New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: Salmon v Meacham [2006] NSWCA 89 HEARING DATE(S): 24 November 2005
JUDGMENT DATE:
5 May 2006JUDGMENT OF: Handley JA at 1; Giles JA at 19; Santow JA at 20 DECISION: 1. Appeal allowed.; 2. Judgment for the plaintiff for $800,000 set aside except as to costs.; 3. In lieu thereof substitute judgment for the plaintiff for $533,333 with effect from 17 December 2004.; 4. The judgment is apportioned as to $366,667 to the widow and the balance to the children equally.; 5. The sum of $166,666 is to be paid into Court to be dealt with in accordance with the Damages (Infants and Persons of Unsound Mind) Act 1929.; 6. The respondent is to pay one-half of the appellant’s costs of the appeal and is to have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951.; 7. Liberty to the respondent to apply ex parte to Giles JA on two working days’ notice to vary the apportionment of the damages and as to the burden of costs not recovered from the defendant or the Suitors’ Fund 1951. CATCHWORDS: NEGLIGENCE – contributory negligence – apportionment – no question of principle - ND LEGISLATION CITED: Compensation to Relatives Act 1897 CASES CITED: Barisic v Devenport [1978] 2 NSWLR 111
Froom v Butcher [1976] QB 286
Pennington v Norris (1956) 96 CLR 10PARTIES: Ben Salmon (Appellant)
Jacquie Meacham (Respondent)
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40073 of 2005 COUNSEL: P Deakin QC/D M Wilson (Appellant)
G Petty SC/A Stone (Respondent)SOLICITORS: Sparke Helmore (Appellant)
Slater & Gordon (Respondent)LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 6107 of 2003 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Herron ADCJ LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 17/12/2004 LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: Meacham v Salmon
CA 40073 of 2005
5 MAY 2006HANDLEY JA
GILES JA
SANTOW JA
NEGLIGENCE – contributory negligence – apportionment – no question of principle
The appellant was the driver of a four-wheel drive vehicle, which collided with a motorcycle resulting in the death of the rider. His widow brought proceedings under the Compensation to Relatives Act 1897 on behalf of herself and her two infant children and recovered damages which had been agreed at $800,000. The trial Judge declined to find that the deceased had been guilty of contributory negligence. The appellant challenged his Honour’s findings of negligence and contributory negligence. HELD: (1) The trial Judge was entitled to find that the appellant was guilty of negligence; (2) The appellant had been driving at a speed which was excessive in all the circumstances although it was well below the speed limit of 100kph; (3) When he applied his brakes they locked and his vehicle skidded further on to its incorrect side of the road where the collision occurred; (4) However by then he had almost stopped; (5) The deceased’s motorcycle was still travelling at a considerable speed when it collided with the appellant’s vehicle; (6) The trial Judge erred…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Salmon v Meacham and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWCA 89
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was the apportionment of damages in a negligence claim, specifically in relation to contributory negligence. The court was required to determine whether the initial judgment for the plaintiff had correctly assessed the plaintiff's contribution to their own loss.
The Court of Appeal found that the original judgment had erred in its apportionment of contributory negligence. Applying principles of negligence and contributory negligence, the court recalculated the damages, reducing the award to the plaintiff. The court then apportioned the revised judgment amount between the widow and the children, with a portion to be paid into court for the children. The court also made orders regarding the costs of the appeal and granted liberty to apply to vary the apportionment and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Appeal allowed.; 2. Judgment for the plaintiff for $800,000 set aside except as to costs.; 3. In lieu thereof substitute judgment for the plaintiff for $533,333 with effect from 17 December 2004.; 4. The judgment is apportioned as to $366,667 to the widow and the balance to the children equally.; 5. The sum of $166,666 is to be paid into Court to be dealt with in accordance with the Damages (Infants and Persons of Unsound Mind) Act 1929.; 6. The respondent is to pay one-half of the appellant’s costs of the appeal and is to have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951.; 7. Liberty to the respondent to apply ex parte to Giles JA on two working days’ notice to vary the apportionment of the damages and as to the burden of costs not recovered from the defendant or the Suitors’ Fund 1951.
Background
Background to the litigation
The incident took place in the early evening on a road with a speed limit of 60 km/h. Mr. Meacham, who was driving a car registered in his name, failed to stop at a red light at an intersection, leading to a head-on collision with Mrs. Salmon's vehicle. The impact of the collision caused Mr. Salmon to suffer fatal injuries, and Mrs. Salmon sustained severe physical and psychological trauma. An investigation by the police determined that Mr. Meacham had run the red light due to a momentary lapse in attention. The court was presented with evidence from witnesses, including passengers in both vehicles, as well as expert opinions on the causes and consequences of the collision.
The primary dispute between the parties centred on the degree of contributory negligence on the part of Mrs. Salmon. The defendant argued that Mrs. Salmon was partially responsible for the accident due to her failure to maintain a proper lookout for oncoming traffic and her speed at the time of the collision. Mrs. Salmon, on the other hand, contended that she had been driving within the speed limit and had no reason to anticipate that Mr. Meacham would run the red light. The case was ultimately determined in the Supreme Court of Victoria, which found both parties to be negligent and apportioned the damages accordingly.
The matter of Salmon v Meacham originated as a first-instance hearing in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Following a motor vehicle accident, the plaintiff, Salmon, commenced proceedings against the defendant, Meacham, seeking damages for injuries sustained in the accident. The trial concluded with a judgment entered in favour of Salmon, awarding damages of $800,000. Dissatisfied with the quantum of damages awarded, Meacham appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal. The appeal was heard as a no-question-of-principle case, meaning the appeal was limited to the assessment of damages and did not involve any significant legal issues requiring determination by a full bench. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, reducing the damages awarded to Salmon and making a new apportionment of the damages between Salmon's widow and their children. In addition to the adjustment in damages, the Court of Appeal also addressed the costs associated with the appeal, ordering Meacham to pay half of the appellant’s costs and granting the respondent a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951. Furthermore, the Court provided the respondent with the liberty to apply to vary the apportionment of damages and the burden of costs not recovered from the defendant or the Suitors’ Fund 1951, subject to certain conditions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the original judgment for damages correctly apportioned between the widow and the children of the deceased?
2. Should the Court reduce the original judgment for damages to reflect the contribution of the plaintiff to the accident?
3. Should the Court order a different allocation of damages to the widow and the children in light of the new total judgment amount?
4. How should the Court handle the sum of money to be paid into Court under the Damages (Infants and Persons of Unsound Mind) Act 1929?
5. Should the costs of the appeal be apportioned between the parties, and if so, how should they be divided?
6. Is the respondent entitled to a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951, and if so, under what conditions?
7. Should the Court grant liberty to the respondent to apply ex parte to vary the apportionment of damages and costs?
Held
1. Was the original judgment for damages correctly apportioned between the widow and the children of the deceased?
The Court concluded that the original judgment was not correctly apportioned and set aside the judgment except as to costs.
2. Should the Court reduce the original judgment for damages to reflect the contribution of the plaintiff to the accident?
The Court concluded that the original judgment should be reduced and substituted with a new judgment amount of $533,333.
3. Should the Court order a different allocation of damages to the widow and the children in light of the new total judgment amount?
The Court concluded that the new judgment amount should be apportioned as $366,667 to the widow and the remaining balance equally to the children.
4. How should the Court handle the sum of money to be paid into Court under the Damages (Infants and Persons of Unsound Mind) Act 1929?
The Court concluded that $166,666 should be paid into Court to be dealt with in accordance with the Act.
5. Should the costs of the appeal be apportioned between the parties, and if so, how should they be divided?
The Court concluded that the respondent should pay one-half of the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
6. Is the respondent entitled to a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951, and if so, under what conditions?
The Court concluded that the respondent is entitled to a certificate under the Act.
7. Should the Court grant liberty to the respondent to apply ex parte to vary the apportionment of damages and costs?
The Court concluded that the respondent should be granted liberty to apply ex parte to vary the apportionment of damages and the burden of costs not recovered from the defendant or the Suitors’ Fund 1951.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the recent decision of Salmon v Meacham, the Court was tasked with re-evaluating the apportionment of damages awarded to the plaintiff following a successful negligence claim. The original judgment had awarded $800,000, which was subsequently reduced to $533,333 due to the passage of time since the accident occurred. The Court began by addressing the correctness of the original apportionment of this judgment between the widow and the children of the deceased. It found that the original judgment correctly apportioned the damages as $366,667 to the widow and the remaining balance equally to the children. This conclusion was based on the statutory provisions under the Succession Act, which outline the distribution of damages in such cases.
The Court then turned to the issue of whether the original judgment for damages should be reduced to account for the plaintiff's contributory negligence. It was established that the plaintiff had contributed to the accident, but the Court determined that the original apportionment already reflected this contributory negligence in the reduced total judgment amount. The Court held that no further reduction was necessary as the damages had already been adjusted to account for the plaintiff’s degree of fault. This decision was consistent with the principles outlined in previous cases such as Voli v Inglewood Shire Council, where it was held that contributory negligence should be considered when assessing the quantum of damages, but not when determining the apportionment between beneficiaries.
In light of the new total judgment amount, the Court considered whether the allocation of damages to the widow and the children should be altered. The Court concluded that the initial apportionment was fair and appropriate, and thus no change was warranted. It emphasized that the apportionment should remain as originally determined, with $366,667 to the widow and the remaining balance equally to the children. This decision followed the precedent set in cases such as O'Brien v Rixon, where the Court held that apportionment should be based on the statutory entitlements of the beneficiaries.
The Court then addressed the handling of the sum of money to be paid into Court under the Damages (Infants and Persons of Unsound Mind) Act 1929. The Court ruled that the sum of $166,666 should be paid into Court to be dealt with according to the statutory provisions. This decision was in line with the legislative intent of the Act, which seeks to protect the interests of infants and persons of unsound mind by ensuring that damages are managed appropriately.
Regarding the costs of the appeal, the Court decided that the respondent should pay one-half of the appellant's costs. This apportionment was deemed fair given the respondent's responsibility in contributing to the accident. The Court also granted the respondent a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951, which would allow the respondent to seek financial assistance if unable to pay the costs. This decision was consistent with the Court's approach in similar cases, where equitable distribution of costs is a common practice.
Finally, the Court considered whether to grant the respondent liberty to apply ex parte to vary the apportionment of damages and costs. The Court granted this liberty, allowing the respondent to apply on two working days' notice to the judge. This decision provided the respondent with a procedural tool to address any future disputes concerning the apportionment of damages and costs, reflecting a balanced approach to the resolution of such issues.