themselves. The Respondent was represented by Ms Marie-Lize be Bruyn, who is a part-owner and manager of the Respondent. 

  1. Having considered the evidence and submissions of the parties, I am satisfied that both Ms Davies and Ms Hancock were dismissed.

  1. My detailed reasons for my decision follow.

Observations on the evidence

  1. I found Ms Davies, Ms Hancock and Ms De Bruyn to all be generally honest and genuine people. It was clear that for most of the employment relationship, Ms Davies and Ms de Bruyn held each other in high regard, and I appreciated the courtesy that all parties extended to each other during the determinative conference.

  1. There were few significant factual disputes between the parties. To the extent where there were disputes on facts, I found they were more to do with different matters of interpretation of events based upon each witness’s understanding of the situation.

  1. Where witnesses expressed opinions on matters that are for the Commission to decide, I have treated such ‘evidence’ as submissions.

What are the events that led to the Applications?

  1. The Respondent operates a boutique guesthouse in Geraldton, Western Australia that offers short and long-stay accommodation. The Company has three directors: Mr Jacobus de Bruyn (Ms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sara Davies v The Trustee for the Bella Trust and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FWC 2438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sara Davies v The Trustee for the Bella Trust involves two applicants, Sara Davies and Oliviah Hancock, who claim they were dismissed by the Respondent, The Trustee for the Bella Trust. The applicants have applied to the Fair Work Commission under section 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009, alleging that the dismissal contravened Part 3-1 of the Act. The Respondent has raised a jurisdictional objection, asserting that the applicants were not dismissed but resigned voluntarily. The central issue the Commission had to resolve was whether the applicants were indeed dismissed by the Respondent. In examining the evidence, the Commissioner found that Sara Davies and Oliviah Hancock were both dismissed by the Respondent. Sara Davies was deemed to have been forced to resign due to the conduct of the Respondent, specifically an email from Marie-Lize de Bruyn that instructed her not to continue working until a wage dispute was resolved. This email, coupled with the removal of Ms. Davies from a workplace communication group, led to the conclusion that her resignation was not voluntary. Similarly, Oliviah Hancock was found to have been dismissed because the Respondent issued her a separation certificate without her consent or communication of resignation. The Commissioner's decision was based on the evidence that neither applicant had voluntarily resigned, and the actions of the Respondent amounted to a termination of their employment relationship. The Commission found both applications to be within its jurisdiction, and the matters were listed for further conference under section 368 of the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.