SAPPHIRE DEVELOPMENTS ALLIANCE PTY LTD and CITY OF NEDLANDS

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   SAPPHIRE DEVELOPMENTS ALLIANCE PTY LTD and CITY OF NEDLANDS [2020] WASAT 149

MEMBER:   JUDGE D R PARRY, DEPUTY PRESIDENT

HEARD:   9 AND 10 NOVEMBER 2020

DELIVERED          :   1 DECEMBER 2020

FILE NO/S:   DR 142 of 2020

BETWEEN:   SAPPHIRE DEVELOPMENTS ALLIANCE PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

CITY OF NEDLANDS

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Grouped dwellings - Varied and eclectic streetscape - Locality in transition following recent up-coding from R10 to R40 - Whether proposed development satisfies relevant deemed-to-comply provision of R-Codes Volume 1 in relation to setback of garages - Whether proposed development demonstrates compliance with design principles and satisfies objectives of R-Codes Volume 1 in relation to street setback, open space, setback of garages and outdoor living areas - Streetscape - Whether proposed development is compatible with its setting - Whether proposed development would have unacceptable impact on residential amenity of adjoining properties in terms of location of bin store, loss of privacy, overshadowing and bulk and scale

Legislation:

City of Nedlands Local Planning Scheme No. 3, cl 7(1)(a), cl 9(a), cl 9, cl 16(2), cl 17, cl 18(2), cl 25(1), cl 32.4(1), cl 32.4(3)
City of Nedlands Town Planning Scheme No. 2
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2 (deemed provisions), cl 1, cl 67
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 17(1), s 27(1), s 27(2), s 31(1), s 31(3)
State Planning Policy 7.3 ­ Residential Design Codes Volume 1, cl 1.3.1, cl 1.4, cl 1.5, cl 2.1, cl 2.4, cl 2.5, cl 2.5.1, cl 2.5.4, cl 5.1, cl 5.1.2, cl 5.1.4, cl 5.2, cl 5.2.1, cl 5.3, cl 5.3.1, cl 5.4.2

Result:

Application for review allowed

Development approval granted for nine grouped dwellings at Nos. 130 and 132 (Lots 234 and 235) Waratah Avenue, Dalkeith subject to conditions

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

The applicant sought review by the Tribunal of the decision of the respondent to refuse to grant development approval for a grouped dwelling development comprising nine units at Nos. 130 and 132 Waratah Avenue, Dalkeith.  The streetscape in the immediate locality of the site is relatively varied and eclectic and the immediate locality is undergoing transition in built form and character in consequence of the up-coding of the area from R10 to R40 and, on two corner properties, to R60.

The Tribunal determined that, insofar as the proposed development does not satisfy relevant deemed-to-comply requirements of the R-Codes Volume 1, it demonstrates compliance with the corresponding design principles and satisfies relevant objectives of the R-Codes Volume 1 in relation to street setback, open space, setback of garages (if the garage of Unit 8 is relocated by 1 metre to the west) and outdoor living areas.  The Tribunal also determined that the proposed development is compatible with its setting and, if modified in accordance with conditions discussed in the Tribunal's reasons, would have…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SAPPHIRE DEVELOPMENTS ALLIANCE PTY LTD and CITY OF NEDLANDS and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASAT 149
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sapphire Developments Alliance Pty Ltd and City of Nedlands, the dispute centred around a development application concerning a proposed development of grouped dwellings in an area undergoing transition, following a recent up-coding from R10 to R40. The City of Nedlands raised objections to the proposal, questioning whether it complied with the relevant provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1, particularly regarding setbacks, open spaces, garages, and outdoor living areas, as well as its compatibility with the existing streetscape. The primary legal issues for the court to determine were whether the proposed development adhered to the deemed-to-comply provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1 in relation to street setbacks, open space, setback of garages, and outdoor living areas, and whether it was compatible with its setting and would have an unacceptable impact on the residential amenity of adjoining properties.

The court examined the relevant provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1, particularly clause 2.5.1, which mandates the exercise of judgment by the decision-maker in assessing proposals, considering objectives and design principles. The court noted that there was common ground that the proposed development met most deemed-to-comply requirements, except for certain provisions related to street setback, open space, setback of garages, and outdoor living areas. The City of Nedlands argued that the proposed development did not meet the deemed-to-comply requirement for setback of garages, while the applicant contended otherwise. The court held that the Tribunal was required to exercise judgment to determine the proposal, having regard to objectives and balancing these with the design principles provided in the R-Codes Volume 1.

After reviewing the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, the court concluded that the proposed development did not satisfy the relevant deemed-to-comply requirements in the R-Codes Volume 1, particularly in relation to street setback, open space, setback of garages, and outdoor living areas. The court also found that the proposed development was not compatible with its setting and would have an unacceptable impact on the residential amenity of adjoining properties, particularly in terms of the location of the bin store, loss of privacy, overshadowing, and bulk and scale. The court further held that the decision to refuse the development application was not unreasonable and was, therefore, upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Clause 2.5 of the R-Codes Volume 1, which is entitled 'Exercise of judgement', states, in part, as follows:[21][21] Original emphasis.2.5.1Subject to clauses 2.5.2 and 2.5.3, the decision-maker is to exercise its judgement to consider the merits of proposals having regard to objectives and balancing these with the consideration of design principles provided in the R-Codes Volume 1.The decision-maker, in its assessment of a proposal that addresses the design principle(s), should not apply the corresponding deemed-to-comply provision(s).2.5.2In making a determination on the suitability of a proposal, the decision­maker shall exercise its judgement, having regard to the following:(a)any relevant purpose, objectives and provisions of the scheme;(b)any relevant objectives and provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1;(c)a provision of a local planning policy adopted by the decision­maker consistent with and pursuant to the R-Codes Volume 1; and(d)orderly and proper planning.…2.5.4The decision-maker shall not refuse to grant approval to an application where the application satisfies the deemed-to-comply provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1 and the relevant provisions of the scheme and any relevant local planning policy.… It is common ground between the parties that the proposed development satisfies all relevant deemed-to-comply requirements in the R-Codes Volume 1, other than under cl 5.1.2 Street setback, cl 5.1.4 Open space and cl 5.3.1 Outdoor living areas. The City also contends ­ and the applicant disputes ­ that the proposed development does not satisfy the relevant deemed-to-comply requirement in cl 5.2.1 Setback of garages and carports. Thus, it is common ground that the Tribunal 'is required to exercise judgement to determine the proposal',[22] 'having regard to objectives and balancing these with the consideration of design principles provided in the R-Codes Volume 1',[23] namely the objectives in cl 5.1 Context and the design principles in cl 5.1.2 Street setback and in cl 5.1.4 Open space, and the objectives in cl 5.3 Site planning and design and the design principles in cl 5.3.1 Outdoor living areas. In addition, the City contends that the proposed development requires '[j]udgement of merit' having regard to the objectives in cl 5.2 Streetscape and the design principles in cl 5.2.1 Setback of garages and carports in the R-Codes Volume 1, whereas the applicant contends that the proposed development satisfies the relevant deemed-to-comply requirement in cl 5.2.1 C1.3 of the R-Codes Volume 1 and, consequently, does not require '[j]udgement of merit' under cl 5.2.1.[24] I will set out the provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1 in question when discussing the relevant issue (issues 1 to 4) pertaining to the provision below.[22] R-Codes Volume 1 cl 2.4.[23] R-Codes Volume 1 cl 2.5.1 (original emphasis).[24] The City contends that cl 5.2.1 C1.3 is not the relevant deemed-to-comply requirement, but rather the relevant deemed-to-comply requirement is cl 5.2.1 C1.4, which, the City submits, the proposed development does not satisfy. This is addressed under issue 3 below.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established