Sands Contracting Pty Ltd v Foodcorp (VIC) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sands Contracting Pty Ltd v Foodcorp (VIC) Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1274

File number: WAD 9 of 2020
Judgment of: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 4 September 2020
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – liquidators – application for removal of – whether liquidator acted impartially and independently – where plaintiffs are the only major creditor – where plaintiffs’ claim is the subject of litigation – where liquidator valued the claim at one dollar for voting purposes – where liquidator admitted debts of the other two creditors before being provided with invoices – where plaintiffs were opposed to the Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) – where DOCA was approved on the votes of the other two creditors – consideration of principles on the removal of liquidator

CORPORATIONS – external administration – liquidation – whether company has passed into liquidation or remains in administration – where DOCA approved at creditors meeting – where DOCA is not prepared or executed because application is brought to remove liquidator – where company is deemed to pass into liquidation if DOCA is not executed within 15 days of being prepared – where ASIC Register shows the company to be in liquidation – where no application was made to amend the ASIC Register

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 435C(2), 437A, 437B, 437D, 439C, 444A, 444A(1), 444A(3), 444B, 444B(1), 444B(2), 444B(7), 446A, 446A(1)(b), 446A(2)(a), 446A(5)(a), 446A(5)(b), 447A, 450C, 482, 556, Pts 5.3A, 5.6, Sch 2 r 70-45, 90-15

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) regs 5.6.12-5.6.36A (repealed)

Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016 (Cth) rr 70-15, 70-15(2)(a), 70-15(2)(c), 70-15(2)(e), 70-15(2)(f), 75-85(1), 75-85(2), 75-85(3), 75-85(4), 75-95, 75 100(1), 75-100(2), Divs 70, 75 

Cases cited:

AMP Music Box Enterprises Ltd v Hoffman [2002] BCC 996

Apple Computer Australia Pty Ltd v Wily [2003] NSWSC 719

Bacnet Pty Ltd v Lift Capital Partners Pty Ltd (in liq) (2010) 183 FCR 386

Bovis Lend Lease v Wily & Anor(2003) 45 ACSR 612

Domino Hire Pty Ltd v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 496; (2003) 21 ACLC 1330

El-Saafin v Franek (No 3) [2019] VSC 155

Re Free Wesleyan Church of Tonga in Australia Inc (administrators appointed) (2012) 260 FLR 348

Re Giant Resources Ltd [1991] 1 Qd R 107

Re Keypak Homecare Ltd [1987] 3 BCC 558

Multi-Core Aerators Ltd v Dye [1999] VSC 205

Re Mutual Livestock Financial & Agency Co Ltd (1886) 12 VLR 777

MYT Engineering Pty Limited v Mulcon Pty Limited (1999) 195 CLR 636

Network Exchange Pty Ltd v MIG International Communications Pty Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 544

Re Oriel Homes Pty Ltd (1998) 15 ACLC 564

Selim v McGrath (2003) 177 FLR 85; [2003] NSWSC 927

Re St Gregory’s Armenian School (in liq) [2012] NSWSC 1215; (2012) 92 ACSR 588

Weriton Finance Pty Ltd v PNR Pty Ltd (in admin); Australian Residential and Commercial Finance Pty Ltd v PNR Pty Ltd (2012) 92 ASCR 88

Re Zambena Pty Ltd (1995) 13 ACLC 1020

Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sands Contracting Pty Ltd v Foodcorp (VIC) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sands Contracting Pty Ltd and others sought the removal of liquidators and the winding up of Foodcorp (VIC) Pty Ltd. The plaintiffs argued that the liquidators had not acted impartially and independently, particularly in their handling of the plaintiffs' debt claim, which was the subject of ongoing litigation. The liquidators valued the plaintiffs' claim at one dollar for voting purposes, despite negotiations indicating a potential settlement of around $200,000. Additionally, the plaintiffs claimed that the liquidators admitted the debts of other creditors before receiving their invoices, while opposing the plaintiffs' claims. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the liquidators acted impartially and independently in their duties, specifically in their valuation and consideration of the plaintiffs' debt claim.

The court examined the principles established in previous cases, particularly focusing on the necessity for liquidators to make just estimates of debts and to conduct proper inquiries. In this case, the court found that the liquidators failed to make a just estimate of the plaintiffs' debt, given the significant negotiations and the director's offer to settle the matter. Furthermore, the court noted that the liquidators did not conduct proper inquiries into the other creditors' claims, as the necessary documentation was not provided until after the creditors' meeting. These actions indicated a lack of impartiality and independence on the part of the liquidators.

Consequently, the court ruled in favour of the plaintiffs, finding that the liquidators did not act impartially and independently. The court also addressed the question of whether the company had passed into liquidation, noting that the approval of the Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) did not necessarily mean the company had entered liquidation if the DOCA was not executed. The court determined that the company remained in administration until such time as the DOCA was executed or the company officially entered liquidation. The court ordered the parties to submit agreed minutes of orders or competing proposals within 14 days, along with short submissions on the costs of the amended originating process. The final orders and costs were to be determined based on the submissions provided.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the parties are to file either:

(a) an agreed minute of orders reflecting the outcome of these reasons; or

(b) competing minutes of proposed orders.

2. Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the parties are to file short submissions (not to exceed three pages) on the question of the costs of the plaintiffs’ amended originating process.

3. Unless the Court orders otherwise, the settling of the orders and the question of costs be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Company Accountants have been joined as interested parties, as has Superior Foods. The relief sought is opposed by all active defendants. The Liquidators say that there is no basis for the relief. The Company Accountants say they should not have been joined in the proceeding. Superior Foods says that the Company has never actually passed into liquidation because the DOCA was not prepared, so the occasion to exercise the relief sought has not arisen. THE EVIDENCE The plaintiffs rely on affidavits of: (a)Mr Anthony Sands sworn 17 January 2020; Mr Sands is the fourth named plaintiff and a director of the first, second, and third named plaintiffs. The fifth named plaintiff is his mother, the sixth named plaintiff is his brother. The seventh named plaintiff is his sister-in-law in her capacity as the executor of the Estate of his late brother. The plaintiffs carry on business as a partnership in Western Australia under the name ‘Sands Fridge Lines’. (b)Mr Gregory Metaxas sworn 12 February 2020; and(c)Mr Metaxas sworn 13 May 2020. The Liquidators rely on the affidavit of Mr Anthony Cant sworn 9 April 2020. Mr Cant was the person most directly involved in the role as liquidator of the Company. THE BASIC FACTS From the affidavits just identified and the key documents the following basic facts emerge. There was a lengthy history of previous disputation between the first plaintiff (in which the other plaintiffs are interested in different ways) and the Company. In 2016, the plaintiffs commenced the District Court action against Superior Foods, claiming $300,775.79. On 30 August 2017, the Company was added as a party to the District Court action. Between March and October 2019, the plaintiffs and the defendants had protracted negotiations regarding the resolution of the District Court action. On 9 March 2019, Mr Craig Phillips as director of the Company and, on behalf of the defendants in that litigation, sent an SMS to Mr Sands as follows:Hi Tony, if you agree to split the difference I will concede to move on. $187,500 and we both take some pain. Your call. Craig On 21 March 2019, Mr Sands replied to Mr Phillips as follows:CraigHave just come out of an early meeting this morning in regards to your last SMS offer. Sands position is $225,000.00 and Sands absorbs current legal fees and interest incurred on Sands side.Regards,Tony Negotiations continued until late October 2019 but with no agreed outcome. On 6 November 2019, Mr Troy Jeffs, the financial controller of the Company, signed a declaration that the Company did not owe money, goods or services to others in a Report on Company Activities and Property (ROCAP). On 15 November 2019, the directors of the Company passed the following resolutions:1.In the opinion of the directors voting for the resolution, the Company is insolvent, or is likely to become insolvent at some future time.2.That [Mr Cant] and [Ms Di Carlo] of Romanis Cant, registered Liquidators, … be appointed Administrators of the Company pursuant to Section 436A of the Corporations Act. 3.That the document appointing the Administrator be executed in accordance with section 436A of the Corporations Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Later in Lyons J’s reasons in El-Saafin, his Honour examined circumstances which appear to demonstrate some comparisons with the present situation, noting (at [95] and [190]-[192]): 95Further, I have concluded that the person on whom the obligation to request evidence in writing is imposed must consider all the circumstances of the particular case to determine if such a request is necessary to make. In my view, those circumstances would include the nature of the meeting for which the information was relevant, the previous requests made for information and/or evidence in relation to the debt claimed, and the information in fact provided.…190To adopt the terminology of Black J in Re Free Wesleyan Church [of Tonga in Australia Inc 260 FLR 348], the value of the debt owing to MAG could not be ascertained merely by reference to the MAG proof in light of all the issues raised in this proceeding. Substantial further enquiries were required to be made by Mr Glavas. On the evidence before me, he did not make such enquiries. This is contrast to [sic] Free WesleyanChurch where the Administrators received and tendered into evidence legal advice on the true value of the amount claimed.191Further, Mr Glavas’ failure to do so is troubling in light of the significant nature of the MAG debt in any vote of the second creditors’ meeting. I note there is no evidence that Mr Glavas received legal advice in relation to the true amount owing to MAG in light of the issues raised in this proceeding. After careful consideration, I have formed the view, based on the evidence before me, that Mr Glavas did not act independently and impartially when he failed to consider the merits of the MAG claim in light of the issues raised in my Reasons. I refer also to the difference between the way in [sic] he approached the challenged proofs and the way in which he approached the Mekkya proof and the Ibrahim proof, as set out above at [168]-[175] and [176]-[181] above.192On the evidence before me, it is difficult to determine the amount of the MAG debt in fact owing. Indeed, this is a question in the proceeding. There were no detailed submissions from either party based on the evidence about it. In oral submissions, counsel for the plaintiffs relied upon the matters set out at [6]-[11] of their submissions dated 23 July 2018 and [20]-[29] of the proposed further amended statement of claim.(Emphasis added, citations omitted.)CONSIDERATION The plaintiffs primarily contend that the Liquidators failed to:(a)make a just estimate of the plaintiffs’ proof of debt in circumstances where the director of the Company (Mr Phillips) had informed Mr Cant that he had offered to the plaintiffs in the vicinity of $200,000 to settle the District Court action;(b)make a just estimate of, or proper enquiries into, the Company Accountants’ proof of debt in circumstances where no tax invoices were provided to substantiate the amount claimed until after the meeting during which the DOCA was approved; and(c)make a just estimate of, or proper enquiries into, Superior Foods’ proof of debt in circumstances where no tax invoices or agreement between Superior Foods and the Company were provided to substantiate the claim for legal fees incurred with respect to the District Court action until after the meeting during which the DOCA was approved.