Administrative
Appeals
Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2006] AATA 308
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No W2005/17
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re JULIANA LEO Applicant
And
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Associate Professor G A Barton, Member Date4 April 2006
PlacePerth
Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the respondent’s delegate of 3 December 2004 to cancel the business visa pursuant to s.134 of the Act.
.............(sgd G Barton).................
Member
29. The Australian Securities and Investment Commission extract for Optel of 6 December 2004, shortly after the respondent’s delegate cancelled the business visa, records there were 8572 issued fully paid “A” class shares in Optel held by Joeminto Rahardjo, and 40 001 issued fully paid ordinary shares held by Wandi Investments Pty Ltd. (‘Wandi’) and Mr Robert Charles MacGregor was the current director (T22). The Optel company extract of 24 November 2005 shows no changes to the register of ordinary shareholders but records the applicant’s holding of 22 189 fully paid “A” class shares and an increase of Joeminto Rahardjo’s holding of “A” class shares to 13 283(R1).The memorandum of association of Tanby Holdings Pty Ltd provides that its authorised capital is $100 000 divided into 100 000 ordinary shares of $1. 00 with a power to divide them into one or more classes with any preferential, deferred, qualified or special rights, privileges, conditions or stipulations and to issue shares with or without any preference priority or special privileges and subject to any postponement of rights or to any conditions or restrictions or without any right of voting(A6). In cross - examination Mr MacGregor stated that Joeminto Rahardjo is an Indonesian business skills migrant to Australia whose role in Optel was similar to that of the Applicant. Wandi is Mr MacGregor’s family company.
30. After the applicant was notified of the respondent’s intention to cancel the business visa, she and Mr Saleh Leo met with the representative of Gilete Management Consultants and AVMS in Jakarta to discuss business investment opportunities in Perth. They then travelled to Perth for a meeting with Mr Allan Hodder of AVMS who advised them that without additional investment in an Australian business the business visa might well be cancelled(A1;A8). They visited five businesses including Optel and after meeting with the various business owners and taking advice from Allan Hodder, the applicant decided to invest in Optel (A1).
31. On 24 September 2004 the applicant applied for 22189 “A” class shares in Optel enclosing $250 000 with her application and authorising the board of Optel to “register the company as the holder of such shares” subject to the terms of the constitution of Optel (A6). When Optel accepted the applicant’s offer to purchase a 29.4% shareholding in Optel for $250 000 payable on 27 September 2004 and undertook to issue a share certificate to the applicant for 22 “189” A class shares in the capital of Optel (‘the shares’), she contemporaneously executed put and call option…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Saleh Leo v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] AATA 308
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the AAT needed to address were the interpretation of the term ‘substantial’ in the context of an ownership interest in an eligible business and whether Leo's indirect and conditional interests in the business, through put and call options and an indemnity agreement, constituted a substantial ownership interest. The AAT had to consider the ordinary meaning of 'substantial', the nature of shares, and relevant case law to determine if Leo's underlying ownership interest in the business was substantial.
The AAT examined the ordinary meaning of 'substantial' and noted that it typically means considerable or significant in amount, value, or size. The Tribunal also considered the nature of shares and the cases of Evans v FC of T and Re Rose, Rose v Inland Revenue Commissioners, which highlighted that a shareholder does not necessarily need to have the right to dividends to be considered a substantial owner. The AAT concluded that Leo’s indirect and conditional interests, despite not being absolute or conferring a right to dividends, were substantial enough to meet the requirements of the subclass 127 visa. The Tribunal found that the delegate's decision to cancel the visa was unreasonable and set it aside.
As a result, the Tribunal ordered that the decision of the respondent’s delegate to cancel the business visa be set aside.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the respondent’s delegate of 3 December 2004 to cancel the business visa pursuant to s.134 of the Act.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi