Santisteban v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Santisteban v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2025] NSWPIC 14
CLAIMANT: Javier Santisteban
INSURER: Allianz
MEMBER: Gary Victor Patterson
DATE OF DECISION: 6 January 2025
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; Sections 3.11(1) and 3.28(1) miscellaneous claims assessment; where the accident caused wholly by the fault of the claimant; where claimant’s motor scooter and insured motorcycle came into contact as they travelled abreast in the same lane; differing versions of what occurred causing the vehicles to come into contact; claimant lost control of his motor scooter and crashed onto the surface of the motorway; circumstances of loss of control disputed; claimant sustained various injury and was transported by ambulance to hospital; insured rider may have obtained details of only independent witness; no statement obtained from that witness; claimant and insured rider each maintain that the other was wholly at fault; insurer concedes that it bears the onus of proving that the claimant was wholly at fault; insurer failed to discharge that onus; assessment on the papers; Held – sections 3.11(1) and 3.28(1) are concerned with causation of the accident that involve fault; the accident was not caused wholly by the fault of the claimant.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

CERTIFICATE FOR MISCELLANEOUS CLAIM

Issued under Division 7.6 Subdivision of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017

1. For the purposes of s 3.11 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, the motor accident on 23 August 203 was not caused wholly by the fault of the claimant.

2. For the purpoes of s 3.28 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, the motor accident was not caused wholly by the fault of the claimant.

3.     The insurer is to pay the claimant’s regulated costs.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. This determination relates to whether the motor accident was caused wholly by the fault of Javier Santisteban (the claimant).

  2. This miscellaneous claim dispute has been referred for assessment under Part 7, Division 7.6, Subdivision 3 and Schedule 2, cl 3(e) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the Act).

ON THE PAPERS

  1. Section 52(3) of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (the PIC Act) provides:

    “(3)    if the Commission is satisfied that sufficient information has been supplied to it in connection with the proceedings, the Commission may exercise functions under this Act and enabling legislation without holding any conference or formal hearing.”

  2. Having regard to procedural direction PIC 2, the documents that are before me, including the parties’ submissions that the dispute can be determined on the basis of those documents, I am satisfied that I had sufficient information to proceed on the papers, without holding any conference or formal hearing, and that this is the appropriate course in the circumstances.

BACKGROUND

  1. The claimant is a 59-year-old male who was working on a full-time basis as a Data Engineer at the time of the accident.

  2. On 23 August 2023, the claimant was riding his registered Piaggio Beverley 350 motor scooter from his home to his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Santisteban v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPIC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Santisteban v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the plaintiff sought to recover damages for injuries sustained in a motor accident. The parties disputed the circumstances leading to the accident, with the plaintiff alleging that the defendant's motorcycle collided with his motor scooter, while the defendant claimed that the plaintiff lost control of his scooter. The case was adjudicated in the court where the plaintiff's claim for damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 was assessed.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff was wholly at fault for the accident, which would preclude him from recovering damages under sections 3.11(1) and 3.28(1) of the Act. The court had to determine the credibility of the conflicting versions of events provided by the plaintiff and the defendant, and whether the insurer had met its burden of proving the plaintiff's fault on the balance of probabilities.

The court examined the evidence presented by both parties, including statements from witnesses and medical records. The plaintiff's accounts to his treating doctors and the police varied slightly, which the insurer argued indicated a lack of reliability. However, the court found that the insurer had not successfully discharged the onus of proving that the plaintiff was wholly at fault. The objective evidence, such as the lack of damage to the defendant's motorcycle and the absence of an independent witness statement, did not conclusively support the defendant's version of events. Therefore, the court held that the accident was not caused wholly by the plaintiff's fault.

Consequently, the court ruled in favour of the plaintiff, finding that the insurer had not proven that the plaintiff was wholly at fault for the accident. The court's decision allowed the plaintiff's claim for damages to proceed, as the statutory provisions did not apply to bar his recovery.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In relation to the Post-Accident Treating Evidence, the insurer notes as follows:(a) In an ambulance report dated 23 August 2023, the following was noted (A5):“Driving to work on motorway on a Bespa/scooter. Not sure exactly what happened, but had some part of scooter clipped by another vehicle which caused him to wobble to the edge of the road where wet leaves caused the scooter to slip out from under him. Things was going about 10 to 20 kilometres per hour. Landed hard on rider’s [sic] side (emphasis added).”(b) In a Certificate of Capacity dated 29 August 2023 (R4), it was noted that:“Passing motorbike coming from behind accidentally came within 30 centimetres of patient bike and caused loss of bike control.”(c) Consultation notes recorded by Dr Avni Garg, GP, on 2 November 2023 noted (R5):“Javier was involved in a MVA on 23 August, where his scooter was clipped by a bike and slipped out from under him.”(d) Consultation notes recorded by Dr Peter Lam, orthopaedic foot and ankle surgeon, on 30 April 2024 (R6) recorded:“In August 2023, Javier was involved in an accident where… he lost control of his scooter and fell on his right side.”The insurer submits it is therefore apparent that the claimant has provided different versions of events to his treatment providers. The insurer then summarises the Insured’s Versions of Events and the Police’s Version of Events which previously have been summarised. Under the heading Damage to the Claimant and Insured’s vehicle, the insurer notes that the insured rider said there was no damage to his motorcycle which, it is submitted, is consistent with the insured’s version of events, rather than the claimant’s, as damage to the mirror would have been expected if the claimant’s version was correct. The insurer notes the extensive damage to the claimant’s scooter and submits there is no objective evidence that the claimant’s handle bar collided with the insured’s mirror/left handle bar, as the claimant suggested to Police. The insurer concedes that the onus of establishing, on the balance of probabilities, facts said to demonstrate that the motor accident was caused wholly by the fault of the claimant, rests with the insurer. The insurer submits that the claimant does hold at least some onus of improving the relevant facts, which have not been made out in this matter, so it is submitted. The insurer submits that the evidence plainly meets the standard of proof to refute the claimant’s version of events for the purposes of s 3.11 and s 3.28 of the Act. For the reasons outlined below, the insurer submits that the evidence shows the claimant was wholly at fault for the accident, under s 3.11 and s 3.28(1)(a) of the Act:(a)the claimant alleged that the road was “partially wet” (A8) whereas the photographs annexed to the claimant’s submissions demonstrate that the lane where the accident occurred was dry, consistent with the insured’s version of event;(b)contrary to the claimant’s allegation that the insured veered towards his scooter, which caused their handle bars to make contact, the insured sustained no damage to his motorcycle, which is consistent with the insured’s version of events that the claimant attempted to overtake his motorcycle;(c)the claimant’s versions of events to his treatment providers are inconsistent, and(d)the insurer submits that the insured’s version should be preferred as the totality of the objective evidence is in favour of the insured’s version, noting the various inconsistencies in the claimant’s version outlined above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established