Sandford and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Sandford and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2017] AATA 2038 (1 November 2017)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:           2016/2591

Re:Raymond Sandford

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member T. Tavoularis

Date:1 November 2017

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

.......................[SGD]..............................

Senior Member T. Tavoularis

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – Disability pension – whether post-traumatic stress disorder was war-caused or defence-caused – Tribunal satisfied that Applicant suffers from Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (‘PTSD’) – where Tribunal not reasonably satisfied PTSD was war caused – where Tribunal not satisfied on balance of probabilities PTSD was defence caused - decision under review affirmed.

Legislation

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) Part II and IV, ss 6, 9, 13, 68, 69, 70, 120, 120A, 120B

Cases

Border v Repatriation Commission (No. 2) (2010) 191 FCR 163
Parr and Repatriation Commission [2003] AATA 13
Repatriation Commission v Deledio (1998) 83 FCR 82
Repatriation Commission v Gorton (2001) 110 FCR 321
Roncevich v Repatriation Commission (2005) 222 CLR 115

Secondary Materials

Statement of Principles concerning Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (Instrument No. 83 of 2014)

Statement of Principles concerning Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (Instrument No. 82 of 2014)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member T. Tavoularis

1 November 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for review of the decision of the Veterans’ Review Board (“the VRB”) dated 23 March 2016. The VRB’s decision affirmed the decision of the Repatriation Commission (“the Respondent”) dated 7 January 2015, which refused a claim by Mr Raymond Sandford (“the Applicant”) for post-traumatic stress disorder (“PTSD”) to be accepted as service-related.[1]

    [1] I note that the original decision also included a claim for bilateral hypermetropia but this condition was withdrawn at the VRB.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant is 65 years old. He served in the Royal Australian Navy from 8 March 1969 to 12 March 1979 (aged 17 to 27).

  3. On 20 October 2014, the Applicant lodged a claim for disability pension for disabilities that had not yet been accepted as service related. The Applicant specifically wanted to claim compensation in respect of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (“PTSD”) and Hypermetropia, which he asserted were war or defence caused.[2]

    [2] See Exhibit 3, “T documents”, T5, pp 43 – 52.

  4. On 7 January 2015 a delegate of the Repatriation Commission refused the claim, stating that they had “decided that bilateral hypermetropia and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder are not related to service”.[3]

    [3] See Exhibit 3, T10, p 69.

  5. In that decision it was noted that the Repatriation Commission was satisfied that the Applicant had rendered operational service in Vietnam from 16-29 November 1969. Further, he had rendered eligible service as a member of the Defence Forces during the period from 7 December 1972 to 12 March 1979.[4]

    [4] Ibid, p 70.

  6. On 13 February 2015, the Applicant lodged an application for review with the Veterans’ Review Board (“VRB”), indicating that further information and detail would be supplied by Dr Holy.[5]

    [5] See Exhibit 3, T11, p 73.

  7. On 23 March 2016 the VRB made a decision…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sandford and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2038
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Veterans’ Review Board (VRB), which affirmed the Repatriation Commission's refusal of Mr Raymond Sandford's claim for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) to be accepted as service-related. Mr Sandford, who served in the Royal Australian Navy between 1969 and 1979, including operational service in Vietnam, sought compensation for PTSD.

The court was required to determine whether Mr Sandford had a diagnosis of PTSD, and if so, whether that PTSD was war-caused or defence-caused, having regard to the applicable Statements of Principles. The court also needed to consider the appropriate rate of pension if the claim was successful. A key aspect of the determination involved distinguishing between "operational service" and "eligible defence service" and the different standards of proof that applied to each.

The court noted that the Repatriation Commission conceded that Mr Sandford had a valid diagnosis of PTSD. The court accepted the views of Dr Holm, given his historical connection with Mr Sandford, and also noted that an updated report from Dr Garg acknowledged the PTSD diagnosis. The court explained that the distinction between operational service and eligible defence service was significant because only operational service attracted the more generous "reasonable hypothesis" standard of proof under sections 120 and 120A of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth), whereas eligible defence service was assessed under the less generous "reasonable satisfaction" standard of proof in sections 120(4) and 120B of the Act.

The court found that Mr Sandford had rendered both operational service in Vietnam and eligible defence service. The determination of whether the PTSD was war-caused or defence-caused would proceed by reference to the relevant Statements of Principles, with the applicable standard of proof depending on the type of service.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for review of the decision of the Veterans’ Review Board (“the VRB”) dated 23 March 2016. The VRB’s decision affirmed the decision of the Repatriation Commission (“the Respondent”) dated 7 January 2015, which refused a claim by Mr Raymond Sandford (“the Applicant”) for post-traumatic stress disorder (“PTSD”) to be accepted as service-related.[1] [1] I note that the original decision also included a claim for bilateral hypermetropia but this condition was withdrawn at the VRB. BACKGROUND The Applicant is 65 years old. He served in the Royal Australian Navy from 8 March 1969 to 12 March 1979 (aged 17 to 27). On 20 October 2014, the Applicant lodged a claim for disability pension for disabilities that had not yet been accepted as service related. The Applicant specifically wanted to claim compensation in respect of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (“PTSD”) and Hypermetropia, which he asserted were war or defence caused.[2] [2] See Exhibit 3, “T documents”, T5, pp 43 – 52. On 7 January 2015 a delegate of the Repatriation Commission refused the claim, stating that they had “decided that bilateral hypermetropia and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder are not related to service”.[3] [3] See Exhibit 3, T10, p 69. In that decision it was noted that the Repatriation Commission was satisfied that the Applicant had rendered operational service in Vietnam from 16-29 November 1969. Further, he had rendered eligible service as a member of the Defence Forces during the period from 7 December 1972 to 12 March 1979.[4] [4] Ibid, p 70. On 13 February 2015, the Applicant lodged an application for review with the Veterans’ Review Board (“VRB”), indicating that further information and detail would be supplied by Dr Holy.[5] [5] See Exhibit 3, T11, p 73. On 23 March 2016 the VRB made a decision that: (1) noted the withdrawal of the application in relation to the claim for Bilateral Hypermetropia, and (2) affirmed the decision under review in relation to the claim for PTSD.[6] The Applicant was notified of this decision by letter dated 29 April 2016.[7] [6] See Exhibit 3, T2, p B2.[7] See Exhibit 3, T2, p B1. On 17 May 2016, the Applicant lodged an Application for Review of Decision with this Tribunal.[8] [8] See Exhibit 3, T1, p A1-2.ISSUES The issues which fall under my consideration in this matter are as follows: 1)whether a diagnosis of PTSD is present; and if so:2)whether that PTSD is war-caused, having reference to the applicable Statement of Principles;[9] or 3)whether that PTSD is defence-caused, having reference to the applicable Statement of Principles;[10] and if so, then:4)what the appropriate rate of pension should be. [9] See Statement of Principles concerning Posttraumatic Stress Disorder No. 82 of 2014.[10]See Statement of Principles concerning Posttraumatic Stress Disorder No. 83 of 2014. I will consider each of these issues and the applicable law in turn. ISSUE 1: WHETHER A DIAGNOSIS OF PTSD IS PRESENT?

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Garg provided an updated report in February 2017. The majority of his report essentially reflects his earlier report. This time, however, his diagnosis included: (1) Recurrent Depressive Disorder, and (2) Posttraumatic Stress Disorder. Dr Garg was again of the view that the clinical onset of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder occurred soon after the Applicant’s discharge from the navy, and for depression it was in 2005 or 2006.[33][33] Exhibit 11, Report of Dr A Garg dated 3 February 2017.Conclusion I again note that the Respondent has now conceded that the Applicant does have a valid diagnosis of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (“PTSD”). Given the historical connection between the Applicant and Dr Holm, I am inclined to accept the views of Dr Holm and accordingly find that the Applicant suffers from PTSD. In any event, I note Dr Garg’s updated report acknowledged a diagnosis of PTSD.THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF SERVICE - OPERATIONAL SERVICE VS ELIGIBLE DEFENCE SERVICE When considering the standard of proof for establishing the causal connection between the Applicant’s PTSD and his service, the difference lies in the type of “relevant service” the Applicant has rendered at the time he suffered his injury or contracted the disease (in this case, PTSD). Broadly speaking, in this case there are two levels of eligibility within the Repatriation system: (1) a veteran with service that is ‘operational service’ and sustained a ‘war-caused’ injury or disease, is entitled to compensation under Part II of the Act, and (2) a veteran is eligible for the pension under Part IV of the Act if they have rendered eligible ‘defence service’ and are incapacitated as a result of a defence-caused injury or disease. Section 6 of the Act broadly defines ‘operational service’ to include overseas service within a defined area by a member of the Defence Forces in a time of war or during warlike operations. Section 68 of the Act defines the concept of ‘defence service’, which includes continuous full-time service rendered by a member of the Defence Forces between 7 December 1972 and 7 April 1994. To be eligible for a pension under part IV of the Act a veteran must have completed three years’ effective full-time service.[34] [34] See Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) s 69(1)(c). As previously mentioned, it has been accepted that the Applicant rendered ‘operational service’ in Vietnam from 16-29 November 1969. Further, he had rendered ‘eligible defence service’ as a member of the Defence Forces during the period from 7 December 1972 to 12 March 1979.[35] [35] See Exhibit 3, T10, p 70. The principal significance of the distinction between “eligible service” and “operational service” (aside from the different pensions), is that it is only operational service which attracts the more generous “reasonable hypothesis” standard of proof set out in ss 120 and 120A of the Act. The eligibility for pension of a person who has eligible but non-operational service is to be determined in accordance with the less generous “reasonable satisfaction” standard of proof in ss 120(4) and 120B of the Act. Both standards of proof are assessed by reference to the applicable Statement of Principles.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I again note that the Respondent has now conceded that the Applicant does have a valid diagnosis of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (“PTSD”). Given the historical connection between the Applicant and Dr Holm, I am inclined to accept the views of Dr Holm and accordingly find that the Applicant suffers from PTSD. In any event, I note Dr Garg’s updated report acknowledged a diagnosis of PTSD.THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF SERVICE - OPERATIONAL SERVICE VS ELIGIBLE DEFENCE SERVICE When considering the standard of proof for establishing the causal connection between the Applicant’s PTSD and his service, the difference lies in the type of “relevant service” the Applicant has rendered at the time he suffered his injury or contracted the disease (in this case, PTSD). Broadly speaking, in this case there are two levels of eligibility within the Repatriation system: (1) a veteran with service that is ‘operational service’ and sustained a ‘war-caused’ injury or disease, is entitled to compensation under Part II of the Act, and (2) a veteran is eligible for the pension under Part IV of the Act if they have rendered eligible ‘defence service’ and are incapacitated as a result of a defence-caused injury or disease. Section 6 of the Act broadly defines ‘operational service’ to include overseas service within a defined area by a member of the Defence Forces in a time of war or during warlike operations. Section 68 of the Act defines the concept of ‘defence service’, which includes continuous full-time service rendered by a member of the Defence Forces between 7 December 1972 and 7 April 1994. To be eligible for a pension under part IV of the Act a veteran must have completed three years’ effective full-time service.[34] [34] See Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) s 69(1)(c). As previously mentioned, it has been accepted that the Applicant rendered ‘operational service’ in Vietnam from 16-29 November 1969. Further, he had rendered ‘eligible defence service’ as a member of the Defence Forces during the period from 7 December 1972 to 12 March 1979.[35] [35] See Exhibit 3, T10, p 70. The principal significance of the distinction between “eligible service” and “operational service” (aside from the different pensions), is that it is only operational service which attracts the more generous “reasonable hypothesis” standard of proof set out in ss 120 and 120A of the Act. The eligibility for pension of a person who has eligible but non-operational service is to be determined in accordance with the less generous “reasonable satisfaction” standard of proof in ss 120(4) and 120B of the Act. Both standards of proof are assessed by reference to the applicable Statement of Principles. In this case two relevant Statements of Principles exist in relation to Posttraumatic Stress Disorder. Stated briefly they are: No. 82 of 2014 and No. 83 of 2014. The former relates to the Applicant’s operational service, and the latter to his defence service.